Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think 'first blood in your knickers' and a drawing of children's underwear with blood spots

190 replies

OneOfThoseOldFashionedWomen · 10/02/2024 23:24

Is closer to red flags than it is to child safeguarding?

OP posts:
mumda · 11/02/2024 10:55

serin · 11/02/2024 10:51

I much prefer John Donne TBH.

https://www.poetryfoundation.org/poems/46467/the-flea
We could probably complain about bits of that!

The Flea by John Donne | Poetry Foundation

Mark but this flea, and mark in this,

https://www.poetryfoundation.org/poems/46467/the-flea

serin · 11/02/2024 10:51

I much prefer John Donne TBH.

Doingmybest12 · 11/02/2024 10:44

I just didn't get it. Is it a mum who lost a child and missed these things, a adult who was a child who missed these things with their mum . And blood in knickers made me think were they listing all the usual stuff but then SA happened, it can happen to anyone. Haven't heard the poem before so heard it as random statements.

Flowers4me · 11/02/2024 10:40

Jellycats4life · 11/02/2024 10:37

I both agree and disagree. I agree it’s weird that a man wrote it and I’m surprised that a man wrote it. I would have preferred it if the job had been given to a woman.

I disagree that it’s wrong for any mother to talk about her daughter getting a period because it’s deeply private and personal. My daughter started very young (as did a few of her peers in year 6) and, in the main, they were all quite open and matter of fact about it all.

The days of girls being embarrassed and desperate for no one to know are long gone, thankfully.

Sorry I haven't made myself clear; I have been very open with my daughters about periods etc. What I meant to say is, I wouldn't be talking about her experiences with other people unless for example medical support was needed. If she wanted to discuss it with friends that's up to her, if she felt comfortable with friends she could trust. She is autistic so there was a particular vulnerability there around friendships so it was not a case of opening up because of lack of embarrassment but how would that peer group react. So it was never straightforward for her - adolescence was challenging for her in many ways and it was not right for me to share private things against her wishes.

Jellycats4life · 11/02/2024 10:37

Flowers4me · 11/02/2024 10:30

As a mum, I find it strange that a man is writing about deeply personal female experiences. I know it relates to parenting and some of it I can relate to but I don't think the line about blood in your knickers (assuming its periods) helps to normalise periods at all. As a mum, I would not be talking about this aspect of my daughter's life - it is personal to her and I respect her privacy. It can also be a difficult and upsetting experience in a girl's life - no need to make a thing of it in a poem.

I both agree and disagree. I agree it’s weird that a man wrote it and I’m surprised that a man wrote it. I would have preferred it if the job had been given to a woman.

I disagree that it’s wrong for any mother to talk about her daughter getting a period because it’s deeply private and personal. My daughter started very young (as did a few of her peers in year 6) and, in the main, they were all quite open and matter of fact about it all.

The days of girls being embarrassed and desperate for no one to know are long gone, thankfully.

Flowers4me · 11/02/2024 10:30

As a mum, I find it strange that a man is writing about deeply personal female experiences. I know it relates to parenting and some of it I can relate to but I don't think the line about blood in your knickers (assuming its periods) helps to normalise periods at all. As a mum, I would not be talking about this aspect of my daughter's life - it is personal to her and I respect her privacy. It can also be a difficult and upsetting experience in a girl's life - no need to make a thing of it in a poem.

mumda · 11/02/2024 10:30

I've watched it twice on TV in ad breaks.

I don't like the blood / period reference and think there are much better ways to say "children going through puberty have experiences" without making it so very girl centric.

I don't know what it's aim is either.

The don't let go of my hand at the end, after the child has long gone away from holding a parents hand made me think of parents aging and getting dementia and needing their child's support.

I think it was a terrible advert.
It does not inspire confidence in their charity work.

BIossomtoes · 11/02/2024 10:30

But is he even talking about periods?

Of course it’s about periods. Look at the context. It’s in a section describing changes that come with puberty. The entire poem is chronological.

OneOfThoseOldFashionedWomen · 11/02/2024 10:24

tempnameforadvice · 11/02/2024 09:36

I can't believe people have a problem with this advert.

Anyone who thinks that periods should be hidden are the reason they are a taboo subject. 4 billion people have periods, it's hardly a fucking rarity not to be discussed.

Absolute idiots.

I don't think periods should be hidden. We can talk about periods in a much more meaningful and useful way than a line in a poem.

But is he even talking about periods?

OP posts:
OneOfThoseOldFashionedWomen · 11/02/2024 10:21

newnamethanks · 11/02/2024 09:27

If you're thinking about perversion OP perhaps you might question your thought process. It doesn't seem to be widely shared.

That's because so many have become immune to child sexualization and the blurring of boundaries.

OP posts:
IHaveNeverLivedintheCastle · 11/02/2024 10:20

SpraggleWaggle · 11/02/2024 06:45

The poem is dreadful- just a series of cliches- and it didn’t really speak to me at all. I found it very negative, although maybe it’s supposed to be negative to better speak to people who are struggling. Not my bag anyway.

