Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think I don't owe this person a refund?

113 replies

JustlikeElllie · 09/02/2024 08:25

Sold something on Vinted. An item of children's clothing. It cost around £25 new and I sold it for a few pounds. It was barely used so like new.

I sell a lot on there and I'm always over cautious about condition of items and haven't had any problems.

The person is complaining that it doesn't fit and suggesting it's been tumble dried. It 100% hasn't. I was everything on a cool short wash and air dry. They are after a refund but don't want to send the item back understandably because sure of postage.

In my opinion it wasn't a small fitting item or I'd have mentioned this in the listing.

OP posts:
Dusty27 · 10/02/2024 16:53

Selling online can be such a nightmare. My husband looked for advise on a trade FB page about the value of some tools he had. They were old but never used, and stainless steel which aren’t made anymore. He was advised anywhere between £150-£350. One person offered to buy & the agreed to £150. This was back in early Dec & it’s only been sorted last week. The transaction was done through PayPal & he sent loads of threatening msgs through FB before lodging a complaint. Once we sent PayPal the msgs they said the buyer would return them & then refund them. We were ok with that, both would have had to pay postage but he’d get his money back, us the tools. Then all of a sudden PayPal said they were refunding him & fining us & wouldn’t get the goods back 🤯 resorted to calling PayPal and the lady we spoke to was great & credited up back the line, and the original sale value. It was so stressful. I think some people are just chancers who see what they can get away with. I would fight refunding her.

Kisskiss · 10/02/2024 15:57

She’s trying it on, it doesn’t matter if she hasn’t clicked received yet as it will autocomplete very soon anyway.

I’ve had to post back some toys which had been listed as working but were clearly not ( rusty battery leads) at my own expense so Vinted can be a minefield both ways it seems…

Lighteningstrikes · 10/02/2024 15:37

You’re being scammed.

I wouldn’t get into a long narrative with her, I would simply message/email:

Please return the item for refund.

Thank you.

Repeat if necessary.

What can she do? It’s according to the terms and conditions.

You are being fair/correct.

Shes trying to scam you, which unfortunately happens.

You’ll probably find because you’re not falling for her shit, she won’t bother and she’ll keep it, as it’s too much effort for her.

DyslexicPoster · 10/02/2024 15:11

She has to either raise a case or refund. If she does nothing, Vinted will release the funds and she will be too late to do anything. You will get auto feedback so ignore her

Emotionalsupportviper · 10/02/2024 14:47

Cerealkiller4U · 10/02/2024 14:44

Hehehe. That’s the one!!!

"Buyer's cravat" would be rather nice - if a bit Lord Peter Wimsey. Grin

Cerealkiller4U · 10/02/2024 14:44

Rosscameasdoody · 10/02/2024 14:43

Caveat Emptor - buyer beware.

Hehehe. That’s the one!!!

Rosscameasdoody · 10/02/2024 14:43

Cerealkiller4U · 10/02/2024 14:33

It’s buyers craveat or whatever

yoire 100% ok

Caveat Emptor - buyer beware.

Rosscameasdoody · 10/02/2024 14:42

Bamboobzled · 10/02/2024 14:26

I hate Vinted. People always want something for 50p even if they know fine it's worth way more than the pittance its listed for. Then there's the people I've been unfortunate enough to deal with, one cancelled a sale after I'd literally just posted and got home to mark it posted to see he had been refunded! I was fuming as I was well within the posting time limit. Vinted just basically shrugged their shoulders.

EBay do the same and I closed my account for that reason. If it wasn’t for sellers, these sites couldn’t operate, but in the event of problems they always come down on the side of the buyer and hang the seller out to dry. I’ve had buyers report items not received despite proof of delivery - one buyer collected an item in person and then claimed a refund saying I hadn’t posted it. I had specified cash if collecting so that paypal buyer protection didn’t apply but EBay advised he had the right to use Paypal and then sided with him because I couldn’t prove it had been collected. So he got the item and a refund.

I’ve also had buyers damage items and then return them for refund, saying they’ve been received in that condition - despite listing photos showing otherwise. And as you say, they want things for next to nothing. It’s just not worth the effort.

JustlikeElllie · 10/02/2024 14:36

roarrfeckingroar · 10/02/2024 09:05

Did you sell it as new without tags or as very good? Because it wasn't new

I sold it as very good condition. Which it was.

I don't try to pass things off as new if they've been worn.

