Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Hoping for a rise in VAT on items costing 500+ pounds RRP

138 replies

DistinguishedSocialCommenator · 09/02/2024 10:24

I was positing on another thread and came up with a way we in England and Wales could raise billions in tax revenue every years that could fund a better NHS HC and educating people for better HS etc, etc and better schools.

I would propose (Someone will now actually use this idea)
Raise VAT to 30% on every item that costs more than 500 pounds RRP to 30% and use the money towards NHS and education re better health for all. (Most washing machines, driers, fridges, tv's, sofas, beds, clothing, food, and eating out cost m a lot less that 500. A bit like the new tax that was introduced many years ago on cars costing RRP 40k plus

We've boguth cars easily surpassing the 40k mark, though the extra road tax hurts, we have a choice if to buy or not or buy a cheaper brand new car or a used car. Therefore, IMO, the above is a good idea and we can be flexible with the exact figures of extra vAT kicks in at xxx - RRP and the new could be slightly higher or lower.

AIBU as this will help all of us.

OP posts:
MotherOfRatios · 10/02/2024 12:45

DistinguishedSocialCommenator · 10/02/2024 12:43

Even these days you can get a decent washing machine sub 500
Gas hob, sub 500
Electic over sub 500
and many other items

You may have missed it but I've agreed with posters here who posted that car emchains should be expsmt and I said all services EG builders/decorator etc

The 500 pounds is not fixed, just a blal-park figure

Having lived in a number of rented properties where they choose the cheapest white goods. It never works out in the long run. It pays to buy more expensive things which will last.

NeverDropYourMooncup · 10/02/2024 12:44

DistinguishedSocialCommenator · 10/02/2024 12:01

Someone talked about this on a phone-in radio
"Liz Truss" - I predicted IRL and another blog that Truss would either,
Bankrupt the country
Or, get us nuked by the sick Putin
I also predicted she would be gone in 4/5 weeks max - she went in 6 weeks and
two of those weeks on the back of our Queen Elizabeth, passing.

FYI, my OP is not set in stone and many good ideas in the thread what we could put the exta VAT on and what not to.
Even the RRP was an idea and it can be lower or higher. Judging by the comments, the RRP price set at 650 pounds and increased at the rate of inflation every year is a really good way forward

So you still want to punitively tax my hearing aids, glasses and floor coverings as luxuries?

DistinguishedSocialCommenator · 10/02/2024 12:43

MotherOfRatios · 10/02/2024 12:40

Just make it even harder for first time buyers then because white goods and finishing a property is expensive and you have to save for that as well as allows deposit and solicitors and convenient fees....

this wouldn't help the average Joe blogs it would just make things worse for them.

We need to tax the 0.1% tbh

Even these days you can get a decent washing machine sub 500
Gas hob, sub 500
Electic over sub 500
and many other items

You may have missed it but I've agreed with posters here who posted that car emchains should be expsmt and I said all services EG builders/decorator etc

The 500 pounds is not fixed, just a blal-park figure

OP posts:
DistinguishedSocialCommenator · 10/02/2024 12:40

Alcyoneus · 10/02/2024 12:13

MN never fails to amaze with the economically illiterate coming along with their brainwaves. This thread is another gem.

OP, where are are you substituting a £40k car with one that’s £499. Do share.

If you had concentrated on the fundamentals of this thread and noted what I have stated, you would know that myself and all of my family would be impacted by my proposal of 30% VAT as everything we buy is often over that well over it other than the washing machine a couple of years ago that came with a free 5 year guarantee.

I don't like paying tax and even our 20% rate of income tax hurts but all of our children pay 40% income tax. You are allowed to have spending options if you are working hard and utilising your money prudently as we are.

To be CLEAR. This proposal will hit us hard, but something needs to be done to ensure we have a decent, streamlined NHS, alog with the security of benefits for those less able and the infrastructure of England.

So the 30% vAT impacts me and the family on almost every spend as per my OP.

