Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Black character for World Book Day?

160 replies

WorldBookDayChoice · 09/02/2024 10:08

My almost four year old is white with wavy/curly hair. She has a story book whose main character is black with curly hair, and DD has always said this character looks like her. She now wants to dress as this girl for WBD. In practice this will just mean wearing specific coloured clothes and holding the book up, but she's also mentioned making her hair even curlier to match the character's hair.

Basically is this okay? Or disrespectful?

YANBU it's okay
YABU it's not okay

OP posts:
Universalsnail · 09/02/2024 14:59

As long as you don't face paint her brown this is fine I think.

IsthisthereallifeIsthisjustfantasy · 09/02/2024 14:50

I imagine a lot of girls will want to dress up as the Little Mermaid and have mermaid parties after the new film came out. I don't see a problem with wearing the same costume as your favourite character.

The hair would be a line for me. Children with afro hair are still unfairly penalised by school uniform codes, and still have to deal with people touching their hair without permission. There are only really just now swim caps for afro hair coming out in the UK that are affordable in comparison with swim caps for white hair. It's complicated and by just styling your daughter's hair in that style I think you'd be over simplifying something that is still a political issue.

kitsuneghost · 09/02/2024 14:37

It's completely acceptable IMO
Movies coming out now don't adhere to certain ethnic groups playing certain roles as they are characters, not real people. Anyone can play Cinderella, The little mermaid, Tiana. It's all fine nowadays

Sonora25 · 09/02/2024 14:36

I have been wondering the same about Ada Twist.

TheRealKatnissEverdeen · 09/02/2024 14:35

Gonna read the whole thread shortly.

Please don't stop her imagination, fun amd having a black role model. She's just 4.

I'm a black mumsnetter. If anyone wants to beef me over my opinion have at it.

Y6yhnsr5 · 09/02/2024 14:31

Honestly I didn't see the bit about her hair before. That's a no in my opinion but dressing like the book character is fine.

sensationalsally · 09/02/2024 14:28

Nothing wrong with it at all so long as you don't paint her face black. The curly hair is neither here nor there.

NewOrder · 09/02/2024 14:18

Just seen the book.

Fine to match the clothes but would leave her hair alone.

NewOrder · 09/02/2024 14:17

I think it depends on what the character is, surely?

I would never, for example. let my white DD dress up as Moana.

Mirabai · 09/02/2024 14:14

I’m mixed heritage. I think different poc would feel differently about it. On the one hand you wouldn’t want any poc to feel they couldn’t come as a white character; on the other the history of white people dressing up as poc is grim and tone deaf.

So - I don’t know. I wouldn’t do anything to her hair, it’s a loaded issue for people with African heritage.

Mischance · 09/02/2024 14:02

One of my (white - fair hair, blue eyes) GDs has a best friend who is black. GD describes her as her twin. She relates to her as a twin soul.

She and my GD have played dressing up in the girl's mother's African clothes and had a great time. There is no way it should be seen as racist.

If your DD identifies with the book character sufficiently to dress up as her on WBD, then she is clearly already looking beyond skin colour for her role models and looking at what that character represents that she admires.

SlightlygrumpyBettyswaitress · 09/02/2024 13:52

I can't see it's any different to a black child dressing as Harry Potter tbh.

Mumsanetta · 09/02/2024 13:47

I am black. This is not offensive, in fact I’m almost offended by the suggestion that a black character is only for black kids! I hope your DD enjoys dressing up as her favourite character.

Writely · 09/02/2024 13:46

ComtesseDeSpair · 09/02/2024 12:42

Okay, I’ll give it a go. I’m mixed. I wouldn’t be “offended” by OP’s DD, and it’s clear no offence is intended, but I would find it somewhat uncomfortable that a parent might not have thought about what curling her DD’s hair to make her look more like a black character represents. It’s taking a physical feature which carries a lot of weight and contention in all kinds of ways both historically and currently for black people, and trivialising it for dress up. It doesn’t mean that the OP or her DD are racist, but what is racist is telling black and mixed people they shouldn’t have the feelings they do and those feelings are stupid.

