Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Scotland - care home. Who has the legal 'say'

259 replies

flourpot · 09/02/2024 17:15

Looking for a bit of advice as I'm in a situation where I have POA for a relative and I disagree with the discharge team at hospital.

Relative is 93, has no capacity, no idea what's going on and lives upstairs flat. I think it would be dangerous to send her home.

Brief phone call today indicated the team think home with carers is acceptable

I did not realise that when the decision needed to be made about a care home it might not be my decision.

I'm struggling to find out whether my POA means I can disagree with the team at the hospital or if I have to accept their choice.

Any ideas?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
5
snoopyfanaccountant · 09/02/2024 22:58

flourpot · 09/02/2024 18:18

@snoopyfanaccountant

Do you know any legislation that says I can refuse this move?

I have had my eyes well and truly opened this week I had no idea how utterly awful things are

We were able to stall due to the lack of carers. DF and DSM lived in a rural village and even before he went into hospital the carers he needed weren't available (DSM was paying a neighbour to help with bedtime). Carers refused to service their village due to time constraints.
DF was initially taken into hospital in one of the cities. Once he was medically stable, he was transferred to a community hospital nearer home. I attended a case meeting on my own (DSM was on a much needed holiday) and was I bullied into agreeing that DF be discharged home despite the necessary care not being in place (DSM has a back injury which means that she couldn't do the lifting that was needed). I had limited contact with SW, OT etc due to covid restrictions and living 70 miles away; DSM went through everyone when she came home (her work was linked to SW so she knows the system) and DF's discharge was delayed.

flourpot · 09/02/2024 22:56

@Checkmymoves

You don't say what your relatives current expressed wishes are ( I accept that they have been assessed as lacking capacity but that does not negate the fact they still have views, wishes and preferences). Be aware it is likely that, if your relative strongly objects to a move into a care home, then it will end up with the court being asked to make a final decision and the judge will want to hear your reasoning.

She doesn't understand anything. She can't object she wouldn't even know what a care home was

OP posts:
halfshutknife · 09/02/2024 22:54

What you are reporting is not normal practice.

As poa you should be at a case conference and you should be called upon to make decisions.

I've never attended a case conference where a relative has not been allowed to come unless the patient was at risk from the relative.

The OT should be informing their recommendations based on assessment. It would always be the norm to try at home with a poc if no poc in place previously unless there are significant concerns that this won't work. Or if informal care has assimilated a care package.

flourpot · 09/02/2024 22:53

I just want to thank everyone again. I am going to read through the whole thread in the morning and take some notes as there is a lot of helpful stuff here. I feel like I have been arguing when people are trying to help but i am just trying to work out how to prevent a dangerous situation for my loved one. I'm sorry I do appreciate everyone's help (except the poster who suggested death by stairs was preferable) and I am truly grateful

OP posts:
Checkmymoves · 09/02/2024 22:51

I'm a mental capacity lead for a hospital and advise on these situations pretty frequently. My home area is England but the law in Scotland is very similar.
Your POA makes you the decision maker. That is the entire point of the role - your relative chose you as someone they trusted to make such decisions on their behalf when they could no longer do so.
You can only make a decision from the options that are available - it sounds like there are the funds for a care home so that is certainly one option, as is going home with a full package of support.
You do have to make the decision in you relatives best interest.. as pp's have said, that isn't as simple as choosing the 'safest' option, it also nedds to factor in emotional wellbeing and past/present expressed wishes. I'd recommend hearing the views of professionals and what support might be available to your relative at home (it may not change your mind but your legal role demands that you carefully consider all the options).
I'd provide them with evidence of your PoA and, in writing, ask them to confirm your authority to make the decision.
You don't say what your relatives current expressed wishes are ( I accept that they have been assessed as lacking capacity but that does not negate the fact they still have views, wishes and preferences). Be aware it is likely that, if your relative strongly objects to a move into a care home, then it will end up with the court being asked to make a final decision and the judge will want to hear your reasoning. That's not to put you off, I'm just saying that it's important to be clear about how you've come to that 'best interests' conclusion.
Good luck!

herewegoagainy · 09/02/2024 22:49

Sorry you have no right to insist she is admitted to a community hospital. The professionals decide if she can have a place.

