Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Weighting for the backlash

185 replies

quisensoucie · 09/02/2024 08:01

Weighing aeroplane passengers is not a new phenomenon, so the 'fat-shaming' trope is rather misplaced
'In the early days of air travel, Airlines frequently weighed passengers and even crew to properly balance the smaller, less sophisticated aircraft, according to the Smithsonian.

Passenger weight can have an impact on another aspect of flying: seat size.'
https://www.google.com/url?sa=t&source=web&rct=j&opi=89978449&url=www.smithsonianmag.com/air-space-magazine/then-amp-now-a-weighty-matter-46320857/&ved=2ahUKEwi8--2O452EAxU2a0EAHa-9B8sQFnoECCsQAQ&usg=AOvVaw36nIvu41LW3mTW1jC32O9v

https://www.independent.co.uk/travel/news-and-advice/airlines-weigh-passengers-check-in-baggage-cargo-balance-a8860071.html

This is a safety issue, not about making larger people pay more. But again, the science and physics are dismissed because 'feelings'

https://www.google.com/url?opi=89978449&rct=j&sa=t&source=web&url=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.smithsonianmag.com%2Fair-space-magazine%2Fthen-amp-now-a-weighty-matter-46320857%2F&usg=AOvVaw36nIvu41LW3mTW1jC32O9v&ved=2ahUKEwi8--2O452EAxU2a0EAHa-9B8sQFnoECCsQAQ

OP posts:
bestmoment · 10/02/2024 11:07

crew2022 · 10/02/2024 11:01

I personally don't like sitting next to someone who is obese and spilling on to my seat. It's unfair as my journey is made uncomfortable, it's difficult to get up and stretch my legs if they are by the aisle etc.

me neither. an 11 hour flight. I had half the seat. The other half was occupied by my next door passenger’s excess flesh

GrumpyPanda · 10/02/2024 11:05

Wasbedeudetetdas · 09/02/2024 08:13

I do think some sort of rules need to be brought in regarding seating, where people who do take up more space than their seat really need to pay for an extra seat - while it might not be their fault they are large, it also isn't the fault of the person who happens to be squashed in next to them. Their right to comfort isn't more than anyone else's.

Hate to prick your balloon but them's already the rules with the majority of air lines.

crew2022 · 10/02/2024 11:01

I personally don't like sitting next to someone who is obese and spilling on to my seat. It's unfair as my journey is made uncomfortable, it's difficult to get up and stretch my legs if they are by the aisle etc.

0rangeCrush · 10/02/2024 11:00

Wasbedeudetetdas · 10/02/2024 10:51

The flight company local to my area (yes only one flies there) has different allowances than the norm, especially on the smaller flights, so for anyone flying to remote locations or city hop type locations which are on smaller planes might be advised to check the baggage allowance for individual parts of the flight.
Even bigger airlines sometimes operate much smaller flights on certain routes.

I worked for a holiday company, so mainly dealt with charter flights and scheduled airlines from/to major cities, the only time we dealt with “small planes” were when we booked cruises from Southampton with FlyBe flights, but even then they were allowed the full allowance. This was mid 2000s until about 2013 though.

Wasbedeudetetdas · 10/02/2024 10:58

TorringtonDean · 10/02/2024 10:57

Yes, like maybe providing adequate seating?

Well that's one of the options.
Until all planes have more generous seating there needs to be other solutions.

TorringtonDean · 10/02/2024 10:57

Yes, like maybe providing adequate seating?

Wasbedeudetetdas · 10/02/2024 10:56

TorringtonDean · 10/02/2024 10:51

@notimagain The fact that there are a lot more passengers crammed in, as you admit, shows that the weight of the passengers is not a genuine issue.

A lot of the comments on Mail Online, not MumsNet, were just unvarnished fat shaming. I wonder if all those trolls are really such perfect individuals?? Some seem to truly relish the idea of humiliating others.

I don't want to humiliate anyone, but I also don't want someone next to me who is effectively sitting in my seat and theirs - this is why airlines need a firm and clear policy for anyone of size, not so shame them but to ensure the comfort (as far as possible) of all passengers.

Wasbedeudetetdas · 10/02/2024 10:54

TorringtonDean · 10/02/2024 10:33

I think he took something during the flight. Just over half way through the trip a load of passengers at the back suddenly became very noisy. There was a guy a few rows forward who took his shirt off and had to be told to get dressed. Then the off-his-head one suddenly loomed up from the back and sat in the empty seat in front of me. A hostess tried to humour him but everyone else was trying not to make eye contact as he was menacing too. Then, during landing he started trying to WhatsApp a friend, stood up, got his bag from the overhead locker and headed down the aisle for the door. Was finally got to sit down by fellow passengers.

He was the correct BMI. People can be perfectly slim and a menace to others!

Oh, of course BMI is not related in to whether someone is a menace or not.
How unbelievably stupid to get so deliberately off your face (in any way) on a flight that you are a danger to yourself and those around you.