OP posts:
MotherOfRatios · 10/02/2024 12:40

Just make it even harder for first time buyers then because white goods and finishing a property is expensive and you have to save for that as well as allows deposit and solicitors and convenient fees....

this wouldn't help the average Joe blogs it would just make things worse for them.

We need to tax the 0.1% tbh

Braksonsboss · 10/02/2024 12:33

OP is very grandiose. I’ve not read so much nonsense in a long time.

Alcyoneus · 10/02/2024 12:14

OP is probably Diane Abbott.

Alcyoneus · 10/02/2024 12:13

MN never fails to amaze with the economically illiterate coming along with their brainwaves. This thread is another gem.

OP, where are are you substituting a £40k car with one that’s £499. Do share.

DistinguishedSocialCommenator · 10/02/2024 12:01

ohididntrealise · 09/02/2024 21:42

"I am relatively sure the media and the politicians will air my idea as their own"

😂 😂

OP, your misplaced confidence is astounding.

Your "idea" is rudimentary, flawed, and just nowhere near as good / groundbreaking as you think it is.

Everyone is telling you so and yet you are responding as if you are getting good feedback.

Can I ask what you do for a career?

Are you a politician?

Are you Liz Truss?

Although, I have to say, you have a somewhat male arrogance about you....are you male?

Someone talked about this on a phone-in radio
"Liz Truss" - I predicted IRL and another blog that Truss would either,
Bankrupt the country
Or, get us nuked by the sick Putin
I also predicted she would be gone in 4/5 weeks max - she went in 6 weeks and
two of those weeks on the back of our Queen Elizabeth, passing.

FYI, my OP is not set in stone and many good ideas in the thread what we could put the exta VAT on and what not to.
Even the RRP was an idea and it can be lower or higher. Judging by the comments, the RRP price set at 650 pounds and increased at the rate of inflation every year is a really good way forward

OP posts:
Zwicky · 10/02/2024 00:28

If they are in the 15% band and buy an item for £120 + £24 VAT(at 20%) and sell it for £160 + £24 VAT(at 15%) do they pass nothing on to the government?

The answer to “do they pass nothing on to the government” is “no, they don’t” as the whole point of the scheme would be to reduce the tax burden on small business, and increase total tax receipts by business growth and increased employment, rather than to get as much as humanly possible from each small transaction. It would recognise the particular struggles in staffing and investment that small businesses face. The aim is to stop the tsunami of business closures, not just because it’s devastating for individuals and communities, but because closed businesses pay no tax, redundant workers pay no tax and the landlords of empty properties pay no tax.

Businesses that are not registered for VAT don’t charge it, but they do charge pretty much the same for goods and services as VAT registered businesses so make a higher profit. Also, for lots of VAT registered businesses the VAT they charge and the VAT they pay aren’t the same because of the flat rate scheme. There aren’t a load of hospitality businesses all over the place charging 20% below what they good realistically achieve in the market because they are not VAT registered. It does make it hard to be competitive when you are up against a business who automatically keeps 20% more of their turnover than you do. The threshold encourages people to keep their declared turnover low by either being criminals or by being underproductive. As a pp said, if a business turns over £85k, they need to turnover £105k to make the same profit as soon as they tip over into being VAT registered. Why bother when you can just shut for January instead and HMRC gets exactly zero.

