Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Weighting for the backlash

185 replies

quisensoucie · 09/02/2024 08:01

Weighing aeroplane passengers is not a new phenomenon, so the 'fat-shaming' trope is rather misplaced
'In the early days of air travel, Airlines frequently weighed passengers and even crew to properly balance the smaller, less sophisticated aircraft, according to the Smithsonian.

Passenger weight can have an impact on another aspect of flying: seat size.'
https://www.google.com/url?sa=t&source=web&rct=j&opi=89978449&url=www.smithsonianmag.com/air-space-magazine/then-amp-now-a-weighty-matter-46320857/&ved=2ahUKEwi8--2O452EAxU2a0EAHa-9B8sQFnoECCsQAQ&usg=AOvVaw36nIvu41LW3mTW1jC32O9v

https://www.independent.co.uk/travel/news-and-advice/airlines-weigh-passengers-check-in-baggage-cargo-balance-a8860071.html

This is a safety issue, not about making larger people pay more. But again, the science and physics are dismissed because 'feelings'

https://www.google.com/url?opi=89978449&rct=j&sa=t&source=web&url=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.smithsonianmag.com%2Fair-space-magazine%2Fthen-amp-now-a-weighty-matter-46320857%2F&usg=AOvVaw36nIvu41LW3mTW1jC32O9v&ved=2ahUKEwi8--2O452EAxU2a0EAHa-9B8sQFnoECCsQAQ

OP posts:
TheHateIsNotGood · 09/02/2024 21:11

When I first (mis) heard this 'news' as 'Thinair' I guessed what it was about. Ditto this post's title pun weighting/waiting.

Irrespective of 'feelz' loaded weight is a fundamental factor in calculating fuel loads (=costs) and ultimately load 'distribution' to enable the safe take off, flight and landing of aircraft. Each type of aircraft flown has this basic info going along with it.

It doesn't matter what the cargo is - people and luggage, plastic noses filled with cocaine, etc, etc - it's the weight that matters. (nb: exceptions apply, such as horses and racing cars, more through uneven distribution/hazards).

It's actually Finnair, but an idea worth running with - mefinks.

Pandadunks · 09/02/2024 19:20

It’s an entirely pointless thread. Airlines aren’t trying to get people to allow themselves to be weighed.
it’s a non-issue.
Its not needed, it would be prohibitively expensive for airlines, the tech isn’t there to roll it out, no-one is asking for it.

Vegetus · 09/02/2024 15:52

EdinGirl · 09/02/2024 08:04

There are many, many reasons that people are overweight.

Including trauma, hormonal imbalance, genetics, disabilities, finances, pregnancies... The list goes on.

Humiliating people is not the answer.

We have been flying around just fine without this, it doesn't need to come back.

It is a dangerous path to go down with ozempic making the rounds and people going back to the "heroin chic" of a few decades ago.

There's only one reason and It's because they eat too much.

There are however many reasons why people eat too much.

bestmoment · 09/02/2024 15:41

Pandadunks · 09/02/2024 15:27

OP’s clearly woken up on the wrong side of the bed today and thought, let’s have a little stir. Fat people! No-one cares about fat people so let’s give that a poke.

well yes that is possible

or she wants to debate something that i personally reckon is very much on a possibility of being spread out, and her own view is that it’s reasonable.

I do as well actually!

doesn’t mean we’re grumpy! do you think anyone disagreeing with you must be grumpy?

quisensoucie · 09/02/2024 15:39

Pandadunks · 09/02/2024 15:27

OP’s clearly woken up on the wrong side of the bed today and thought, let’s have a little stir. Fat people! No-one cares about fat people so let’s give that a poke.

