Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Massive Cruise ship holidays

319 replies

Roiesin57 · 09/02/2024 22:30

Do you enjoy them, or do you refuse to take one due to their impact on the environment?
We have taken one a few years ago and we had a lovely time. Everything about it was gorgeous and I fancy another one; but when I look at photos of them they look quite grotesque when they're docked in these relatively little seaside ports abroad.
Have you given up on foreign holidays because of the impact on the environment? And they're so damn expensive too

OP posts:
Thread gallery
7
Poppysmom22 · 10/02/2024 17:27

KreedKafer · 10/02/2024 14:02

That wasn’t my experience of the people of Venice at all. But I didn’t go there on a cruise.

then you wouldn’t have experienced it it’s specific to cruise ship visitors. Venitians have very strong opposition to cruise ships (with good reason a ship that displaces tonnes of water at at time going up and down waterways of a city built on mud was never a great idea) interestingly it was somewhere I always wanted to go but now I will never go back

KimberleyClark · 10/02/2024 17:24

cruisebaba1 · 10/02/2024 16:20

The Queen Mary 2 is not a “resort ship”. I doubt you have been on a Cunard ship, it’s the more traditional elegant ocean liner, beautiful restaurants , great staff, cabins are well appointed. No one would try to go into to dinner on the QM2 with shorts on (as some smaller ships seem to allow this and have a more relaxed dress code. )

No I realise QM2 is more of a ocean liner than a cruise ship. I've never been on a Cunard ship but actually the line I cruise with does have a dress code for the main fine dining restaurant of no shorts or distressed jeans or bare feet. But dinner jackets and evening dresses are not required. Though I do like to wear a summer maxi. We've done the formal dress on the past on P & O ships but no longer care for it.

alfagirl73 · 10/02/2024 17:07

I think cruising is the type of holiday you either love or hate - there is very little in between, but not everyone does like the same type of holiday. I can always tell the people who have never set foot on a cruise ship or even really spoken to someone with a lot of experience of them because the statements people come out with are so far removed from my experience of cruise ships.

For the record, I don't like package holidays or busy resorts, I don't like crowded shopping centres, I don't like places too busy and I don't like "organised fun". I like my space, I like freedom to do things I want, I like posh food and I like peace and quiet and getting away from the crowd. Based on many comments on here, I should hate cruises, right?

I LOVE cruises. They are NOT like Butlins or even close. The ones I have been on have been larger ships - lots of people but I have loved every second, and met some amazing people who have become great friends.

I have never struggled to find quiet spots to relax or felt like the volume of people on board was an issue. Trust me - that would be one of the main things that would've put me off. I am keenly aware of when I am surrounded by too many people and too much noise.

The food on the ships I have been on has been amazing - lots of variety, and some Michelin star quality restaurants as well.

The cabins I've had have been lovely and I've had no complaints about them at all.

I have never felt like any of it was "organised fun". Yes, there are activities on board that you can participate in if that is your type of thing, and there is a wide variety too, but unless you actively seek it out and sign up for it, you never notice it. It is literally up to you how much or how little you do on a cruise holiday.

The excursions - I have never booked one or gone with a tour guide. I usually get off at ports that interest me and have a relaxing day doing my own thing, eating in local restaurants and perhaps making my own way via local transport to any "sights" or points of interest that I particularly want to see.

I often view the stops at ports as an opportunity to check out a place and consider if I may want to book a longer holiday to that particular place. There are a few on my list as a result of visiting on a cruise.

There is something for everyone - I'm not one for sitting in the sun, but I usually find myself a relaxing spot and, as someone who finds it hard to relax generally, cruises are the one place I have always ended up managing to properly relax, read loads of books, enjoy some sea breeze and really feel like I've escaped from the world.

If you like to be active, aside from getting off and exploring at the ports, the ships I've been on have had very impressive gyms. There are usually nice spas as well if you enjoy that type of thing.

The cruises I have been on have not been tacky at all (I hate that sort of thing too!) - in fact quite the opposite.

Yes, some cruise lines and ships have different vibes but I'd be the first to admit that my perception of cruises before I went on them was so far removed from the experience. I love them - my favourite type of holiday. Of course, they're not for everyone, but then life would be boring if everyone liked the same things.

CatamaranViper · 10/02/2024 16:39

bruffin · 10/02/2024 15:26

@Deepmore, how am i looking down on people . I want more out of seeing a place than being rushed and want time to explore. Everything i hear about cuises from friends and relatives tells me that it wouldnt suit us as a couple. I have friends who love cruising but it's not for me.

