Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Or is DDs ballet teacher too intense?!?

93 replies

FrenchFancie · 09/02/2024 20:02

I can’t decide if I’m being a bit PFB here but.

DD is 11, has been dancing since 4, mostly at a different school. We moved house 18 months ago and she started a new ballet school and this woman is intense to say the least! DD has to do 3-4 hours of ballet every week and isn’t allowed to miss lessons - if she does she may get ‘chopped’ from one of the classes.

the kids regularly come out from classes in tears. I’ve tried to speak to the teacher on several occasions but she’s always too busy. The one time I did get to speak to her I was told ‘I know my teaching methods get the best from the girls so I’m not going to change anything’

i understand from DD that the teacher very rarely praises the girls, instead she’s very critical ‘that needs more work’ and ‘that’s not good enough’. A girl has been sent away from class today and told she can’t continue with it because her feet are wrong and her physique is wrong (I assume the teacher means she’s too plump).

i get that DD is moving up through the grades and therefore things get harder, but this seems to be so intense and unpleasant . I hate seeing DD and the other girls cry. She’s not going to be a professional dancer- this is just meant to be a fun hobby.

whats other people’s experience of ballet beyond grade 3? If we change schools will it be just as bad elsewhere?

and is her teacher too intense or am I just being PFB and assuming it should be more fun than this?

OP posts:
ChiefWiggumsBoy · 10/02/2024 00:37

There's about a million and one different ballet schools you could sign her up to. This isn't normal, and she shouldn't be subjected to it.

ZephrineDrouhin · 10/02/2024 00:27

Well the feet might be a problem. I have a long second toe - longer than my big toe. It would make pointe work hard and probably wreck my feet. But the physique thing sounds mad.

I once had a riding lesson. I was meant to be varying the numer of strides the horse took behind jumps I was having g a lot of trouble doing it and the teacher kept up a barrage of abuse. I finally managed it, halted, got off and handed the teacher the reins and told her I wasn't paying good money to be insulted by her. (I was a recreational rider too rather than somebody with competitive ambitions.) My husband was watching and I asked him if I'd gone too far. He told me he was amazed I'd lasted that long. I made sure to not have her as a teacher again. Other riding teachers could be firm and no-nonsense but nothing like this person I hope she reflected on it because she was open-mouthed with astonishment.

Rachie1973 · 09/02/2024 23:37

Jeez, not quite the same but one of my granddaughters is an exceptionally talented gymnast. She trains 4 days a week, and it’s intense.

However, she leaves her coaching smiling and tired, but looking forward to the next one. If she came out crying or upset over a teacher she’d be pulled faster than her front somersault.

FofB · 09/02/2024 23:24

My daughter has been doing ballet for 14 years- Royal Academy of Ballet the whole time. She has never been made to cry. She has corrections, yes (e.g. turn you hip out to improve this move....etc) but nothing like this.

She's a teenager and shows no sign of wanting to give up because the class encourages her- she freely admits she is mid-level in terms of ability but she enjoys it anyway. That is what a decent ballet class should look like.

jamimmi · 09/02/2024 23:12

Dd is grade 8 and advanced RAD for her it is an adored hobby , her teacher is strict and pushes them, with very high standards, she frequently sends to the royal ballet school and associate programmes. She never ever treats them like this, under stood when dd missed classes and had to postpone an exam grade due to GCSE'S and loves her girls, as much as they love her. She finds something to praise in them all and weekly but is old school. Move your daughter now!