Sadly, you seemed determined to derail this thread and are falling back on the 'goady' trope.
Some interesting points have been made by MNs, and having a debate is the adult way to express opinions, not just shouting your point

OP posts:
Pandadunks · 09/02/2024 15:27

OP’s clearly woken up on the wrong side of the bed today and thought, let’s have a little stir. Fat people! No-one cares about fat people so let’s give that a poke.

fonfusedm · 09/02/2024 15:03

I take it you've never been unfortunate enough to sit beside someone who sits effectively diagonally in their seat and protrudes their legs in front of your seat as well as their own?

im 5ft 10 & have never put my legs across my neighbour.

notimagain · 09/02/2024 14:33

TBH if you actually look at typical fuel burn penalties for weight increases the thin folk here might be disappointed at how little they would gain financially if it was pay by weight…maybe a quid or two absolute max difference between fuel costs for a heavy verse a light passenger on a shorthaul flight.

Any rush to load the aircraft to near-perfect theoretical level of cargo vs. Fuel will inevitably lead to more frequent catastrophic events in flight.

@Anyotherdude

But it’s to some extent theoretical now….where I worked the fuel burn for a sector from A to B was based the projected load for the flight, which was amongst other things based on theoretical (assumed) weights. Some days the reality was the weight was known slightly below plan but some days it was above..

The really important thing is as long as the extra legal buffers for contingencies (such as the weight possibly being slightly wrong, forecast winds being wrong..there’s a whole list), plus possible diversion at destination and then other bits of padding that are in the current rules for fuel loading stay in place there’s should not be any increased risk of catastrophic events..and in any event never mind the theory, the crew do have fuel gauges.

Wasbedeudetetdas · 09/02/2024 14:33

MartinsSpareCalculator · 09/02/2024 14:30

They are paying for more room. The reason may be so as to not inconvenience people but the tangible thing they pay their money for is more room.

I don't like to fly economy because I like more space and find it inconvenient to either have to get up to let someone out or to have someone have to get up to let me out. But I pay for a complete service, not just the bit that prevents inconvenience to me and others. The same is true of people who pay for an additional seat.

My point stands.
You're entitled to yours.

MartinsSpareCalculator · 09/02/2024 14:32

DrinkFeckArseBrick · 09/02/2024 14:12

I agree with a PP that said that passengers who need more than one seat due to size, pay for one seat. I don't see how that's unfair.

And agree there are many many reasons for being overweight. But by far the most common is eating too much or too much of the wrong food.

Also it seems unfair to get charged a fortune for being a kilos over on a 15kg baggage limit, when someone else can literally be 30kg over a healthy weight.

I do understand the practicalities though of why weighing everyone and charging or allocating seats accordingly may not work

Someone has to lift your bag. The charge is supposed to be a disincentive to overpacking. Nobody has to lift you.

MartinsSpareCalculator · 09/02/2024 14:30

Wasbedeudetetdas · 09/02/2024 13:51

They're not paying for more room, as it stands, they're being charged not to inconvenience those around them.

They are paying for more room. The reason may be so as to not inconvenience people but the tangible thing they pay their money for is more room.

I don't like to fly economy because I like more space and find it inconvenient to either have to get up to let someone out or to have someone have to get up to let me out. But I pay for a complete service, not just the bit that prevents inconvenience to me and others. The same is true of people who pay for an additional seat.

FrangipaniBlue · 09/02/2024 14:18

@DRS1970 the OP says in her opening post that it is NOT about charging people extra......

DrinkFeckArseBrick · 09/02/2024 14:12

I agree with a PP that said that passengers who need more than one seat due to size, pay for one seat. I don't see how that's unfair.

And agree there are many many reasons for being overweight. But by far the most common is eating too much or too much of the wrong food.

Also it seems unfair to get charged a fortune for being a kilos over on a 15kg baggage limit, when someone else can literally be 30kg over a healthy weight.

I do understand the practicalities though of why weighing everyone and charging or allocating seats accordingly may not work

Anyotherdude · 09/02/2024 14:11

@Spagb0l the OP seemed to be anticipating that their post would get people emotive about their choice of words in that way…

Spagb0l · 09/02/2024 14:08

@Anyotherdude where is the weight shaming in the OP?

