Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Negative review - threat of legal action

87 replies

letmeeatinpeace · 09/02/2024 15:29

I recently had a stone worktop installed. The stone has an imperfection which I hadn't spotted when I viewed it at the stone supplier - the slab was 3 metres wide, and the imperfection is 3cm. The stone FABRICATOR (a separate company), unfortunately, positioned this imperfection in a prominent area where it's really visible - right in the middle of the food prep area next to the stove. As well as being an eyesore, the imperfection is rough to the touch and has little holes where food gets in so it's difficult to keep clean.

The day it was installed I asked what they could do to fix it but they were extremely dismissive/aggressive and just said I should use candle wax to fill the holes. They demanded payment (cash in hand) and I didn't feel comfortable pushing back about it on the day. I followed up afterwards, but they refused to fix it or offer advice on how I can fill the holes properly.

My review was going to be about how it would have been helpful if the stone fabricator had flagged the main imperfections before cutting it, and either avoided them or asked me where I'd prefer them to be positioned so they wouldn't be in such a prominent area. I think this is fair, seeing as they decided how the stone was cut. (Obviously, in hindsight, I should not have relied on their 'expertise' and should have gone there in person to check before it was cut - however, my untrained eyes may have missed it as I did the first time round).

I let them know I would be writing a review of my experience and they immediately threatened legal action for defamation if I were to go ahead. They included their solicitor's details, and said they have been instructed.

This company only has 5 star reviews (although the most recent one is 2 years old). I imagine they keep negative reviews at bay by using similar tactics.

I have been burned in the past with poor tradespeople so I feel strongly about warning others re what they could potentially be getting in to. Obviously, I would keep my review factually accurate, but I don't know the technicalities of defamation law... Could I include a screengrab of their email reply? It was so aggressive, they really don't come off well.

AIBU - should I let it go, and just let others walk into this kind of crap?

Or should I go ahead? Do I need a solicitor to check my review before posting??

Negative review - threat of legal action
Negative review - threat of legal action
OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
DistinguishedSocialCommenator · 11/02/2024 15:18

letmeeatinpeace · 11/02/2024 15:03

@DistinguishedSocialCommenator yes I selected the slab in person. It was not discounted / cheaper than other slabs of the same material.

When you picked it - there is/was a notice that warned you about any imperfections.? I doubt it but I thought I'd ask

letmeeatinpeace · 11/02/2024 15:03

@DistinguishedSocialCommenator yes I selected the slab in person. It was not discounted / cheaper than other slabs of the same material.

OP posts:
letmeeatinpeace · 11/02/2024 15:00

pootlin · 11/02/2024 12:42

In that last pic you posted, I can’t even see any caulk or anything in the gap between the slab and the wall. Is it transparent or non-existent? Is that normal?

Yes there's a gap as the tiles aren't up yet.

OP posts:
pootlin · 11/02/2024 12:42

In that last pic you posted, I can’t even see any caulk or anything in the gap between the slab and the wall. Is it transparent or non-existent? Is that normal?

DistinguishedSocialCommenator · 11/02/2024 12:27

Hello OP

Just to be clear, you bought the stone by pointing to a piece of it? Was it on a discount, or anything?

With our review, I wrote, "I will update on any developments" and I did and I even thanked them when they finally sort it out, but the rest was like my previous post here.

Any stone masons here - can it be polished out?

Good luck

letmeeatinpeace · 11/02/2024 10:50

UPDATE: I have posted the review just now. Let's see what happens. I stated all the facts, and invited the owner to reply with any further details, or to flag any inaccuracy.

It feels like he's a pretty shady character, so I'm hoping he doesn't show up at our door!

I didn't include a screengrab of his email, as I wasn't sure if it would breach his right for privacy.

In the meantime, I've placed this large pot holder over the offending area so I don't have to think about it!

Negative review - threat of legal action
OP posts:
Itwasmeinthebox · 10/02/2024 23:00

thebestinterest · 10/02/2024 15:56

Came back to say, please share the company name with us so that we can also leave them some bad reviews 😡 the nerve!

