Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Weighting for the backlash

185 replies

quisensoucie · 09/02/2024 08:01

Weighing aeroplane passengers is not a new phenomenon, so the 'fat-shaming' trope is rather misplaced
'In the early days of air travel, Airlines frequently weighed passengers and even crew to properly balance the smaller, less sophisticated aircraft, according to the Smithsonian.

Passenger weight can have an impact on another aspect of flying: seat size.'
https://www.google.com/url?sa=t&source=web&rct=j&opi=89978449&url=www.smithsonianmag.com/air-space-magazine/then-amp-now-a-weighty-matter-46320857/&ved=2ahUKEwi8--2O452EAxU2a0EAHa-9B8sQFnoECCsQAQ&usg=AOvVaw36nIvu41LW3mTW1jC32O9v

https://www.independent.co.uk/travel/news-and-advice/airlines-weigh-passengers-check-in-baggage-cargo-balance-a8860071.html

This is a safety issue, not about making larger people pay more. But again, the science and physics are dismissed because 'feelings'

https://www.google.com/url?opi=89978449&rct=j&sa=t&source=web&url=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.smithsonianmag.com%2Fair-space-magazine%2Fthen-amp-now-a-weighty-matter-46320857%2F&usg=AOvVaw36nIvu41LW3mTW1jC32O9v&ved=2ahUKEwi8--2O452EAxU2a0EAHa-9B8sQFnoECCsQAQ

OP posts:
fuckingheartbroken · 09/02/2024 09:19

AIstolemylunch · 09/02/2024 09:06

But they dont want to carry max fuel. They want to carry adequate fuel for the total weight of the plane on that day. which will be affected by particular make up of luggage (some people pack light, some dont) - and that is checked at check in, and the particular make up of people on that day- some are way heavier than the average figures, some are babies or small children - and that bit isn't currently checked so they have to err on the side of caution add max fuel to account for every single person possibly being max weight.

Why would anyone want that to spare a few sensitive people's perceived feelings, when everyone can see what they look like anyway? It's worse for the environment and makes the airlines operating costs higher, which is reflected in ticket prices for us.

Completely agree with this.
The weight isn't being published. But if someone's fat, it's public knowledge anyway.
And no one's going to take the blindest bit of notice. Well, the vast majority of people anyway.

Thebestwaytoscareatory · 09/02/2024 09:19

Wasbedeudetetdas · 09/02/2024 09:00

That's assuming that all the adults on the flight are from the UK and that there is an 'average' distribution of people - actual figures would be more reassuring surely?

Well, the average weight of an adult from the official fattest country on the planet (Nauru) is 100kg, so even if you found yourself on a flight exclusively filled with people from there you'd still be way below the capacity.

You'd need every single person on the plane to be around 130kg (20.5st) for there to start to be an issue.

Spagb0l · 09/02/2024 09:17

AIstolemylunch · 09/02/2024 08:52

they don't reuse extra fuel. They have to dump it over the ocean before landing for safety as they don't want to land with it in case of incident as it would it much worse and people would die in a fireball even from survivable impacts. I'd rather they used fuel more efficiently and didn't dump it all over marine life, personally.

I'm neither fat nor thin and have absolutely no problem with myself and my family stepping on a pressure pad scale at checkin. You could presumably do it with your luggage anyway so it wouldn't highlight your own weight.

The fuel in most situations vaporises before it hits the sea / ground.

Inthebitterend · 09/02/2024 09:15

Not sure why I read posts like this that make it clear so many people are okay with completely dehumanising people for how they look, and the fact they dare want to travel while being such hideous beasts.

Does anyone want to talk about these airlines making seats smaller constantly to squeeze more people in so they make more money? Not to mention that most airlines these days charge you for even wanting to take a bag, on your holiday! Or charging you to sit with your family! There are bigger fucking issues at play than a fat person daring to want to go on holiday or travel for business. Jesus fucking christ.

Shaming people doesn't work to make them lose weight, btw. Being shamed is a fat person's life, if it worked no one would be fat.

AIstolemylunch · 09/02/2024 09:08

I've always wondered why they don't just weigh everybody once they're all herded onto the walkway gantry and then make the last minute adjustments to fuel then. But that would mean hanging around a bit longer before the flight which people of all shapes and sizes would moan about.

