Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Scotland - care home. Who has the legal 'say'

259 replies

flourpot · 09/02/2024 17:15

Looking for a bit of advice as I'm in a situation where I have POA for a relative and I disagree with the discharge team at hospital.

Relative is 93, has no capacity, no idea what's going on and lives upstairs flat. I think it would be dangerous to send her home.

Brief phone call today indicated the team think home with carers is acceptable

I did not realise that when the decision needed to be made about a care home it might not be my decision.

I'm struggling to find out whether my POA means I can disagree with the team at the hospital or if I have to accept their choice.

Any ideas?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Thread gallery
5
Notmorerainagain · 10/02/2024 20:21

Glad to hear you've got the POA all sorted and a medical professional on your side.

Be confident! You know your relative better than they do and it's your duty as attorney to act in their best interest. I write everything down (good excuse for a nice new notebook) in front of them and read it back to them, "helpfully summarise" conversations after they happen in emails to SW ("I'll just put that in an email"). I think it focuses their mind to know that there is an audit trail to show the reasons why I disagree with them. In those emails I've set out specific evidence of risks to relative's safety - bulletpoints are good - and when they happened eg accidents and hospital admissions, where safety risks can be found and that they can't be overlooked or fixed.

I am quite pushy and I don't care if they think I'm a pain in the neck! It's the squeaky wheel that gets the oil and my relative deserves to be cared for properly.

halfshutknife · 10/02/2024 20:18

flourpot · 10/02/2024 18:27

Minor update

I spoke to the ward nurse today who is involved in various meetings and she said she completely agrees with me and that she will vote things down and make sure concerns are heard but that also nothing will happen without them talking to me despite what I was led to believe. She also said I can disagree with a discharge to home and that I should be strong and push as far as I can with it.

Fabulous news.

I really firmly believe that people have just rushed in and given your concerns they will re stock. You see this a lot and although it's not the best people do 9/10 back track and re evaluate.

Please feel free to dm if you wish. Much like you not wanting to say too much, neither do I.

Lots of things people have said are so different in different areas. Ie Edinburgh can take an age for care to be put in place, Glasgow it can be arranged within 24 hours.

NeedToChangeName · 10/02/2024 20:06

flourpot · 10/02/2024 18:27

Minor update

I spoke to the ward nurse today who is involved in various meetings and she said she completely agrees with me and that she will vote things down and make sure concerns are heard but that also nothing will happen without them talking to me despite what I was led to believe. She also said I can disagree with a discharge to home and that I should be strong and push as far as I can with it.

That sounds encouraging

I'm going to bow out now. I wish you well and hope you get this sorted

flourpot · 10/02/2024 19:59

prettybird · 10/02/2024 18:52

That's good news Flowers

I agree that the scaremongering talk about "guardianship" is moot a red herring, as the whole point of organising a POA is to avoid having to go through expensive guardianship proceedings.

That's why, even though our POAs have not yet been registered at the OPG, we're not concerned as, should they be needed, they would be expedited by the OPG.

You've had them sorted and activated, so that's one less thing going for you to worry about. And it means you do have the right to make welfare decisions on your relative's behalf.

Just re-reading your posts, you need to stop doubting yourself and worrying whether or not you are "allowed" to advocate for her. You need to be crystal clear with the hospital team that you have Welfare PoA (you should have been sent it by the OPG: I know I had a letter from the OPG with my Dad's although I never had to use it) and that you therefore expect to be present at any meeting where her future care is discussed.

Thank you so much, I think you are right and I do need to stop doubting myself. I can see part of this is just a confidence issue. I'm not too sure of the process/system so that's made me a bit apprehensive.

OP posts:
flourpot · 10/02/2024 19:57

@NeedToChangeName

I don't think any of this is relevant to my circumstances.

OP posts:
NeedToChangeName · 10/02/2024 19:52

flourpot · 10/02/2024 16:02

Thank you, I think I will. It's not something that has come up at all.

I don't mind at all if you choose to ignore my comments about guardianship and deprivation of liberty

But, please understand I'm only trying to be helpful (and i do work in this area)

If you have time / inclination, you might wish to look at Suoreme Court decision in "Cheshire West case". And ECHR article 5. And the MWC guidance I referred to. In short, people who are "under continuous supervision and control" and "not free to leave" (basically, many care home residents) are deemed to be deprived of their liberty, and many people aren't aware that this needs to be lawfully authorised

Anyway, I hope you get this sorted

prettybird · 10/02/2024 18:52

That's good news Flowers

I agree that the scaremongering talk about "guardianship" is moot a red herring, as the whole point of organising a POA is to avoid having to go through expensive guardianship proceedings.

That's why, even though our POAs have not yet been registered at the OPG, we're not concerned as, should they be needed, they would be expedited by the OPG.

You've had them sorted and activated, so that's one less thing going for you to worry about. And it means you do have the right to make welfare decisions on your relative's behalf.