And here’s the thing - black people aren’t a hive mind. I’m uneasy with it; another mixed poster on this thread says they wouldn’t care; there will be other mixed and black people who share both or neither of these opinions. All of those opinions are valid. So when people start confidently saying “there’s nothing wrong with it” and using words like unhinged and stupid towards those who don’t agree with them, as if theirs is the only opinion that matters, that’s where the contention begins.

Edited

This will be my last comment on this before I exit the thread, but just wanted to say that although I hold a different position to yours I feel this is an excellent post.

If more people could be more respectful regarding nuanced topics like this it would be great.

Of course some people will find certain things offensive that others - even the majority - don’t. However, that’s always been the case.

We are all different and just like people have different views on what they view as acceptable or proper in regards to what politicians or newspapers say , climate change solutions, what children should be learning at school/home, what issues should be taboo in children’s media /literature or even what people say about the royal family and many many other things, there’s going to be differences of opinions within topics like this too.

You’ll get the people who can’t wait to say “people find everything offensive nowadays” or they are being too “woke” (hate the misuse of that word btw!) but they are normally people lacking in empathy.

There have and will always be people who hold different views based on upbringing, personality and background etc. It’s just nowadays, minority voices can’t be silenced as much.

I remember as a teen, a group of friends told a racist joke. I was disgusted and me and my (white) best friend challenged them. They kept arguing with us that we were being over sensitive. This was the 90s and they’d probably be embarrassed if I reminded them of it now.

My point being I can imagine, especially in the past, people have remained silent when they’ve found things offensive but nowadays feel more empowered to state their position as you have here @ComtesseDeSpair .

So kudos to you 👏🏾👏🏾

TheOriginalEmu · 09/02/2024 13:37

My daughter went as Auoda from Around The World in 80 days once and until I read this thread it never occurred to me that people might have seen it as racist 😕
she just loved the character and her jewellery

Y6yhnsr5 · 09/02/2024 13:30

Anyways OP, it's a lovely idea and it's not racist at all. I wish we would see more of this actually...

Y6yhnsr5 · 09/02/2024 13:29

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

Are you alright?

10ThousandSpoons · 09/02/2024 13:24

WorldBookDayChoice · 09/02/2024 12:40

Ok but she isn't

Good

missmollygreen · 09/02/2024 13:23

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

How is dressing as her favourite character racist?

You know when you read articles about randomly find things that "they" are calling to ban, and you wonder "who on earth would want to ban people wearing blue t-shirts?"

Do you also think black people should not wear western clothes? Making children see people of other colours as different is how racism begins

LilBus · 09/02/2024 13:22

My daughters have dressed up for their birthdays as Cinderella and Anna it would be like telling a white child they can’t dress as Tiana because she’s black, that sounds more racist to me. My son was also Harry Potter for world book day as was another child in his class who is black never occurred to us he couldn’t dress as him because he isn't white.

(Though I personally don’t allow my children to straighten their hair)

CaptainMyCaptain · 09/02/2024 13:22

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

I have to assume this is an attempt at a joke.

missmollygreen · 09/02/2024 13:18

ComtesseDeSpair · 09/02/2024 10:29

Whilst it’s difficult to verbalise explicitly exactly what would be wrong with it, I would discourage her tbh. It isn’t blackface, but people/characters of colour are more than just their hairstyle, and whilst most people wouldn’t take offence to a child dressed up, you aren’t going to be there to explain the reasoning behind the costume all day to anyone who does find it a bit off.

Teaching white children that black people are different and it is not ok to what to dress like them. Seems like a step backwards to me!

Surely we should be teaching kids not to see colour

Kerfuffleplunk · 09/02/2024 13:16

Would anyone tell a black child that they can only dress up as a black character and that they shouldn’t straighten their hair ? Hairstyles do not “belong” to any race or culture .

JuJuHeyHey · 09/02/2024 13:12

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

But that's like saying 'a black person is nothing more than the colour of their skin'. The book character won't be in the book just going around 'being black'; she will be a dancer, an astronaut, a whatever, who happens to be black.

Saying a child can only admire characters that have the same colour skin as themselves is ridiculous.

Pinkelephant66 · 09/02/2024 13:08

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

This has got to be a joke 😂

Swipe left for the next trending thread