AIstolemylunch · 09/02/2024 09:06

But they dont want to carry max fuel. They want to carry adequate fuel for the total weight of the plane on that day. which will be affected by particular make up of luggage (some people pack light, some dont) - and that is checked at check in, and the particular make up of people on that day- some are way heavier than the average figures, some are babies or small children - and that bit isn't currently checked so they have to err on the side of caution add max fuel to account for every single person possibly being max weight.

Why would anyone want that to spare a few sensitive people's perceived feelings, when everyone can see what they look like anyway? It's worse for the environment and makes the airlines operating costs higher, which is reflected in ticket prices for us.

Wasbedeudetetdas · 09/02/2024 09:00

Thebestwaytoscareatory · 09/02/2024 08:53

A Boeing 737 (average sized aeroplane) has a take-off capacity of around 80,000kg.

Once you account for the aeroplane itself, the max fuel load it can carry, and the crew it has around 24000kg of load to spare.

The average number of people one of those is fitted out to carry is 150. meaning each passenger has an allowance of 133.3kg.

The average weight of an adult in the UK is 78.5 kg and average allowance for checked baggage is 23kg, so a per passenger total of 101.5 kg (but let's say it's closer to 110.5 kg to allow for clothing and hand luggage).

That means that, even if a 737 was exclusively filled with adults who've all checked a suitcase and carried on some hand luggage, there would still be around 7425 kg of spare capacity.

There's no issue with the weight capability of commercial aeroplanes.

That's assuming that all the adults on the flight are from the UK and that there is an 'average' distribution of people - actual figures would be more reassuring surely?

Wasbedeudetetdas · 09/02/2024 08:58

quisensoucie · 09/02/2024 08:48

I added mine because as OP, I was responding to a suggestion from another poster!

People seem to believe that their weight is going to be broadcast over some tannoy system for the whole airport to hear

I know you did, but agree with pp that it's not really helpful.

Thebestwaytoscareatory · 09/02/2024 08:53

bestmoment · 09/02/2024 08:14

it’s not about “people’s weight”

it is about the weight capability of the aeroplane

does anyone feel its is entirely unnecessary to weigh luggage? nope, didn’t think so

A Boeing 737 (average sized aeroplane) has a take-off capacity of around 80,000kg.

Once you account for the aeroplane itself, the max fuel load it can carry, and the crew it has around 24000kg of load to spare.

The average number of people one of those is fitted out to carry is 150. meaning each passenger has an allowance of 133.3kg.

The average weight of an adult in the UK is 78.5 kg and average allowance for checked baggage is 23kg, so a per passenger total of 101.5 kg (but let's say it's closer to 110.5 kg to allow for clothing and hand luggage).

That means that, even if a 737 was exclusively filled with adults who've all checked a suitcase and carried on some hand luggage, there would still be around 7425 kg of spare capacity.

There's no issue with the weight capability of commercial aeroplanes.

Fluorescentgem · 09/02/2024 08:52

I don't see the problem with this. If you're ashamed of your weight, then do something about it. I'm not madly overweight but I could stand to lose a stone. This would give me a bit of motivation to lose it.

AIstolemylunch · 09/02/2024 08:52

they don't reuse extra fuel. They have to dump it over the ocean before landing for safety as they don't want to land with it in case of incident as it would it much worse and people would die in a fireball even from survivable impacts. I'd rather they used fuel more efficiently and didn't dump it all over marine life, personally.

I'm neither fat nor thin and have absolutely no problem with myself and my family stepping on a pressure pad scale at checkin. You could presumably do it with your luggage anyway so it wouldn't highlight your own weight.

quisensoucie · 09/02/2024 08:48

I added mine because as OP, I was responding to a suggestion from another poster!

People seem to believe that their weight is going to be broadcast over some tannoy system for the whole airport to hear

OP posts:
MissRheingold · 09/02/2024 08:46

I love vintage planes and it's part and parcel of going up in one that everyone has to be weighed and then seated accordingly to ensure even distribution of weight.

All this fat shaming stuff is just ridiculous.

Spagb0l · 09/02/2024 08:43

Oh, and for the record I'm 5,5 and 9 stone.

I used to be overweight.

Wasbedeudetetdas · 09/02/2024 08:43

5128gap · 09/02/2024 08:39

Its not remotely useful to the discussion for posters to start declaring their own weight and height. All that does is give people the opportunity to reduce the debate to 'fat v thin' and 'fat shaming' accusations, with people disregarding the views of the larger people as being defensive and the smaller ones as fatphobic, when what matters is the points made not the size of the person making them.

