Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Or is DDs ballet teacher too intense?!?

93 replies

FrenchFancie · 09/02/2024 20:02

I can’t decide if I’m being a bit PFB here but.

DD is 11, has been dancing since 4, mostly at a different school. We moved house 18 months ago and she started a new ballet school and this woman is intense to say the least! DD has to do 3-4 hours of ballet every week and isn’t allowed to miss lessons - if she does she may get ‘chopped’ from one of the classes.

the kids regularly come out from classes in tears. I’ve tried to speak to the teacher on several occasions but she’s always too busy. The one time I did get to speak to her I was told ‘I know my teaching methods get the best from the girls so I’m not going to change anything’

i understand from DD that the teacher very rarely praises the girls, instead she’s very critical ‘that needs more work’ and ‘that’s not good enough’. A girl has been sent away from class today and told she can’t continue with it because her feet are wrong and her physique is wrong (I assume the teacher means she’s too plump).

i get that DD is moving up through the grades and therefore things get harder, but this seems to be so intense and unpleasant . I hate seeing DD and the other girls cry. She’s not going to be a professional dancer- this is just meant to be a fun hobby.

whats other people’s experience of ballet beyond grade 3? If we change schools will it be just as bad elsewhere?

and is her teacher too intense or am I just being PFB and assuming it should be more fun than this?

OP posts:
wellington77 · 09/02/2024 22:12

I’m a teacher, this is no way to treat children. I honestly can’t work out why you haven’t pulled your daughter out of the class yet especially as it’s just a hobby. Her mental health could become permanently affected by this. I’d also get in contact with whoever oversees dancing teachers in this country and complain, or better yet band with the other parents and demand a meeting this woman or write a group letter to get her to stop her awful behaviour

Malbecfan · 09/02/2024 22:09

madeinmanc · 09/02/2024 20:19

That's how life in the arts is, rightly or wrongly. Music tends to be the same.

As a music teacher, I think this is unfair. I teach class music, run ensembles and do instrumental teaching and have done for >30 years. My DDs took instrumental lessons and this was never our experience. Please don't generalise.

MrsBennetsPoorNerves · 09/02/2024 22:07

It sounds toxic... move her to a healthier environment. Not all dance schools are like this.

Malbecfan · 09/02/2024 22:04

Agreeing with everyone else. Both my DDs did ballet from age 2 to 18 then danced for fun at uni. Both did up to grade 8 in ballet, grade 5 tap and DD2 did IDTA Inter too. Their ex-professional teacher and her assistant were never anything other than encouraging. In your position, I would move your DD.

Also, I was always allowed to sit in lessons - mostly I didn't want to, but when they did a 45 minute pointe class on a school night, I did. I was always welcomed and made to feel part of the group. As a courtesy if we had an issue with a lesson or illness, we would let the teachers know, and it was never an issue (and we didn't get charged for it). I know we were lucky but it sounds like the OP has a raw deal.

Pointey · 09/02/2024 22:03

Get her out of there. I have a dd who has done IF (and beyond) and is in a dance school that sends a lot to vocational schools. This is not good teaching, it is not necessary and it is harmful to your dd and the other children.

MoserRothOrangeandAlmond · 09/02/2024 22:01

Switch dancing schools!
I'm now 35 but I've danced since I was 10 and I did grade 1 up to advanced 2 in ballet (last exam when I was 20)
My teacher never treat us like that!
For me it's always been a hobby but for other people I danced with they have gone into to professional dance schools post 18 and have gone onto professional dancers/performers. So she gets good results from not treating her pupils awfully!
My daughter and niece go to the same school now and love it.

Thankyouthankyoujellybean · 09/02/2024 21:56

I was taught by ex-pros who had the highest standards. A good number from our school went on to become professional dancers. They never behaved anything like this.

The only time I remember someone being banned from class was when she got too thin. We danced until our feet bled, absolutely, but that was our choice. Almost weekly we were jokingly reminded that we'd need hip replacements by the time we were 30.

