Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Black character for World Book Day?

160 replies

WorldBookDayChoice · 09/02/2024 10:08

My almost four year old is white with wavy/curly hair. She has a story book whose main character is black with curly hair, and DD has always said this character looks like her. She now wants to dress as this girl for WBD. In practice this will just mean wearing specific coloured clothes and holding the book up, but she's also mentioned making her hair even curlier to match the character's hair.

Basically is this okay? Or disrespectful?

YANBU it's okay
YABU it's not okay

OP posts:
WorldBookDayChoice · 09/02/2024 13:07

CheekboneMagazine · 09/02/2024 13:03

My daughter went as Tiana from Princess in the Frog for a party because she is her favourite Disney princess. We didn't do anything with skin or hair, just the same dress and focused on the attributes of the character such as great cook, kind, hard working.

And a toy frog? 😁 We had problems with Room on the Broom because she wanted to take the cat with her. She has a stuffed one but she wanted to take the real one 🤣 Anyway sorry I digress

OP posts:
CheekboneMagazine · 09/02/2024 13:03

My daughter went as Tiana from Princess in the Frog for a party because she is her favourite Disney princess. We didn't do anything with skin or hair, just the same dress and focused on the attributes of the character such as great cook, kind, hard working.

WorldBookDayChoice · 09/02/2024 13:02

iLovee · 09/02/2024 12:58

I'm mixed heritage but look white and I personally don't see it as any different to wearing a white plait for Elsa or plaits/messy hair for Hermione but its a tricky one because we are not a hive mind.

I also don't think a 3 year old can be racist.

Just out of interest, whats the book? X

Thank You for the Little Things by Caryl Hart

OP posts:
OnlyFoolsnMothers · 09/02/2024 13:00

I think it’s lovely your child has embraced a character who happens to be black. It’s hair- my children are mixed raced, if they want to stick a blonde plait in their hair to be Elsa why not?! It’s not corn rowing or dreadlocks!

BobblyJumpers · 09/02/2024 12:59

LilBus · 09/02/2024 12:07

See stuff like this confuses me, is it just white children that can’t dress as black characters or are black children not suppose to dress as white characters either?

I find it confusing as well. Especially the hair thing. If someone is dressing up as a specific character no matter what the colour of their skin, then I would assume they want to look as similar as they can to that character within their means (obviously no black face).

Are we saying now that if a black child wanted to go as Dorothy from the wizard of Oz they wouldn't be allowed to put their hair in two plates? But wearing the dress would be fine? Or if they wanted to dress as Cinderella, and has natural curly hair - is it not acceptable to comb it back wear it in a bun because it's considered too white?

Or a white blonde child that loved the story of Pocahontas wasn't allowed to wear a brown wig as part of the costume?

Theres so many blurred lines of what's acceptable and what's not. Everyone is offended by something these days

iLovee · 09/02/2024 12:58

I'm mixed heritage but look white and I personally don't see it as any different to wearing a white plait for Elsa or plaits/messy hair for Hermione but its a tricky one because we are not a hive mind.

I also don't think a 3 year old can be racist.

Just out of interest, whats the book? X

WorldBookDayChoice · 09/02/2024 12:54

FourLeggedBuckers · 09/02/2024 12:52

I was basing that on this thread, the responses (not the bonkers ones, but the reasonable ones as above) and the potential for it to seem off, because of the historic attitude towards characteristics associated with being black. It isn’t - to me - a stance worth arguing, if there’s the chance than even a minority of people of colour would find it unsettling.

Understood, thank you

OP posts:
FourLeggedBuckers · 09/02/2024 12:52

WorldBookDayChoice · 09/02/2024 12:38

Thanks - why is the hair contentious? Not arguing I just want to know. I think DD would not want to do it without doing her hair (she went as the witch from Room on the Broom last year and took great delight in having the plait with the right bow in it, etc) so it would probably be a no to the whole thing if this is the case.

The character is not offensive, just a normal girl in a story

I was basing that on this thread, the responses (not the bonkers ones, but the reasonable ones as above) and the potential for it to seem off, because of the historic attitude towards characteristics associated with being black. It isn’t - to me - a stance worth arguing, if there’s the chance than even a minority of people of colour would find it unsettling.

