Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Weighting for the backlash

185 replies

quisensoucie · 09/02/2024 08:01

Weighing aeroplane passengers is not a new phenomenon, so the 'fat-shaming' trope is rather misplaced
'In the early days of air travel, Airlines frequently weighed passengers and even crew to properly balance the smaller, less sophisticated aircraft, according to the Smithsonian.

Passenger weight can have an impact on another aspect of flying: seat size.'
https://www.google.com/url?sa=t&source=web&rct=j&opi=89978449&url=www.smithsonianmag.com/air-space-magazine/then-amp-now-a-weighty-matter-46320857/&ved=2ahUKEwi8--2O452EAxU2a0EAHa-9B8sQFnoECCsQAQ&usg=AOvVaw36nIvu41LW3mTW1jC32O9v

https://www.independent.co.uk/travel/news-and-advice/airlines-weigh-passengers-check-in-baggage-cargo-balance-a8860071.html

This is a safety issue, not about making larger people pay more. But again, the science and physics are dismissed because 'feelings'

https://www.google.com/url?opi=89978449&rct=j&sa=t&source=web&url=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.smithsonianmag.com%2Fair-space-magazine%2Fthen-amp-now-a-weighty-matter-46320857%2F&usg=AOvVaw36nIvu41LW3mTW1jC32O9v&ved=2ahUKEwi8--2O452EAxU2a0EAHa-9B8sQFnoECCsQAQ

OP posts:
MrsSkylerWhite · 09/02/2024 10:13

You’ll be weighed with your carry on luggage and it will be seen by 1 person and not recorded anywhere. Can’t see the problem.

Panterus · 09/02/2024 10:11

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

therealcookiemonster · 09/02/2024 10:10

what a non issue. the real problem is overly cheap flight tickets encouraging us all to jet off to various destinations and increasing our carbon footprints.

WinterLobelia · 09/02/2024 10:07

As a person with a 45 year history of eating disorders I am oddly not bothered by this. (As long as only the flight staff see my weight and not DH - or my mother who has fat shamed me also for 45 years... )

Wasbedeudetetdas · 09/02/2024 10:03

Newusernameforthiss · 09/02/2024 09:51

I also love a boat!! So civilised. Planes aren't really that nice any more and seats have got smaller and smaller over recent decades. You need to take that up with airlines, not passengers 🤷‍♀️

Passengers of above average size also have a responsibility.
Boats are fine when it's not too rough (or too smooth) - it's been a bit crazy here recently with weather related cancellations!

Ponoka7 · 09/02/2024 10:02

@FixTheBone it isn't a human right, but companies providing services do have to abide by equality acts, charters etc.

If airlines were concerned with safety then all families would be automatically sat together. One of the reasons why no-one died in the Tokyo plane fire was because there didn't need to be hesitation because families are sat together. Bags have a weight limit because they have to be lifted by baggage handlers, people don't.

Newusernameforthiss · 09/02/2024 09:51

Wasbedeudetetdas · 09/02/2024 09:42

@Newusernameforthiss

Someone impinging on your space... That's the reality of contemporary air travel... It sucks but there it is! Much prefer the train for this reason.

Someone being so large that they are spilling into my seat should not be the 'reality of contemporary air travel' though. If you don't fit in one seat you should be paying for another seat. Alas trains don't go all the places that planes do, however I prefer to take boats than planes (live on an island) as you can get up and move around more.

I also love a boat!! So civilised. Planes aren't really that nice any more and seats have got smaller and smaller over recent decades. You need to take that up with airlines, not passengers 🤷‍♀️

Newusernameforthiss · 09/02/2024 09:49

quisensoucie · 09/02/2024 09:42

@Newusernameforthiss Please do not accuse me of hating fat people. You know nothing of my life
And are Finnair and the other airlines giving the wrong ratioale to weigh people

OK OK I'm sorry I said you hate fat people. You're right, I don't know anything about you.

But I do know that weighing passengers would just slow the whole airport experience down for everyone, and is another stick used to beat larger people - who are just trying to live in society and go on a plane, the same as everyone else - for a problem which isn't really a problem because commercial planes are big and safe enough to fly with whole rugby teams/larger people/vast mountains of luggage on them.

Its Not "because feelings" it's because it really isn't an issue. So just trying having a bit more empathy 🤗

5128gap · 09/02/2024 09:43

There is often very little 'dignity' or accommodation of people's sensitivities in a process that can require you to let a stranger rummage through your personal belongings, do a pat search of your body, xray you, require you to explain your medical needs to a lay person, including those relating to continence/ostomy, move your body around so your wheelchair can be checked etc. If we chose to fly, its generally with the acceptance that security and safety procedures mean we are not afforded the usual levels of privacy and dignity. I don't know how much a person's weight really matters, but if it does, then in light of that, stepping on a scale doesn't seem that big a deal.

