Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Scotland - care home. Who has the legal 'say'

259 replies

flourpot · 09/02/2024 17:15

Looking for a bit of advice as I'm in a situation where I have POA for a relative and I disagree with the discharge team at hospital.

Relative is 93, has no capacity, no idea what's going on and lives upstairs flat. I think it would be dangerous to send her home.

Brief phone call today indicated the team think home with carers is acceptable

I did not realise that when the decision needed to be made about a care home it might not be my decision.

I'm struggling to find out whether my POA means I can disagree with the team at the hospital or if I have to accept their choice.

Any ideas?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
5
Malbecmoron · 10/02/2024 15:04

Also jfi there's no such thing as best interest meetings in Scotland

Malbecmoron · 10/02/2024 15:02

That doesn't apply in Scotland @Soontobe60

Speaking to the local carers centre is a good idea OP, as is speaking to advocacy.

As POA you can make the decision about where she lives (if it's in your POA powers, it probably is) but only from the options available. You don't need guardianship as you already have all the powers you need. Section 13za suggested by a previous poster doesn't apply here as you have an active POA.
You can move her to a care home now if you self fund but you won't get the free free personal care element of the fees as this needs to be assessed and given by the local authority

My advice is
Contact carers centre and advocacy to help get your voice heard
Ask social work to do an assessment
Ask if there is a risk assessment in place
Keep saying the discharge will be unsafe.

Soontobe60 · 10/02/2024 12:23

NeedToChangeName · 10/02/2024 11:23

Abdolutely no way would your appointment be revoked for advocating for a safe placement. Don't worry about that

That’s not technically correct.
If the local authority social workers genuinely consider that the attorney/deputy is taking decisions that are not in the best interests of the person, then this a matter that needs to be addressed by way of an application to the Court of Protection which can – as a last resort – direct the removal of the attorney or the deputy. It should be noted that, by the same token, a health and welfare attorney (or deputy) cannot decide on behalf of a self-funding individual lacking the material capacity where they should live, although by definition the views of the attorney/deputy as to where their interests would best be served should carry very great weight with any property and affairs attorney (or deputy) appointed if the same individual – or individuals – is not discharging both health and welfare and property and affairs functions
https://www.mentalcapacitylawandpolicy.org.uk/powers-of-attorney-care-homes-best-interests-and-deprivation-of-liberty/#:~:text=If%20the%20local%20authority%20social,removal%20of%20the%20attorney%20or

Powers of attorney, care homes, best interests and deprivation of liberty

I have been asked by a good BIA (you know who you are!) to write something about powers of attorney, care homes and best interests. Because I am nice like that, here are some thoughts, but with the…

https://www.mentalcapacitylawandpolicy.org.uk/powers-of-attorney-care-homes-best-interests-and-deprivation-of-liberty/#:~:text=If%20the%20local%20authority%20social,removal%20of%20the%20attorney%20or

Soontobe60 · 10/02/2024 12:18

She is lying in a hospital bed and would be utterly confused by being wheeled into a meeting full of strangers talking about things she doesn't understand. That's not an option
If you said this to them, they may see you as being controlling. It’s perfectly possible for the meeting to take place on the ward either in a side room or at her bedside. Professionals need to see her to get a full picture of her condition. They clearly think she’s relatively OK to be discharged. It was only when we insisted on having a best interest meeting with my SF present that his social worker, who had never met him face to face, realised how bad he was. The following week we met again to assess him for capacity. He is now under a DOLs order as a result.
Make sure that she is assessed for having capacity before leaving hospital and insist that she is admitted to a discharge to assess unit where an informed decision can be made. It’s an absolute minefield where professionals are hoping family will rally round to support their relatives as the broken system cannot cope with the immense load.

