Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Weighting for the backlash

185 replies

quisensoucie · 09/02/2024 08:01

Weighing aeroplane passengers is not a new phenomenon, so the 'fat-shaming' trope is rather misplaced
'In the early days of air travel, Airlines frequently weighed passengers and even crew to properly balance the smaller, less sophisticated aircraft, according to the Smithsonian.

Passenger weight can have an impact on another aspect of flying: seat size.'
https://www.google.com/url?sa=t&source=web&rct=j&opi=89978449&url=www.smithsonianmag.com/air-space-magazine/then-amp-now-a-weighty-matter-46320857/&ved=2ahUKEwi8--2O452EAxU2a0EAHa-9B8sQFnoECCsQAQ&usg=AOvVaw36nIvu41LW3mTW1jC32O9v

https://www.independent.co.uk/travel/news-and-advice/airlines-weigh-passengers-check-in-baggage-cargo-balance-a8860071.html

This is a safety issue, not about making larger people pay more. But again, the science and physics are dismissed because 'feelings'

https://www.google.com/url?opi=89978449&rct=j&sa=t&source=web&url=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.smithsonianmag.com%2Fair-space-magazine%2Fthen-amp-now-a-weighty-matter-46320857%2F&usg=AOvVaw36nIvu41LW3mTW1jC32O9v&ved=2ahUKEwi8--2O452EAxU2a0EAHa-9B8sQFnoECCsQAQ

OP posts:
Wasbedeudetetdas · 09/02/2024 13:20

Jovacknockowitch · 09/02/2024 12:51

Tall people should pay extra due to their height?

If their tallness/long legs causes their legs to intrude in the leg space of the neighbouring seats then perhaps yes.

ilovebreadsauce · 09/02/2024 13:06

Have you actually read your own links?
No airline is suggesting such a thing, just another fat bashing thread

Jovacknockowitch · 09/02/2024 12:51

Wasbedeudetetdas · 09/02/2024 12:50

Agreed.
I didn't restrict my original comment to weight, hence use of the word size.

Tall people should pay extra due to their height?

Wasbedeudetetdas · 09/02/2024 12:50

Jovacknockowitch · 09/02/2024 12:48

Not just fat people - taller people weigh more, as on average do Men.

Agreed.
I didn't restrict my original comment to weight, hence use of the word size.

Jovacknockowitch · 09/02/2024 12:48

Paradiddlediddle · 09/02/2024 08:14

@Wasbedeudetetdas why in earth do you like that idea? Literally the only benefit would be to upset someone who is fat? It wouldn’t benefit anyone in any way, it wouldn’t increase safety or efficiency? It would just be saying “you’re fat you need to pay more” when the fat person gains no benefit, a bit like highway robbery?

Not just fat people - taller people weigh more, as on average do Men.

notimagain · 09/02/2024 12:37

Blimey there are some weird ideas being put around about fuel (I'll get back to weight).

Dumping at the end of a flight is definitely not done as a matter as routine...

General policy (as agreed with the regulator) is carry enough for flight from departure to destination plus enough for a diversion to a nominated airport, plus some other buffers. The aircraft commander can opt to put even more on if for example the weather forecast is crappy but you shouldn't get to destination above maximum landing weight...there's no point.

Also maybe worth pointing out that putting lots of extra fuel over above what is needed for a flight makes the aircraft less efficient, you burn some of the extra fuel carrying the extra fuel which is not a good thing, especially for those who are fans of cheap flights.

As for passenger weighing..I suspect the outage bus in the MSM started rolling on this a few days ago when Finnair announced they were doing a survey to check their assumed weights were still correct...most airlines do similar at intervals over the years but nobody in the media could be bothered to read and understand what Finnair were up to:

https://www.finnair.com/fr-en/frequently-asked-questions/airport-and-flights/why-is-finnair-weighing-passengers-before-flying3267140

Why is Finnair weighing passengers before flying?

https://www.finnair.com/fr-en/frequently-asked-questions/airport-and-flights/why-is-finnair-weighing-passengers-before-flying--3267140

Wasbedeudetetdas · 09/02/2024 11:30

MartinsSpareCalculator · 09/02/2024 10:27

And this would be fine and well if all aircraft had armrests that could be fully raised between seats, and all airlines adopted the policy of not overbooking and thus giving away second seats to other passengers.

