Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Scotland - care home. Who has the legal 'say'

259 replies

flourpot · 09/02/2024 17:15

Looking for a bit of advice as I'm in a situation where I have POA for a relative and I disagree with the discharge team at hospital.

Relative is 93, has no capacity, no idea what's going on and lives upstairs flat. I think it would be dangerous to send her home.

Brief phone call today indicated the team think home with carers is acceptable

I did not realise that when the decision needed to be made about a care home it might not be my decision.

I'm struggling to find out whether my POA means I can disagree with the team at the hospital or if I have to accept their choice.

Any ideas?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
5
Jadebanditchillipepper · 09/02/2024 23:51

flourpot · 09/02/2024 23:08

@Jadebanditchillipepper

Playing devils advocate here, but why should the NHS pay for what are actually social care needs and not health care needs?

There is actually an interim stage which is either community hospital or a different care home until a permanent arrangement is made. I feel she needs further assessment and I think she should have it or the NHS will be paying a lot more when she ends up back in hospital due to another fall or something dangerous happening

Edited

Not in England and Wales there isn't. You still haven't said why the NHS should pay for social care needs? And saying it will cost them more if she falls at home isn't an answer to that question. Patients also fall in hospital and in care homes, you can't mitigate against everything.

This is why the NHS is on It's knees. For every patient like your relative, there is another patient out in the community or stuck on an ambulance who needs a bed because they are medically sick and could die without rapid intervention. I'm not saying it's right - it isn't, the NHS has been underfunded and totally inefficient for years - Tory Austerity and COVID have excerbated these effects, but I still don't think patients should be kept in hospital because of social care needs - social services and self funding families should be responsible for that.

I am not unsympathetic to your situation - as I said, I went through very similar with my Mum. We were self funding and eventually sorted a care home out for her. But I really wouldn't have wanted her in hospital when she didn't need to be there (by that I mean didn't have NHS needs, not, didn't have social care needs) because she could have ended up a lot sicker if she had remained in hospital.

OldLabMummy · 09/02/2024 23:48

flourpot · 09/02/2024 22:53

I just want to thank everyone again. I am going to read through the whole thread in the morning and take some notes as there is a lot of helpful stuff here. I feel like I have been arguing when people are trying to help but i am just trying to work out how to prevent a dangerous situation for my loved one. I'm sorry I do appreciate everyone's help (except the poster who suggested death by stairs was preferable) and I am truly grateful

Good luck OP. It is so difficult. The reality is as POA you are only able to make the decisions that your relative would make. You effectively are your relative when talking to health care providers etc. Unfortunately this doesn’t count for much as the NHS isn’t in a good place. People can’t even get a GP or dentist appointments never mind the care and treatment they need.

Unfortunately resources are so limited that if a patient has support from a relative then they are often discharged when they shouldn’t be.

You have had a lot of advice and I appreciate you may not feel comfortable with some of it eg making sure your relative doesn’t have a house key etc so they can’t go home. It’s appalling that you would have to resort to this but you may have too.

Another thing I learned was that the number of falls affected the care offered eg. 3 falls triggered a certain level of care so make sure the hospital are aware of any previous falls.

Also please look at the legislation I mentioned above. Asking for this review bought us a lot of time. I can’t really remember the ins and outs of it but it was something about people without capacity being released into a safe environment. My relative was hospitalised with a broken foot not anything to do with their capacity. This was something a health care professional (at a local dementia group) advised us to do.

I hope everything works out for you.

halfshutknife · 09/02/2024 23:43

They will but someone has to organise it, pay for it and put keys in.

As Poa of someone who's incapax you would need to ok it and pay unless it's a council that provide for free you'll also need to go get keys cut.

Unlikely you'll manage that before Monday so she can't be discharged on Monday.

Letsbekindplease · 09/02/2024 23:41

Hi

if you hold full POA then you have the right to speak on behalf of your relative if you feel long term care is needed.

you need to speak with the assessors who I would assume is the occupational and physio therapists. Speak with the care staff. Ask to see the notes. What is the over night needs. How many times a day are they seeking staff. Are they incontanent of urine and bowels. Do they need encouragement to eat?

you can ask for an assessment to be done for a social worker to be allocated.

sometimes people get sent home to fail if they haven’t had a package of care before. This can be 4 times daily. Not over night. Then they would consider lo g term care

there’s nothing stopping you to put loved one into a care home but without the correct assessment of needs they wouldn’t have the personal care fees paid. So wait for an assessment from social work

hope this helps.

halfshutknife · 09/02/2024 23:41

herewegoagainy · 09/02/2024 23:35

@halfshutknife they will get a key safe put in, that is standard if you have carers.