I know in Scotland the person with POA can be overridden but I do not know the mechanism. I only know of a case where the family wanted their mother to go home with carers, and the POA was over ruled and she was sent to a care home with her home being sold to pay for it.

But there is a severe shortage of carers so it is very doubtful they can organise this quickly. They might decide this should happen, it actually happening is a different story.

Tahinii · 09/02/2024 22:47

flourpot · 09/02/2024 22:28

@Tahinii

You can put it in place. If she has access to funds, she’s given you the power to find her a care home and to arrange payment.

I understand that now but I need the interim care whilst it's sorted/. Not at home

The route you need to go down involves explaining the risks to the hospital and how she would be at risk of significant harm. You need to ask them how they’ve considered safeguarding be cause you believe she would be at risk of harm even if she spent 1 day at home.

Leave aside the PoA because, this alone, cannot force them into arranging interim care.

If you feel the risks are too high (and based on what you’ve said, it sounds like you’re right), focus on these.

I am not in Scotland but perhaps someone else can advise if you have hospital discharge nurses /
coordinators?

Try to put aside the long term plan and reiterate to them that you want it recorded that she object to her returning home. Be really clear and give examples. “Jane fell down the stairs and broke her hip and wrist. She has declined in cognition since then and she forgets she cannot use the stairs so she will try.” “Jane gets up approx 3 times a night and wanders around, she goes into the garden. She does not recognise her surroundings.” “Jane has set fire to her toaster and microwave.” “Jane does not understand hot and cold taps, she has burnt her hands multiple times.” “Jane smokes and forgets to put out the cigarette.” “Jane has had 10 falls in the last 6 months. From this, she had paramedics every time and was admitted to hospital on 3 occasions due to the nature of her injuries.”

Hope this helps!

flourpot · 09/02/2024 22:45

@Bonbon21

If she is to be 'discharged home' then the OT should be making a home visit to assess what the home is like and what 'aids' will be required..

I told the woman on the phone today the carpet still needs cleaning as it has been soiled as she hasn't managed toileting

Bear with me on this...
Without a home visit they cannot carry out a risk assessment for the discharge.
If she can mobilise with a zimmer or similar at all then I would suggest if she has been able to go to the toilet in hospital ' with assistance', then who will assist her when she is in the house alone and decides to head to the loo?
... at this point she becomes a 'falls risk'.. and it therefore becomes ' an unsafe discharge'.

Well she got a zimmer in hospital so as a new thing it is more likely to cause a fall. It's more likely to make her think she can go outside so she will fall downstairs with it. She has a Zimmer and a nurse to toilet in hospital

If she is recognising that she is in hospital, then she will not recognise she is at home and the stairs are lethal in those circumstances as she will be incapable of assessing any danger in using them... especially if she is also coping with a zimmer/ walkkng aid.

They don't seem to agree but I am making notes and what you say is very helpful thank you

Make sure you get the names of everyone you speak to... and make it clear that you will not forget them.

I didn't even think of this

OP posts:
MistressoftheDarkSide · 09/02/2024 22:45

@flourpot

Your frustration is completely understandable - there is a huge gap in policy especially for complex cases. I had no idea either until SM ended up in hospital.

The problem is that organising appropriate long term care takes time but from the hospital POV once a patient is "medically fit for discharge," out the door they go. It becomes a "social care" issue. Which i find mind boggling because dementia is a progressive brain disease affecting cognitive function and physical health. And you're in that no man's land between these two policies.