Can you please not quote the whole of the opening post whenever you reply, it's so annoying to have to keep scrolling down the whole thing each time for the point you're making. It's totally unnecessary, we all know what we're discussing. Thanks

DistinguishedSocialCommenator · 10/02/2024 22:41

We had threats of legal action for an Orangery we had installed. The firm was massively delaying the repair of a leaky rrof. I gave them chance after chance to come over they failed to keep appointments etc and then were rue on thr phone to my OH

We left a review on a well-known site used by millions - the threats came got us worried and I said to my OH delete it, leave it - we even had the review site contacting us - our children said to leave it up as its a honest and very fair review - we left it there - they fixed the leak - We updated the review to say it was fixed but would not be using them again due to the stress, waste of time ect they cause - more threats to take it doen - it was stressful - then the CEO rang and was very nice and asked us to take it don - OH was going to when we got another call from a manager that was really rude and told us to take down the review - because of that call we did not but it was a100% honest and very fair review. It can be stressful no matter how honest and right you are

BlueGrey1 · 10/02/2024 22:32

Tell them that you are in no way afraid of their legal threats and that you will be leaving a negative review unless it is resolved in 5 working days….

Namemchangeforthispostonly101 · 10/02/2024 16:54

This reply has been withdrawn

The OP has privacy concerns, so we've agreed to take this down now.

penjil · 10/02/2024 16:48

Wanting payment in cash sounded a bit dodgy.

How much was this stone worktop anyway?

PinkyBlueMe · 10/02/2024 16:11

They won't have a successful legal action against you if your review is honest. No wonder they only have 5 star reviews - they probably threaten everyone and people either remove reviews or don't leave one.
I left an honest review of a local restaurant. A few days later my boss found his firm had a dreadful review naming me with some personal insults but we were confused as the review writer was definitely not a client. When we looked into it he was the owner of the restaurant. He then tried to blackmail me to take mine down and he'd do the same. I didn't though because the firm was closing anyway so his shitty review didn't really matter. Google were appalling though - we sent them the blackmail messages to try to get it taken down and they just ignored all communication.

MikeRafone · 10/02/2024 16:05

If I saw a review

Was unhappy with the work, I let them know the work was unsatisfactory and as nothing was corrected I wouldn't use again.

less is often more

What they might try to do is write a lot underneath, but often these type of people then box themselves into a corner in public

Tattletwat · 10/02/2024 16:01

thebestinterest · 10/02/2024 15:56

Came back to say, please share the company name with us so that we can also leave them some bad reviews 😡 the nerve!

Don't do this.

thebestinterest · 10/02/2024 15:56

letmeeatinpeace · 09/02/2024 15:29

I recently had a stone worktop installed. The stone has an imperfection which I hadn't spotted when I viewed it at the stone supplier - the slab was 3 metres wide, and the imperfection is 3cm. The stone FABRICATOR (a separate company), unfortunately, positioned this imperfection in a prominent area where it's really visible - right in the middle of the food prep area next to the stove. As well as being an eyesore, the imperfection is rough to the touch and has little holes where food gets in so it's difficult to keep clean.

The day it was installed I asked what they could do to fix it but they were extremely dismissive/aggressive and just said I should use candle wax to fill the holes. They demanded payment (cash in hand) and I didn't feel comfortable pushing back about it on the day. I followed up afterwards, but they refused to fix it or offer advice on how I can fill the holes properly.

My review was going to be about how it would have been helpful if the stone fabricator had flagged the main imperfections before cutting it, and either avoided them or asked me where I'd prefer them to be positioned so they wouldn't be in such a prominent area. I think this is fair, seeing as they decided how the stone was cut. (Obviously, in hindsight, I should not have relied on their 'expertise' and should have gone there in person to check before it was cut - however, my untrained eyes may have missed it as I did the first time round).

I let them know I would be writing a review of my experience and they immediately threatened legal action for defamation if I were to go ahead. They included their solicitor's details, and said they have been instructed.