Hence my slightly tongue in cheek reply to the person who did.
Of course we don't want this to become about fat shaming, more just the realities of transporting larger people and the implications for them and those around them.

Sparklfairy · 09/02/2024 08:42

Pandadunks · 09/02/2024 08:02

I must have missed the bit where commercial airliners are crashing because they aren’t weighing people…

Maybe an extreme example but the singer Aaliyah died because of the weight + weight distribution of the plane. AFAIK all the music equipment (they were shooting a music video) were put at the back, and then the security staff (some weighing 300lbs+) sat at the back too... The weight calculations for the plane during the inquest only accounted for 800lb total weight for 9 people, which is of course, ludicrous.

Spagb0l · 09/02/2024 08:42

AIstolemylunch · 09/02/2024 08:33

this seems perfectly fine and rational to me. people want greener travel and the airlines are trying to do their bit. Knowing the total weight of everybody and everything on the plane will aĺow them to be more precise about fuel allocation an use less as currently they guesstimate and add more than is necessary.

Asking people to step onto some sort of pressure pad at check in isn't humiliating them. They're not going to broadcast the weight.

I completely agree.

bestmoment · 09/02/2024 08:42

5128gap · 09/02/2024 08:39

Its not remotely useful to the discussion for posters to start declaring their own weight and height. All that does is give people the opportunity to reduce the debate to 'fat v thin' and 'fat shaming' accusations, with people disregarding the views of the larger people as being defensive and the smaller ones as fatphobic, when what matters is the points made not the size of the person making them.

might not be “useful”

would be interesting though (for some of us!)

5128gap · 09/02/2024 08:39

Its not remotely useful to the discussion for posters to start declaring their own weight and height. All that does is give people the opportunity to reduce the debate to 'fat v thin' and 'fat shaming' accusations, with people disregarding the views of the larger people as being defensive and the smaller ones as fatphobic, when what matters is the points made not the size of the person making them.

Hoardasurass · 09/02/2024 08:39

Ktime · 09/02/2024 08:30

Do they not just use the leftover fuel for the next flight? 😂

Nope they use it up on that flight because they need to use more fuel for a heavier plane and fuel weights quite a lot and is added to the total weight of the plane

bestmoment · 09/02/2024 08:37

whether it’s for safety
or
to save money being spent on fuel (which also impact consumer prices)

both completely fair enough in my opinion

Ladyjanegreysketle · 09/02/2024 08:36

Hoardasurass · 09/02/2024 08:26

3 have that I know of
1 in Canada (us military highered a commercial plane to move troops) they used average weights and it crashed
2 in the US 1 was a delta airline and the other was a small Alaska air flight.
So yes you missed it may I suggest watching air crash investigation for more information

Also https://www.mlive.com/news/2022/09/pilot-error-too-much-weight-cited-as-causes-for-fatal-2019-plane-crash.html

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Air_Midwest_Flight_5481

https://www.dailymail.co.uk/travel/travel_news/article-11960653/Cargo-plane-clipped-tree-took-filmed-passing-mere-feet-electrical-wires.html

AIstolemylunch · 09/02/2024 08:33

this seems perfectly fine and rational to me. people want greener travel and the airlines are trying to do their bit. Knowing the total weight of everybody and everything on the plane will aĺow them to be more precise about fuel allocation an use less as currently they guesstimate and add more than is necessary.

Asking people to step onto some sort of pressure pad at check in isn't humiliating them. They're not going to broadcast the weight.

bestmoment · 09/02/2024 08:31

wubwubwub · 09/02/2024 08:28

It isn't a safety issue.

It's about airlines wanting to put the bare minimum of fuel in to save money.

which is bloody fair enough

these are commercial businesses not charities
plus it will impact prices they charge
plus not great for the climate to even even more fuel being used

Wasbedeudetetdas · 09/02/2024 08:31

quisensoucie · 09/02/2024 08:26

1.57m 48kg

I honestly don't know what I weigh as I don't own scales - however the last time I was weighed (approx 4 years ago) I was well within a healthy range for my height (and I eat much the same, only exercise a little less and fit into mostly the same size of clothes....). I know that I am around 170cm depending on the time of day. I wouldn't mind being weighed, I just don't do it personally! I also travel quite light too.

Swipe left for the next trending thread