The “blood in your knickers” line didn’t especially bother me, although the teen section as a whole was pretty reductive- periods, make up and bras. Not surprised they fell out if that’s all the parent saw in the child.

Yes, that's a very good analysis.

TeabySea · 11/02/2024 10:19

IHaveNeverLivedintheCastle · 11/02/2024 10:14

Duplicate post deleted

Edited

Agree.
Whilst periods are not shameful or a subject of ridicule, etc. I equally don't understand why they're a cause for celebration.
Everything is becoming competitive- first steps, first period, first kiss, first to be married...for no reason.

I don't particularly like the poem but there's nothing offensive or disturbing in it.

IHaveNeverLivedintheCastle · 11/02/2024 10:14

tempnameforadvice · 11/02/2024 09:36

I can't believe people have a problem with this advert.

Anyone who thinks that periods should be hidden are the reason they are a taboo subject. 4 billion people have periods, it's hardly a fucking rarity not to be discussed.

Absolute idiots.

Duplicate post deleted

BIossomtoes · 11/02/2024 10:13

BlankTimes · 10/02/2024 23:32

Thank you for the link. That’s really beautiful.

IHaveNeverLivedintheCastle · 11/02/2024 10:11

tempnameforadvice · 11/02/2024 09:36

I can't believe people have a problem with this advert.

Anyone who thinks that periods should be hidden are the reason they are a taboo subject. 4 billion people have periods, it's hardly a fucking rarity not to be discussed.

Absolute idiots.

Oh I don't have a problem with discussing periods. I have a problem with this pile of chichéd codswallop being presented as something breathtaking and profound.

Bibbetybobbity · 11/02/2024 10:11

Yep agree OP it’s ill judged and as pp have pointed out, the male equivalent wouldn’t work at all and exposes quite how weird it is. Not for me and would never make me donate.

OneOfThoseOldFashionedWomen · 11/02/2024 10:00

LostInPoetry · 11/02/2024 02:08

If the advert mentioned some of the more personal changes that happen to boys, along with a picture of their ‘stained’ boxers, more people would see how ‘off’ this advert is. But talking about ‘first blood in girls knickers’ with a drawing of their underwear is just fine with people. 🙄

'First semen in boys pants' along with a cartoon drawing.

I agree with a pp, that it is the picture that makes it worse.

-TW-

But it is the language as well, those that are saying it is just a poem, should then realise that 'art' is meant to be read in different ways, that poets choose words and images carefully.

How do we know the the discussion is about periods, when the words are vague.
The term 'first blood' has a double meaning, 'First blood' is more commonly used to mean the first killing or wounding in a fight or war. the first damage

So what are we meant to take away from 'first damage?'

OP posts:
Beautiful3 · 11/02/2024 09:57

A link would have steered people in the right way! I read that poem to represent a child's right of passage. The first blood meant the period, the clown face, represented the awful make up teens put on etc. I enjoyed the poem, it's very clever.

Nitgel · 11/02/2024 09:43

It's unclear what the ad was trying to convey imo.

Zoomzoomzoomzoom0 · 11/02/2024 09:42

No problem with people normalising periods.
But this poem does appear to have been written by a man, describing an exclusively female experience. Many exclusively female experiences actually, the cabbage in the bra etc.

Doingmybest12 · 11/02/2024 09:41

I haven't heard the poem before, so thought it was random statements and so things can be ticking along as usual, usual development then , something dreadful can happen to anyone causing blood. It is very clumsy

Newsenmum · 11/02/2024 09:40

tempnameforadvice · 11/02/2024 09:36

I can't believe people have a problem with this advert.

Anyone who thinks that periods should be hidden are the reason they are a taboo subject. 4 billion people have periods, it's hardly a fucking rarity not to be discussed.

Absolute idiots.

Agreed. Let’s normalised periods please.

Newsenmum · 11/02/2024 09:39

She has a daughter. It’s about her daughter. Girls get periods.

Zoomzoomzoomzoom0 · 11/02/2024 09:38

Also the term " first blood" has an uncomfortable hunting association for me, but perhaps that's just my rural background!

Zoomzoomzoomzoom0 · 11/02/2024 09:37

JFDIYOLO · 11/02/2024 08:49

I'm looking with interest at my own reactions to it:

It's a poem about parenting a daughter, not a son.

The fact that it's BY a man (if I'm reading the name right) felt slightly odd - I think it's unlikely a father would get involved with first period stuff unless no mum.

Performed by a woman, it's very moving. Mum prepared me well for my first at 11 because I was already wearing a bra in junior school. I remember I came rushing downstairs going 'mum! I've got my first one!!'

I'm not sure I like the picture. It's very literal and would come as a bit much to many viewers.

But it's caught my attention and I think so many parents of girls will recognise so much.

Yes this really. A poem about mothering a daughter, not parenting.
And it does appear to be written by a man
Perhaps there will be a follow on add about being a father to sons. Written by a woman?