Anyotherdude · 09/02/2024 14:02

I’m not even going to get het up about the weight-shaming part of the OP.
This is one of those hare-brained schemes where someone with no knowledge of aeronautics is given column inches to explain his “fuel-economy” theory to try to persuade the airline’s accountants and shareholders to install a policy that could lead to a potential reduction in passenger safety.
Aircraft are not the safest form of transport, but airlines currently operate above the minimum standards required to make the risk of, say, running out of fuel, an unlikely event.
Bits can break on them while they are in the air - they can keep flying. Fuel can suddenly start to leak while they are in the air - they can shut an engine down and keep flying.
Any rush to load the aircraft to near-perfect theoretical level of cargo vs. Fuel will inevitably lead to more frequent catastrophic events in flight. Commercial aircraft are, in some cases, over 30 years old: they do have a number of flight hours after which minor and major overhauls are mandatory, and carried out by aircraft engineers, but during my relative’s 40-year long career in aircraft engineering, there were a regular number of ad-hoc repairs to do between these checks, as well as the scheduled work - and most of that emergency repair work was fuel-leak related!
If this were introduced, I, for one, wouldn’t be setting foot on any flight…

Wasbedeudetetdas · 09/02/2024 13:51

MartinsSpareCalculator · 09/02/2024 13:48

Except often when they do, it's because they don't physically fit into the seat. How comfortable do you expect you'd be with an arm rest cutting into your torso for however many hours? And that would be assuming the airline have the good grace not to assign your extra seat to someone else.

If someone is paying for more room, they should have full unobstructed use of it.

They're not paying for more room, as it stands, they're being charged not to inconvenience those around them.

MartinsSpareCalculator · 09/02/2024 13:48

Wasbedeudetetdas · 09/02/2024 13:45

They're purchasing the other seat so that the only seat they spill into isn't occupied.

Except often when they do, it's because they don't physically fit into the seat. How comfortable do you expect you'd be with an arm rest cutting into your torso for however many hours? And that would be assuming the airline have the good grace not to assign your extra seat to someone else.

If someone is paying for more room, they should have full unobstructed use of it.

Wasbedeudetetdas · 09/02/2024 13:47

fonfusedm · 09/02/2024 13:24

If their tallness/long legs causes their legs to intrude in the leg space of the neighbouring seats then perhaps yes.

😆

I take it you've never been unfortunate enough to sit beside someone who sits effectively diagonally in their seat and protrudes their legs in front of your seat as well as their own?

Wasbedeudetetdas · 09/02/2024 13:45

MartinsSpareCalculator · 09/02/2024 13:43

I didn't suggest it would. The point was if someone purchases 2 seats as they won't fit into 1, it only works if the armrest between their seats lifts up completely.

They're purchasing the other seat so that the only seat they spill into isn't occupied.

MartinsSpareCalculator · 09/02/2024 13:43

Wasbedeudetetdas · 09/02/2024 11:30

Why on earth would raising the arm rest on a seat be of benefit to the person who is already being squished though?

I didn't suggest it would. The point was if someone purchases 2 seats as they won't fit into 1, it only works if the armrest between their seats lifts up completely.

notimagain · 09/02/2024 13:43

quisensoucie · 09/02/2024 13:29

@Pandadunks others have reported similar reactions, but you can find them for yourself

The Mail certainly led with the story a few days back in the context of the Finnair survey (TBF they mentioned the reasons for it eventually, but probably well past the point most people had stopped reading).

From the airlines' POV weighing all passengers plus hand baggage would be a logistical nightmare ....just one of many reasons would be that many passengers these days don't use airport check in, they check in on line and are often HBO.

That would mean weighing would have to be done at the gate and that would really slow the whole loading and boarding process down to more of a crawl than it is now.

quisensoucie · 09/02/2024 13:29

@Pandadunks others have reported similar reactions, but you can find them for yourself

OP posts:
fonfusedm · 09/02/2024 13:24

If their tallness/long legs causes their legs to intrude in the leg space of the neighbouring seats then perhaps yes.

😆

fonfusedm · 09/02/2024 13:23

I like the idea of everyone having an allowance, which includes weight of person + baggage, and anything over and above = charge.

Surely it can’t be just weight as a 6ft person will weigh a bit more than a 5ft person!