Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Black character for World Book Day?

160 replies

WorldBookDayChoice · 09/02/2024 10:08

My almost four year old is white with wavy/curly hair. She has a story book whose main character is black with curly hair, and DD has always said this character looks like her. She now wants to dress as this girl for WBD. In practice this will just mean wearing specific coloured clothes and holding the book up, but she's also mentioned making her hair even curlier to match the character's hair.

Basically is this okay? Or disrespectful?

YANBU it's okay
YABU it's not okay

OP posts:
ShoePalaver · 09/02/2024 19:45

ComtesseDeSpair · 09/02/2024 11:29

Wearing a sari or traditional dress to a celebration when the hosts have encouraged you to do so is different to making your hair more curly to dress up as a black person as if the defining feature of a black person is their hair. Saying “well, I wouldn’t be bothered by this so screw anybody who would be, they’re thinking wrong” is how people have traditionally been silenced.

You wouldn’t (I hope) let your child wear a false nose to emphasise that they were Anne Frank for WBD, so why would OP’s DD curling her hair to “be more black” be acceptable?

Edited

Dressing up as Anne Frank for world book day seems hideously distasteful to me.

But OP's daughter would be curling her hair to look like this specific character, not to look more black.

Anne Frank did not have a distinctive nose. Are you being deliberately anti Semitic?

TheKeatingFive · 09/02/2024 19:42

It's important to avoid stereotypes and to teach our children what a stereotype is and why we try to avoid stereotyping

But why are you assuming that's happening? If the children are responding so positively to a character, there will be multiple reasons for that. I don't understand why you would reduce this to 'stereotypes'

mathanxiety · 09/02/2024 19:39

Allthingsdecember · 09/02/2024 15:58

I wouldn’t let her mimic the character’s hair texture. There’s too much history and culture associated with black peoples hair for it to be used as part of a costume by any non black person.

Dressing up as a black character that she looks up to is fine though (in fact, it’s a really positive thing, IMO).

Agree.

Please don't do the hair modification, OP.

NewOrder · 09/02/2024 19:37

Kerfuffleplunk · 09/02/2024 19:36

SE Asian people comprise a variety of ethnic groups and cultures and yet you have just dismissed a sarong as “ having no symbolic meaning “?

Because it doesn’t appear to? Not from anything I have read. Happy to be corrected - we are all constantly learning.

FourLeggedBuckers · 09/02/2024 19:37

SquashedSquashess · 09/02/2024 19:05

It’s important that any argument can be expressed coherently, whatever reasoning that argument may be based on. A person’s race doesn’t give them absolute authority, whatever race they are, if they cannot make their argument.

It’s this sort of “right side of history” and “just be kind” thinking that takes us down rabbit holes that aren’t thought out, just blindly accepted for fear of not being “nice”.

I’m not telling the poster how to feel, I am expressing my belief that it is worth reflecting on why they cannot articulate their discomfort. Perhaps that reflection will help them to do so, and persuade others.

Then you should have read the thread. Your post absolutely is telling them that they are in the wrong for being uncomfortable with the OP’s suggestion - unless your second paragraph isn’t meant to relate to the post you quoted, in which case, I really think you should’ve made that clear.

And, fwiw, I do believe that a person’s race does give them authority on a matter of potential racism directed against that race, even if they cannot express it to an arbitrary level of satisfaction.

mathanxiety · 09/02/2024 19:37

TheKeatingFive · 09/02/2024 18:43

Of course not, yet this lazy fearful thinking will create a more divided world, not an inclusive one

Exactly this.

Little children are honouring characters they admire, love, relate to. Why on earth would we tell them that characters from different backgrounds, different to their own, are out of bounds?

Because individual backgrounds are nuanced and varied and not one dimensional.

It's important to avoid stereotypes and to teach our children what a stereotype is and why we try to avoid stereotyping.

It's more trouble to find and adhere to the fine lines in a portrayal of a character than it is to just slap on a costume and do hair, but the message around stereotyping is worth teaching.

Ultimately, focusing on a physical representation of a character, or a character's accent, can reinforce stereotypes.

Kerfuffleplunk · 09/02/2024 19:36

NewOrder · 09/02/2024 19:28

Probably not personally. The sarong has no symbolic meaning to SE Asian people but if someone from that background had issue with it, I would listen to them and try and learn why.

SE Asian people comprise a variety of ethnic groups and cultures and yet you have just dismissed a sarong as “ having no symbolic meaning “?

NewOrder · 09/02/2024 19:28

Kerfuffleplunk · 09/02/2024 19:12

So I take it you’d never wear a sarong then?

Probably not personally. The sarong has no symbolic meaning to SE Asian people but if someone from that background had issue with it, I would listen to them and try and learn why.

