Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Massive Cruise ship holidays

319 replies

Roiesin57 · 09/02/2024 22:30

Do you enjoy them, or do you refuse to take one due to their impact on the environment?
We have taken one a few years ago and we had a lovely time. Everything about it was gorgeous and I fancy another one; but when I look at photos of them they look quite grotesque when they're docked in these relatively little seaside ports abroad.
Have you given up on foreign holidays because of the impact on the environment? And they're so damn expensive too

OP posts:
Thread gallery
7
Sirzy · 10/02/2024 06:00

We have done P and O cruises and have a princess one booked for next year. They are ideal for autistic DS who can’t fly. Always easy to avoid people and contrary to what some may believe no forced fun (but plenty for people who do want activities)

for me the Royal Caribbean type wouldn’t be my cup of tea but I can see why it appeals to others.

Sirzy · 10/02/2024 05:59

On the environmental note cruise liners are doing a lot with the newer ships to change how they operate to reduce the environmental impact. Like most other industries they are responding to what we now know and changing accordingly. Its Not perfect of course it isn’t but it’s getting betters

judgementfail · 10/02/2024 05:51

Shoxfordian · 10/02/2024 05:42

I've been on a few cruises, I like them a lot - they're not all tacky with beige food and a tiny pool, it really depends on what lines you go on

We went on a virgin one last year to Croatia, was great

I realise that. The OPs post was about 'massive' cruise ship holidays to which I assumed she meant Princess, Carnival, NCL, P&O

Shoxfordian · 10/02/2024 05:42

I've been on a few cruises, I like them a lot - they're not all tacky with beige food and a tiny pool, it really depends on what lines you go on

We went on a virgin one last year to Croatia, was great

IloveAslan · 10/02/2024 05:36

judgementfail · 10/02/2024 03:09

Utterly utterly awful things in every way imaginable. I've seen 'walkthrough' videos of cruise ships and they are so lacking in any kind of refinement or class.
Shops, amusement arcades, wall to wall noise and people. Buffets of brown food and the clientele look like the kind of people I would pay to avoid. Packed tight sun loungers around a tiny pool with bodies everywhere and some kind of brash loud holiday park 'fun' game going on with blasting music.
Seriously hell on earth.
The environmental and local impact is appalling too.
I live in Nz and to see and hear these floating fucking monstrosities in the pristine natural wonder of Milford sound was one of the most depressing sights I've experienced.

Yep, it's obscene.

IloveAslan · 10/02/2024 05:35

I wouldn't go on a cruise if you paid me to, as a pp said they are just glorified floating holiday camps and I've never understood the attraction. I don't go on foreign holidays either.

Flottie · 10/02/2024 03:16

I refuse to go on one because they’re tacky as hell

NewYear24 · 10/02/2024 03:15

I enjoy cruising and many other types of holidays.

judgementfail · 10/02/2024 03:09

Utterly utterly awful things in every way imaginable. I've seen 'walkthrough' videos of cruise ships and they are so lacking in any kind of refinement or class.
Shops, amusement arcades, wall to wall noise and people. Buffets of brown food and the clientele look like the kind of people I would pay to avoid. Packed tight sun loungers around a tiny pool with bodies everywhere and some kind of brash loud holiday park 'fun' game going on with blasting music.
Seriously hell on earth.
The environmental and local impact is appalling too.
I live in Nz and to see and hear these floating fucking monstrosities in the pristine natural wonder of Milford sound was one of the most depressing sights I've experienced.

Deepmore · 10/02/2024 03:01

We did lots of Pontins holidays when I was growing up. My dad was a working man and my mum was a school dinner lady. They had 4 kids and it was all they could afford. Nice to know people like you were laughing at them because they were poor.

You seem to have awarded yourself some sort of superior status but laugh at poor people. I don't think that paints you in a good light.

QueenBitch666 · 10/02/2024 01:46

Floating Pontins. You couldn't pay me enough to go on one of those chav magnets Grin

caringcarer · 10/02/2024 01:45

EdinaMonsoon · 10/02/2024 00:52

I live on a Greek island that thankfully has a ban on cruise ships. Despite this, myself and many other volunteers spend hours every week clearing up rubbish and debris on the beaches from passing cruise ships, despite our council doing weekly cleans during the height of the tourist season. It is truly hideous.

I see these towering, sea faring apartment blocks up close on neighbouring islands and they are hideous. The passengers getting on and off in a rush, surging en mass to the bus or taxi. Not giving a crap about others because they are on a tight schedule. There’s no sense of individual adventure. They rarely have time to make it much further than the port or main town. And frankly, whilst they might be able to state that they have visited XYZ, they really haven’t. At best they have had a week or two on a floating hotel with a couple of hours spent in the port of one island or another.

All the cruises I have been on dock for 10 hours in most ports, not just a couple of hours.

SiobhanSharpe · 10/02/2024 01:43

I'd like to go on one of the new (but still quite small) Hurtigruten ships visiting Antarctica but the cruises are incredibly expensive -- starting prices are around £12,000 pp.

caringcarer · 10/02/2024 01:42

I love a cruise holiday. I've been on 5 now. 2 weeks and visiting about 10 countries. I get off at each port, sometimes go for a tour or sometimes just go off for a wander around, get a meal, an ice cream then go back to ship. Entertainment is good in the evenings, food is good and plentiful. You meet new interesting people most days. Best of all some sun in November which is good for my arthritis. You go to sleep and wake up in a different place. Very relaxing.

montelbano · 10/02/2024 01:32

Shadowsindarkplaces · 10/02/2024 00:21

I went on the Hurtigruten coastal express, small ferry ship up the coast if Norway. It is used as a ferry, and as such, I decided it was best of both worlds.