Wasbedeudetetdas · 09/02/2024 09:42

@Newusernameforthiss

Someone impinging on your space... That's the reality of contemporary air travel... It sucks but there it is! Much prefer the train for this reason.

Someone being so large that they are spilling into my seat should not be the 'reality of contemporary air travel' though. If you don't fit in one seat you should be paying for another seat. Alas trains don't go all the places that planes do, however I prefer to take boats than planes (live on an island) as you can get up and move around more.

quisensoucie · 09/02/2024 09:42

@Newusernameforthiss Please do not accuse me of hating fat people. You know nothing of my life
And are Finnair and the other airlines giving the wrong ratioale to weigh people

OP posts:
Newusernameforthiss · 09/02/2024 09:38

Wasbedeudetetdas · 09/02/2024 09:34

@Newusernameforthiss it's not about hating fat people, but accepting that the comfort of all passengers matters. Passengers above a certain size do often end up impinging on the seat of the person next to them.

OP says it's a safety issue 🤷‍♀️ right there in the end of her post. It isn't.

Someone impinging on your space... That's the reality of contemporary air travel... It sucks but there it is! Much prefer the train for this reason.

FWIW Important businessmen types sticking their elbows out to read papers/work on laptop/manspreading have impinged on my space far more over the years than fatties 😉

FixTheBone · 09/02/2024 09:34

Don't see the problem with this.

There is no basic human right to get on a plane, go on holiday or fly anywhere at all.

As a private enterprise, airlines are pretty much free to set their own rules regarding what makes their business as safe and efficient as they deem necessary...

Wasbedeudetetdas · 09/02/2024 09:34

@Newusernameforthiss it's not about hating fat people, but accepting that the comfort of all passengers matters. Passengers above a certain size do often end up impinging on the seat of the person next to them.

DRS1970 · 09/02/2024 09:32

I wouldn't mind paying more for being large if they reciprocally allocated me more space to accommodate my larger size.

Newusernameforthiss · 09/02/2024 09:30

OMG OP you need to learn some physics yourself.

If you go in a little six seater plane or something, absolutely, you and the luggage get weighed, it really matters.

On an A319 or a 747???? Absolutely not 😂😂😂 you know they can carry horses. And an entire Saudi Princess' luggage. It really doesn't matter if the average passenger weighs 70kg or 120kg. It's a commercial airliner 🫠

Once, years ago, I went on a BMI flight from (IIRC) Geneva to Edinburgh and there were like 5 passengers on the entire plane. They made us all move to the front for weight distribution at the landing. But it was truly exceptional -- in 12 years of flying for work, that was once that weight distribution mattered on a normal flight.

If you hate fat people fair enough 🤷‍♀️ but don't try and tell me the engineers at the worlds biggest aviation companies didn't design their plans right 😂😂

(Edited for typos sorry)

Wasbedeudetetdas · 09/02/2024 09:29

LoveSandbanks · 09/02/2024 09:25

How about this; there are seats with extra legroom that passengers pay extra for even tho their height is completely beyond their control. If you want to sit together you ALL pay for extra legroom.

have a few rows of wider seats that larger passengers pay extra for. Again if you all want to sit together, again you all pay extra. The fact is that very very few cases of people being morbidly obese is down to factors other than eating too much. The reasons for eating too much could be down to trauma etc but the cause is the same. Regardless of the cause the dangers of being seriously overweight are exactly the same.

The issue with this is that there is no way of checking the size (weight, height etc) of people when booking so they could book the wrong option. Assigning these on the day wouldn't work as you may have not enough of the larger seats (or too many and standard sized folk not wanting to pay more). I suppose that issue comes with booking an extra seat too. Maybe there needs to be some sort of tick disclaimer regarding whether you are booking a standard or larger seat at the time of purchase, so you cannot then complain? I wonder if some folk would book larger seats for comfort too, even if they don't need the space?

LoveSandbanks · 09/02/2024 09:25

How about this; there are seats with extra legroom that passengers pay extra for even tho their height is completely beyond their control. If you want to sit together you ALL pay for extra legroom.

have a few rows of wider seats that larger passengers pay extra for. Again if you all want to sit together, again you all pay extra. The fact is that very very few cases of people being morbidly obese is down to factors other than eating too much. The reasons for eating too much could be down to trauma etc but the cause is the same. Regardless of the cause the dangers of being seriously overweight are exactly the same.

maddening · 09/02/2024 09:24

There are ways to weigh without anyone seeing - eg the floor that everyone walks over.