This company only has 5 star reviews (although the most recent one is 2 years old). I imagine they keep negative reviews at bay by using similar tactics.

I have been burned in the past with poor tradespeople so I feel strongly about warning others re what they could potentially be getting in to. Obviously, I would keep my review factually accurate, but I don't know the technicalities of defamation law... Could I include a screengrab of their email reply? It was so aggressive, they really don't come off well.

AIBU - should I let it go, and just let others walk into this kind of crap?

Or should I go ahead? Do I need a solicitor to check my review before posting??

Came back to say, please share the company name with us so that we can also leave them some bad reviews 😡 the nerve!

thebestinterest · 10/02/2024 15:55

letmeeatinpeace · 09/02/2024 15:29

I recently had a stone worktop installed. The stone has an imperfection which I hadn't spotted when I viewed it at the stone supplier - the slab was 3 metres wide, and the imperfection is 3cm. The stone FABRICATOR (a separate company), unfortunately, positioned this imperfection in a prominent area where it's really visible - right in the middle of the food prep area next to the stove. As well as being an eyesore, the imperfection is rough to the touch and has little holes where food gets in so it's difficult to keep clean.

The day it was installed I asked what they could do to fix it but they were extremely dismissive/aggressive and just said I should use candle wax to fill the holes. They demanded payment (cash in hand) and I didn't feel comfortable pushing back about it on the day. I followed up afterwards, but they refused to fix it or offer advice on how I can fill the holes properly.

My review was going to be about how it would have been helpful if the stone fabricator had flagged the main imperfections before cutting it, and either avoided them or asked me where I'd prefer them to be positioned so they wouldn't be in such a prominent area. I think this is fair, seeing as they decided how the stone was cut. (Obviously, in hindsight, I should not have relied on their 'expertise' and should have gone there in person to check before it was cut - however, my untrained eyes may have missed it as I did the first time round).

I let them know I would be writing a review of my experience and they immediately threatened legal action for defamation if I were to go ahead. They included their solicitor's details, and said they have been instructed.

This company only has 5 star reviews (although the most recent one is 2 years old). I imagine they keep negative reviews at bay by using similar tactics.

I have been burned in the past with poor tradespeople so I feel strongly about warning others re what they could potentially be getting in to. Obviously, I would keep my review factually accurate, but I don't know the technicalities of defamation law... Could I include a screengrab of their email reply? It was so aggressive, they really don't come off well.

AIBU - should I let it go, and just let others walk into this kind of crap?

Or should I go ahead? Do I need a solicitor to check my review before posting??

They are threatening you if you leave a review? Who are they? A mafia group? How about they correct the issue? OP, I would go ahead and leave them a review and also mention how they are threatening you with a lawsuit! bastards 😡

Abitofalark · 10/02/2024 15:49

They are trying to intimidate you but it's doubtful they have instructed solicitors or would take legal action. And don't worry about getting into trouble for paying in cash. It's not illegal to do so and your money is presumably sound.

The truth and honest opinion is your protection and I would be factual, taking care to describe things precisely. What to you is the imperfection? From the photograph it seems like an irregular shape or patch of stone (is 5cm length - area would be sq cm?) which appears to be of a different colour from the surrounding slab and to have pitting in three places. Your text suggests also that the surface is not smooth. Is the colour difference the main issue for you, or one issue, along with the pitting and the surface texture?

In later photographs, one circled in red makes it look tiny and one alongside it is presumably an overview of the patch but it doesn't show the pitting seen in your first photo - colour variation yes, and perhaps something of the texture but not so clearly and it does look very different from the first,

Cerealkiller4U · 10/02/2024 14:49

Londonrach1 · 09/02/2024 21:01

Factual review with photo evidence.

This!!!

no emotions. No name calling no put downs.

just the exact factual review

Mazuslongtoenail · 10/02/2024 14:27

That would spur me on to be extra scathing. If you’re stating a fact that can’t and won’t do anything.