It's clear from what you say that your relative needs 24 hour care / supervision as does my SM. We've also been offered carers 4 times a day but the expectation is that my Dad will do the rest. In the two weeks prior to admission my SM was awake for stretches of up to 60 hours, rampaging round the house etc and resisting care because of her distractions.

Her paranoid delusions have included serious allegations about my Dad, she had been uncharacteristically aggressive to him and me yet she is described as pleasantly confused.

Her right to autonomy means she can make "unwise decisions".

There has also been guilt tripping as although her delirium may last for months our resistance to her returning home is implied as a factor in delaying her potential recovery. There are two vulnerable elderly people at risk from this policy in my case and I will stall any discharge home as long as I can.

The uncertainty is the worst part of it and feeling unheard.

I really really feel for you x

Mydustymonstera · 09/02/2024 22:43

@op
the mdt to discuss her discharge hasn’t happened yet. you’ve been told no one is discharging her anywhere until her case is discussed there.

you sound utterly frantic but please, try to take the weekend to draw breath as she isn’t going anywhere right now.

in the mean time you raise your concerns. You tell OT, Physio, charge nurse and do your best to get in touch with her consultant. Actually any one of these will do but u don’t want your concerns getting lost. You ask for a social work referral. You state it would in your view be a unsafe discharge.

you acknowledge she hasn’t had homecare but stress that’s because you’ve been doing that, and it is no longer keeping her safe (falls, confusion, delirium).

you can also contact your local social work dept to self refer.

which local authority are you in?

Bonbon21 · 09/02/2024 22:36

If she is to be 'discharged home' then the OT should be making a home visit to assess what the home is like and what 'aids' will be required..
Bear with me on this...
Without a home visit they cannot carry out a risk assessment for the discharge.
If she can mobilise with a zimmer or similar at all then I would suggest if she has been able to go to the toilet in hospital ' with assistance', then who will assist her when she is in the house alone and decides to head to the loo?
... at this point she becomes a 'falls risk'.. and it therefore becomes ' an unsafe discharge'.

If she is recognising that she is in hospital, then she will not recognise she is at home and the stairs are lethal in those circumstances as she will be incapable of assessing any danger in using them... especially if she is also coping with a zimmer/ walkkng aid.

Make sure you get the names of everyone you speak to... and make it clear that you will not forget them.

KinKenKon · 09/02/2024 22:33

If I recall once you request this assessment, they have to delay discharge until this assessment is completed.

This is not the situation in Scotland now. The assessments are usually done at home now since the introduction of Home First

Notmorerainagain · 09/02/2024 22:31

If you have access to funds, is a live-in carer an option for her so she could go home but safely?

Penguinfeetteal · 09/02/2024 22:30

I don't know if it's the same in Scotland but we had exactly the same in England. I am presuming it is social care who are funding the package of care at home. I had to challenge social care on their decision of care package and the social worker outright lied on the assessment form. I complained and used the medical evidence provided (mostly OT and physio reports) to counter evidence the level of care they had seemed suitable (at home carers 4 Times a day).

It took ages and we refused to allow my nan to be discharged stating that we're were unable to care for her and if anything happened to her it would be on their responsibility.

Social care manager reviewed the assesment and admitted the social worker had completely missed relevant medical information that completely changed the outcome and agreed that care home was more relevant.

I also then requested a CHC assessment, and did an assessment and used the checklist myself with evidence of all medical reports from the hospital and previous hospital admissions and provided this in writing. They then completed their own chc checklist and agreed that she met the criteria for funded nursing care. We still had to sell her house to fund the care home fees as nursing care didn't fund enough.

Ultimately the first thing you want in writing is the assessment and what evidence was used to determine the current care package they are deeming suitable and then you challenge that. Our social worker was very sneaky in only selecting bits info and deliberately ignoring other quite clear evidence of why she couldn't be safe at home.

Link to CHC here: https://www.nhs.uk/conditions/social-care-and-support-guide/money-work-and-benefits/nhs-continuing-healthcare/

If I recall once you request this assessment, they have to delay discharge until this assessment is completed.