Surely the only safety concern is enough fuel (there was a plane that crashed as it didn't have enough fuel for the total weight) so it is possible to weigh as people walk to the place without anyone being stood on scales and weighed as individuals.

Spagb0l · 09/02/2024 09:23

Inthebitterend · 09/02/2024 09:15

Not sure why I read posts like this that make it clear so many people are okay with completely dehumanising people for how they look, and the fact they dare want to travel while being such hideous beasts.

Does anyone want to talk about these airlines making seats smaller constantly to squeeze more people in so they make more money? Not to mention that most airlines these days charge you for even wanting to take a bag, on your holiday! Or charging you to sit with your family! There are bigger fucking issues at play than a fat person daring to want to go on holiday or travel for business. Jesus fucking christ.

Shaming people doesn't work to make them lose weight, btw. Being shamed is a fat person's life, if it worked no one would be fat.

No one is dehumanising anyone 🙄
If something can be done to be more eco friendly, then I stand for it. Doesn't mean fat people are 'hideous beasts'.

The carbon footprint is roughly 20% bigger in an obese person.

Wasbedeudetetdas · 09/02/2024 09:23

Thebestwaytoscareatory · 09/02/2024 09:19

Well, the average weight of an adult from the official fattest country on the planet (Nauru) is 100kg, so even if you found yourself on a flight exclusively filled with people from there you'd still be way below the capacity.

You'd need every single person on the plane to be around 130kg (20.5st) for there to start to be an issue.

It's not just about capacity though, it's also about fuel usage!

AIstolemylunch · 09/02/2024 09:22

Inthebitterend · 09/02/2024 09:15

Not sure why I read posts like this that make it clear so many people are okay with completely dehumanising people for how they look, and the fact they dare want to travel while being such hideous beasts.

Does anyone want to talk about these airlines making seats smaller constantly to squeeze more people in so they make more money? Not to mention that most airlines these days charge you for even wanting to take a bag, on your holiday! Or charging you to sit with your family! There are bigger fucking issues at play than a fat person daring to want to go on holiday or travel for business. Jesus fucking christ.

Shaming people doesn't work to make them lose weight, btw. Being shamed is a fat person's life, if it worked no one would be fat.

So? Most isn't all and someone has to pay for the extra fuel, ultimately us in ticket prices. I'd rather pay less.

quisensoucie · 09/02/2024 09:22

Inthebitterend · 09/02/2024 09:15

Not sure why I read posts like this that make it clear so many people are okay with completely dehumanising people for how they look, and the fact they dare want to travel while being such hideous beasts.

Does anyone want to talk about these airlines making seats smaller constantly to squeeze more people in so they make more money? Not to mention that most airlines these days charge you for even wanting to take a bag, on your holiday! Or charging you to sit with your family! There are bigger fucking issues at play than a fat person daring to want to go on holiday or travel for business. Jesus fucking christ.

Shaming people doesn't work to make them lose weight, btw. Being shamed is a fat person's life, if it worked no one would be fat.

You have missed the point. it is a safety issue, particularly with the increase in obesity over the past decade or so
Yes, they added more seats to get more money, but again, it remains an issue. Rather like getting in a lift; it says max 4 people but also adds a maximum weight because 4 morbidly obese people would weigh more than 4 non-obese people. That is a fact. So putting more seats in can increase the weight, but if more seats are filled with heavier people, the overall weight would be greater
Again, this is not about shaming - particularly as size is visibly obvious

OP posts:
Wasbedeudetetdas · 09/02/2024 09:20

@Inthebitterend nobody is suggesting dehumanising anyone, simply taking into account that weight does actually matter when calculating flight load (especially if it differs significantly than average!).
Also, what is a 'wind up plane' - I live somewhere with lots of small planes and they all use fuel.

Inthebitterend · 09/02/2024 09:20

MissRheingold · 09/02/2024 08:46

I love vintage planes and it's part and parcel of going up in one that everyone has to be weighed and then seated accordingly to ensure even distribution of weight.

All this fat shaming stuff is just ridiculous.

If you're flying in a tiny, wind up plane then yes, you need to distribute weight and make it accurate otherwise there will be massive safety issues.

In a huge commercial airliner that is designed to carry tonnes and tonnes of weight, I don't see how a few overweight people are going to make a difference at all.