Nolarbear · 09/02/2024 23:11

I did ballet, tap and jazz/modern from the age of 3 until I was 20. My dance teachers were bullies. I used to be on the toilet before classes with a nervous stomach because I was scared of the teachers. I absolutely loved it at the same time though because when it was good, it was amazing. And I had very very strong friendships there. I know some other people that went to dance schools and didn’t have teachers like this, so they aren’t all like that. If I ever have a child I will not be sending them to the same dance school that I went to. I would pull your child out and send her somewhere new if I were you. One of my friends has OCD and after working with a therapist has figured out that it stemmed from our dance school experience

SavBlancTonight · 09/02/2024 23:08

At dd's dance school, one of the best, most committed and loveliest older students is brilliant but she is unlikely to ever be a prima ballerina or dancer as she does not have the "accepted" body type. What she is though is a talented and committed dancer who takes part in a variety of dance and theatre classes, is a supportive and kind helper for the junior classes and is someone who has clearly found something she is passionate about. She is loved by the other students and teachers alike as a result (dd IDOLISES her). It sounds like she would have been tossed out of your dance school at age 11. What a waste of talent and energy and enthusiasm. I look forward to.possibly seeing her on stage in musical theatre or drama in the future.

MigGirl · 09/02/2024 23:01

madeinmanc · 09/02/2024 20:19

That's how life in the arts is, rightly or wrongly. Music tends to be the same.

It certainly doesn't have to be like this.

Op find another dance school for your DD, my daughters teacher was lovely and we never had any of this. She only stopped as she wanted to do other things. My friend sent hers to a different local school and said the girls would come out of class crying, she stopped sending them there.

Bigcoatweather · 09/02/2024 23:00

This kind of thing was common when I was learning in the 1980s as a child. It just doesn’t wash now.
Remove her asap and if you can report her, do.
Things are a bit more like this at very high pro level, but dancing is also supposed to be for hobby and enjoyment.

rubberneckerr · 09/02/2024 22:58

I had a Gymnastics coach (former Olympian for her country) like this. All those years of torture for me were pointless.

If your daughter's not aiming to get into ballet school and become a professional career ballerina (and maybe even if she is), there's absolutely no point torturing her.

TwelveKeys · 09/02/2024 22:54

How depressing that one person can destroy the love of an activity in so many children.
You're right to get her out and look for an alternative.

Mariposistaaa · 09/02/2024 22:53

TimeForTeaAndG · 09/02/2024 22:52

How patronising. The teacher should not be criticising pupil's body shapes, or any of the things that OP describes. Noone should leave a dance class, recreational or otherwise, in tears because of how they've been spoken to and treated. It's perfectly possible to teach any level of student in a way that gets the best out of them with encouragement and respect for their time and effort. Noone said anyone expects pats on the heads and cuddles, ffs.

Totally agree. You can be firm and get the best out of your students without tearing them apart. It’s bullying. These are still young, impressionable children, not streetwise adults.

Karwomannghia · 09/02/2024 22:53

It’s old school (archaic) ballet which demands perfection.
Take her out.

TimeForTeaAndG · 09/02/2024 22:52

Theredfoxfliesatmidnight · 09/02/2024 21:31

Ballet is a very strict discipline and your child is an older child. I would not be expecting head pats and cuddles at this stage. If she is looking for a hobby rather than a profession now is probably the time to change her class to something else.

How patronising. The teacher should not be criticising pupil's body shapes, or any of the things that OP describes. Noone should leave a dance class, recreational or otherwise, in tears because of how they've been spoken to and treated. It's perfectly possible to teach any level of student in a way that gets the best out of them with encouragement and respect for their time and effort. Noone said anyone expects pats on the heads and cuddles, ffs.

BobbyBiscuits · 09/02/2024 22:48

It doesn't sound like a fun hobby to me if people are weeping and being body shamed. Is there another more casual dance school, with other types of dance she might enjoy she could try instead? It's really down to her, if she wants to keep going then I guess let her, but I would question why anyone would want that level of stress for a fun after school activity?

Mariposistaaa · 09/02/2024 22:48

redalex261 · 09/02/2024 20:05

I know nothing about ballet but don’t think any child should be leaving a recreational lesson in tears.

This.
It will only get worse OP. Withdraw her now before her MH is irreparably damaged. Plenty of other ways to keep fit and enjoy being active.