Tbf, it completely depends on the ships itinerary. Some you get a decent amount of time in ports and others rush you. I found if sail away was 4pm then crew had to be onboard by 3 and usually we couldn't get off until 9/10ish then there wasn't much point exploring. Instead we'd just find the nearest place with free WiFi or local supermarket to buy cabin snacks.

But, if you had an overnight or late sail away (10/11pm) then you'd have loads of time.

bruffin · 10/02/2024 16:37

Deepmore · 10/02/2024 16:27

Then why does it matter to you if people holiday differently to you?

If you read my posts properly i have never had a problem with people holidaying differently to me, really not sure where you picking that up from. I do have an issue with large liners damaging the enviroment in places like Kotor

marmaladeandpeanutbutter · 10/02/2024 16:32

@CatamaranViper Interesting, thank you.

Deepmore · 10/02/2024 16:27

bruffin · 10/02/2024 15:26

@Deepmore, how am i looking down on people . I want more out of seeing a place than being rushed and want time to explore. Everything i hear about cuises from friends and relatives tells me that it wouldnt suit us as a couple. I have friends who love cruising but it's not for me.

Then why does it matter to you if people holiday differently to you?

cruisebaba1 · 10/02/2024 16:20

KimberleyClark · 10/02/2024 09:05

We like smaller ships. Hate massive resort ships. We aren't made to share tables or chum up with people! And we like a variety of holidays and sometimes combine a cruise with a city break.

Can't stand those big resort ships. Once the Queen Mary 2 was docked alongside our ship and dwarfed it. This might give some idea.

The Queen Mary 2 is not a “resort ship”. I doubt you have been on a Cunard ship, it’s the more traditional elegant ocean liner, beautiful restaurants , great staff, cabins are well appointed. No one would try to go into to dinner on the QM2 with shorts on (as some smaller ships seem to allow this and have a more relaxed dress code. )

CatamaranViper · 10/02/2024 16:15

marmaladeandpeanutbutter · 10/02/2024 15:50

Why not @CatamaranViper ?

Mainly because of the other guests and some of the awful behaviour, hygiene standards and attitudes I've seen. I'd either want all my other passengers to be former crew or no other guests onboard

Petrine · 10/02/2024 16:00

@IthinkIamAnAlien

It isn't true to say that the hold is full of sewage. The sewage is treated board the ship and then discharged into the sea far from land.

marmaladeandpeanutbutter · 10/02/2024 15:50

Why not @CatamaranViper ?

BarrelOfOtters · 10/02/2024 15:48

We get them visiting our small island about once a week …. They do spend money and keep some of the attractions going.

ive been on one Carnival type one, it was a work freebie and only for 2 nights, I’d have paid to leave if it had been any longer. Bad food, you had to walk past gambling machines to get anywhere….crowded. Windowless cabin. I dint think it’s representative though.

i have been on a Nile cruise and loved it, watching the river banks go past, hawkers in boats selling stuff and throwing it on to the deck, good food.

CraftyGin · 10/02/2024 15:47

kitsuneghost · 10/02/2024 15:29

I refuse to take one. They are awful for environment and destroy cities. Nothing was than having a gorgeous harbour and one of these monstrosities pull up.
They do nothing for the tourism of that city and who on earth wants to get off at Barcelona for a few hours anyway. Its not like properly visiting a city.

When we were in Barcelona, we did five or six things in the day. It wasn't rushed. The ship docked in a cruise terminal, so didn't destroy the city.

A great thing about cruising is that you get a taster of your destination, so can plan to go back on a more land-based holiday. I am definitely planning that for Rome.

CatamaranViper · 10/02/2024 15:32

I used to work on cruise ships and I would never go on as a guest.
I know too much haha! Plus the best bit was the crew bar

Belovedbagle · 10/02/2024 15:30

This is quite funny- when I posted on this thread that I didn't like cruising I was asked "you must have been on a few to know, so why do you keep going?"... Whereas people who have said they haven't been but don't think it's for them are asked "how do you know if you've never been?"

It seems you can't win, that if for any reason you don't like cruising you're seen as a snob and looking down at those that do.

kitsuneghost · 10/02/2024 15:29

I refuse to take one. They are awful for environment and destroy cities. Nothing was than having a gorgeous harbour and one of these monstrosities pull up.
They do nothing for the tourism of that city and who on earth wants to get off at Barcelona for a few hours anyway. Its not like properly visiting a city.

bruffin · 10/02/2024 15:26

@Deepmore, how am i looking down on people . I want more out of seeing a place than being rushed and want time to explore. Everything i hear about cuises from friends and relatives tells me that it wouldnt suit us as a couple. I have friends who love cruising but it's not for me.

