Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Hoping for a rise in VAT on items costing 500+ pounds RRP

138 replies

DistinguishedSocialCommenator · 09/02/2024 10:24

I was positing on another thread and came up with a way we in England and Wales could raise billions in tax revenue every years that could fund a better NHS HC and educating people for better HS etc, etc and better schools.

I would propose (Someone will now actually use this idea)
Raise VAT to 30% on every item that costs more than 500 pounds RRP to 30% and use the money towards NHS and education re better health for all. (Most washing machines, driers, fridges, tv's, sofas, beds, clothing, food, and eating out cost m a lot less that 500. A bit like the new tax that was introduced many years ago on cars costing RRP 40k plus

We've boguth cars easily surpassing the 40k mark, though the extra road tax hurts, we have a choice if to buy or not or buy a cheaper brand new car or a used car. Therefore, IMO, the above is a good idea and we can be flexible with the exact figures of extra vAT kicks in at xxx - RRP and the new could be slightly higher or lower.

AIBU as this will help all of us.

OP posts:
MarnieMarnie · 09/02/2024 14:57

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines - previously banned poster.

DistinguishedSocialCommenator · 09/02/2024 14:44

Reading all of the posts, some really good ones here

Yes, the new vAT will negatively impact small business.

Someone saying if the VAT went ahead on a higher cost on items 500+ and compaies would seell a 700 laptop for 500 and then batter for 200, good point but as we all know many laptops caost over 1k if not more as do mobile phones

To be clear, my proposals are not set in stone.

The new VAT could be set higher or lower than 30%
The 500 plus RRP could be raided

A forum member had a good idea here and I quoted them in an earlier post, "tax handbags" they said

Yes, possibly apply the tax to handbags, mobile phones, tv's, furniture but not carpets, holidays, car hire, and a few other items and some expenses, eg, food but not clothing, the service sector like car repairs, getting bolier, roof fixed, new fence, drive etc

This will raise billions but I fear the prized clowns from both main parties will quite quickly redirect this extra income or cut back on what was targeted earlier

We don't want Labour back in as trust me if you've got a bit of savings, own your own home and a private pension, you will be seriously hammered.

Both parties will say anything to get to number 10 but as soon as they are in there, its everyone for themselves

I believe what politicians say just as much as I trust a serial cheat

OP posts:
unsync · 09/02/2024 13:51

Toottooot · 09/02/2024 10:36

Awa bile yer heid min.

This. With knobs on.

MontyDonsBlueScarf · 09/02/2024 13:46

OiGetOff · 09/02/2024 12:29

VAT is an arse of a tax to legislate for.

Just do a little dig into the caselaw precedent for ‘single or multiple supply’, and you’ll see what I mean. Those +£500 items would be stripped below the threshold into various component parts, before you could say biscuit tin.

Edited

I came on to say 'what's an item?' but this puts the point so much better. Businesses would be marketing things like dining room suites as 6 separate chairs and a table, with all the associated extra paperwork, and then there would need to be legislation that clarified whether or not that was acceptable. CGT legislation already attempts to address this but it's not as simple as you might at first think.

Zwicky · 09/02/2024 13:29

the idea is really good

You haven’t provided a single reason as to why it’s a good idea. As everyone has already pointed out, goods will be split into components for billing, small businesses will go bust creating unemployment and even more empty retail premises which reduces income for the freeholder and accelerate the death of the high street further, it will discourage quality manufacturing and encourage cheap imports that will have to be frequently replaced. What, specifically, is “really good” about it? You think it will generate more tax revenue but it’s not massively likely, especially when offset against unemployment in the manufacturing and retail sector. Morally why is it ok to tax a £400 piece of jewellery, a £50 pair of boxer shorts, a £480 belt, a £40 eyeshadow, a £300 birthday cake at 20%, but £500 washing machine, a £800 carpet, a £700 laptop at 30%? Which of those are the greater luxury? Which of those make a meaningful impact on people living a decent, comfortable life?

