Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Hoping for a rise in VAT on items costing 500+ pounds RRP

138 replies

DistinguishedSocialCommenator · 09/02/2024 10:24

I was positing on another thread and came up with a way we in England and Wales could raise billions in tax revenue every years that could fund a better NHS HC and educating people for better HS etc, etc and better schools.

I would propose (Someone will now actually use this idea)
Raise VAT to 30% on every item that costs more than 500 pounds RRP to 30% and use the money towards NHS and education re better health for all. (Most washing machines, driers, fridges, tv's, sofas, beds, clothing, food, and eating out cost m a lot less that 500. A bit like the new tax that was introduced many years ago on cars costing RRP 40k plus

We've boguth cars easily surpassing the 40k mark, though the extra road tax hurts, we have a choice if to buy or not or buy a cheaper brand new car or a used car. Therefore, IMO, the above is a good idea and we can be flexible with the exact figures of extra vAT kicks in at xxx - RRP and the new could be slightly higher or lower.

AIBU as this will help all of us.

OP posts:
Leafbuds · 09/02/2024 12:39

reading people's points about the quality of things declining to get them under the price point etc makes me agree that this probably isn't a useful idea, but nonetheless I am not against the idea that something to create more money that could be directed towards the NHS could help, even if people think it's well funded already. If it were, we wouldn't have doctors and nurses leaving in droves or avoiding going in, we wouldn't have falling apart buildings and equipment, etc.

CringeQueen · 09/02/2024 12:37

£3k for a telly! 😲

tenbob · 09/02/2024 12:33

Tell me you have never worked in business without telling me you’ve never worked in business

This is SUCH a dumb and unworkable idea

Plus the arrogance of believing some random thought that’s come to you is a) original b) workable c) actually a good idea

Mercurial123 · 09/02/2024 12:32

ilovesooty · 09/02/2024 12:04

I doubt the politicians and media are reading Mumsnet to pick up on your ideas either

Of course they aren't. Did I say they were? I'm not deluded like the OP.

OiGetOff · 09/02/2024 12:29

VAT is an arse of a tax to legislate for.

Just do a little dig into the caselaw precedent for ‘single or multiple supply’, and you’ll see what I mean. Those +£500 items would be stripped below the threshold into various component parts, before you could say biscuit tin.

SalviaDivinorum · 09/02/2024 12:28

What a dreadful idea.

Encourage the purchase of cheap and poor quality products which will break and be in landfill within a year. Force out all the quality makers and small artisan businesses in favour of cheap Chinese imports.

And we all know the level will not be regularly reviewed.

Sorry OP but I'm not voting for you!

Leafbuds · 09/02/2024 12:25

More money could still help the NHS if they actually paid doctors, nurses, and other staff a competitive amount to stop them leaving. It would make their workload more realistic too, which would again stop some leaving, and convince others that training was a sensible career idea. More staff would have a big impact on quality of care and waiting lists. Or they could provide more money to eg. help pay energy bills in hospitals or some of the other massive increases this year that end up taking away the funding that would help patients if used in other ways.

So anything that provides more money for the NHS is a good thing in my view, if it's used appropriately - yes also lots of reform needed in how it's managed.

Whether this would be the best way to do it or not, I'm not sure, but I don't see why ideas like this shouldn't be considered, even if it's not this exactly amount or on that price level. I'd think a smaller % might be better, and on more luxurious things than £500; it might not even be this sort of tax - but I wouldn't write ideas like this off wholesale - nothing wrong with considering alternative ideas, whether it's actually put into practice or not.

Anotherparkingthread · 09/02/2024 12:22

This is one of the worst ideas I've seen trotted out on Mumsnet and I've seen some corkers.

As others have said, you will just get cheap shitty version of appliances in the under 500 bracket which is awful for the environment and the more expensive 'luxery' products will be even further out of reach for normal people. A 30 percent increases on the lowest price eg 500 would be 150 pounds, which is going to be a real slap on the face when unexpectedly your washing machine packs up. People are struggling as it is.
Also I imagine medical machinery costing hundreds of thousands would have this tax applied too, the NHS isn't tax proof it pays just like anybody else. So you have just made already incredibly expensive precision equipment even more expensive.