IncompleteSenten · 10/02/2024 15:25

I've never been interested in taking to the seas in a big boat. I watched the Poseidon Adventure when I was a kid and I'm still scared of rogue waves!

TeenLifeMum · 10/02/2024 15:20

I kinda thought it would be like butlins on the sea but I was with friends so was fine with that. What I actually experienced was truly superb! Very clean, amazing food, outstanding west end quality entertainment and a lovely day in Bruges (we only did 3 nights).
i want to do a ffjords cruise (probably dc leave home) and a January/february Caribbean cruise so we can visit lots of places and then pick one to return to in a hotel holiday in the future. There’s one that goes through the Panama Canal to New Orleans I’m eyeing up.

I’m very environmentally friendly I’m other aspects of my life - recycling, minimal work commute but holidays are my treat.

BintuBombatu · 10/02/2024 15:20

IthinkIamAnAlien · 09/02/2024 22:38

Sorry but I think they are grotesque, polluting, probably expensive but I don't care because I wouldn't go on a cruise if it was free. All that poo in the hold, crowds of people, jammed in little cabins, Butlins on sea. Thank goodness many cities are banning them.
And yes, I limit travelling because of the cost to the planet, those cheap flights carry hidden costs. One flight to Australia pre pandemic, wiped out every carbon footprint saving of our entire household.
The planet is precious, thinking carefully before travelling and maybe imposing some limits is something we can all do for the sake of future generations who are going to have to live in a hotter, wetter, troubled world.

Do you have children?

Deepmore · 10/02/2024 15:18

bruffin · 10/02/2024 15:12

@KreedKafer
That is also my issue, i dont see how you adequately get see a place properly having to stick to a cruise schedule.We have done the occassional coach trip on holiday but even they are rushed compared to the pace we normally go at.

Why does everyone have to experience a place the same way as you?

Maybe some people are different to you?

Or maybe the truth is you enjoy looking down on people?

marmaladeandpeanutbutter · 10/02/2024 15:15

The thing which might stop me trying a cruise is a concern about the speedy spread of infection. I was surprised how quickly whole ships went down with covid, for example. Is that correct?

bruffin · 10/02/2024 15:12

@KreedKafer
That is also my issue, i dont see how you adequately get see a place properly having to stick to a cruise schedule.We have done the occassional coach trip on holiday but even they are rushed compared to the pace we normally go at.

dingledangledinkledoo · 10/02/2024 15:06

Who says people don't spend locally?

You can book official trips through the cruise company at eye watering rates , and the cruise company gets richer) but you can also book independently to go on all sorts of trips and tours at EVERY SINGLE PORT.

My DH is a coach driver and everyone a cruise ship docks in Liverpool he does day trips. City tours, Beatles tours, day trips to Chester etc . His company gets paid and so does he and dozens and dozens of other drivers. These holiday makers go to the city centre too, spend money and buy food and go on local independent walking tours. They certainly DO contribute to the local economy and they do it without taking up accommodation.

If you are worried about pollution, travel on euribia with MSC. It's the greenest ship there is apparently.

And as for absorbing the culture, not everybody can afford to go to 5/6 different places for a week at a time to "absorb the culture". Cruising seems to offer a taste of a place that could persuade you to go back and spend longer there in the future. You can also do a cruise that say, starts in Southampton and ends in Barbados, then stay there for a week to explore.

I've never been on a cruise, but I have booked some for the future. It's incredible value too, I booked a two week 2025 Barbados cruise for me and DH with p and o and it was £2200 including flights. I've paid £100 a month for it so it so pretty easy to save that by not buying coffees when out and skipping a weekly cafe lunch when out shopping etc. Then I've booked a 7 day Norwegian fjord cruise in June 2025. Two adults and 2 kids and it was £1050 and I pay £56 a month. Then my sister and I booked a 7day European Christmas market cruise in December with MSC this year to mark a birthday. Two adults, 2 kids and including all inclusive drinks, cocktails and champagne by the glass it was £1350 for all 4 of us. Kids club, loads of restaurants, swimming for the kids and all that entertainment. I'm mega looking forward to it, and I couldn't care less if judgmental people think it's Butlins at sea 😂🤷🏼‍♀️

Sirzy · 10/02/2024 14:57

we have always explored places on our own. The only excursion we have done was to a fantastic WW2 museum when in the fjords because it was the easiest way to get there.

there is such a variety of cruises available that it’s impossible to try to generalise at all. I seem some ships and think “nah not for me” but that doesn’t mean they are bad just a bit too big/busy for my personal taste.

Swipe left for the next trending thread