Just re-reading your posts, you need to stop doubting yourself and worrying whether or not you are "allowed" to advocate for her. You need to be crystal clear with the hospital team that you have Welfare PoA (you should have been sent it by the OPG: I know I had a letter from the OPG with my Dad's although I never had to use it) and that you therefore expect to be present at any meeting where her future care is discussed.

flourpot · 10/02/2024 18:27

Minor update

I spoke to the ward nurse today who is involved in various meetings and she said she completely agrees with me and that she will vote things down and make sure concerns are heard but that also nothing will happen without them talking to me despite what I was led to believe. She also said I can disagree with a discharge to home and that I should be strong and push as far as I can with it.

OP posts:
flourpot · 10/02/2024 18:23

@KittenKins

Thank you, you are right about them reacting to incidents rather than preventing them. I had no idea until now that this was the case.

OP posts:
flourpot · 10/02/2024 18:18

@halfshutknife

It's ok, that poster has no idea what they are talking about. I don't need to tell the hospital this, they already know. I think that poster just wanted to have a dig at me because I can't see any other reason for saying that.

OP posts:
halfshutknife · 10/02/2024 18:16

flourpot · 10/02/2024 15:20

I don't know anything about guardianship and it's not something that's been mentioned by anyone I have spoken to.

The liberty thing? I don't really know what people are trying to suggest. I don't actually want to deprive her or anything. Quite the opposite in fact. I feel she would have a better quality of life in a care home where there are activities, TV etc available, not to mention other people, then she would sitting/lying in her house alone for the majority of her time unable to do anything.

as well as the obviously safety risks

I haven't read the links re liberty but I will do when I get home, I thought the POA saying I can make decisions was enough. Now it seems it's not worth the paper it's printed on

Edited

Guardianship is the same powers as poa but applies if the person loses capacity without poa.

You don't need to worry about that.

Example. Someone comes into hospital and is deemed as an AWI. No one has powers. When planning discharge you need to apply for guardianship or move under section 13za whilst awaiting it.

Someone comes into hospital and is demoed as an awi and has poa. Job done. No need for guardianship.

KittenKins · 10/02/2024 18:16

I wish I could give you the answers you are looking for as I feel your frustration in every other post. Unfortunately, as you've been told you cannot insist your relative is discharged to a community bed.

The issue is everyone feels theirs relative isn't capable of being at home. For what it's worth, I agree with you. The thing is, as most community carers will tell you there are women, just like your mother in homes as I type with stairs, kitchens rugs & various other hazards with no clue that cleaning fluid isn't to drink, hobs cause fires & stairs aren't safe. Usually the system reacts to circumstances, ie the police finding a wandering concised gentleman on the street or a little old lady breaks her hip.

I've known a care provider telling staff to leave confused elderly peoples front door be left unlock (despite key safe) so the confused client could get out. Of course, they may not have the cognitive ability to achieve this, let alone the mobility.

As you've been made aware, as a self funder you can make calls & arrange assessments yourself as you have POA. The hospital won't be able to arrange a care package on a day or two anyway. Any provider (community or residential) usually complete their own assessment in the hospital as it's not uncommon to find hospitals over egg the patients abilities.

Tell the hospital your plans, stress your concerns, point out it's an unsafe discharge, give examples of near misses in the past with mum. Just remember they hear this every day, sadly.

You won't find anything in writing that gives you rights you wish, as far as I am aware.

Good luck & make sure you are looking after yourself, you are doing everything you can.

halfshutknife · 10/02/2024 18:14

flourpot · 10/02/2024 15:14

She is lying in a hospital bed and would be utterly confused by being wheeled into a meeting full of strangers talking about things she doesn't understand. That's not an option

If you said this to them, they may see you as being controlling

I'm not saying it to them. I'm saying it to you. They already know this information.

Edited

There's a lot of scare mongering here.

Being part of this procedure every working day I can assure you saying that you don't think your relative would cope with the meeting would not be viewed as controlling.

prettybird · 10/02/2024 17:08

Dh and I did our Powers of Attorney (both financial and welfare) back in September, naming each other and my lovely SIL. They can act "together or separately" (I trust SIL competely, as well as, of course, Dh Wink).

I've just checked the paper work and it says....

2.7 I have considered how my incapacity is to be determined and have decided it shall be so where my welfare attorneys reasonably believe that I am incapable.

....

2.12 This deed incorporates the necessary “capacity certificate” in the form prescribed by the 2000 Act.

I know that are are massive delays at the Office of the Public Guardian so they're in the "queue" and they've not yet been registered, but the lawyer assured us that if (heaven forfend) the powers of attorney should be needed, the OPG would expedite it.

My dad ended up having to put my mum into a home, using his power of attorney (which fortunately they'd both done for each other just before they went on the holiday where she acquired the head injury that ultimately ended up killing her 5 years later through a head injury induced early onset dementia Sad) with an emergency admission, rather than one of the ones he'd been looking at, as he recognised he wasn't coping and she'd had yet another fall. He ended up having some money paid back after (I think) the Social Work assessment confirmed her needs - but payment was never the issue as he just wanted her to be in a place where she would be safe.