WorldBookDayChoice · 09/02/2024 12:44

ComtesseDeSpair · 09/02/2024 12:42

Okay, I’ll give it a go. I’m mixed. I wouldn’t be “offended” by OP’s DD, and it’s clear no offence is intended, but I would find it somewhat uncomfortable that a parent might not have thought about what curling her DD’s hair to make her look more like a black character represents. It’s taking a physical feature which carries a lot of weight and contention in all kinds of ways both historically and currently for black people, and trivialising it for dress up. It doesn’t mean that the OP or her DD are racist, but what is racist is telling black and mixed people they shouldn’t have the feelings they do and those feelings are stupid.

And here’s the thing - black people aren’t a hive mind. I’m uneasy with it; another mixed poster on this thread says they wouldn’t care; there will be other mixed and black people who share both or neither of these opinions. All of those opinions are valid. So when people start confidently saying “there’s nothing wrong with it” and using words like unhinged and stupid towards those who don’t agree with them, as if theirs is the only opinion that matters, that’s where the contention begins.

Edited

Thank you, I appreciate this

OP posts:
ComtesseDeSpair · 09/02/2024 12:42

TheKeatingFive · 09/02/2024 12:22

Whilst it’s difficult to verbalise explicitly exactly what would be wrong with it

You find it difficult to verbalise because there isn't anything wrong with it

Okay, I’ll give it a go. I’m mixed. I wouldn’t be “offended” by OP’s DD, and it’s clear no offence is intended, but I would find it somewhat uncomfortable that a parent might not have thought about what curling her DD’s hair to make her look more like a black character represents. It’s taking a physical feature which carries a lot of weight and contention in all kinds of ways both historically and currently for black people, and trivialising it for dress up. It doesn’t mean that the OP or her DD are racist, but what is racist is telling black and mixed people they shouldn’t have the feelings they do and those feelings are stupid.

And here’s the thing - black people aren’t a hive mind. I’m uneasy with it; another mixed poster on this thread says they wouldn’t care; there will be other mixed and black people who share both or neither of these opinions. All of those opinions are valid. So when people start confidently saying “there’s nothing wrong with it” and using words like unhinged and stupid towards those who don’t agree with them, as if theirs is the only opinion that matters, that’s where the contention begins.

WorldBookDayChoice · 09/02/2024 12:40

10ThousandSpoons · 09/02/2024 12:18

3 year old can be racist

Ok but she isn't

OP posts:
WorldBookDayChoice · 09/02/2024 12:38

FourLeggedBuckers · 09/02/2024 12:32

There’s no need to curl her hair. That’s the only bit that is likely to be contentious, so I’d sidestep that entirely.

But otherwise, it seems perfectly reasonable, unless the character is themselves an offensive stereotype / their dress is a stereotype / inaccurate etc. In that case, you probably have bigger issues than WBD.

Thanks - why is the hair contentious? Not arguing I just want to know. I think DD would not want to do it without doing her hair (she went as the witch from Room on the Broom last year and took great delight in having the plait with the right bow in it, etc) so it would probably be a no to the whole thing if this is the case.

The character is not offensive, just a normal girl in a story

OP posts:
FourLeggedBuckers · 09/02/2024 12:32

There’s no need to curl her hair. That’s the only bit that is likely to be contentious, so I’d sidestep that entirely.

But otherwise, it seems perfectly reasonable, unless the character is themselves an offensive stereotype / their dress is a stereotype / inaccurate etc. In that case, you probably have bigger issues than WBD.

watcherofpie · 09/02/2024 12:27

I'm very pale whit son went as a black football player, didn't even occur to me it wasn't ok. He just loves that player.

TossieFleacake · 09/02/2024 12:24

I think it's a lovely example of how our children rarely see skin colour as being relevant. Your DD is inspired by and loves a character from a book ... the colour of that characters skin is of no importance to her. The only people who would have a problem with this are the people who overthink racism and people who want to find a problem with everything.