Ridiculous and ill informed again.

Couldyounot · 09/02/2024 12:10

A withholding tax on money leaving the jurisdiction might be a better idea. But that will never get off the ground as it would be viewed as boring and difficult.

ilovesooty · 09/02/2024 12:04

Mercurial123 · 09/02/2024 11:30

Lol it certainly wouldn't be a party I'd vote for. Your "brilliant " idea is a bit rubbish.

I doubt the politicians and media are reading Mumsnet to pick up on your ideas either

10ThousandSpoons · 09/02/2024 11:57

Nah that's a silly idea. Everything will just cost £499

mummymeister · 09/02/2024 11:55

The problem with giving the government - any government whatever colour their rosette - more money is that its just more money for them to waste. the whole idea of the NHS just needing more money and it will be fine is absolutely bonkers. It needs a politician with the balls to go for a complete root and branch review. its broken it cant be tinkered with it has to be looked at all over again with fresh eyes. give it more money and it will still be the same hopelessly inefficient thing that it is now.

CatherinedeBourgh · 09/02/2024 11:53

Sounds like a fantastic way to encourage people to buy disposable crap instead of high quality items to last a lifetime.

Just what the environment needs.

PrincessCharlette · 09/02/2024 11:52

That's a real vote winner !.

MarnieMarnie · 09/02/2024 11:49

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines - previously banned poster.

Tinkerbyebye · 09/02/2024 11:45

@DistinguishedSocialCommenator

My proposal does not impact those on low wages or mid wages, unemployed or even the rich for that matter, as you have a choice

this sentence alone shows you don’t understand, of course it impacts them, or are you saying they are not allowed furniture, TVs, houses, cars, holidays and the rest?

your idea is not a good one

Tinkerbyebye · 09/02/2024 11:43

The NHS gets enough, what’s needed is a bottom up review, waste stripped out, pay increases to nurses and doctors, reduction in nonsensical jobs and management, and a streamlined records system that can be accessed b6 any doctor or nurse in the country to get full medical history

then let’s add in getting money back from those holiday residents that need to pay, and if that means credit card out before treatment so be it

Procurement needs to be centralised, with better deals arranged than now

Trusts need to work the same

we don’t need to pay more, we need someone to sort the nhs

HoboSexualOnslow · 09/02/2024 11:40

It would cripple small businesses

SuperBored · 09/02/2024 11:39

Throwing more money at things doesn't always fix things. There are fundamental issues with the education system and the NHS and yes whilst these will take money to fix, money is not the root cause imo

Twentypastfour · 09/02/2024 11:35

And it’s a great idea to make it harder for people to pay car repairs (often over £500) and buy new boilers because theirs is knackered or make general house repairs. Building work is expensive enough as it is but let’s make it worse.

Mercurial123 · 09/02/2024 11:30

DistinguishedSocialCommenator · 09/02/2024 11:00

Thank you

I live i a real world where disgusting politics comes first and the ordinary people last

What you are suggesting is happening EG, oil producers but more need to be done, pushed too far like our Labour friends did years ago, the rich and companies will leave England

My proposal will impact me and my family as the last tv we bought last year was close to 3k - the car we bought a couple of years ago cost well in excess of 40k

The sofas we bought, ie 3 x 4 seaters cost over 2k each - the washig machine we bought about 3 years ago cost 800 but there were many below 500, etc etc

The VAT to brand new items. However, the exmaple I gave of the car tax, extra tax is road tax on cars new costing 40k+ RRP and you pay it for 5 years

My proposal is not set in stone and the new VAT could be less and the miimum item price where the higher VAT kicks in could be played around with

My proposal does not impact those on low wages or mid wages, unemployed or even the rich for that matter, as you have a choice.

However, the minimum price will need adjusting every year or two, other like cars, most cars of mid size are 40k plus

The money needs to be spent well, EG, Education, NHS, our roads. Not thrown away on useless, aircraft carriers, flying the flag in far away countries tryign to be a world leader when we are not.

