Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Negative review - threat of legal action

87 replies

letmeeatinpeace · 09/02/2024 15:29

I recently had a stone worktop installed. The stone has an imperfection which I hadn't spotted when I viewed it at the stone supplier - the slab was 3 metres wide, and the imperfection is 3cm. The stone FABRICATOR (a separate company), unfortunately, positioned this imperfection in a prominent area where it's really visible - right in the middle of the food prep area next to the stove. As well as being an eyesore, the imperfection is rough to the touch and has little holes where food gets in so it's difficult to keep clean.

The day it was installed I asked what they could do to fix it but they were extremely dismissive/aggressive and just said I should use candle wax to fill the holes. They demanded payment (cash in hand) and I didn't feel comfortable pushing back about it on the day. I followed up afterwards, but they refused to fix it or offer advice on how I can fill the holes properly.

My review was going to be about how it would have been helpful if the stone fabricator had flagged the main imperfections before cutting it, and either avoided them or asked me where I'd prefer them to be positioned so they wouldn't be in such a prominent area. I think this is fair, seeing as they decided how the stone was cut. (Obviously, in hindsight, I should not have relied on their 'expertise' and should have gone there in person to check before it was cut - however, my untrained eyes may have missed it as I did the first time round).

I let them know I would be writing a review of my experience and they immediately threatened legal action for defamation if I were to go ahead. They included their solicitor's details, and said they have been instructed.

This company only has 5 star reviews (although the most recent one is 2 years old). I imagine they keep negative reviews at bay by using similar tactics.

I have been burned in the past with poor tradespeople so I feel strongly about warning others re what they could potentially be getting in to. Obviously, I would keep my review factually accurate, but I don't know the technicalities of defamation law... Could I include a screengrab of their email reply? It was so aggressive, they really don't come off well.

AIBU - should I let it go, and just let others walk into this kind of crap?

Or should I go ahead? Do I need a solicitor to check my review before posting??

Negative review - threat of legal action
Negative review - threat of legal action
OP posts:
Itsagreatdaytosavelives · 10/02/2024 13:59

but you need to speak to supplier as well. why are they recommending dodgy cash in hand folk?? they need to be told not to recommend as well

Marblessolveeverything · 10/02/2024 13:55

Bully boy tactics!
Keep it factual, accurate and evidence based. They won't have a leg to stand on. Mind you that won't stop any solicitor writing a generic letter quoting defamation law. That letter has no standing as it is an opinion and can often cause people fear and for them to retract.

Wolfpa · 10/02/2024 13:54

You can review whatever you want as long as it is factual but they didn’t cause the imperfection they were just installing what you had provided them.

will you also be talking to the people who provided the stone? Maybe they have a way of fixing it.

DragonGypsyDoris · 10/02/2024 13:48

Re cash arrangement at the outset for a cheaper price. That's when you lost the battle. Can you get in trouble for paying someone in cash? Theoretically not, but if it's a large amount the authorities could wonder where you got it from. If drawn from the bank, then fine. But if there is no audit trail ...

Lighrbulbmo · 10/02/2024 13:28

They can’t take legal action for a bad review unless the review was malicious or a lie. You are representing the truth and fact. Backed up with evidence. They are trying to intimidate you.
Did you receive a proper invoice for your cash payment?

doilooklikeicare · 10/02/2024 12:53

peakygold · 09/02/2024 16:32

Oh my god, the drama. Get get a stonemason in to fix it.

Are you always such a push over?

Sodndashitall · 10/02/2024 09:43

Factual information cannot be defamation.
Facts are these

  • you did see the slab first but didn't notice imperfection
  • you were disappointed to see imperfection so prominent in the worktop
  • imperfection is annoying to you (food etc)
  • they advised candle wax as a solution which seems not appropriate for a prominent part of worktop
  • they threatened you with defamation when you suggested you'd write a review of your experience
LlynTegid · 10/02/2024 09:21

I wish there could be a criminal offence of threatening to sue in some instances. Robert Maxwell used legal proceedings to bully people whilst he was effectively stealing pension funds.

LlynTegid · 10/02/2024 09:20

Let HMRC know about their tax dodging before anything else.

hamsterswhiskers · 10/02/2024 08:54

Could you give them the opportunity to rectify the damaged stone first. Ask them. If they refuse you can pop that in your review too. Your review will be factual and professional so they can't do anything and are just being bully's. Hate this sort of behaviour.

letmeeatinpeace · 10/02/2024 08:34

@newnamesix - yes, it was expensive... Almost £5k for the one slab, and cutting and installation. We didn't use the whole slab either. There's a section left over - I asked if we could replace the hob section with the leftover but they said removing the current worktop would cause extensive damage to the kitchen units...

Sounds like you got really good service! Would have been so helpful to get renderings of the templating - I didn't even realise that was an option! Did your company offer any kind of workmanship warranty as well? If it's ok, it would be super if you could share their details in a PM. I'd like to check if they agree that removing the worktop would cause too much damage.

