Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Lying re car accident

117 replies

Crikeyalm · 10/02/2024 17:05

DP son has written off his car but so insurance doesn’t go up is not telling insurance company he has had accident , his dad is going to buying him a new car and they will just insure this . Aibu to thinking this is awful ?

OP posts:
DelilahsHaven · 10/02/2024 21:00

imnotsickbutimnotwell · 10/02/2024 20:29

Are people just not reading the thread where the OP has stated he’s hit a lampost under the influence of drugs and hasn’t reported it to the insurance or police or are all these replies just AI bots??

I give up with some of these replies. All these people saying it’s ok and don’t tell the insurance are going to have a big shock one day when something similar happens to them and their insurance is invalidated.

In fairness, neither the lampost or the drugs were mentioned until a lot of those replies were made.

So, in summary, he probably wouldn't obliged to report damaging his car, repairable or not, if no other person or property was damaged, to his insurer.

If he buys a replacement car, he will be obliged to declare that he had the crash but didn't make a claim, so that his new policy is based on the correct risk.

As he has hit a lamppost he is obliged to report to the owner of said lampost so that they can claim, and possibly also to the police.

If he was, as alleged, under the influence of drugs, then the OP and/or her partner, and/or anyone else who knows this, should report to the police.

The OP is obviously upset, and sounds frustrated at her DP and his son, but has confused the discussion by saying that the car was "written off", when it had just been declared irreparable by a garage, "lying" when this had not taken place, and not mentioning the lampost, and more crucially, the drugs, until people disagreed with her.

Other factors in whether this was a serious, irresponsible crash include what damage the car actually sustained, the car's age, weather, lighting, and particularly whether drugs were involved or not.

imnotsickbutimnotwell · 10/02/2024 20:53

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

TheSilentSister · 10/02/2024 20:52

I would be tempted to do this if no third party involved and my imaginary Sugar Daddy could buy me a new car. However, how does he know that there isn't CCTV, dashcam or doorcam footage or even an actual witness? It could be weeks before the council investigates and then he'd be in an awful lot of trouble.
I guess that's the risk he takes.
If he was my DS he wouldn't be getting another car for sure!

InAPickle12345 · 10/02/2024 20:51

Exactly @FatPrincess! The stories from people I know personally who had not had their house, health and car insurances pay out are sickening. I wouldn't have any loyalty or sense of obligation to an insurance company. The only reason I have insurance is because it's illegal not to but I would avoid making a claim against my insurance in the vast majority of instances.

FatPrincess · 10/02/2024 20:47

Mumsgirls · 10/02/2024 20:23

One of the principals of insurance is ‘ utmost good faith’ it is a contract where you give them facts and they assess a risk. So they will be pricing the new policy without the full facts. Very definitely fraud. You will have cheated them out of the full premium due. Depends if you have integrity or not, but fraud is a crime.

I'm not sure how much integrity I'd have towards an insurance company given how they look for pretty much any tiny reason to deny a claim.

penjil · 10/02/2024 20:37

helpnohelpno · 10/02/2024 20:26

Yea he can scrap the car with no repercussions providing no one was hurt (who wish to seek compensation) and no damage was caused to another car or property.

Which was not the case, as he hit a lamppost, which is someone else property. Council property.

InAPickle12345 · 10/02/2024 20:37

@imnotsickbutimnotwell and you're another poster who has missed the fact that she has NO proof of this alleged drug driving. She said she is '90% sure' which, judging by her obvious dislike of her DP son, could be utter bollocks as well.

Also no mention of him driving away after the accident which you mentioned earlier.

I don't condone drink or drug driving by anyone, but the OP is ridiculous to think he should report this to his insurance if it's not necessary to buy a new car.

FuckinghellthatsUnbelievable · 10/02/2024 20:29

Wasn’t the lamppost damaged? I know someone who got an £800 bill to repair a street lamp after a bump. Scrapping a car is a completely normal thing though. I’ve scrapped a car after hitting my own house. It was in gear jumped forward and hit an iron drainpipe ( which was fine). I think if the car is worth less than 1k it’s not really worth claiming due to excess / increased premiums

imnotsickbutimnotwell · 10/02/2024 20:29

Are people just not reading the thread where the OP has stated he’s hit a lampost under the influence of drugs and hasn’t reported it to the insurance or police or are all these replies just AI bots??

I give up with some of these replies. All these people saying it’s ok and don’t tell the insurance are going to have a big shock one day when something similar happens to them and their insurance is invalidated.

helpnohelpno · 10/02/2024 20:26

Yea he can scrap the car with no repercussions providing no one was hurt (who wish to seek compensation) and no damage was caused to another car or property.

imnotsickbutimnotwell · 10/02/2024 20:24

InAPickle12345 · 10/02/2024 20:20

Jesus, the dislike you have for your DPs son is dripping off this post.

There was no other party involved and he doesn't need the insurance payout to buy a new car so why would he inform his insurance company and have his premiums affected for the next 5 years? That would make absolutely no sense.

You'd do well to just keep your nose out of it and whatever opinions you have about it to yourself.

Another poster who’s missed the fact he hit a lampost whilst under the influence of drugs!

As a drug driver killed my friend I I don’t give a shit if his premiums go up I hope they don’t ever insure him again.