Importantly, we need people to spend the money wisely unlike the Tories and the Labour lot that will always have their own agenda to get into number 10.

I am relatively sure the media and the politicians will air my idea as their own

Lol it certainly wouldn't be a party I'd vote for. Your "brilliant " idea is a bit rubbish.

Twentypastfour · 09/02/2024 11:18

And like the 40k car rule the amount presumably will not go up with inflation. So as of now it might impact day 70% of new sofas, come 2030 it’ll be 85% of new sofas.

NB on the car thing you said We've boguth cars easily surpassing the 40k mark, though the extra road tax hurts, we have a choice if to buy or not or buy a cheaper brand new car or a used car.
You still have to pay it for a used car that costs less than 40k when you buy it if the value was 40k at purchase, so buying a 4 year old car for 28k doesn’t actually exempt you from this extra tax either.

And I don’t know what percentage of cars were over 40k when they introduced it but if will be higher now and still higher in 5/10/15 years.

Fundamentally I don’t trust the government (under any party) not to sell us extra tax policies as somehow only hitting the minority and the richest and not adjusting by inflation to catch more and more people in the net.

Hereyoume · 09/02/2024 11:11

I don't think that's a great idea OP.

First off, the NHS will never function properly, no matter how much money you throw at it. The idea of infinitely free medical care, for life, for everyone, is just a ridiculous premise.

Also there would be unintended consequences, with people deliberately choosing to buy cheap crap, that just ends up being dumped in order to avoid paying the extra tax.

There is plenty of money in the country to fund services, it's just being spent in the wrong areas.

150 billion and counting on giant a train set, just to cut (wait for it) 20 minutes off a journey between Manchester and London.

7 billion on "Aid", when WE arw the ones with food banks on street corners.

Billions of pounds on a massive Aircraft Carrier which has no planes and keeps breaking down.

Stammerer wants to spend 28 BILLION a year of "green schemes"!

Hundreds of billions on an army that can't fight, a Navy that can't sail, an Airforce that can't fly. It's a disgrace.

Local councils wasting millions on LTN's and cycle routes when nobody has the slightest interest or intention to cycle anywhere.

We are not short of money.

We just allow politicians and local councils to lie to us about where they spend it.

DistinguishedSocialCommenator · 09/02/2024 11:00

AllAboardTootToot · 09/02/2024 10:28

How about stop squeezing Joe Public and focus on the tax breaks and favours for the rich inner circles.

Why should the common man be squeezed again?

Thank you

I live i a real world where disgusting politics comes first and the ordinary people last

What you are suggesting is happening EG, oil producers but more need to be done, pushed too far like our Labour friends did years ago, the rich and companies will leave England

My proposal will impact me and my family as the last tv we bought last year was close to 3k - the car we bought a couple of years ago cost well in excess of 40k

The sofas we bought, ie 3 x 4 seaters cost over 2k each - the washig machine we bought about 3 years ago cost 800 but there were many below 500, etc etc

The VAT to brand new items. However, the exmaple I gave of the car tax, extra tax is road tax on cars new costing 40k+ RRP and you pay it for 5 years

My proposal is not set in stone and the new VAT could be less and the miimum item price where the higher VAT kicks in could be played around with

My proposal does not impact those on low wages or mid wages, unemployed or even the rich for that matter, as you have a choice.

However, the minimum price will need adjusting every year or two, other like cars, most cars of mid size are 40k plus

The money needs to be spent well, EG, Education, NHS, our roads. Not thrown away on useless, aircraft carriers, flying the flag in far away countries tryign to be a world leader when we are not.

Importantly, we need people to spend the money wisely unlike the Tories and the Labour lot that will always have their own agenda to get into number 10.

I am relatively sure the media and the politicians will air my idea as their own

OP posts:
WaitingfortheTardis · 09/02/2024 10:45

I'm not sure this would be very environmentally friendly, it may well encourage the making of cheaper, disposable versions of things.