OP posts:
Cerealkiller4U · 10/02/2024 14:33

It’s buyers craveat or whatever

yoire 100% ok

Bamboobzled · 10/02/2024 14:26

I hate Vinted. People always want something for 50p even if they know fine it's worth way more than the pittance its listed for. Then there's the people I've been unfortunate enough to deal with, one cancelled a sale after I'd literally just posted and got home to mark it posted to see he had been refunded! I was fuming as I was well within the posting time limit. Vinted just basically shrugged their shoulders.

TheSilkLady · 10/02/2024 14:23

You’re not a business. It’s the spirit off vinted that if you buy something it does fit you sell it on. Chase them

Nanny0gg · 10/02/2024 13:18

feathers7 · 10/02/2024 08:39

I had this, a never worn dress which the buyer said had a hole in it. I said I'd refund if she returned it. This was followed by some nasty messages from her. I ended up refunding her-it was about £5 and I thought life is too short to quibble over that amount.
Still doesn't sit well that she ended up with a new fat face dress for free though!
Definitely put me off Vinted selling.

You should have insisted on a return and reported the messages to vinted

millymog11 · 10/02/2024 13:07

not read the whole thread but this is why i dont bother with selling on vinted

DuckbilledSplatterPuff · 10/02/2024 12:32

caringcarer · 10/02/2024 08:39

This. No return no refund.

Is the postage that expensive?

I'm very much in the no return/no refund camp,

But if as a gesture of goodwill you offer to split the return postage 50-50 if she provides a receipt.... it might get the whole thing off your plate and provide a reasonable answer to any bad reviews.

But it sounds a bit like she's trying it on and wants to keep the garment, or can't be bothered to return and just wants a refund. You'd soon find out.

NOTANUM · 10/02/2024 12:31

It’s a scam. I had the same and they said they’d only return if if I sent a label for free returns or gave them extra. Mine had a Next tag on it saying size 10 which they claimed was not a size 10.
eBay sided with them so I wrote it off and they kept the item.
I don’t sell anything now that can’t be collected as it’s not worth the row.

Emotionalsupportviper · 10/02/2024 12:13

JustlikeElllie · 09/02/2024 08:25

Sold something on Vinted. An item of children's clothing. It cost around £25 new and I sold it for a few pounds. It was barely used so like new.

I sell a lot on there and I'm always over cautious about condition of items and haven't had any problems.

The person is complaining that it doesn't fit and suggesting it's been tumble dried. It 100% hasn't. I was everything on a cool short wash and air dry. They are after a refund but don't want to send the item back understandably because sure of postage.

In my opinion it wasn't a small fitting item or I'd have mentioned this in the listing.

If they aren't prepared to return the item (at their own expense), then they aren't entitled to a refund.

They're trying to con you..

Myotherrideisabroom · 10/02/2024 12:09

I've had a couple of issues with buyers on Vinted like this - I didn't issue a refund in either case.

One buyer claimed a brand new, with tags, stickers etc was actually worn and washed as the item 'smelled of washing powder'. The only explanation I had was it had been in my wardrobe, hung amongst freshly laundered clothes for so long.

2nd one - lady bought a size 18 dress and then wanted a refund as I hadn't told her "it was more like a 12/14" - I've never been a 14 for years and certainly wouldn't fit into a size 14 dress myself! Tags were an 18. Vinted sided with me and she removed her horrendous feedback she left me.

D600 · 10/02/2024 12:02

Returns are the bane of clothing and shoe online sellers. You say you are an experienced and careful seller on Vinted, but with small sums in this type of situation, it can be more pain than its worth.
Online selling has some unique characteristics, in that unlike the high street the buyer can always just simply change their mind.

Typically an item has to be returned for a refund, unless otherwise agreed.

Take a look at the terms and conditions of Vinted, and it may answer a lot of your questions.

Basically if buyer and seller cannot agree then it can be escalated to the Vinted team (Customer Support) and they will adjudicate. Vinted has a Returns policy too.

Here are excerpts from the terms, relevant to your case which is item was Significantly Not As Described (SNAD) according to the buyer:

14. Buyer Protection
Purpose of Buyer Protection. Buyer Protection provides you with a refund policy if an Item is lost, damaged or significantly not as described. Customer Support will assist you during this process and follow our Refund Policy. Your payment will be held in Escrow until the Transaction is marked as completed. As a heads up, Buyer Protection is not an insurance or a legal protection service and is in addition to all other legal rights or guarantees you have. Buyer Protection is mandatorily applied for a fee and for each purchase made using the buying button.