Yes the supplier we got the slab from is in London and starts with an M, but I felt they were good, at least with communication. The fabricator, not so much...

OP posts:
Itwasmeinthebox · 09/02/2024 21:21

Just awful, we have vaguely similar situation going on at the moment and it can feel very intimidating

Londonrach1 · 09/02/2024 21:01

Factual review with photo evidence.

aurynne · 09/02/2024 20:59

Also, as they have willingly and unpromptedly given you their lawyer's details, I would phone the lawyer and let them know the company is using their details to threaten customers out of reviewing. I guarantee you the lawyer will not be happy about this.

aurynne · 09/02/2024 20:56

I would add to my review that they had threatened legal action, and suggest this is how they keep their good ratings.

The arseholes!

letmeeatinpeace · 09/02/2024 20:55

minipie · 09/02/2024 20:14

We had a marble worktop installed and they did a fabulous job of choosing the best bits of the slab for the most visible areas and vice versa. I would say this is part of the job. Certainly any flaws should have been flagged and if possible remedied or hidden.

If you post just facts and your own feelings (ie your disappointment) then there is no defamation.

Separately, I’d be surprised if that couldn’t be polished out.

My thoughts exactly. Sounds like you had a great fabricator!

OP posts:
letmeeatinpeace · 09/02/2024 20:53

BlueGrey1 · 09/02/2024 20:41

I went to several different supplier warehouses to find the perfect slab

You did select the slab though beforehand?

Yes I viewed and selected the slab. If you read my posts I said I didn't spot the imperfection.

The issue I have is not with the imperfection itself- natural stone is not pristine. The problem is the positioning of the imperfection - in a very visible area (right in the middle of food prep area next to the hob). I wouldn't have minded as much if it were in a corner.
The fabricator decided what bits to use and how to cut it, so should have avoided that bit or at least asked me where I'd prefer to position it.

OP posts:
BlueGrey1 · 09/02/2024 20:41

I went to several different supplier warehouses to find the perfect slab

You did select the slab though beforehand?

minipie · 09/02/2024 20:14

We had a marble worktop installed and they did a fabulous job of choosing the best bits of the slab for the most visible areas and vice versa. I would say this is part of the job. Certainly any flaws should have been flagged and if possible remedied or hidden.

If you post just facts and your own feelings (ie your disappointment) then there is no defamation.

Separately, I’d be surprised if that couldn’t be polished out.

letmeeatinpeace · 09/02/2024 20:11

For those who are wondering what it’s like to choose a stone slab - they are HUGE. Here’s a pic, with the imperfection circled. I didn’t spot it at the time. The slabs also have a sort of plastic protection in places to avoid scratching against other slabs, so you can’t do a really thorough check. I feel the fabricator should have flagged it before cutting, as they're the professionals.

Negative review - threat of legal action
Negative review - threat of legal action
OP posts:
mumda · 09/02/2024 20:10

You could do a fishing expedition on social media asking for recommendations for solving your problem worktop. Lots of photos.

People might ask who on earth did such a rubbish job.

letmeeatinpeace · 09/02/2024 20:08

@WillimNot - omg that sounds terrifying! At least mine is just stone, not my body!!

@newnamesix - yes Taj Mahal quartzite. It’s a beautiful stone, and I went to several different supplier warehouses to find the perfect slab!

OP posts:
letmeeatinpeace · 09/02/2024 20:08

Payment - they initially sent a written quote, then said they could do it cheaper if it’s cash in hand. They didn’t invoice. Yes, I should have known better. But again, I was trusting the glowing recommendation from the supplier.

Stupid question - but can the customer get into trouble for paying cash in hand? I assume not, as it’s purely the company’s responsibility to ensure they’re compliant/pay taxes etc?

OP posts:
letmeeatinpeace · 09/02/2024 20:08

In answer to the qns -

I arranged the stone worktop directly, it wasn’t through the kitchen company. I viewed it at a popular stone supplier warehouse (they were very good), and they recommended this fabricator, saying they’ve worked with them for many many years. When I first spoke to the fabricator I had an ‘off’ gut feeling (nothing concrete), but as they were so highly recommended, and had all 5 star reviews, I thought it would be safer than going with a company that I had zero recommendations for.
The fabricators website says they are skilled stonemasons, working for over 20 yrs, etc.

I kept the suppliers informed of all this and they actually said that they’ve been getting a lot of negative feedback lately about this fabricator, so they no longer recommend them.

OP posts:
letmeeatinpeace · 09/02/2024 20:07

Thanks everyone for your replies.

Hearing about your experiences of intimidation is so infuriating. Yes, I did wonder if being a woman they thought I’d be an easy target.

Little do they know I’m like a dog with a bone with these kind of things. When something is not right I just can’t let it go. I would feel bad for future customers not having a full picture of what they’re potentially getting into (I certainly wish I had been warned!).

OP posts:
Swipe left for the next trending thread