NeedToChangeName · 10/02/2024 11:23

Abdolutely no way would your appointment be revoked for advocating for a safe placement. Don't worry about that

NeedToChangeName · 10/02/2024 11:21

Yes, I think its a question of where to focus your energies

I would also say to professionals that you wish it to be minuted in the recird of the meeting that you are attorney, adult has lost capacity, you are actively exploring care homes as a matter of urgency and accept no responsibility if they insist on dischsrging home and she sustains injury. And

Remember, even if she does go home, you could move her as soon as you find a care home

flourpot · 10/02/2024 11:16

halfshutknife · 10/02/2024 10:46

I'd bet my house on the fact that your poa will not be revoked based on what you are saying.

I get the impression that the mdt just haven't appreciated your significant concerns.

Everything you are saying is completely valid.

Which hospital is your relative in?

Thank you, that one threw me a bit as I don't think I am doing anything wrong here by trying to advocate for her, that's rather the point of the POA and it's concerning anyone thinks that could be removed by me trying to push for a safer environment.

I'm not happy to share the hospital at the moment, it's a current ongoing situation so I don't feel that appropriate.

OP posts:
flourpot · 10/02/2024 11:11

DingDongDenny · 10/02/2024 10:48

As her carer you also have rights under the Carers Scotland Act. This includes the right to be involved in decisions about hospital discharge.

This leaflet explains it https://www.carersnet.org/wp-content/uploads/2021/06/6.-What-to-expect-when-the-person-you-care-for-is-discharged-from-hospital.pdf

My advice would be to point this out to them, even send them the leaflet to make sure you get to attend the meeting on Monday to have your say.

Someone else up thread also suggested contacting your local carers centre, who might have a hospital discharge worker. You can find them here careinfoscotland.scot/topics/support-for-carers/carer-centres/

Thank you this is very helpful

OP posts:
flourpot · 10/02/2024 11:03

2Rebecca · 10/02/2024 10:28

You can't force the hospital even a community hospital to keep in a patient they have assessed as suitable for home care, just as I can't demand I stay in hospital rather than go home. POA is irrelevant. You and your relative can decide between you depending on capacity and funding whether a care home may be a better alternative available if there is one you can fund but you can't force them to keep anyone in hospital

I wasn't really trying to. It's the choice of where the discharge is to that I am questioning.

At no time have I said I want her to stay in hospital, juts who has the overall say of where she is discharged too.

OP posts:
DingDongDenny · 10/02/2024 10:48

As her carer you also have rights under the Carers Scotland Act. This includes the right to be involved in decisions about hospital discharge.

This leaflet explains it https://www.carersnet.org/wp-content/uploads/2021/06/6.-What-to-expect-when-the-person-you-care-for-is-discharged-from-hospital.pdf

My advice would be to point this out to them, even send them the leaflet to make sure you get to attend the meeting on Monday to have your say.

Someone else up thread also suggested contacting your local carers centre, who might have a hospital discharge worker. You can find them here careinfoscotland.scot/topics/support-for-carers/carer-centres/

https://www.carersnet.org/wp-content/uploads/2021/06/6.-What-to-expect-when-the-person-you-care-for-is-discharged-from-hospital.pdf

halfshutknife · 10/02/2024 10:46

I'd bet my house on the fact that your poa will not be revoked based on what you are saying.

I get the impression that the mdt just haven't appreciated your significant concerns.

Everything you are saying is completely valid.

Which hospital is your relative in?

NeedToChangeName · 10/02/2024 10:41

Look at adults with incapacity (Scotland) act 2000. Section 1 general principles . And section 15 or 16 (?) and the POA doc, to check your powers are definitely in force

And mental welfare commission Scotland guidance on deprivation of liberty and powers of attorney

My take is, you can't insist she stays in any form of hospital if healthcare professionals say she's ready for discharge

Instead of fighting hospital about that,
I would contact a care home or two urgently, ask them to assess if they could care for your relative and progress that, as attorney. Emphasise that she'll be self funding. I think they usually need evidence that she can pay the fees for a set period, perhaps between 6 and 18 montgs, not sure

(Technically, you should probably seek guardianship to comply with deprivation of liberty issues, but that's a long journey and you don't have time on your side, so perhaps leave that for now)

Hope this helps

flourpot · 10/02/2024 10:29

Penguinfeetteal · 10/02/2024 08:54

@Jadebanditchillipepper with respect, the OP has asked for help not a discussion on NHS versus social care.. if you want to discuss that then start another thread instead of adding to the OP stress. Both nhs and social are on their knees in terms of funding and that is why most social care packages are carers in the home as it's cheaper than admitting a person needs a care home.