I would agree VAT needs a huge overhaul. I don’t agree with 20% on lots of things (hospitality where the VAT can’t be offset as the raw materials are zero rated) and the whole biscuit/cake millionaires shortbread debacle. I think it’s so high now it has a negative effect on retail, construction and manufacturing, but I’m sure someone cleverer than me knows the tipping point where so many business can’t survive the the negative impact negates the VAT collected. 20% added to everything you make on top of your wages and energy and premises and equipment costs is already huge. 30% on quite basic stuff like kitchen appliances and furniture is just stupid.

Meadowfinch · 09/02/2024 13:28

That's going to kill most people's attempts to buy an air source heat pump. Or carry out any environmental improvements.Or buy a new boiler. Or perhaps you'd like people to just get cold.

I've got three major expenses this year -

  1. replace our broken water pump - OP, would you like us to keep sharing bathwater or just not wash?
  2. Replace my two remaining windows that are single glazed - or should I just keep wasting gas heating? Hardly environmentally helpful.
  3. I've replaced our roof because it was way past end of life. Should I just have knocked the house down? Or lived with rain coming in?

And anyway, buying a cheaper, lower quality item is almost always a false economy. Better quality lasts longer.

Sorry OP, Possibly the silliest suggestion yet...

Fizbosshoes · 09/02/2024 13:21

another implication if VAT on high cost items rises, is potentially more transactions moving to the black market.

But agree with pp how is this not going to impact low earners?
If you're a low earner £500 will be a greater proportion of your wages, but that won't mean you never need anything costing over £500 🙄 and adding an extra 10% would surely have a bigger impact? Bikes, fridges wardrobes not outrageously luxurious items that could easily cost more than 500

GoodOldEmmaNess · 09/02/2024 13:20

The £500 rule wouldn't target wealthier people. It would target anyone, rich or poor, who had to buy something that it is hard to buy for less than £500.
VAT isn't structured to be charged on the basis of price. It is structured to be paid on the basis of the categories that goods and services fall into.
The way to target wealthier people is to increase income tax, capital gains tax, etc.

TheDowdyQueen · 09/02/2024 13:17

There are significant challenges facing our economy and way of living, including health and social care.

It's not going to be fixed by bunging 10% more tax on some items. It requires long term, cross party collaboration to bring about radical change.

Until our governments stop using the NHS and education as political points to be scored, they are never going to make any real progress.

Besides, who'd trust this bunch with any more money? Not me.

doodoodahdah · 09/02/2024 13:16

How stupid. Inflation would rocket and you'd knacker the economy.

Snugglemonkey · 09/02/2024 13:16

JoeLovesGina · 09/02/2024 10:33

VAT was originally introduced to just be in luxury items and still should be.

Private schools, expensive cars, jewellery etc. Things that nobody needs.

There are many reasons why a child may need to attend a private school.

LaPalmaLlama · 09/02/2024 13:15

Inequality in the Uk is better defined by assets than income so some sort of tax on the value of an individual’s total net assets would likely be the fairest way to increase taxation.

Bumpitybumper · 09/02/2024 13:15

user1497207191 · 09/02/2024 13:00

@Leafbuds

increase people wanting to go into medicine, etc., and that has to be helpful in the end.

There's no shortage of people wanting to go into healthcare. Medical schools are grossly over-subscribed by applicants with the required exam grades etc. The problem is retention, both of trainee/newly qualified staff and those later in their careers who either give up or reduce their working days/hours because they don't need to earn more.

We need more medical schools as a starting point. We've needed more for decades, but between successive governments and the BMA, the number of training places just hasn't increased enough. Govts didn't want to spend money, the BMA didn't want too may new doctors as it would reduce their bargaining power and career prospects.

Exactly right, loads of young people are desperate to be doctors and there really isn't a shortage of applicants. The bottle neck initially is in training them and then there are further issues with retention and working hours. Not to mention that the NHS can find that it is competing with the private sector in its efforts to get doctors to work more. Why would they do this for less for the NHS when they can get more money in the private sector?