SquashedSquashess · 09/02/2024 19:17

WorldBookDayChoice · 09/02/2024 19:09

Fwiw that poster did articulate it later in the thread

Apologies to @ComtesseDeSpair - that is my fault for not reading the whole thread (RTFT exists for a reason, lesson learned)

Kerfuffleplunk · 09/02/2024 19:12

NewOrder · 09/02/2024 18:08

Because that’s cultural appropriation. My daughter isn’t Polynesian. Culture isn’t a costume.

plenty of other things for her to dress up as.

So I take it you’d never wear a sarong then?

WorldBookDayChoice · 09/02/2024 19:12

NewOrder · 09/02/2024 19:00

If she really wanted to dress as Moana I would perhaps put her in a red top and yellow skirt with a flower in her hair perhaps.

There is huge cultural significance of a Puletasi, Ta’ovala, Masi, Tabua, Salusalu, Lei, Valatao, Kiekie. That’s not my culture. It’s not a costume. It’s not for me.

there are other ways to appreciate other cultures than dressing up with items that have real importance to people.

Thanks for expanding on this, I was also wondering why. I understand that there's definitely a difference between just wearing the day to day clothes a person wears vs the ceremonial dress of their culture, or items that are earned etc.

OP posts:
WiddlinDiddlin · 09/02/2024 19:10

I can't see the issue in doing a hair style you'd normally do anyway to accentuate her curls, to go with the outfit shes picked in order to look more like the character.

You're not using a wig, you're not taking dead straight hair and trying to make it look like tightly curled hair of a totally different texture, you're not changing the colour of any hair or skin.

WorldBookDayChoice · 09/02/2024 19:09

SquashedSquashess · 09/02/2024 19:05

It’s important that any argument can be expressed coherently, whatever reasoning that argument may be based on. A person’s race doesn’t give them absolute authority, whatever race they are, if they cannot make their argument.

It’s this sort of “right side of history” and “just be kind” thinking that takes us down rabbit holes that aren’t thought out, just blindly accepted for fear of not being “nice”.

I’m not telling the poster how to feel, I am expressing my belief that it is worth reflecting on why they cannot articulate their discomfort. Perhaps that reflection will help them to do so, and persuade others.

Fwiw that poster did articulate it later in the thread

OP posts:
SquashedSquashess · 09/02/2024 19:05

FourLeggedBuckers · 09/02/2024 18:50

It’s pretty uncomfortable reading when posters start telling a PP who is mixed race (according to their longer post explaining their feelings) what they should be comfortable with, and blaming them for divisions in society…

If someone is uncomfortable with a portrayal of features or characteristics from their heritage, nobody has the right to dismiss that out of hand.

It’s important that any argument can be expressed coherently, whatever reasoning that argument may be based on. A person’s race doesn’t give them absolute authority, whatever race they are, if they cannot make their argument.

It’s this sort of “right side of history” and “just be kind” thinking that takes us down rabbit holes that aren’t thought out, just blindly accepted for fear of not being “nice”.

I’m not telling the poster how to feel, I am expressing my belief that it is worth reflecting on why they cannot articulate their discomfort. Perhaps that reflection will help them to do so, and persuade others.

NewOrder · 09/02/2024 19:00

outWithTheOuting · 09/02/2024 18:32

I dont know about Moana or if the mlvie is controversial or offensive in some way. Also, I am not Polynesian either and I can't speak for anyone Polynesian or for anyone from any other culture but if a child dressed as someone as a character from my culture and wore our traditional clothes I wouldn't be offended. I'd like it.

Most characters, and in particular, historical characters, belong to a culture. If you dress up as a character you'd wear the clothes they'd be wearing or do your hair the way they would do it.

I can't say I'm super well informed about cultural appropriation but I do get that it's unfair that for instance when my mother wears a saree or any other traditional dress she gets looked down on and when a white person does they don't get treated badly but it's different with world book day I think.

The kids are meant to dress as someone they look up to. A character they love and admire. Promoting this character and openly dressing like them normalises that characters of colours and that by extension people of colour can be someone admirable or brilliant. It shows that white doesn't have to be the default when it comes to characters we admire or love. I think that's something very positive.

If she really wanted to dress as Moana I would perhaps put her in a red top and yellow skirt with a flower in her hair perhaps.

There is huge cultural significance of a Puletasi, Ta’ovala, Masi, Tabua, Salusalu, Lei, Valatao, Kiekie. That’s not my culture. It’s not a costume. It’s not for me.

there are other ways to appreciate other cultures than dressing up with items that have real importance to people.

FourLeggedBuckers · 09/02/2024 18:50

SquashedSquashess · 09/02/2024 18:30

@ComtesseDeSpair if you find it hard to articulate why something makes you uncomfortable, maybe you should examine whether your discomfort is rational or based on a fear of being seen to do the “wrong” thing, despite not knowing why that thing is wrong.