@flourpot you have to be strong, request everything in writing as well. It doesn't sound like they have fully done a social care assessment yet or at least they should have been asking you questions too as their POA as part of the social care discharge assessment. This is where our social worker outright ignored things we said (and had medical evidence to back up). Our complaint was upheld against her for just simply believing we should be caring for our nan and she was downright rude to us about it, judging us for saying we work full time and have young kids. She outright said you should give up work for your nan (our mum has already passed away). I really hope she isn't in the same role.

Unfortunately It is the difference between being clinically ready to discharge from hospital and then being safe at home etc but unfortunately it does involve having to push and hold your ground. It is not easy and so stressful!

Thank you for this it really made a difference when I read it this morning.

The idea that I can do her shopping is all good and well but what happens when she tries to cook said shopping is what I'm trying to impress upon them.

OP posts:
2Rebecca · 10/02/2024 10:28

You can't force the hospital even a community hospital to keep in a patient they have assessed as suitable for home care, just as I can't demand I stay in hospital rather than go home. POA is irrelevant. You and your relative can decide between you depending on capacity and funding whether a care home may be a better alternative available if there is one you can fund but you can't force them to keep anyone in hospital

flourpot · 10/02/2024 10:22

ask the ward staff if it’s a ‘best interest’ meeting and tell them you will be attending with your relative.

She is lying in a hospital bed and would be utterly confused by being wheeled into a meeting full of strangers talking about things she doesn't understand. That's not an option.

Just be cautious about how you word your concerns. Yes, you have POA, but if in the eyes of the medical professionals or Social workers you are trying to make decisions that they consider to NOT be in her best interest, they can apply to the courts to have the POA rescinded.

This is my sticking point. How can anyone think k sending her home is in her best interest.

I though POA being rescinded would be the opposite of I was trying to keep her home to be for myself in the future with inheritance, not by speaking up to get her to a lace of safety.

This is something i need to seriously consider as I am absolutely here for her and I didn't realise trying to push for a after environment could result in me losing the POA

OP posts:
Soontobe60 · 10/02/2024 09:15

OP, I would try to switch off this weekend. There’s nothing that can be done over the weekend anyway. You say there’s a meeting on Monday - ask the ward staff if it’s a ‘best interest’ meeting and tell them you will be attending with your relative.
At that meeting, there should be a discussion on what is best for the relative, and how that will be implemented. If they decide the relative needs to go home with a care package, then a care package will need to be implemented before she leaves the hospital. That could, quite frankly, take weeks. There are no carers around at the moment! In the meantime, tell them you are investigating care homes as your relative has expressed a desire for this. Contact care homes, ask them to assess your relative and set those wheels in motion. Just be cautious about how you word your concerns. Yes, you have POA, but if in the eyes of the medical professionals or Social workers you are trying to make decisions that they consider to NOT be in her best interest, they can apply to the courts to have the POA rescinded.
‘When dealing with my stepfather in a similar situation, I found that saying things like ‘I appreciate what you’re telling me, but there is no one to visit him at home and he is not safe’ said with a smile meant they didn’t see me as being obstructive. After several weeks in hospital, bed blocking, he was transferred to a care home for respite, and is still there 2 years later.

Penguinfeetteal · 10/02/2024 08:54

@Jadebanditchillipepper with respect, the OP has asked for help not a discussion on NHS versus social care.. if you want to discuss that then start another thread instead of adding to the OP stress. Both nhs and social are on their knees in terms of funding and that is why most social care packages are carers in the home as it's cheaper than admitting a person needs a care home.