It is so stressful having to go through all this!

nhs.uk

NHS continuing healthcare - Social care and support guide

Find out about NHS funding for social care for people with long-term complex health needs.

https://www.nhs.uk/conditions/social-care-and-support-guide/money-work-and-benefits/nhs-continuing-healthcare

Bryterlayter1 · 09/02/2024 22:28

flourpot · 09/02/2024 22:21

@Bryterlayter1

Of course you can disagree, you could complain formally if you think the assessment is wrong. However, what you are asking about is what powers you have as a POA and unfortunately you wouldn't have the power to force them to provide a higher level of support. If your DM had capacity she wouldn't be able to insist they to provide care higher level either.

If she had capacity she wouldn't need to

Also. She is not my DM

My apologies for saying DM.

flourpot · 09/02/2024 22:28

@Tahinii

You can put it in place. If she has access to funds, she’s given you the power to find her a care home and to arrange payment.

I understand that now but I need the interim care whilst it's sorted/. Not at home

OP posts:
flourpot · 09/02/2024 22:27

KinKenKon · 09/02/2024 22:25

If you Google
Home First Scottish Gov

I have read the home first stuff/

The point is that I don't agree it's an appropriate option. She would not be safe and I don't know how anyone could consider she would be

OP posts:
Tahinii · 09/02/2024 22:27

flourpot · 09/02/2024 22:06

@Bryterlayter1

I don't agree with their assessment.

How can it be ok to send her home? She will fall downstairs and that's if she doesn't burn the place down. How would she ask for help?

Why can't I disagree?

I'm gutted that she put everything in place so I could step up when needed but they won't let me

Edited

You can put it in place. If she has access to funds, she’s given you the power to find her a care home and to arrange payment.

flourpot · 09/02/2024 22:26

HellsBells67 · 09/02/2024 22:24

I'm in Scotland and dealing with similar right now. 102 year old grandmother broke hip three weeks ago, had had operation and 'physio' (getting her out of bed and onto chair with zimmer) and been sent home with a care package, two carers four times a day. She cannot toilet, walk and is registered blind. It's carnage. My 81 year old mother is expected to clean her up and wash bedding twice a day as the carers are not there overnight obviously. I despair and have such empathy for you.

That's actually horrendous, I'm so sorry.

I had no idea until this week how awful things were, both in hospital and out

OP posts:
KinKenKon · 09/02/2024 22:25

If you Google
Home First Scottish Gov

HellsBells67 · 09/02/2024 22:24

I'm in Scotland and dealing with similar right now. 102 year old grandmother broke hip three weeks ago, had had operation and 'physio' (getting her out of bed and onto chair with zimmer) and been sent home with a care package, two carers four times a day. She cannot toilet, walk and is registered blind. It's carnage. My 81 year old mother is expected to clean her up and wash bedding twice a day as the carers are not there overnight obviously. I despair and have such empathy for you.

KinKenKon · 09/02/2024 22:22

Sorry those links don't work!

I'll try again

flourpot · 09/02/2024 22:21

@Bryterlayter1

Of course you can disagree, you could complain formally if you think the assessment is wrong. However, what you are asking about is what powers you have as a POA and unfortunately you wouldn't have the power to force them to provide a higher level of support. If your DM had capacity she wouldn't be able to insist they to provide care higher level either.

If she had capacity she wouldn't need to

Also. She is not my DM

OP posts:
KinKenKon · 09/02/2024 22:21

This reply has been withdrawn

This message has been withdrawn at the poster's request

TerriPie · 09/02/2024 22:20

Requiring an extensive care package might work in your favour as the care sector is bursting at the seams.

I waited 4 months with daily chasing up for a relative with Dementia and we never did get a care package set up in the end. No carers anywhere, even charity sector couldn't help.

Keep up with delay tactics, try and get her moved to a community hospital and push for a care home place.