I’m so tired of our society sleepwalking into a more segregated unforgiving way of being. Of course it’s important to be respectful of and make space for all cultures, but when a child is celebrating a fictional character of a different ethnicity to them (no awful blacking up) and we discourage it, what message do we give them? Should they not have those as favourite characters, or read such books at all, because they can’t fully identify with the character’s ethnicity? Of course not, yet this lazy fearful thinking will create a more divided world, not an inclusive one

It’s pretty uncomfortable reading when posters start telling a PP who is mixed race (according to their longer post explaining their feelings) what they should be comfortable with, and blaming them for divisions in society…

If someone is uncomfortable with a portrayal of features or characteristics from their heritage, nobody has the right to dismiss that out of hand.

TheKeatingFive · 09/02/2024 18:43

Of course not, yet this lazy fearful thinking will create a more divided world, not an inclusive one

Exactly this.

Little children are honouring characters they admire, love, relate to. Why on earth would we tell them that characters from different backgrounds, different to their own, are out of bounds?

outWithTheOuting · 09/02/2024 18:32

NewOrder · 09/02/2024 18:08

Because that’s cultural appropriation. My daughter isn’t Polynesian. Culture isn’t a costume.

plenty of other things for her to dress up as.

I dont know about Moana or if the mlvie is controversial or offensive in some way. Also, I am not Polynesian either and I can't speak for anyone Polynesian or for anyone from any other culture but if a child dressed as someone as a character from my culture and wore our traditional clothes I wouldn't be offended. I'd like it.

Most characters, and in particular, historical characters, belong to a culture. If you dress up as a character you'd wear the clothes they'd be wearing or do your hair the way they would do it.

I can't say I'm super well informed about cultural appropriation but I do get that it's unfair that for instance when my mother wears a saree or any other traditional dress she gets looked down on and when a white person does they don't get treated badly but it's different with world book day I think.

The kids are meant to dress as someone they look up to. A character they love and admire. Promoting this character and openly dressing like them normalises that characters of colours and that by extension people of colour can be someone admirable or brilliant. It shows that white doesn't have to be the default when it comes to characters we admire or love. I think that's something very positive.

SquashedSquashess · 09/02/2024 18:30

ComtesseDeSpair · 09/02/2024 10:29

Whilst it’s difficult to verbalise explicitly exactly what would be wrong with it, I would discourage her tbh. It isn’t blackface, but people/characters of colour are more than just their hairstyle, and whilst most people wouldn’t take offence to a child dressed up, you aren’t going to be there to explain the reasoning behind the costume all day to anyone who does find it a bit off.

@ComtesseDeSpair if you find it hard to articulate why something makes you uncomfortable, maybe you should examine whether your discomfort is rational or based on a fear of being seen to do the “wrong” thing, despite not knowing why that thing is wrong.

I’m so tired of our society sleepwalking into a more segregated unforgiving way of being. Of course it’s important to be respectful of and make space for all cultures, but when a child is celebrating a fictional character of a different ethnicity to them (no awful blacking up) and we discourage it, what message do we give them? Should they not have those as favourite characters, or read such books at all, because they can’t fully identify with the character’s ethnicity? Of course not, yet this lazy fearful thinking will create a more divided world, not an inclusive one

NewOrder · 09/02/2024 18:08

Biffbaff · 09/02/2024 17:40

Why not?

Because that’s cultural appropriation. My daughter isn’t Polynesian. Culture isn’t a costume.

plenty of other things for her to dress up as.

Mischance · 09/02/2024 18:04

So many characters in children's books, especially older books, are white. Can a black child not dress as one of these? Superman?

juanitasolis · 09/02/2024 17:52

Tell her she's not black therefore cannot identify with a black character in the same way she can with a white one

My black niece has straightened her hair and gone as Hermoine Granger and Taylor Swift for Halloween within the last few years. Am I to tell her shes not white so she cannot identify with these ladies?

outWithTheOuting · 09/02/2024 17:49

I'm of Asian origin and honestly, I'd be happy to see a child dressed up as a non white character. It would show other people that non white characters can be someone to aspire to.

For whatever it's worth my own children usually dress as some white character or the other. Just because that's what they are mostly exposed to. Obviously, no one questions that but then does white really have to be the default? So yes, I'd applaud your child for giving publicity to a non white character.

Biffbaff · 09/02/2024 17:40

NewOrder · 09/02/2024 14:17

I think it depends on what the character is, surely?

I would never, for example. let my white DD dress up as Moana.

Why not?

MiCorazon · 09/02/2024 17:05

My daughter is mixed race black/white, she likes little mermaid 🧜‍♀️ and all the white Disney princesses and the non white ones, I don't think it matters at that age they are just dressing up and showing appreciation for a fictional or non fictional character for just a day.

Swipe left for the next trending thread