TheKeatingFive · 09/02/2024 12:22

Whilst it’s difficult to verbalise explicitly exactly what would be wrong with it

You find it difficult to verbalise because there isn't anything wrong with it

10ThousandSpoons · 09/02/2024 12:18

WorldBookDayChoice · 09/02/2024 12:15

To clarify re. the hair, as I said her hair is wavy/curly anyway and she sometimes asks for plaits or bunches in overnight to emphasise the curls, just as she sometimes asks for a ponytail or space buns or whatever hairstyle. So that's what we would be doing - something we already do on occasion anyway and which uses her hair's existing curliness. I wouldn't be getting a wig or anything like that. I just mentioned the hair to make sure I included all the details.

Thanks for all the responses, even those saying don't do it, I appreciate the perspectives. (Apart from the one OTT comment, that is. Calling a not even four year old racist for wanting to dress as a character she likes is preposterous. I was asking about the appropriateness of dressing up, not whether she is racist or not. She clearly isn't, she's three.)

3 year old can be racist

Writely · 09/02/2024 12:18

If you’re active on social media and post your child (which I appreciate not everyone does want to do ) you might want to tag the author. I love getting tagged in pictures of kids dressed up as my characters :)

Good luck @WorldBookDayChoice and hope you and your daughter enjoy WBD.

Sux2buthen · 09/02/2024 12:17

ComtesseDeSpair · 09/02/2024 10:29

Whilst it’s difficult to verbalise explicitly exactly what would be wrong with it, I would discourage her tbh. It isn’t blackface, but people/characters of colour are more than just their hairstyle, and whilst most people wouldn’t take offence to a child dressed up, you aren’t going to be there to explain the reasoning behind the costume all day to anyone who does find it a bit off.

Literally no one in real life would comment

TinyYellow · 09/02/2024 12:16

I wouldn’t want to send my child the message that her choice of book character is wrong because of the colour of that characters skin, so I would support your dds choice wholeheartedly. Anyone who has a problem with it needs to take a hard look at themselves, because they are wrong.

WorldBookDayChoice · 09/02/2024 12:15

To clarify re. the hair, as I said her hair is wavy/curly anyway and she sometimes asks for plaits or bunches in overnight to emphasise the curls, just as she sometimes asks for a ponytail or space buns or whatever hairstyle. So that's what we would be doing - something we already do on occasion anyway and which uses her hair's existing curliness. I wouldn't be getting a wig or anything like that. I just mentioned the hair to make sure I included all the details.

Thanks for all the responses, even those saying don't do it, I appreciate the perspectives. (Apart from the one OTT comment, that is. Calling a not even four year old racist for wanting to dress as a character she likes is preposterous. I was asking about the appropriateness of dressing up, not whether she is racist or not. She clearly isn't, she's three.)

OP posts:
10ThousandSpoons · 09/02/2024 12:13

ErrolTheDragon · 09/02/2024 12:09

My dd went to one book day as Captain Hook.
She wasn't 'identifying as male', or as disabled come to that.

Did she have a hook and pretend her hand was amputated??

Mumof3girlsandaboy · 09/02/2024 12:12

redalex261 · 09/02/2024 12:03

Your suggestion is fine OP. Those warbling about potential offence on this thread are frankly unhinged - I would suggest they are the “racists” if they honestly think black people would be upset at a small child choosing to dress up as a black fictional character SHE ADMIRES for world book day, or that a white child should not choose a black character as their hero. Used to be there were no black characters in kids’ books. It’s great there now is and that’s who your daughter has chosen as her hero. As for curling her hair - definitely, why ever not? People of all ethnic backgrounds have curly hair - its just a benign way for your daughter to present as the character. We should be teaching kids to be colour blind accept all people, not to see people as “other.” There is still real racism affecting people all across the world - this is not it.

Agree

Writely · 09/02/2024 12:12

LilBus · 09/02/2024 12:11

That’s not even anywhere near the same though as a child wearing a custom from a book where the character is black.

Exactly. It’s very different which was my point.

10ThousandSpoons · 09/02/2024 12:12

Just do it without the curly hair?