@flourpot you have to be strong, request everything in writing as well. It doesn't sound like they have fully done a social care assessment yet or at least they should have been asking you questions too as their POA as part of the social care discharge assessment. This is where our social worker outright ignored things we said (and had medical evidence to back up). Our complaint was upheld against her for just simply believing we should be caring for our nan and she was downright rude to us about it, judging us for saying we work full time and have young kids. She outright said you should give up work for your nan (our mum has already passed away). I really hope she isn't in the same role.

Unfortunately It is the difference between being clinically ready to discharge from hospital and then being safe at home etc but unfortunately it does involve having to push and hold your ground. It is not easy and so stressful!

halfshutknife · 10/02/2024 00:29

That's what I'm trying to say. They work well in some situations but not in all.

I get you're not arguing but these are the types of things an mdt will suggest and im preparing you so you know what your response will be and what questions to ask.

As I said as a professional I know what can be recommended. As a daughter/wife/niece I know what I'd want for a 92 yr old with an inability to recognise risk and safe guard them self. Your humanity always forms part of the assessment.

flourpot · 10/02/2024 00:24

Sorry I'm not arguing with you I'm annoyed at the situation

OP posts:
flourpot · 10/02/2024 00:24

halfshutknife · 10/02/2024 00:17

Depends on the council but you can also manage that risk in the community with a falls detector. It's an upgrade to the community alarm and detects a change in height. The alert goes straight through to the call centre without the person pressing it.

A great piece of technology if someone wants peace of mind and to stay in their own home.

All of these safe guarding measures are great but my view (as a professional with 20+ years of experience) is want my loved one in 24 hour care

I don't want to know when she has fallen down a flight of stairs though . I want to prevent it.

OP posts:
halfshutknife · 10/02/2024 00:17

Depends on the council but you can also manage that risk in the community with a falls detector. It's an upgrade to the community alarm and detects a change in height. The alert goes straight through to the call centre without the person pressing it.

A great piece of technology if someone wants peace of mind and to stay in their own home.

All of these safe guarding measures are great but my view (as a professional with 20+ years of experience) is want my loved one in 24 hour care

flourpot · 10/02/2024 00:06

halfshutknife · 10/02/2024 00:04

Re not preventing the falls.

As op said people do fall in care homes and hospitals but the fall doesn't tend to be the biggest issue. The amount of time they lie and effect that causes is often worse.
In hospitals and care homes it's highly unlikely that the will be a long lie associated with a fall. This managing the risk rather than taking it away.

She already fell in hospital. My consideration was simply a fall at home can potentially be much worse because of stairs but actually I didn't consider that she could be lying for ages as well. No idea how becsue this is what lenses us in the situation we are in.

OP posts:
halfshutknife · 10/02/2024 00:05

Oops. I meant pp and I don't know how to edit 🤦🏼‍♀️

halfshutknife · 10/02/2024 00:04

Re not preventing the falls.

As op said people do fall in care homes and hospitals but the fall doesn't tend to be the biggest issue. The amount of time they lie and effect that causes is often worse.
In hospitals and care homes it's highly unlikely that the will be a long lie associated with a fall. This managing the risk rather than taking it away.

flourpot · 09/02/2024 23:57

Not in England and Wales there isn't

I'm not in England or Wales. I'm talking about Scotland and what the options are here/

. You still haven't said why the NHS should pay for social care needs?

I don't have to. Please don’t challenge me needlessly, I'm having a bad enough time right now without this crap

And saying it will cost them more if she falls at home isn't an answer to that question.

I was being sarcastic.

Patients also fall in hospital and in care homes, you can't mitigate against everything.

Less likely to break their necks on stairs in those settings though. Also able to be evacuated in case of emergency which would not happen immediately at home/

OP posts:
Swipe left for the next trending thread