A variable banding would ably to the submitted VAT returns for that quarter, not a previous years turnover. It’s not a variable rate for consumers, it’s a variable payment for businesses. It would be complicated but tax often is and we manage with different rates for other taxes. If you, for example, turned over £80k in rateable goods in one quarter and the rate was set at £1k zero, £1-6k 8% and £10-20k 15%, £20-50 18% and £50-80 20% you would do your sums, arrive at just over £13, and deduct your VAT on what you have bought at 20% so if you had bought £10k of goods inc 20% VAT then you deduct £2k and send £11k to HMRC. You’ve saved £3k on the current system which for a lot of businesses in the current climate is the difference between staying open and closing down. Your supplier will have charged you 20% but they will have done similar sums and their overall VAT burden will be less. How much less depends on their size as a company turning over £50k a year will end up on a different overall rate than a company turning over £10million. This is already in existence with the flat rate scheme where the customer per is charged 20% but the business pays less, but the threshold for the flat rate scheme, like the zero rate scheme encourages under productivity. We need different thresholds and, frankly, a reduction in the standard rate. We already recognise that as a “sales tax” VAT is not applied equally to all sales. Its business dependent, not purely goods dependent. If I sell you a meal for £10 it’s not rateable. If I sell you 8499 meals for £10 each, it’s not rateable, if I sell you 8501 meals for £10 then it is rateable and I have a tax bill of £17k. I up my price to £12 to cover it and you go somewhere else where it’s only £11.50, but they only open 3 days a week and close from Christmas to Easter. For most basic goods from independent suppliers, consumers are unaware if they are being charged for VAT and how much of that charge will actually end up at HMRC. Someone just says “that’ll be a tenner please mate” and that’s the end of it. Even if you check and find out it’s a registered business, if that business is on the flat rate scheme then they aren’t passing over the 20% you think they are.

MontyDonsBlueScarf · 09/02/2024 22:18

@ohididntrealise thanks for the best laugh of the day

ohididntrealise · 09/02/2024 21:42

"I am relatively sure the media and the politicians will air my idea as their own"

😂 😂

OP, your misplaced confidence is astounding.

Your "idea" is rudimentary, flawed, and just nowhere near as good / groundbreaking as you think it is.

Everyone is telling you so and yet you are responding as if you are getting good feedback.

Can I ask what you do for a career?

Are you a politician?

Are you Liz Truss?

Although, I have to say, you have a somewhat male arrogance about you....are you male?

Ohdeardddddeardear · 09/02/2024 21:33

Spaghettieis · 09/02/2024 10:43

Terrible idea unless it’s only on actual luxuries. VAT is generally regarded as a very regressive tax. Much better to increase capital gains taxes, introduce wealth taxes/land value tax etc.

Agree.

jcyclops · 09/02/2024 21:22

Zwicky · 09/02/2024 18:55

And staggering the payments, 8% on first £10k, 12% up to £80k, 15% up to £250k, 18% up to £500k, 20% up to £1.5mil, 22% over that would massively help independents. You would still get stalling around the thresholds but not so much was we do now.

This looks to be even more impractical than OP's proposal.
Businesses that are not VAT-registered are not allowed to charge VAT and also can not reclaim VAT on goods bought.
So a £200 (exc VAT) item would be £216, £224, £230, £236, £240 or £244 solely depending on the size of the business selling it?
Also, how would a trader decide on which band to apply? Would it be based on previous year's sales?
If they are in the 15% band and buy an item for £120 + £24 VAT(at 20%) and sell it for £160 + £24 VAT(at 15%) do they pass nothing on to the government?

DistinguishedSocialCommenator · 09/02/2024 20:06

Zwicky · 09/02/2024 18:56

Re example of a bottle of the real stuff Vs a box, valid points are easily addressed, IE, as a bottle of the hot stuff can be a complete stand-alone item, then it does not attract the 30%

So a £200 bottle of wine, or a case costing £1200 is 20% VAT but some poor bastard replacing a mattress is 30%? But it doesn’t impact low and mid pay workers?

Rubbish, Loads of good mattresses around sub 500, read the reviews

OP posts:
Braksonsboss · 09/02/2024 19:57

What a totally awful idea and really poorly thought out.

BIossomtoes · 09/02/2024 18:57

This is about as sensible as your idea that doctors shouldn’t be allowed to strike @DistinguishedSocialCommenator.