I went on a Hurtigruten ship as well. It was a great mix of tourists and locals going home for Xmas. As you said it was a ferry for both cars and foot passengers (stopping at 3am to let a family get off at a tiny village). Cabins were comfortable and clean but quite basic. The food was absolutely fantastic esp if you like fish. The staff were efficient and very professional. Times in port varied according to the size of the port and varied from 30 minutes to 6 hours which was plenty of time to wander around, etc.
However a number of British passengers were upset as there was no nightly entertainment, there were few daylight hours, the Northern lights had a habit of appearing in the early hours so they had to get out of warm comfy beds, etc., etc. If they had read the brochure properly , then it might have sunk in that this was a working boat with space for tourists who didn't want to be cossetted and waited on every moment of the day.
One of the best bits was when a heel came off my boot; a heel that had just been repaired in UK. Reception said they would send it down to Engineering; 15 years later and heel still intact!

SouthLondonMum22 · 10/02/2024 01:14

We went on a Caribbean cruise several years ago and it was wonderful. Definitely spent money in all of the areas we visited too including tipping taxi drivers etc.

We went with P&O and it was a good experience, it was Ventura.

QueenMegan · 10/02/2024 01:12

My idea of hell but each to their own.

Crumpleton · 10/02/2024 01:10

I've done a few Thomson/TUI cruises and loved going.
It suited as my idea of a holiday is not being stuck on one island/city and pretty much seeing most if it within the first few days of being there.
I loved waking up and visiting part of a new country daily.

Back then the ships were smaller in size, nothing like the size of the MSC ships, although the cabins were a perfect size and not once did I ever feel on any it was over crowded.

fridaynight1 · 10/02/2024 01:02

Why settle for one country when you can go to seven? We always book our excursions with local tour guides. Always eat locally and always buy from local shops. And hell - what a way to see Pompeii, Ravello, Amalfi coast, the Colosseum, Vatican Trevi fountain, Ephesus, the Parthenon, La Sagrada, Lisbon and lots more .. all on one holiday.
Cruises may be exhausting but beat 2 weeks sitting by a pool by a mile.

EdinaMonsoon · 10/02/2024 00:52

I live on a Greek island that thankfully has a ban on cruise ships. Despite this, myself and many other volunteers spend hours every week clearing up rubbish and debris on the beaches from passing cruise ships, despite our council doing weekly cleans during the height of the tourist season. It is truly hideous.

I see these towering, sea faring apartment blocks up close on neighbouring islands and they are hideous. The passengers getting on and off in a rush, surging en mass to the bus or taxi. Not giving a crap about others because they are on a tight schedule. There’s no sense of individual adventure. They rarely have time to make it much further than the port or main town. And frankly, whilst they might be able to state that they have visited XYZ, they really haven’t. At best they have had a week or two on a floating hotel with a couple of hours spent in the port of one island or another.

saltinesandcoffeecups · 10/02/2024 00:50

My opinion… they’re not for me (been on one…had a good time but won’t go out of my way to back on one) but go if you enjoyed it and think you would again.

Buy stuff from the people hawking in the markets, have a drink when in port, tip your taxi driver…once an economy tips to a tourist based one, then tourist money is key.

Marchintospring · 10/02/2024 00:48

MissAmbrosia · 09/02/2024 22:48

Cruise liners are like the vultures of the holiday world. Disgorge their multitudes into the same small spaces without spending much money within the local infrastructure. Poor people following a local guided tour just for the day with their headphones on, and not getting to experience anything about a place. That new behemoth liner!

Equally Airbnb's and holiday cottage cause massive long term problems for the resident populations. Both small towns and large tourist cities have cracked down. Which leaves hotels with their daily towel changing and buffets and pools no different to cruises.

Maybe its better if 5,000 people see Barcelona on one journey than on 2,000 individual flights? Cruise ship passengers are no different to any other day trippers; they buy stuff, they go to bars and restaurants and they use local services like taxis.
Cruise ships are also trying to convert to other fuel than crappy grade diesel mostly to comply with ever more environmental conscious law. Things improve every year.

Flamme · 10/02/2024 00:43

I wouldn't go because I can't see the attraction. SIL went on a cruise to celebrate a big birthday and was hell-bent on us joining her, but fortunately we managed to get out of it. I would have really resented paying out all that money and using up a big chunk of my annual leave for a stay in a glorified floating holiday camp.

HeddaGarbled · 10/02/2024 00:31

Hundreds of visitors every year who are not spending locally

I think the port fees and the tour groups bring a lot of money in, so there’s a conflict between the local population and local governance.

Passingthethyme · 10/02/2024 00:31

IthinkIamAnAlien · 09/02/2024 22:38

Sorry but I think they are grotesque, polluting, probably expensive but I don't care because I wouldn't go on a cruise if it was free. All that poo in the hold, crowds of people, jammed in little cabins, Butlins on sea. Thank goodness many cities are banning them.
And yes, I limit travelling because of the cost to the planet, those cheap flights carry hidden costs. One flight to Australia pre pandemic, wiped out every carbon footprint saving of our entire household.
The planet is precious, thinking carefully before travelling and maybe imposing some limits is something we can all do for the sake of future generations who are going to have to live in a hotter, wetter, troubled world.

You do realise that there is probably even more poo coming off planes right?