I read a blog by an oversized traveller who has pointed out many issues, of which those are just 2.

Why on earth would raising the arm rest on a seat be of benefit to the person who is already being squished though?

DRS1970 · 09/02/2024 11:29

FrangipaniBlue · 09/02/2024 10:31

Extra legroom seats are also wider, so you are free to book those and pay are you not?

Yes, but I believe the OP is talking about enforced charging, not optional.

AIstolemylunch · 09/02/2024 11:28

Where is personal responsibility? I am very claustrophobic so pay extra for seats that have more space. No way I'd try and cram myself into a seat I didn't fit in, that's way more embarrassing than being discretely weighed with my luggage at checkin. it's nothing to do with fat shaming, it's physics. Tall family members have to pay for extra legroom seats because they cant phsically fold their legs into the space of a normal economy seat. Why should wide people be any different to long people?

It's no different to travelling with small children, everyone is side eyeing you at the gate thinking God I hope I'm not sat next to them. I've been on both sides of that equation. if you're very obese people are going to be thinking that at the gate, irrespective of whether you've been discretely weighed at checkin or not.

Pandadunks · 09/02/2024 11:10

‘For those asking about mention of feelings, in Daily M today’

ah! Of course, this non-issue is from the Daily Fail!

Daily Fail - Fat people are too embarrassed to get weighed before getting in the plane!
Airlines - we aren’t weighing anyone. We don’t need to.
DF - their feelings will get hurt! The snowflake fat people
Airlines- we don’t need to weight people. And we can’t anyway, no infrastructure to do so.
DF - where do YOU stand in this ‘debate’ ? Should fatties lose weight or pay more?
Airlines - there is no debate.

MartinsSpareCalculator · 09/02/2024 10:48

The weight thing also penalises taller people, who in the majority of cases will weigh more than somebody shorter. So my mum is 147cm and weighs about 45kg. My dad is 193cm and weighs around 95kg, so double what my mum weighs. They're both healthy weights.

Cestfoutu · 09/02/2024 10:46

When in holiday in Costa Rica, we took a number of flights in small planes and every time had to get on the scales with our luggage. A couple on one flight were cross because a previous flight they were on was too heavy and as they were last to check in they had to remove half the contents of their suitcases which would travel on a later plane to (hopefully) catch up with them. I suppose if you scale it all up, there is no reason why the same shouldn't happen in a larger plane?

LoveBluey · 09/02/2024 10:32

I think they do take passenger distribution in to account on the smaller planes. I flew from Southampton to Scotland and was sat next to a stranger. I asked if I could move to an unoccupied pair of seats and the stewardess said she'd have to check with the captain because the seating plan is looked at before take off to ensure everything is balanced.

They didn't know individual passengers weights but they certainly took it in to account.

I did eat salad for a while after that comment!!!

NotQuiteNorma · 09/02/2024 10:32

There are many, many reasons that people are overweight.

Including trauma, hormonal imbalance, genetics, disabilities, finances, pregnancies... The list goes on.

The reasons are irrelevant to the context. Do we need in flight counselling as well?

FrangipaniBlue · 09/02/2024 10:31

DRS1970 · 09/02/2024 09:32

I wouldn't mind paying more for being large if they reciprocally allocated me more space to accommodate my larger size.

Extra legroom seats are also wider, so you are free to book those and pay are you not?

MartinsSpareCalculator · 09/02/2024 10:27

Wasbedeudetetdas · 09/02/2024 08:10

I like the idea of everyone having an allowance, which includes weight of person + baggage, and anything over and above = charge.