As other posters have suggested, just paying doctors more isn't necessarily the answer. Doctors are human like everyone else and are often balancing their home commitments with their demanding work life. If they can get the lifestyle they want by working fewer hours and having more time with their kids then this is what they will often choose. I know at least two doctors who have made this choice in the past year and can afford skiing holidays and private school still. Paying them more wouldn't entice them to work more hours but would actually make them consider cutting down further.

Their main complaints aren't about how much they are paid but about working conditions and the stress that is placed on them. I have no doubt that money would be needed to resolve these issues but the only real solution is proper structural changes where the number of people training to be doctors increases and these recruits are used to help alleviate some of the pressure on the existing doctors.

Catza · 09/02/2024 13:09

I struggle to see how your proposal wouldn't impact people with low and medium income. I work for the NHS and the pay is no way high. I had to invest into a new mattress this year. It was over £500 which was a big investment for me. I am not sure I could stretch my salary any further than this by adding 10% to the cost. Neither I could pay additional 10% to pay for my 3,5k car. So I wouldn't be able to travel to work in under two hours and my partner would continue to struggle to sleep due to chronic pain and unsupportive mattress. I also wouldn't be able to earn extra money through my other job which requires reasonable spec computer.
£500 items are not luxury items. And yes, this will very much affect low and medium earners.

MarnieMarnie · 09/02/2024 13:08

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines - previously banned poster.

user1497207191 · 09/02/2024 13:00

@Leafbuds

increase people wanting to go into medicine, etc., and that has to be helpful in the end.

There's no shortage of people wanting to go into healthcare. Medical schools are grossly over-subscribed by applicants with the required exam grades etc. The problem is retention, both of trainee/newly qualified staff and those later in their careers who either give up or reduce their working days/hours because they don't need to earn more.

We need more medical schools as a starting point. We've needed more for decades, but between successive governments and the BMA, the number of training places just hasn't increased enough. Govts didn't want to spend money, the BMA didn't want too may new doctors as it would reduce their bargaining power and career prospects.

user1497207191 · 09/02/2024 12:57

At the end of the day, if we want more tax revenue to be generated, we need to grow our economy and that means supporting business a hell of a lot more than we currently do.

Actually NOT excluding over 3 million freelancers/self employed would have been a good start as we'd have more businesses who would have survived covid, most making profits, employing people, paying taxes, etc., and fewer people on the dole and empty business premises!

It would be good to have a government who supported smaller and private businesses. Tories just want their "big" business friends. Labour don't seem to like business at all. The vast majority of people in the country are employed by small and medium sized companies, yet they're barely ever given meaningful support, neither at start up stage nor ongoing. Yet some foreign multinational wants to set up a factory here and the govt bungs them a few billion!

Leafbuds · 09/02/2024 12:54

But if they have options to leave the NHS or leave the UK, they won't adjust. Whether anyone thinks that doctors get paid enough or too much or whatever, doesn't really matter - if they are leaving, then we have to do something to fix that. Again, alternative ideas like linking pay rises to hours could be considered - I don't know enough about that yet to have an opinion - but not giving them pay rises because others don't have them isn't going to work either. More doctors, more nurses, more staff, all would make working conditions better, increase people wanting to go into medicine, etc., and that has to be helpful in the end.

user1497207191 · 09/02/2024 12:53

OiGetOff · 09/02/2024 12:29

VAT is an arse of a tax to legislate for.

Just do a little dig into the caselaw precedent for ‘single or multiple supply’, and you’ll see what I mean. Those +£500 items would be stripped below the threshold into various component parts, before you could say biscuit tin.

Edited

Yep, we'll be having laptops sold for £499 but without a battery, so you have to buy a battery separately for £250, all for the same laptop that currently costs £749!

The VAT registration threshold currently screws very small businesses who sometimes "split" their businesses so that they don't have to register for VAT. There are pubs with two separate "businesses" - one owned by hubby selling the drinks and the other owned by wifey doing the food. I know of a fireplace shop who has two businesses - one to sell them and the other to fit them. Look at Carpetright - they sell the carpets, but you have to pay the fitter separately.

Adding a random £500 threshold into the mix will just make that kind of thing more common.