I agree with others that you need to rapidly check out local suitable care homes. Mum needed somewhere with a dementia unit rather than just a "plain" nursing home.

I also agree that you need to be present at the "discharge" meeting - and make it absolutely clear that you will not be present at your relative's home when she is discharged, nor overnight. Ask very explicit questions about what risk assessments have been done.

You can't stop the discharge but you can advocate for a suitable care package. It may be that your relative ends up going somewhere temporarily until you can sort out somewhere better.

Even in the nursing home, mum ended up having to have pressure alarm pads around her bed as she didn't understand that she could no longer balance/walk and would fall every time she tried to go to the toilet.

I wish you well Flowers

flourpot · 10/02/2024 16:02

Malbecmoron · 10/02/2024 15:23

I would ignore the deprivation of liberty stuff OP. It doesn't apply here

Thank you, I think I will. It's not something that has come up at all.

OP posts:
flourpot · 10/02/2024 15:59

Notmorerainagain · 10/02/2024 15:43

In the POA document what does it say about what activates POA and have these conditions been met? My relatives says something like "when a medical practitioner certifies that I am incapable". The POA isn't any use without that certification to go with it. Have you got that evidence (and my apologies if you've already answered the question and I've missed it)

I'm asking because we are trying to sort out relative's financial affairs and the bank wants not only the POA document but also the certification from their doctor. Without both, we can't do anything.

Also it has to be the original document with the seal (?) on it and not a photocopy or email, unless it's been certified by a solicitor.

It's all been done I can't remember what it says but it's not under any question.

OP posts:
OneTC · 10/02/2024 15:49

I'm in England but when my mum was in hospital recently they would discharge her to me (I have fully enacted POA for health and finance) and I then decided to put her in a home but I couldn't object to her discharge

Notmorerainagain · 10/02/2024 15:43

In the POA document what does it say about what activates POA and have these conditions been met? My relatives says something like "when a medical practitioner certifies that I am incapable". The POA isn't any use without that certification to go with it. Have you got that evidence (and my apologies if you've already answered the question and I've missed it)

I'm asking because we are trying to sort out relative's financial affairs and the bank wants not only the POA document but also the certification from their doctor. Without both, we can't do anything.

Also it has to be the original document with the seal (?) on it and not a photocopy or email, unless it's been certified by a solicitor.

Malbecmoron · 10/02/2024 15:23

I would ignore the deprivation of liberty stuff OP. It doesn't apply here

flourpot · 10/02/2024 15:21

@Soontobe60

You haven't said anything remotely helpful on this thread so I'm going to scroll past any further posts from you.

OP posts:
flourpot · 10/02/2024 15:20

I don't know anything about guardianship and it's not something that's been mentioned by anyone I have spoken to.

The liberty thing? I don't really know what people are trying to suggest. I don't actually want to deprive her or anything. Quite the opposite in fact. I feel she would have a better quality of life in a care home where there are activities, TV etc available, not to mention other people, then she would sitting/lying in her house alone for the majority of her time unable to do anything.

as well as the obviously safety risks

I haven't read the links re liberty but I will do when I get home, I thought the POA saying I can make decisions was enough. Now it seems it's not worth the paper it's printed on

OP posts:
Malbecmoron · 10/02/2024 15:17

@Soontobe60 your link does not refer to Scottish law

Malbecmoron · 10/02/2024 15:15

I was referring to the fact that court of protection has no jurisdiction in Scotland @Soontobe60.

Of course poa shouldn't deprive liberty but I don't think the OP is planning to do that! Nobody is going to apply to remove the POA unless they are doing something awful. The OP is clearly trying her very best to ensure her mum gets the right care.

You definitely don't need guardianship if there's an appropriate POA in place. What extra guardianship powers would you ask for? Doesn't make sense

flourpot · 10/02/2024 15:14

She is lying in a hospital bed and would be utterly confused by being wheeled into a meeting full of strangers talking about things she doesn't understand. That's not an option

If you said this to them, they may see you as being controlling

I'm not saying it to them. I'm saying it to you. They already know this information.

OP posts:
NeedToChangeName · 10/02/2024 15:07

Malbecmoron · 10/02/2024 15:02

That doesn't apply in Scotland @Soontobe60

Speaking to the local carers centre is a good idea OP, as is speaking to advocacy.

As POA you can make the decision about where she lives (if it's in your POA powers, it probably is) but only from the options available. You don't need guardianship as you already have all the powers you need. Section 13za suggested by a previous poster doesn't apply here as you have an active POA.
You can move her to a care home now if you self fund but you won't get the free free personal care element of the fees as this needs to be assessed and given by the local authority

My advice is
Contact carers centre and advocacy to help get your voice heard
Ask social work to do an assessment
Ask if there is a risk assessment in place
Keep saying the discharge will be unsafe.

@Malbecmoron mental welfare commission scotland did a briefing on poa and deprivation of liberty. Their view is that POA should not be used to deprive an adult of their liberty. In my local authority, mental health officer would recommend guardianship. But, I understand other authorities may take a different view