There are ways of motivating children, and I do not feel that this is it at all.

zeibesaffron · 09/02/2024 21:52

My sister is an ex ballet teacher - she took pupils up through all the grades, they had fun, no one was body shamed - or told they couldn’t come to lessons or perform in the shows. Please remove your DD from this class its toxic. Can you report the teacher to their professional body (IDTA I think)

Theredfoxfliesatmidnight · 09/02/2024 21:31

Ballet is a very strict discipline and your child is an older child. I would not be expecting head pats and cuddles at this stage. If she is looking for a hobby rather than a profession now is probably the time to change her class to something else.

Astonetogo · 09/02/2024 21:19

Sounds like a toxic ‘Abby Lee Millet’ type teacher on a massive ego trip.

Take your child elsewhere, there are lots of lovely dance schools out there.

Trivium4all · 09/02/2024 21:05

madeinmanc · 09/02/2024 20:19

That's how life in the arts is, rightly or wrongly. Music tends to be the same.

But it doesn't have to be. It's perfectly possible to get "the best" out of students without being destructive. If a student has professional aspirations, then of course honest conversations are needed about what the requirements are and the effort it will take to get there, and it's also true that this honesty won't always be well received, but there's a big difference between that and plain brutality.

Frozenasarock · 09/02/2024 20:52

Regardless of whether my child said they were happy to continue or not, I as the adult with a much better perspective on things than a child would be pulling them out of those classes immediately. I know far too many people who had serious mental health problems and eating disorders from dance and gymnastics experiences, it’s one reason I’ve never allowed my daughter to do those activities. There is nothing precious about protecting your child from abuse and bullying.

MargaretThursday · 09/02/2024 20:50

madeinmanc · 09/02/2024 20:19

That's how life in the arts is, rightly or wrongly. Music tends to be the same.

It's not always.

My dc have done various music, private lessons and groups and even though they've got pretty high up, it's been about encouragement and mutual enjoyment.
And they've done drama/Musical theatre, which can be pretty intense, but their group is lovely and very supportive of each other.

In both they've ended up with really good friends, and loved the instructors.

Catsare · 09/02/2024 20:42

Pull her out . It's not a healthy atmosphere for dd anyway. Join her some other dance class or another activity once she feels ready . No point in talking to someone who is doing this on regular basis. I would though speak to other parents as well. It's not okay at all.

BorisIsACuntWaffle · 09/02/2024 20:40

Fucking hell. My DD is similar age to yours and is in grade 4. She'd want to stop if was coming out crying. Move her

Scirocco · 09/02/2024 20:38

No kid needs that shit. Get her out and let her go do something that makes her feel happy and good about herself.

Londonrach1 · 09/02/2024 20:36

Sounds awful. I'd be removing my child from this. Find another class. Tbh it's not worth the stress. I have a dd who loves ballet and being it since 3...we taken a break for a term ..she misses it but the pressure has gone..and she can do playdates...ballet parents seems ott some are normal but lots are ott. I'm glad we backed away...might try modern dance instead...

FrenchFancie · 09/02/2024 20:34

thanks for everyone’s comments - I’ve thought for a while that this teacher was quite toxic, but I wasn’t sure if it was just me being a bit precious.

DD started doing grade 4 and inter foundation in September - every week someone is threatened with having their invite to IF revoked if they don’t meet the standard. Apparently the teacher has a big tick sheet and will say things like ‘Maisie gets three ticks this week but Annabelle only gets one and SOME of you have none at all’. As parents we are never allowed in the room so I don’t see her teach, but I hung out in the hallway today and herd her shouting at the girls for not answering a question.

DD made the school hockey team (which she was dead proud about) but couldn’t play the match she was selected for because she would be late to ballet and the teacher ‘wouldn’t allow it and I won’t be able to continue with IF’.

everything just seems so pressured and if the girls make even a tiny slip they are threatened with no IF, that IF is a privilege and it will be revoked at any sign of weakness.