Mumsgirls · 10/02/2024 20:23

One of the principals of insurance is ‘ utmost good faith’ it is a contract where you give them facts and they assess a risk. So they will be pricing the new policy without the full facts. Very definitely fraud. You will have cheated them out of the full premium due. Depends if you have integrity or not, but fraud is a crime.

imnotsickbutimnotwell · 10/02/2024 20:21

Seaweed42 · 10/02/2024 20:13

Unfortunately that's perfectly legal thing to do with cars.
You can either claim on the insurance or choose to pay for the damage yourself.

The issue of him drug driving and nearly killing himself and endangering others is a different matter.

You have to inform your insurer of any accidents.
You have to inform the police if you damage something like a lampost. You don’t get to choose to not do those things. If you look at the paper work for your insurance it will state that you must inform them of any accidents even if there is no claim.

InAPickle12345 · 10/02/2024 20:20

Jesus, the dislike you have for your DPs son is dripping off this post.

There was no other party involved and he doesn't need the insurance payout to buy a new car so why would he inform his insurance company and have his premiums affected for the next 5 years? That would make absolutely no sense.

You'd do well to just keep your nose out of it and whatever opinions you have about it to yourself.

imnotsickbutimnotwell · 10/02/2024 20:17

FatPrincess · 10/02/2024 20:12

You're overthinking this, OP. People settle outside of insurance all the time for minor scrapes etc, even when other parties are involved. Usually it's "OK, get a quote and if it's reasonable I'll just pay".

Insurance companies are there for when you need costlier repairs, and the increased premium is to offset against careless customers or bad drivers that end up costing them a fortune. Why should they be given a chance to put up your premium when you haven't even claimed off them?

I bet you don't call your home insurance provider and inform them of every item that gets damaged when you're not claiming.

Did you miss the bit about where he hit a lampost under the influence of drugs and drove off?

Edited to add I assume he drove his written off car home off rather than left the car there or the police would have already been round.

Seaweed42 · 10/02/2024 20:13

Unfortunately that's perfectly legal thing to do with cars.
You can either claim on the insurance or choose to pay for the damage yourself.

The issue of him drug driving and nearly killing himself and endangering others is a different matter.

FatPrincess · 10/02/2024 20:12

You're overthinking this, OP. People settle outside of insurance all the time for minor scrapes etc, even when other parties are involved. Usually it's "OK, get a quote and if it's reasonable I'll just pay".

Insurance companies are there for when you need costlier repairs, and the increased premium is to offset against careless customers or bad drivers that end up costing them a fortune. Why should they be given a chance to put up your premium when you haven't even claimed off them?

I bet you don't call your home insurance provider and inform them of every item that gets damaged when you're not claiming.

imnotsickbutimnotwell · 10/02/2024 20:09

Crikeyalm · 10/02/2024 20:02

He isn’t my son.

If he’s been drug driving and crashed the car you should report him to the police yourself.

OrangeFluff · 10/02/2024 20:04

I work in car insurance and we specifically ask “any accidents, claims or losses in the last 5 years, even if a claim wasn’t made”. So yes he would have to lie on his insurance going forward by not declaring it. It would go down as “notification only” unless the lamppost needed to be repaired.

imnotsickbutimnotwell · 10/02/2024 20:04

ManchesterLu · 10/02/2024 19:44

If he's not claiming off his insurance it's fine. It's not lying. Get the new car then insure it.

Completely wrong advice when there is damage to a third party.

He needs to report the accident to the police and his insurance. He should have called the police at the scene and not left.

He would be “lying” (committing fraud) next time he takes out insurance and does not state he has had an accident in the last x years. His insurance will then be revoked and he will not be able to get insurance at all.

Crikeyalm · 10/02/2024 20:02

He isn’t my son.

OP posts:
MustBeNapTime · 10/02/2024 19:59

DelilahsHaven · 10/02/2024 19:49

But how will telling the insurance improve his driving? Surely the consequence is the loss of the vehicle, so hopefully the lesson is still learnt.

If its a condition of his policy, then I guess he must inform them, but it's seems a bit illogical if its just to create extra consequences to me.

But daddy is buying him a new car, so he doesn't have to learn a lesson! If he has to pay higher premiums (assuming daddy doesn't pay them!), maybe he will learn that bad driving = money out of his pocket, then = lesson learnt!

It's the condition of EVERY policy that accident = informing your insurance.

ShoePalaver · 10/02/2024 19:59

YuleDragon · 10/02/2024 18:43

Lets clear something up.

If you have a single vehicle accident, you are not legally obliged to report it to your insurance, and you can scrap the car and replace it. This is perfectly acceptable to do.

If he hit a lampost, he DOES need to report it to the police and his insurance. THAT is the issue here.

If he hadn't hit the lampost, i'd be telling you to mind your business because scrapping it and not reporting it is absolutely fine.

Surely crashing so hard a car isn't repairable will always involve damage to some other object? What could you crash into that wouldn't be damaged? And whatever you hit would belong to someone.

DelilahsHaven · 10/02/2024 19:58

Crikeyalm · 10/02/2024 19:48

Hmm I am not his greatest fan , he was 90% drug driving .

Well in that case you should surely be reporting it to the police?

imnotsickbutimnotwell · 10/02/2024 19:58

Crikeyalm · 10/02/2024 19:48

Hmm I am not his greatest fan , he was 90% drug driving .

This is so unbelievable now all this drip feeding. I don’t believe any of this is true.