I am aware of this. Was more for OP to ask the team this to see if they have considered it.

Not all therapists are thorough and sometimes there's human error.

flourpot · 09/02/2024 23:35

halfshutknife · 09/02/2024 23:32

Here's a question for you to pose to the team.

The care package - who will provide access? Is the patient expected to go down the stairs to open the door for every carer then lock it afterwards? That's 16 times on the stairs everyday.

Also very easy way to stop a discharge. With hold the 🔑 until you're satisfied and comfortable with the discharge.

I think they would just for a key safe outside?

OP posts:
herewegoagainy · 09/02/2024 23:35

@halfshutknife they will get a key safe put in, that is standard if you have carers.

halfshutknife · 09/02/2024 23:32

Here's a question for you to pose to the team.

The care package - who will provide access? Is the patient expected to go down the stairs to open the door for every carer then lock it afterwards? That's 16 times on the stairs everyday.

Also very easy way to stop a discharge. With hold the 🔑 until you're satisfied and comfortable with the discharge.

flourpot · 09/02/2024 23:28

herewegoagainy · 09/02/2024 23:14

OP is the issue that you want her in the community hospital as an interim measure while you sort out a care home? Because if it is then you do not have the right to make that decision. They are saying she can go home with carers. If you want something else to happen you have to organise and pay for the alternative.

I wanted to know if I had the right to say she cannot be discharged to home. I don't understand how they can consider it. I don't know what to do to prevent it. I don't know how to access help. I don't know how to be involved. Im drowning.

But yes are moment I would prefer the interim option over home because I do not believe she would be safe at home. If she needs to be varies into her house because cannot manage the status she is not safe in there alone

OP posts:
MuchasSmoochas · 09/02/2024 23:25

NRTFT but have been in your situation. The home visits were 15 minutes x 4 a day. We all took it in turns to go round but she just wasn’t safe. What worked for us - the local authority will have a vulnerable adults safeguarding policy with a governing committee. Email them and say there is a vulnerable adult at risk, phone social services daily to report it. Pass the responsibility to them while keeping a sneaky eye on your relative.

As PA you can’t control the medical discharge but you can control what happens next. I honestly think any medical professional will agree that your relative needs a care home and we were able to turn this round in a week after we visited care homes. If your relative objects (unlikely as sounds like capacity issue) then the doctor may have to section your relative (as a last resort). There would then be a court appointed representative to look into it but honestly I think the docs will agree a care home is best. PM me if you need help. Sorry this is happening 💐

Checkmymoves · 09/02/2024 23:20

flourpot · 09/02/2024 22:56

@Checkmymoves

You don't say what your relatives current expressed wishes are ( I accept that they have been assessed as lacking capacity but that does not negate the fact they still have views, wishes and preferences). Be aware it is likely that, if your relative strongly objects to a move into a care home, then it will end up with the court being asked to make a final decision and the judge will want to hear your reasoning.

She doesn't understand anything. She can't object she wouldn't even know what a care home was

Okay. The rest of my post still applies. You are the decision maker here not professionals, and no discharge planning meetings should take place without your input. Your PoA gives you the authority to make welfare decisions on behalf of your relative and this is a welfare decision. Again, ask them, in writing, to confirm your understanding that this is the case.

The relevant legislation is the Adults with Incapacity Act (Scotland) 2000 . Attornies are covered in this section: https://www.legislation.gov.uk/asp/2000/4/part/2

Adults with Incapacity (Scotland) Act 2000

An Act of the Scottish Parliament to make provision as to the property, financial affairs and personal welfare of adults who are incapable by reason of mental disorder or inability to communicate; and for connected purposes.

https://www.legislation.gov.uk/asp/2000/4/part/2

herewegoagainy · 09/02/2024 23:18

I do not know what hospital your relative is in. But my experience with my mum was that the hospital social worker said to me that the medics often want a quick discharge, but she likes to take the time to make sure everything is in place. It will depend on the individual though.

halfshutknife · 09/02/2024 23:18

flourpot · 09/02/2024 23:11

@halfshutknife

Not accurate. A home visit would not be carried out for all patients to make a risk assessment.

Really? I assumed it would be done.

So they won't see the extent of how bad things have been or realise she can't actually get in the house

Nope. If you imagine a caseload of 9 patients at every time and an environmental visit taking around 3 hours, it won't be feasible.

Many situations they are required but in most they aren't.

You tell them the carpet is soiled and the house isn't currently habitable as a result then no one needs to attend and confirm that.

halfshutknife · 09/02/2024 23:15

flourpot · 09/02/2024 23:03

@halfshutknife

She ended up in hospital becsue she fell at home and was lying for hours. Not on the stairs but that is a real risk now her cognitive impairment has dropped dramatically. If it's a risk in hospital it's a bigger risk at home/.

She also fell in hospital before they managed to decide she needed assistance. She had been there for 4 days

I fully understand stairs pose a risk. I hate 4 in a block internal stairs as they are essentially pointless.

Are they of the opinion that the fall was caused by illness? This hoping that if illness treated this is unlikely to happen again?

It sounds like you're dealing with a very inexperienced team who either aren't considering the risks or aren't very good at telling you why they've made their recommendations.

I'd be interested to know what hospital your relative is in. I recall a fairly similar story on here some time back and D&G was the hospital in question.

Jellycatspyjamas · 09/02/2024 23:15

There is no legislation that says she needs to go home unless she’s already had carers in, legally she can move from hospital to community hospital to care home. They prefer to send people home with care because it’s cheaper but they can discharge her to a care facility.

You’re going to need to stand your ground. While she may be clinically ready for discharge, that discharge needs to be safe. The home should be assessed by OT and social work and a care plan agreed before discharge - there will be a hospital social worker who should be responsible for assessing her safe discharge, this isn’t a medical assessment and is separate from the question of whether there’s a clinical need. Ask to speak with the hospital social worker and speak to your local adult care social work team because they’ll take over after discharge.

The final decision should be an agreement between the medical team, social care team, AHPs and social work and you. There’s a legal duty on social work to seek and consider your views, so you need to speak to them.

In terms of funding, the local authority should cover the first few weeks (12 I think) before you’d start having to self fund - this is the bit they’ll be trying to avoid.

It’s appalling but stand your ground and explore their risk assessment fully (ie what makes them think she can mobilise safely, what evidence do they have that she could feed herself, what evidence do they have that she could use a safety alert), basically make them explain their assessment rather than you telling them it’s not safe. Ask for a copy of her care plan and go through it with a fine tooth comb, asking for a clear explanation of each part and what they have in place to keep her safe. Make them do the work of explaining to you, write it all down.

If the person you’re speaking to can’t or won’t, tell them to find you someone who can. Keep punting it up the ladder both in hospital and social work.

In the meantime look for nursing homes/care facilities that have space, there may be a waiting list but it may be possible to negotiate recuperation at a community hospital while waiting for a place. Them not actually discussing it with you isn’t good enough, and is their way of avoiding a difficult conversation - put all of your concerns in writing to the discharge team, social work department (write to the Head of Service if need be), make reference to the 3 point criteria for Adult Support & Protection which your relative definitely meets and ask that they provide a written response to each of your concerns. Written each in a numbered list.

Its time consuming, emotionally heavy work, but if you make enough noise, in writing, citing adult protection, you’ll get a response.

herewegoagainy · 09/02/2024 23:14

OP is the issue that you want her in the community hospital as an interim measure while you sort out a care home? Because if it is then you do not have the right to make that decision. They are saying she can go home with carers. If you want something else to happen you have to organise and pay for the alternative.

flourpot · 09/02/2024 23:13

herewegoagainy · 09/02/2024 23:06

My experience is in Scotland with my mum. The discharge team wanted her discharged quickly with a care package. The reality is very different to what the discharge team want. Even getting a hospital bed delivered to her house took a while, and securing carers took even longer. So whatever the decision things are unlikely to move as fast as the discharge team want.

This is reassuring, it could buy me some time to start dealing with practical arrangements

OP posts:
flourpot · 09/02/2024 23:11

@halfshutknife

Not accurate. A home visit would not be carried out for all patients to make a risk assessment.

Really? I assumed it would be done.

So they won't see the extent of how bad things have been or realise she can't actually get in the house

OP posts:
halfshutknife · 09/02/2024 23:09

Bonbon21 · 09/02/2024 22:36

If she is to be 'discharged home' then the OT should be making a home visit to assess what the home is like and what 'aids' will be required..
Bear with me on this...
Without a home visit they cannot carry out a risk assessment for the discharge.
If she can mobilise with a zimmer or similar at all then I would suggest if she has been able to go to the toilet in hospital ' with assistance', then who will assist her when she is in the house alone and decides to head to the loo?
... at this point she becomes a 'falls risk'.. and it therefore becomes ' an unsafe discharge'.

If she is recognising that she is in hospital, then she will not recognise she is at home and the stairs are lethal in those circumstances as she will be incapable of assessing any danger in using them... especially if she is also coping with a zimmer/ walkkng aid.

Make sure you get the names of everyone you speak to... and make it clear that you will not forget them.

Not accurate. A home visit would not be carried out for all patients to make a risk assessment. They should however complete a comprehensive assessment which includes families concerns.

flourpot · 09/02/2024 23:08

@Jadebanditchillipepper

Playing devils advocate here, but why should the NHS pay for what are actually social care needs and not health care needs?

There is actually an interim stage which is either community hospital or a different care home until a permanent arrangement is made. I feel she needs further assessment and I think she should have it or the NHS will be paying a lot more when she ends up back in hospital due to another fall or something dangerous happening

OP posts:
herewegoagainy · 09/02/2024 23:06

My experience is in Scotland with my mum. The discharge team wanted her discharged quickly with a care package. The reality is very different to what the discharge team want. Even getting a hospital bed delivered to her house took a while, and securing carers took even longer. So whatever the decision things are unlikely to move as fast as the discharge team want.

flourpot · 09/02/2024 23:03

@halfshutknife

She ended up in hospital becsue she fell at home and was lying for hours. Not on the stairs but that is a real risk now her cognitive impairment has dropped dramatically. If it's a risk in hospital it's a bigger risk at home/.

She also fell in hospital before they managed to decide she needed assistance. She had been there for 4 days

OP posts:
halfshutknife · 09/02/2024 23:01

flourpot · 09/02/2024 19:42

I'm just can't see what part of sending her home would be in her best interest. If they can tell me that I'm all ears. Telling me they have alarms for after she has a fall and breaks her neck isn't really going to cut it. Leaving her alone in a flat with stairs for 12 hours overnight when she it is noted 'zimmer + supervision' in her hospital board for walking ability isn't in her best interest.

The board above the bed is for information for any staff working with the person so they know what level of support they require.
She may be zimmer and supervision in hospital due to unfamiliar environment or distance required to walk to the toilet.
Physio may have assessed as supervision in hospital but independent at home.

That's worth clarifying.

Aldo has she previously fallen down the stairs or is this an anticipated risk?

Jadebanditchillipepper · 09/02/2024 22:59

As POA you can absolutely decide where your relative gets discharged to. What you CAN'T do is insist they keep her in hospital once the option they have deemed suitable is arranged. You are absolutely within your rights to arrange a care home, but you can't insist she stays in hospital while you choose a care home and wait for a space if they deem that she is suitable for discharge to her own home with a package of care, once that package of care is available.

Playing devils advocate here, but why should the NHS pay for what are actually social care needs and not health care needs? Beyond that, as well as considering the risks of sending a patient home, they also have to consider the risks of keeping the patient in hospital - and there absolutely are risks to keeping a patient in hospital once they are medically fit for discharge - loss of mobility, but most likely, contracting a hospital acquired infection, or Flu/COVID/any of the other viruses that are floating around at this time of year - any of which could kill a vulnerable, frail, elderly patient. These are a real risk - the NHS doesn't have the resources to isolate everyone and someone who is entirely asymptomatic, could be incubating, and therefore be infectious from one of these viruses and could pass it on to your relative.

I went through the exact same thing with my Mum. I actually cared for her at home for the few days it took to arrange a suitable care home

MistressoftheDarkSide · 09/02/2024 22:58

@flourpot

Bless you, I bet you're exhausted. It is a huge amount to take in and navigate, and when you're trying to keep your loved one safe the legal and policy issues seem like such a blunt tool.

If you can step away for a bit and get some rest you'll be able to regroup in the morning x

Just take care of yourself as much as you can and I hope you get some rest xxx

Swipe left for the next trending thread