TorringtonDean · 10/02/2024 10:51

@notimagain The fact that there are a lot more passengers crammed in, as you admit, shows that the weight of the passengers is not a genuine issue.

A lot of the comments on Mail Online, not MumsNet, were just unvarnished fat shaming. I wonder if all those trolls are really such perfect individuals?? Some seem to truly relish the idea of humiliating others.

Wasbedeudetetdas · 10/02/2024 10:51

0rangeCrush · 10/02/2024 10:43

The maximum permitted bag weight is 32kg across all airlines I believe. You are correct; this is due to the safety of lifting the bag rather than anything to do with the aircraft itself.

When I worked in travel you could pool luggage allowances between families (for example, if a family of 4 were travelling with 20kg luggage allowance, they could take up to 4 bags totalling 80kg) but no individual case could be more than 32kg. Hence why kids often took small trunki size cases weighing maybe 10kg each and the parents would take larger cases weighing maybe 25-30kg.

The flight company local to my area (yes only one flies there) has different allowances than the norm, especially on the smaller flights, so for anyone flying to remote locations or city hop type locations which are on smaller planes might be advised to check the baggage allowance for individual parts of the flight.
Even bigger airlines sometimes operate much smaller flights on certain routes.

0rangeCrush · 10/02/2024 10:43

Pandadunks · 10/02/2024 08:26

‘Also it seems unfair to get charged a fortune for being a kilos over on a 15kg baggage limit, when someone else can literally be 30kg over a healthy weight.’

Can’t argue with stupid!

someone has to lift your bags, that’s why there are weight restrictions or charges for very heavy luggage - which might take a couple of people or piece of equipment to move safely.

The maximum permitted bag weight is 32kg across all airlines I believe. You are correct; this is due to the safety of lifting the bag rather than anything to do with the aircraft itself.

When I worked in travel you could pool luggage allowances between families (for example, if a family of 4 were travelling with 20kg luggage allowance, they could take up to 4 bags totalling 80kg) but no individual case could be more than 32kg. Hence why kids often took small trunki size cases weighing maybe 10kg each and the parents would take larger cases weighing maybe 25-30kg.

notimagain · 10/02/2024 10:42

@TorringtonDean

The real problem is airlines have crammed in more seats and slashed legroom. It was never an issue in the 1970s when there was space. Maybe they should stop treating passengers like cattle?

They shouldn't treat passengers like cattle but when it comes to seating, if you want 1970's seat pitches back do you also want 1970's prices?

Despite rumours the airlines aren't flush with cash, Ryanair might be heading for a bumper year, making maybe an average of 20 pounds profit on the average passenger over the year.....most short haul operators it'll be closer to 10......

Remove seats to improve pitch and prices will go up....

0rangeCrush · 10/02/2024 10:37

bestmoment · 09/02/2024 08:14

it’s not about “people’s weight”

it is about the weight capability of the aeroplane

does anyone feel its is entirely unnecessary to weigh luggage? nope, didn’t think so

Weighing luggage is about the safety of the people lifting the case to and from the plane, not the plane itself.

Given the weight of the actual plane itself; the added weight of heavier passengers is inconsequential.

TorringtonDean · 10/02/2024 10:33

I think he took something during the flight. Just over half way through the trip a load of passengers at the back suddenly became very noisy. There was a guy a few rows forward who took his shirt off and had to be told to get dressed. Then the off-his-head one suddenly loomed up from the back and sat in the empty seat in front of me. A hostess tried to humour him but everyone else was trying not to make eye contact as he was menacing too. Then, during landing he started trying to WhatsApp a friend, stood up, got his bag from the overhead locker and headed down the aisle for the door. Was finally got to sit down by fellow passengers.

He was the correct BMI. People can be perfectly slim and a menace to others!

Wasbedeudetetdas · 10/02/2024 10:25

TorringtonDean · 10/02/2024 09:29

The real problem is airlines have crammed in more seats and slashed legroom. It was never an issue in the 1970s when there was space. Maybe they should stop treating passengers like cattle?

Last year I took a couple of flights where there was a big problem with unruly behaviour from passengers. One guy was completely off his head and trying to open a door during landing when we were still in the air. Instead of weighing passengers maybe they should try drug testing them and checking for illegal substances in their luggage? Might be more to the point.

This begs the question of how 'off his head' this guy was as he was getting on the plane - did he take something prior to flying which just kicked in?

Pandadunks · 10/02/2024 10:19

‘with budget airlines finding a cost-effective balance I do think the pax+baggage weight has some momentum to it.’

it clearly has zero momentum to it - if RyanAir thought they could make more profit this way they’d be doing it. The fact that they aren’t just shows that it’s not viable.

TorringtonDean · 10/02/2024 09:29

The real problem is airlines have crammed in more seats and slashed legroom. It was never an issue in the 1970s when there was space. Maybe they should stop treating passengers like cattle?

Last year I took a couple of flights where there was a big problem with unruly behaviour from passengers. One guy was completely off his head and trying to open a door during landing when we were still in the air. Instead of weighing passengers maybe they should try drug testing them and checking for illegal substances in their luggage? Might be more to the point.

notimagain · 10/02/2024 08:57

@TheHateIsNotGood

with budget airlines finding a cost-effective balance I do think the pax+baggage weight has some momentum to it.

Hi, as I see it it is being cost effective that's the problem here... at most if not all airlines over the years all the pre-departure processes, both those visible to the public and those that are not, have been streamlined to reduce time scales and to reduce cost...we're even down to (almost) self service gates at some airports...

If the idea under any "weigh to fly" scheme is to have an absolutely accurate weight for every single passenger plus their carry on then everybody has to be weighed at the gate on boarding. Reason for that being to any avoid errors with any self declarations of weight on booking😉 or any subterfuge at check in resulting in hand baggage not being weighed, or to account for duty free bought after check-in..)

That's putting an extra step and possibly an extra personpower element into the departure process, so up go costs, and what the LoCos won't stand for is the weighing, or anything associated with it, slowing down boarding and extending turnround times.

I know one should never say never but ATM I'm finding it tough to envisage how any such scheme would work on a Short Haul quick turn with maybe 200'ish passengers....the idea of weighing potentially >400 passengers at the gate during boarding for a Long Haul flight is the stuff of nightmares...

HTH

Pandadunks · 10/02/2024 08:28

‘im 5ft 10 & have never put my legs across my neighbour.’

because that’s not very tall? That average for a U.K. man. I’ve sat beside some very big - as in tall but weight in proportion with that height and their legs and big feet and frame can take up a LOT of space.

Pandadunks · 10/02/2024 08:26

‘Also it seems unfair to get charged a fortune for being a kilos over on a 15kg baggage limit, when someone else can literally be 30kg over a healthy weight.’

Can’t argue with stupid!

someone has to lift your bags, that’s why there are weight restrictions or charges for very heavy luggage - which might take a couple of people or piece of equipment to move safely.

Wasbedeudetetdas · 10/02/2024 06:50

MartinsSpareCalculator · 09/02/2024 14:32

Someone has to lift your bag. The charge is supposed to be a disincentive to overpacking. Nobody has to lift you.

In an accident somebody may well have to lift you, or at least manouvre you.

Wasbedeudetetdas · 10/02/2024 06:47

fonfusedm · 09/02/2024 15:03

I take it you've never been unfortunate enough to sit beside someone who sits effectively diagonally in their seat and protrudes their legs in front of your seat as well as their own?

im 5ft 10 & have never put my legs across my neighbour.

I wouldn't describe your height as especially tall.

TheHateIsNotGood · 10/02/2024 00:22

Forgot to add - weigh-in at 'specialized' check-ins, prior to the gate. And declarations of pax weight to be made at booking, as well as baggage. Any overweight findings at the gate to be subject to the same 'penalty' structures (and more) that some airlines already apply.

Any weight 'margins' are already factored in to the flight calculations.

TheHateIsNotGood · 10/02/2024 00:09

No prob for receiving your perspective NotUAgain (sic.) as I respect your opinion and knowledge. I don't disagree with any of what you say, but.... with budget airlines finding a cost-effective balance I do think the pax+baggage weight has some momentum to it.

With regards to technology, pax+bag scales aren't really beyond the existing tech capabilities; aviation aside, weigh-scales, etc have been around a very long time.

I think the 'Thinair' idea would work well on very busy routes (eg: LGW-AGP).

notimagain · 09/02/2024 22:00

@TheHateIsNotGood

but an idea worth running with - mefinks.

One of the many problems with the whole idea of using real passenger and hand baggage weights is when do you do the weighing? To be genuinely accurate it has to be at the gate (to capture the weight of last minute purchases such as Duty free)...and that opens a whole can of worms, for starters there goes quickish boarding, so bye bye short turnrounds, down goes aircraft utilisation and voila, up go ticket prices

Sorry if I'm teaching you to suck eggs, but for the benefit of others it's maybe worth pointing out that the beauty of the current system - statistically derived, properly validated assumed weights - is that it allows the basics to be done well before the passengers get anywhere near the aircraft, by basics I mean flight planning, fuel planning, fuel loading, performance calculations, load sheet preparation....

If instead you move to using actual weights with weighing at the gate then when does all the planning and performance number crunching get done? After doors close? If that's the case in theory you wouldn't even be able to finish refuelling until the last passenger had boarded.

This is all long winded way of agreeing very much with @Pandadunks previous comment: "Its not needed, it would be prohibitively expensive for airlines, the tech isn’t there to roll it out, no-one is asking for it."

Despite the headlines and column inches all Finnair are doing is their five year crosscheck that the assumed weights they use are valid.