Refund policy. You can claim for a refund for an Item if it’s:
· confirmed as lost or damaged during shipping,
· significantly not as described, which means there’s a significant difference between the Item you received and its description or photo on the Catalogue, such as a different size, colour, or severe damage (like stains, smells or holes), or the Item was missing from a bundle (SNAD), or
· a SNAD counterfeit.

If there are any issues with the Item. You must report the issue under our Buyer Protection policy to us by clicking the “I have an issue” button in your private message screen within 2 calendar days from our notice that the Item has been delivered or it seems lost (the Refund Request Period). This will suspend the Transaction and all money for it will continue to be held in Escrow until the issue is resolved. If you don’t report an issue to us within the Refund Request Period, the Transaction will automatically be marked as completed. ]
[ Handling a SNAD Item (except SNAD counterfeit Items). We suggest discussing with the Seller first to explain what issue you’re experiencing so you and the Seller can agree on a resolution you’re both happy with. But if you’re unable to reach a solution, you can escalate the issue to us. If you claim an Item is SNAD within the Refund Request Period, we’ll notify the Seller about this. The Seller can either:
· not require you to return the Item to them and grant your refund, or
· require you to return the Item to them within 5 business days in order to receive a refund. You’re responsible for return shipping costs unless agreed otherwise with the Seller, and we’ll notify the Seller once they should have received the Item or if it appears to be lost. From the time we notify the Seller, they’ll have 2 days to confirm they have the Item and everything is ok (at which point you’ll receive your refund) or report an issue (in which case your money will still be kept safe in Escrow until the issue is resolved). If the Buyer purchased Items as part of a bundle:
o

o The Buyer will have to return all of the Items in the bundle (applicable until April 2024); or
o The Buyer can return only the SNAD Item(s) out of the bundle (applicable from April 2024).
If the Seller doesn’t take one of the above actions within 14 days of you reporting the issue, or if you or the Seller report an issue to us at any point during this process, Customer Support will make the final decision on whether an Item is SNAD.

Its pretty straight forward for both parties. Good luck.

Sodndashitall · 10/02/2024 11:50

Just be civil and say that you are happy to refund per Vinted policy which is after the item is returned.
Be aware that she can keep it and leave bad feedback of course but that's the way these things roll.
I wouldn't refund without the return, if you want to refund the cost of the return then by all means do that. But the item has to be returned

surreygirl1987 · 10/02/2024 11:34

I had to return a filthy broken item and pay for postage. Vinted wouldn’t do anything even though it wasn’t fit for sale. It was either lose £3 or lose £9.

This is my biggest bugbear with vinted - that someone can sell you something not as advertised, and you're still expected to pay the postage cost to return. Ebag is far better in this respect.

I don't think this is what's going on in the OP's case though- OP, if your item was as advertised, just ignore.

ibelieveinmirrorballs · 10/02/2024 11:15

I had this with someone claiming jeans were smaller than I’d said. They were listed as a size 14 and when I checked they were actually labelled as a 32”.

I checked on manufacturer website and because it showed that that did equate to a size 14 I raised it as a case. Vinted sided with me.

I think hold your ground if you know you’ve done nothing wrong. Sometimes things don’t fit and buyers need to accept that will be the case if you’re buying unseen.

JudgeJ · 10/02/2024 11:12

PigletJohn · 10/02/2024 08:55

Brands differ in their interpretation of sizes. Most are a bit bigger than the label says.

I sometimes sell (adult) clothes and include measurements across shoulders, chest, waist; and length of legs and arms, and advise buyers to compare to a garment that fits well.

Not much scope for a buyer to complain if it doesn't fit.

This is the problem with buying on line although I recall buying our granddaughter a coat from Monsoon. the next year up sizewise. When we sent it to her our daughter phoned to say it was like a straitjacket, far too small. When she returned it to the local branch they too were surprised at how poor a fit it was. When I ordered a raincoat from Seasalt I finished up with 3 sizes smaller than I'd ordered to get a reasonable fit.

Coop21 · 10/02/2024 11:02

I bought my daughter a few horse riding items from Vinted that were her size but we’re to small when I received them, I didn’t ask for a refund as that’s the chance you take when buying from a pre loved site 🤷‍♀️ tell them no 🙄

AskingForAFriend12 · 10/02/2024 11:01

I had similar happen to me. They guy claimed it was too small. I refused a return. He then decided to claim that it was a fake. Vinted upheld their claim and closed my account due to selling fakes (it 100% wasn't). I hope he fucking chokes on it.

Swipe left for the next trending thread