DistinguishedSocialCommenator · 09/02/2024 12:51

user1497207191 · 09/02/2024 12:48

If we're not careful, paying higher wages to nurses and doctors could make things worse. As we saw with Blair's GP contract and then more latterly with the stupidly high tax/pension charges on the likes of GP pension schemes. They just work fewer hours which means the shortage gets worse!

I'd love to see any significant wage rises to doctors and nurses be linked somehow with a requirement for them to work the same, if not more hours, to qualify for it. I.e. a bonus for those working 4 or 5 days per week, or a sliding hourly rate scale which increases the "per hour" rate for the more hours that they work. It's the only way to stop workers from reducing their hours/days when given a significant pay rise.

The last thing we want is a full time doctor being given a 20% pay rise and then deciding to cut their days to just 4 instead of 5 because they can afford to!

Exactly that and this is why I'm against the big increases the docs are seeking

Local gov workers went without a rise for three years - we all have to adjust

For retired people often income reduces and the savings they hold become gradually worthless with high inflation - so keep wages/costs down is good

OP posts:
DancefloorAcrobatics · 09/02/2024 12:51

No thanks.
That would just add a lot of essentials & things that make life more bearable to the unaffordable list.

schloss · 09/02/2024 12:49

Small businesses will be damaged, many never recovered from the mess of lockdowns.

The majority of the public bodies, including the NHS, will never improve no matter how much money is given to them. There needs to be fundemental change.

The way to increase tax take is to increase the tax free amount for earnings, then have a flat rate low tax. A higher tax free amount for employment will encourage work and reduce the benefits paid, therefore more money for NHS etc. A flat rate tax minimises any kind of tax avoidance, people are more willing to pay their tax as they feel it is not too high, this equals a higher tax take.

Finally, lower corporation tax to encourage businesses here, more employment, more corporation tax paid, once again equals more money in the coffers.

DistinguishedSocialCommenator · 09/02/2024 12:49

Twentypastfour · 09/02/2024 11:35

And it’s a great idea to make it harder for people to pay car repairs (often over £500) and buy new boilers because theirs is knackered or make general house repairs. Building work is expensive enough as it is but let’s make it worse.

Hello

Sensible point. As I said, it needs to be looked at a little more closely, but the idea is really good.

One main concern is all of them, tories/labour will waste the money if not properly ring-fenced
Thank you.

OP posts:
user1497207191 · 09/02/2024 12:48

If we're not careful, paying higher wages to nurses and doctors could make things worse. As we saw with Blair's GP contract and then more latterly with the stupidly high tax/pension charges on the likes of GP pension schemes. They just work fewer hours which means the shortage gets worse!

I'd love to see any significant wage rises to doctors and nurses be linked somehow with a requirement for them to work the same, if not more hours, to qualify for it. I.e. a bonus for those working 4 or 5 days per week, or a sliding hourly rate scale which increases the "per hour" rate for the more hours that they work. It's the only way to stop workers from reducing their hours/days when given a significant pay rise.

The last thing we want is a full time doctor being given a 20% pay rise and then deciding to cut their days to just 4 instead of 5 because they can afford to!

Zwicky · 09/02/2024 12:44

My proposal does not impact those on low wages or mid wages, unemployed or even the rich for that matter, as you have a choice

One of the stupidest things I’ve ever read. People on low or mid wages don’t need cars, furniture, carpets, appliances, electronics. I guess if you are poor, you don’t “need” a tv or a washing machine. Poor kids can do all their online homework at the library, if only it wasn’t closed by the time they get home from school because that will be amazing for social equality. You can wash your clothes in the sink and drip dry them. People would be selling sofa frames, plus cushions, plus covers as 3 separate items to get around it. Builders merchants will be splitting £4900 bills into 10 individual ones .People won’t be able to afford the hike, will stop buying and businesses will close. I sell VAT rateable good (food, not luxury) and VAT at 20% is already causing huge closures across my sector. It’s my 3rd biggest bill and 4x my own salary (which is admittedly under min wage as the heavy taxation means I can’t pay myself properly atm). You’ve dropped £80k on cars and you have the cheek to tell me that not having a washing machine won’t impact my life?