Zwicky · 09/02/2024 18:56

Re example of a bottle of the real stuff Vs a box, valid points are easily addressed, IE, as a bottle of the hot stuff can be a complete stand-alone item, then it does not attract the 30%

So a £200 bottle of wine, or a case costing £1200 is 20% VAT but some poor bastard replacing a mattress is 30%? But it doesn’t impact low and mid pay workers?

Zwicky · 09/02/2024 18:55

And staggering the payments, 8% on first £10k, 12% up to £80k, 15% up to £250k, 18% up to £500k, 20% up to £1.5mil, 22% over that would massively help independents. You would still get stalling around the thresholds but not so much was we do now.

Zwicky · 09/02/2024 18:51

A far better way to raise more VAT without changing the system too much is to reduce the level which you need to register

Totally. The £85k threshold was brought in when Moses was a boy to help small businesses with small turnovers stay competitive. It’s a ridiculous amount now. It should either be brought right down to something like £2600 so someone selling a few crafty bits on Etsy doesn’t get embroiled in paperwork, or zero, because it’s a sales tax and everyone selling should collect it, or brought up to something like £500k to encourage small businesses to increase productivity. Lots of businesses in my sector just work fewer and fewer hours to stay under the threshold, rather than being more productive and turning over eg £200k (which would bring in £40k in VAT instead of zero). Don’t even get me started on the “cash only” and “the card machine is broken” crowd.

NeverDropYourMooncup · 09/02/2024 18:02

I spent 650 on a mattress because I needed it due to spinal problems.

I spent 635 on a sofa because it needed to be supportive and the correct height.

If I ever get the money together, it's going to cost that to have something other than bare hardboard upstairs. It'll cost more than that to replace the lino in the wetroom that's torn because it was laid direct onto bare concrete. It'll cost more than that to replace the kitchen units that have rotted through due to an absence of insulation or underlay on the floor underneath more torn lino.

It'll cost about that to replace my laptop that I use for work/makes me employable, as the cheap ones don't have the processing power to cope with the work I do. It'll cost that to set up an ergonomic desk area when I can't physically make it into work everyday.

850 for air filtration due to the pollution in the area.

Maybe if you were nearer to the two grand mark, you might have a point,

My future hearing aids will cost more. So would my glasses or contacts, all thanks to my body being a bit shit.

I'm fine about your car costing an extra 20%, but leave the rest of us poor bastards alone.

Mercurial123 · 09/02/2024 17:48

DistinguishedSocialCommenator · 09/02/2024 17:26

This is one of the most nasty and horrific comments that someone has ever aimed at me on the net.

Surely not?

aitchteeaitch · 09/02/2024 17:45

Bad idea. Nightmare to implement. VAT legislation is complicated enough as it is. And I say that as someone who has this week paid our firm's eyewatering VAT return for the last quarter.

It's a 'No' from me.

RadiatorHead · 09/02/2024 17:37

£500 is quite a low amount. I’m very much of the opinion ‘but cheap, buy twice’ so usually get expensive appliances which are built to last. My spare fridge freezer was £900 and is still going strong after 16 years.

DistinguishedSocialCommenator · 09/02/2024 17:32

jcyclops · 09/02/2024 17:15

I see no fundamental problem taxing different classes of goods at different rates - we do this already, but doing it by sales price has many flaws.

Another problem with OP's proposal is when quantity becomes a factor.
A bottle of Dom Perignon Vintage costs £200 and VAT is 20%. If I bought a case of 6 for £1200 - should this attract VAT at 30%?
Christian Louboutin Loubishark trainers are £800 so VAT would be 30% - but I could buy a left trainer for £400 then a right trainer for £400 and only pay 20% VAT.

Edited

Thank you

As I said it has to be finalised and my public consultation is assisting with this.

Re example of a bottle of the real stuff Vs a box, valid points are easily addressed, IE, as a bottle of the hot stuff can be a complete stand-alone item, then it does not attract the 30%

I believe you will agree with me.

OP posts: