Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Have I been a victim of identity theft?

57 replies

Monkey987 · 09/02/2024 20:45

Aibu to worry about my credit score?

So I always assumed I had a 'good' credit score so was surprised when I checked recently before booking a mortgage in principle appointment with my bank that actually my credit score is low. Around 550.

I have never had any debt (except car repayments) but also very little credit/contracts to boost my score.

For a bit of background I am a care leaver with no family to rely on, got a council flat at 18 and have been very careful/worried with my money. Never had a phone contract etc. I've always saved for things and paid outright.

I've been sensible, went to uni, now earn nearly £50000 a year at 28. Have been paying car finance reliably for 2 years. Have paid all utility bills monthly/ on time for 8 years. So stupidly assumed I would have good credit.

Apparently not. I've taken out a credit card to boost my score which I'm paying back monthly via direct debit.

What else am I doing wrong?

A friend of mine said it sounds like I've been a victim of fraud. I'm now freaked out and have no one in real life to ask.

Aibu to worry?
How long will it take me to boost my score with a credit card?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
MrsRandallFraser · 10/02/2024 09:32

@Densol57 has given the best answer so far OP. You need to check your credit file not just your credit score.

There's a website called checkmyfile. You can sign up for month's free trial. It will show any and all credit you've ever had, the payments you've made and what might be bringing your score down.

I do everything 'right', no missed payments etc but score is 'lower' than it could be because of the electoral roll. There was a problem with our address and it affected my score. Absolutely nothing to do with something I'd done and no identity fraud.

I found the website after a mortgage broker suggested checking it. It's really really interesting and I hope it puts your mind at ease.

SunflowerSeeds123 · 10/02/2024 09:08

Despite having an excellent credit score on two companies my bank won't give me a credit card. I can't make head nor tail of it.

HPenthusiast · 10/02/2024 04:22

Sorry I haven’t been able to read the whole thread but I used to be an admin assistant for a broker so these are what they used to suggest to help-
Try not to have too many bank accounts open if you don’t use them - starling - monzo for example
Having credit is good but they don’t want you using it all up. So if you have a 4k limit, don’t max it out, the more available credit you have the better
Check your report to make sure there’s no old phone/ utility bills etc that have defaulted. We had a few customers who thought they had closed their phone contract years ago but hadn’t and it was showing them owing money. They managed to speak to the company and get it removed but it took a month or so to come off the report.
Having a broker will really help you as they will get you the best deals and organise everything for you.

DragonGypsyDoris · 09/02/2024 22:59

Maxxing out on a new credit card is unlikely to increase your score; it's about managing debt and living within your means, not just creating a big debt and paying it off. When you have successfully serviced a mortgage for two or three years your credit score will increase.

BobbyBiscuits · 09/02/2024 22:56

If you haven't borrowed and paid back a lot then your score will be lower. Being careful is not what makes the banks their money is it, unfortunately. So it's a bit of a scam in itself to encourage people to take credit when they don't really need to. If you do need to then...yeah, not so easy.
If your bank accounts haven't been tampered with/ no money stolen I don't think it's identity fraud. Have you had weird bills coming to your home or anything? I think you can contact the credit agencies to get more details about this stuff/ your score but I reckon they might want payment.

SecondHandFurniture · 09/02/2024 22:46

I'm in the mortgage industry. You need a mortgage broker. Don't go straight to your bank; they can only offer you their own products and there'll almost certainly be a cheaper rate elsewhere.

I wouldn't advise taking out credit now; it won't help if you are close to applying. Check My File is the best place to check your history as it has 3 credit score companies on the same report. I had one that only showed on one of the 3.

Monkey987 · 09/02/2024 22:39

Bluewallss · 09/02/2024 22:24

Yes! Not regularly but we are on good terms. Talk every 2 weeks and see her 3 times a year. Certainly don’t talk about money.

I thought I would never talk to her again. I blamed her for my life being shite. As time passed I realised we shared the same trauma from losing my dad and neither of us knew how to process it. So while I still feel animosity for how badly she has treated me in the past I have some understanding over her actions which have lead to forgiveness.

That's nice to hear. I'm completely the same with my mum.

I completely forgive her and don't blame her.
I still lend her money but she pays it back cos we still have a funny awkward relationship where she knows she has to be be nice ish to me to get me to reply.

OP posts:
Foxblue · 09/02/2024 22:37

I was in a similar position to you OP, except I didn't even have car finance history. Lots of older people (as in 40+) told me that I would have to get a credit card and pay it off, but both my mortgage advisor and mortgage provider assured me that it just wasn't necessary as I otherwise had a consistent history of paying bills/DD, no debt, earnt a good wage etc. I think in the days where direct debit for bills was less common it carried more weight, but it doesn't seem to much now. A mortgage advisor will help with this! Worth popping into any local fb pages you might be part of and asking for recommendations of a local one.

Bluewallss · 09/02/2024 22:24

Monkey987 · 09/02/2024 22:12

F**king hell. This makes me thankful we were estranged from my mum for a while since we became adults.

My mums crazy but has never tried that... Partly because I think she couldn't actually figure it out.
Thank God for your uncle.

Do you talk to your mum now?

Yes! Not regularly but we are on good terms. Talk every 2 weeks and see her 3 times a year. Certainly don’t talk about money.

I thought I would never talk to her again. I blamed her for my life being shite. As time passed I realised we shared the same trauma from losing my dad and neither of us knew how to process it. So while I still feel animosity for how badly she has treated me in the past I have some understanding over her actions which have lead to forgiveness.

Densol57 · 09/02/2024 22:20

Loads of totally wrong replies on here. Why oh why do people ask legal or technical questions on AIBU ?

Credit scores are mickey mouse made up numbers by these "credit scoring companies" to sell you credit products. Banks do NOT see these credit scores. A credit "scoring" factors in lots of stuff added onto your credit HISTORY. See there is a difference !
You should check your credit history for the correct amount of loans, credit agreements etc. Are they YOURS ? Yes ? Obviously no identity theft 🤣

All paid on time, no missed payments - good.
How much line of credit do you have (credit card available credit ) - are you using more than 30% - not good
Had lots of house moves in 3 years - not good
held a bank account for a while - good
plus on electoral register - good
No fraud links - good
Lots of "hard" searches recently - not good
Income ( credit agencies dont have this so how can they fully score ?? )
Employment length - ditto above
What you are buying ? Is credit secured or not secured
Etc etc

As you can see SO MUCH MORE goes into credit scoring for an actual application for a credit product than some silly made up score

Monkey987 · 09/02/2024 22:12

Bluewallss · 09/02/2024 22:06

When I was 18 she asked if she could make an account with Very using my details so that she could get 20% off as it was for new members only. I said yes and though nothing of it. It wasn’t a Very account it was a Very credit card.

I realised when I was 22. It caused a huge rift. I’m very very very fortunate that my uncle found out and paid it off, so my mum owed him the money instead.

F**king hell. This makes me thankful we were estranged from my mum for a while since we became adults.

My mums crazy but has never tried that... Partly because I think she couldn't actually figure it out.
Thank God for your uncle.

Do you talk to your mum now?

OP posts:
Okki · 09/02/2024 22:10

Look at London and country - they're excellent brokers. I've used them more than once and they're always recommended on here. Good luck with buying your home.

Throwaway0912 · 09/02/2024 22:09

If you have been a victim of fraud, it will show on your credit report as a CIFAS warning. You'd know about it. Experian for a free trial or clearscore, who use experian data but is free.

Check you recognise everything and query anything you don't.

Ultimately, lenders don't look at credit scores. They look at how you pay, how you run credit, your pattern of borrowing. Missed payments are a red flag, as are late or returned direct debits on your bank account - poor money management or signs of financial struggle.
Running credit to the limits and making minimum payments is a risk - looks like you're living outwith your means.

Taking multiple short term loans, or multiple borrowing/new accounts doesn't look good either - points again to either poor money management or signs of struggle.

In very basic terms, lenders are looking to see that their investment in you is a safe one. Someone who runs their finances responsibly, paying things on time and borrowing within a reasonable limit is a safer bet than someone who consistently misses payments. Someone who has credit cards maxed, opens new credit accounts every other month and runs those balances up too, could fall outwith responsible lending criteria that institutions must adhere to.

There are so many myths and misinformation around credit files, it's difficult to know where to start.

Monkey987 · 09/02/2024 22:07

Acapulco12 · 09/02/2024 22:03

You don’t need to sign up every year. You just need to sign up each time you move house.

Have you ever voted in an election (e.g. general election or local council/mayor elections)? If you have, that means you were on the electoral roll, as you have to be on it to vote.

This link gives you more info: https://www.gov.uk/electoral-register

This is what I thought. I signed up years ago when I was 19 so assumed I was signed up. They then sent me letter a couple of years later so I signed up again and haven't heard anything again since.
I've signed up again online just now just in case. You know what the council are like...

OP posts:
Bluewallss · 09/02/2024 22:06

Monkey987 · 09/02/2024 21:30

This is my fear. I have some dodgy family members. I want to trust them but since my friend said this I can't let it go that maybe she's right.

How did your mum manage to do it in your name?

When I was 18 she asked if she could make an account with Very using my details so that she could get 20% off as it was for new members only. I said yes and though nothing of it. It wasn’t a Very account it was a Very credit card.

I realised when I was 22. It caused a huge rift. I’m very very very fortunate that my uncle found out and paid it off, so my mum owed him the money instead.

Acapulco12 · 09/02/2024 22:03

Monkey987 · 09/02/2024 21:13

I'm pretty sure I'm on the electorol role.
Do you have to sign up every year?

You don’t need to sign up every year. You just need to sign up each time you move house.

Have you ever voted in an election (e.g. general election or local council/mayor elections)? If you have, that means you were on the electoral roll, as you have to be on it to vote.

This link gives you more info: https://www.gov.uk/electoral-register

The electoral register and the 'open register'

Getting on the electoral register, what happens if you do not register to vote, registering in more than one place, how to opt out of the 'open register', registering anonymously and how to view the electoral register

https://www.gov.uk/electoral-register

acecat · 09/02/2024 22:02

No worries! From what you've said, it sounds like you won't have any trouble getting a mortgage with a mainstream lender, but speaking with a mortgage advisor may put you at ease. Best of luck with your flat! 😀

Monkey987 · 09/02/2024 22:00

acecat · 09/02/2024 21:57

Mortgage lenders don't use your credit 'score' from Experian to make decisions. Each will have its own criteria they'll measure you against, including how many recent credit applications, repayment history, no. of defaults if any, current salary. The number itself is really just there as a summary for you. If you search for a lender and mortgage criteria, you'll often find the intermediary page for brokers which will explain their specific criteria.

A mortgage broker will look at your financial history and current circumstances, and find the mortgage lenders you're most likely to be accepted with. The mortgage lender will pay them a fee, so many are free to use for you. They often handle the paperwork of the application as well.

Edited

OK thanks. I was just looking at high street banks and building societies mostly so this is good to know.

OP posts:
acecat · 09/02/2024 21:57

Mortgage lenders don't use your credit 'score' from Experian to make decisions. Each will have its own criteria they'll measure you against, including how many recent credit applications, repayment history, no. of defaults if any, current salary. The number itself is really just there as a summary for you. If you search for a lender and mortgage criteria, you'll often find the intermediary page for brokers which will explain their specific criteria.

A mortgage broker will look at your financial history and current circumstances, and find the mortgage lenders you're most likely to be accepted with. The mortgage lender will pay them a fee, so many are free to use for you. They often handle the paperwork of the application as well.

Monkey987 · 09/02/2024 21:53

Daisymay2 · 09/02/2024 21:49

My son got his mortgage in 2022 and has never had a credit card, and still doesn’t have one. He had rented for several years and paid utilities reliably, so ignore comments on needing £14k available credit although it’s not a bad idea, provided you set it up so that it is paid in full monthly.
for brokers I would recommend London and Country, l’ve used them and both my kids used them as well.
It’s worth joining Martin Lewis’s MSE credit club and monitor your score every month.

Thanks for this. This is what I thought. I've saved a 20% deposit so thought this would be fine.

Can you explain what a mortgage broker actually does? I'm clueless :-(
Just assumed I would need a surveyor to check everything over?

OP posts:
Daisymay2 · 09/02/2024 21:49

My son got his mortgage in 2022 and has never had a credit card, and still doesn’t have one. He had rented for several years and paid utilities reliably, so ignore comments on needing £14k available credit although it’s not a bad idea, provided you set it up so that it is paid in full monthly.
for brokers I would recommend London and Country, l’ve used them and both my kids used them as well.
It’s worth joining Martin Lewis’s MSE credit club and monitor your score every month.

Monkey987 · 09/02/2024 21:45

MadMapleSyrup · 09/02/2024 21:40

This. Opening too many new credit accounts negatively impacts your score. Just use existing credit for general purchases you normally would. I use my credit card for my monthly petrol and pay it back in full each month for example.

You should access your credit file if you are wanting a mortgage, so I’d recommend you sign up to Experian or similar. You can usually get a free trial.
I had an incident where a lender had made an error and it showed as a default on my credit file. Had I not been a checker of my score and noticed the drop I wouldn’t have known until I came to remortgage. I managed to get this wiped from my file by the lender as it was their error and that sent my score back up, but did take a month or two for it to be corrected.

This really worries me. I will look now

OP posts:
Haggisfish3 · 09/02/2024 21:43

Monkey987 · 09/02/2024 21:34

Where can I get a mortgage advisor cheaply?

I will send you a pm with who i used-we might both get some money from it! 🤣

MadMapleSyrup · 09/02/2024 21:40

PoppingTomorrow · 09/02/2024 21:21

Accept any credit you are given

Don't do this.

Use your credit card for main spends and pay it off in full.

Don't go wild taking out loads of credit- it Is a negative factor to have too many lines of credit open.

This. Opening too many new credit accounts negatively impacts your score. Just use existing credit for general purchases you normally would. I use my credit card for my monthly petrol and pay it back in full each month for example.

You should access your credit file if you are wanting a mortgage, so I’d recommend you sign up to Experian or similar. You can usually get a free trial.
I had an incident where a lender had made an error and it showed as a default on my credit file. Had I not been a checker of my score and noticed the drop I wouldn’t have known until I came to remortgage. I managed to get this wiped from my file by the lender as it was their error and that sent my score back up, but did take a month or two for it to be corrected.

Monkey987 · 09/02/2024 21:34

Laurama91 · 09/02/2024 21:32

You dont need to spend all of it. But they like to see you using it well. You could put petrol every month and make sure you pay it off. If you're wanting to get mortage soon be careful taking out credit. Maybe speak to mortgage advisor

Where can I get a mortgage advisor cheaply?

OP posts:
Swipe left for the next trending thread