TBH if you actually look at typical fuel burn penalties for weight increases the thin folk here might be disappointed at how little they would gain financially if it was pay by weight…maybe a quid or two absolute max difference between fuel costs for a heavy verse a light passenger on a shorthaul flight.
Any rush to load the aircraft to near-perfect theoretical level of cargo vs. Fuel will inevitably lead to more frequent catastrophic events in flight.
@Anyotherdude
But it’s to some extent theoretical now….where I worked the fuel burn for a sector from A to B was based the projected load for the flight, which was amongst other things based on theoretical (assumed) weights. Some days the reality was the weight was known slightly below plan but some days it was above..
The really important thing is as long as the extra legal buffers for contingencies (such as the weight possibly being slightly wrong, forecast winds being wrong..there’s a whole list), plus possible diversion at destination and then other bits of padding that are in the current rules for fuel loading stay in place there’s should not be any increased risk of catastrophic events..and in any event never mind the theory, the crew do have fuel gauges.