NightSprite · 10/02/2024 14:19

I would leave a factual review, including the photos of the damage and their emailed threat.

MCOut · 10/02/2024 14:14

Defamation is not defamation if it’s true. If you put up a factual account of your experience, their attempts at intimidation, and attach the pictures anything they choose to do is a waste of their money.

Tattletwat · 10/02/2024 14:13

I let them know I would be writing a review of my experience and they immediately threatened legal action for defamation if I were to go ahead. They included their solicitor's details, and said they have been instructed.

So they have instructed their solicitors before the review has even been left, what exactly would they have instructed them on something they may not be able to act on. Instructing their solicitor would cost them money which I'm sure they haven't spent.

Basically it seems to be becoming a common thing threatening legal action for bad reviews.

Keep your review unemotional and factual and keep the photos to back it up.

This likely won't go anywhere and is scare but just make sure you are covered by the truth and evidencial truth so they have no where to go.

freeedum · 10/02/2024 14:08

Karensalright · 09/02/2024 15:42

Defamation does not stretch to an honest opinion and the truth. So if you post a review describing what happened and express your disappointment at poor customer service, that you believed you have received that would be fine as well as putting a photo of the threatening letter, would also be fine.

Avoid accusatory words and name calling.

I agree with this. Even adding in the review that they sent OP a solicitor email for “defamation” so long as they have the evidence, I’d mention all of it. OP is doing the right thing, but should still write an anon review so they can’t accuse them anyway. I dont think OP should feel her complaints are unreasonable. Cash in hand for this type of work says a lot too!

freeedum · 10/02/2024 14:04

letmeeatinpeace · 09/02/2024 15:29

I recently had a stone worktop installed. The stone has an imperfection which I hadn't spotted when I viewed it at the stone supplier - the slab was 3 metres wide, and the imperfection is 3cm. The stone FABRICATOR (a separate company), unfortunately, positioned this imperfection in a prominent area where it's really visible - right in the middle of the food prep area next to the stove. As well as being an eyesore, the imperfection is rough to the touch and has little holes where food gets in so it's difficult to keep clean.

The day it was installed I asked what they could do to fix it but they were extremely dismissive/aggressive and just said I should use candle wax to fill the holes. They demanded payment (cash in hand) and I didn't feel comfortable pushing back about it on the day. I followed up afterwards, but they refused to fix it or offer advice on how I can fill the holes properly.

My review was going to be about how it would have been helpful if the stone fabricator had flagged the main imperfections before cutting it, and either avoided them or asked me where I'd prefer them to be positioned so they wouldn't be in such a prominent area. I think this is fair, seeing as they decided how the stone was cut. (Obviously, in hindsight, I should not have relied on their 'expertise' and should have gone there in person to check before it was cut - however, my untrained eyes may have missed it as I did the first time round).

I let them know I would be writing a review of my experience and they immediately threatened legal action for defamation if I were to go ahead. They included their solicitor's details, and said they have been instructed.

This company only has 5 star reviews (although the most recent one is 2 years old). I imagine they keep negative reviews at bay by using similar tactics.

I have been burned in the past with poor tradespeople so I feel strongly about warning others re what they could potentially be getting in to. Obviously, I would keep my review factually accurate, but I don't know the technicalities of defamation law... Could I include a screengrab of their email reply? It was so aggressive, they really don't come off well.

AIBU - should I let it go, and just let others walk into this kind of crap?

Or should I go ahead? Do I need a solicitor to check my review before posting??

You shouldn’t have said you were going to leave negative feedback, you do that anonymously. You could still leave anon feedback but change the details a bit. They can’t just claim defamation. First thing to do is make a formal complain to the company email and go through their complaints procedure. I am sure others can advise , but there should be an ombudsman for this type of issues and tradespeople. Not all tradespeople are the same but I’ve also had poor experiences.

Megifer · 10/02/2024 14:02

Id be ignoring their threats and leaving an objective review, including reference to them threatening legal action, on all review sites possible.