DD seems happy enough that she leaves when we spoke about it in the car. Such a sham as she used to love dancing and did shows but seems so stressed by it all now.

OP posts:
WhereYouLeftIt · 09/02/2024 20:26

The ballet teacher is preening herself and her "teaching methods" at the expense of small children.

I would get my daughter out of there ASAP. Find another ballet school, or another hobby. But do not leave your daughter at this woman's mercy - because she has no mercy.

goingrouge · 09/02/2024 20:26

My god, take the child out immediately. You are paying for your daughter to be in a toxic and abusive environment. No fucking talent or skill is worth that.

madeinmanc · 09/02/2024 20:19

That's how life in the arts is, rightly or wrongly. Music tends to be the same.

badwolf82 · 09/02/2024 20:18

Sounds incredibly toxic. A children’s dance teacher should only ever critique technique, not physique. And critique should always be done in a way that helps build the child up, not tear them down. Stress and tears and misery have no place in a children’s activity.

MargaretThursday · 09/02/2024 20:18

Get her out asap.

I was talking the other day with a ex-fellow ballet mum. When our dc were small we thought the ballet teacher was lovely. She seemed very sweet to the children.

When my dd2 was about 10yo I spoke to the ballet teacher because she'd been saying one of the girls was being nasty to her in lessons (she is missing her arm and the child in question was making comments about it being "disgusting" and things like that). I'd I witnessed it outside the lessons, exactly what dd2 had been saying. The ballet teacher started by denying it, then when I said I'd seen it told me that she should "rise above it". Which I didn't feel was exactly what I'd have expected from a teacher, but thought maybe she'd taken it in and would now watch out for it.

No. About 4 weeks later one of the other mums came to me and asked if I knew "dd2 was being bullied in class." I started to say what had happened, and said could she speak up about it too, and she stopped me, and said "no, by the ballet teacher." Her dd had told her that the teacher was picking on dd2, by telling her to do things, then shouting at her, not letting her have a turn and things. She said she hadn't believed it, so she had stood behind the curtain to watch a lessons and seen exactly what her dd had said.
We both pulled out daughters out that week. It triggered a mental health crisis including self harm in my dd that took about 5 years to recover from.

My older daughter wanted to continue. It was only when she stopped a year later, she told me that the ballet teacher had refused to speak to her, or her best friend in the class, after I'd pulled dd2 out.

Anyway I was talking to this ex-fellow ballet mum who'd had 2 girls who went all the way through from 3-18yo and as far as I knew they both loved it, and she'd thought it was great. And she said to me that she'd only discovered the damage the teacher had done to both her dds after they'd stopped. They'd put up with so many destructive comments that they'd internalised.

So I'm telling you, pull her out now. Ours appeared on the outside lovely, but it wasn't. If you can see them coming out in tears then I can guarantee that they're putting up with a lot inside.

(And if your dancing school has the initials MT, which isn't the one mine went to, then she's well known for not just having the children in tears, but I've known several parents who have been in tears from what she has said too)

LittleMousewithcloggson · 09/02/2024 20:18

Get her out straight away. If she was going to be a top ballerina and this woman was the best teacher in Europe then I MIGHT leave her there, if she really really wanted to stay. If it’s something she really enjoys but probably wont make a career out of it then my aim would be to keep her enjoying it and her mental health would be my top priority

Ionacat · 09/02/2024 20:17

It’s not normal. DD is grade 5 and also doing inter foundation and this is for fun. She does around 4.5 hours of ballet a week (then tap and modern on top.) Her teacher (and now teachers) work them hard and they really have to earn praise, but they also laugh and enjoy it. There’s a scale of looks apparently but the dance teacher is in on the joke! The dance school do get a number each year to professional dance training but also most do it for fun and that’s the most important thing.