TimeForTeaAndG · 09/02/2024 22:47

Take her out and find a new school. That teacher is awful!!!

You can go onto the RAD site and find a teacher. For comparison, my DD is about to sit grade 3 and is also working on inter-foundation. She regularly misses her classes due to her other sport and attending an associate scheme that my sister (qualified RAD teacher) runs in Scotland each month. There is never any threat of being excluded from the IF class.

I am absolutely disgusted, but not surprised as there is a well known teacher who has a similar attitude but their students don't come out crying because they are warned not to go "running to mummy".

There is absolutely no need for that sort of "teaching".

Hughs · 09/02/2024 22:45

That's how life in the arts is, rightly or wrongly. Music tends to be the same.

I have a lot of personal and professional experience of music education, privately, in schools, specialist schools, conservatoire junior departments and youth orchestras. Music is absolutely not like this.

Whoopaday · 09/02/2024 22:44

Fuck me, you need to pull her out. All the people saying “this is just how it is”, are not breaking the bullying cycle. I am in a profession that basically bullied juniors as they were bullied themselves and saw it s a right of passage. Why on earth is any parent keeping their child here, you are just asking for eating disorders and just teaching your daughter she is not good enough and to be shouted at and that’s ok.

AppropriateAdult · 09/02/2024 22:40

Theredfoxfliesatmidnight · 09/02/2024 21:31

Ballet is a very strict discipline and your child is an older child. I would not be expecting head pats and cuddles at this stage. If she is looking for a hobby rather than a profession now is probably the time to change her class to something else.

Nobody has suggested 'head pats and cuddles'. If you think the only alternative to coddling children is regularly driving them to tears, then I very much hope you're not in any position of authority with young people.

OP, I'd agree with the 98% of people here who say you should move her now. It sounds like a really stressful environment and can't be doing her any good in the long run. Even if she was on a professional pathway, this sort of 'teaching by fear' wouldn't be acceptable.

sunbeams74 · 09/02/2024 22:36

This sounds like emotional abuse. If the teacher is part of a professional body you can make a complaint to them, or you can contact the LADO at your local council who can coordinate an investigation of the concerns. No one should treat children this way.

R41nb0wR0se · 09/02/2024 22:34

I did music, not ballet - just here to counter people saying this kind of thing is normal in the arts. It's not. I trained to a high standard, and about 50% of my peers went professional (many via conservatoires). Whilst the "scream at them til they get it right" school of teaching was fairly prevalent at the time many of my teachers learned music (approximately 50 years ago), it was much less common by the time I was learning, and has been totally discredited now (although there are dinosaurs out there). This type of teaching can cause or exacerbate mental illness, performance anxiety and, for dancers in particular, eating disorders. I'm glad your daughter is leaving this ballet school - I hope she finds a better one that will support her to flourish

SavBlancTonight · 09/02/2024 22:33

This may be common, I don't know. But it's certainly not my experience. Dd's dance school might be the single.most welcoming, warm and inclusive clubs/activity we have ever done.

Take her out. If its supposed to be for fun, it's not working. Find a new school and a new teacher.

dancinfeet · 09/02/2024 22:30

Dance teacher here and this is completely unacceptable. Yes, good attendance and hard work equals progress, but children should not be leaving class crying, being threatened with being cut from classes or told to leave due to their physique. Find a better dance school and a much more caring teacher- it’s a hobby! It’s teachers like this that give all dance schools a bad name, your daughter deserves better than this.

AnnaMagnani · 09/02/2024 22:25

Oh god I had a riding teacher like this. I'd be in tears every lesson.

Eventually my parents refused to let me go there any more and found a new riding school. It was tatty and a bit rundown but the teacher was actually encouraging. I had had no idea I was supposed to have fun doing this hobby!

Get her out, she probably can't make the decision herself, and find a dance school where the kids are having fun.