I also think that if you don't fit comfortably in one seat without impinging on anyone else's space then you need to pay for an extra seat - it might not be your fault you that take up extra space but neither is it the fault of the person who is allocated the seat next to you. Ideally these extra seats would be at a supplement rate as opposed to whole seat rate, however that might increase the overall seat price for everyone so that the airline is still making the same money per seat!

And this would be fine and well if all aircraft had armrests that could be fully raised between seats, and all airlines adopted the policy of not overbooking and thus giving away second seats to other passengers.

I read a blog by an oversized traveller who has pointed out many issues, of which those are just 2.

TinselTitts · 09/02/2024 10:25

EdinGirl · 09/02/2024 08:04

There are many, many reasons that people are overweight.

Including trauma, hormonal imbalance, genetics, disabilities, finances, pregnancies... The list goes on.

Humiliating people is not the answer.

We have been flying around just fine without this, it doesn't need to come back.

It is a dangerous path to go down with ozempic making the rounds and people going back to the "heroin chic" of a few decades ago.

It is a dangerous path to go down with ozempic making the rounds and people going back to the "heroin chic" of a few decades ago.

63% of British adults are not going back to the 'heroin chic' route, according to obesity statistics.

MartinsSpareCalculator · 09/02/2024 10:24

If you're travelling on light aircraft you'll probably still be weighed.

It isn't really relevant when you're flying on a jumbo jet, where the weight of the passengers is distributed is fairly immaterial.

CranfordScones · 09/02/2024 10:23

It's not just about airline profits, though that's a factor.

It's not uncommon for passengers to be bumped off flights because the aircraft can't meet it's take-off weight. It's common in hot weather (because the air's thinner which reduces lift) and at smaller airports and on longer flights (because they have to carry more fuel).

In many cases they wouldn't have to bump people if they weighed them accurately, rather than making assumptions which err on the cautious side.

But the principles of engineering have to end where some people's feelings begin.

Think about that next time you're bumped off a flight.

FrangipaniBlue · 09/02/2024 10:21

AIstolemylunch · 09/02/2024 08:33

this seems perfectly fine and rational to me. people want greener travel and the airlines are trying to do their bit. Knowing the total weight of everybody and everything on the plane will aĺow them to be more precise about fuel allocation an use less as currently they guesstimate and add more than is necessary.

Asking people to step onto some sort of pressure pad at check in isn't humiliating them. They're not going to broadcast the weight.

Pretty much this!

Pandadunks · 09/02/2024 10:20

EffortlesslyInelegant · 09/02/2024 10:18

Oh dear. Someone left the gate open at the dick farm this morning 🙄

😂😂😂😂😂😂

Pandadunks · 09/02/2024 10:20

‘what a non issue. the real problem is overly cheap flight tickets encouraging us all to jet off to various destinations and increasing our carbon footprints.’

yup - this.

FrangipaniBlue · 09/02/2024 10:20

Do they not just use the leftover fuel for the next flight? 😂

Nope. There are restrictions on how much fuel they are allowed to have on board when landing (for safety, fire/explosion risk) so if they are carrying over that they have to fuel dump.

EffortlesslyInelegant · 09/02/2024 10:18

PictureALadybird · 09/02/2024 08:02

YANBU. People are too sensitive about their weight.

Everyone can see you! If this bothers you, put some effort into losing the weight.

Oh dear. Someone left the gate open at the dick farm this morning 🙄

Pandadunks · 09/02/2024 10:17

‘Oh, give over. Not goady, raising a point.
But clearly hit a button with you’

what IS that point though? Planes are safe without weighing passengers, and airlines don’t usually implement any passenger weighing system because it’s expensive and unnecessary.

I would say the only people really interested in changing the whole system are probably the ones who stand to make money out of selling airlines all the equipment needed to make weighing people feasible.

And it we’re talking ‘comfort’ of passengers when bigger people sit beside them - well, that’s not going to change with a weighing policy is it?

I’m actually quite small and the most uncomfortable flights I’ve had have been sitting beside really tall men, regardless of their weight because they take up so much leg room, or sitting beside someone who needs to go to the loo constantly.