Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Can anyone help me with the maths, nursery/work/life situation? Feel I’m going mad!

62 replies

greenhouseparling · 09/02/2024 07:46

Single parent on 65k. Ex is involved, pays 50% nursery and 200 a month towards general cost. Since returning from Mat leave I’ve been on a 3 day week using annual leave. This runs out in March, when DD turns 18 months.

I am feeling anxious. I don’t like the idea of her there five days a week, I know she’d be fine but I would prefer she wasn’t. I also feel exhausted as it is so not sure I will cope with five day week work and being a single parent.

I can go down to four days a week for six months. Is this financially crazy? I feel annoyed ex doesn’t have to make financial sacrifices and his pension isn’t affected etc but mine would be if I cut my days. Just wondering if others have done this, maybe it’s not as big an impact as I’m thinking? I’m not great with maths….

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Canthelpmyselffromjoiningin · 12/02/2024 09:10

ApiratesaysYarrr · 11/02/2024 12:08

To play devil's advocate, why should the ex pay an increased proportion of nursery to facilitate OP's contact time? If the positions were reversed, and a man was asking a woman to pay 2.5/4 days instead of keeping it 50/50 then people would be up in arms.

Although currently, it sounds like they are both paying 1.5 days/week if the child is in nursery 3 days per week.

Because the child needs childcare whether that's provided by parent or nursery. OP has said ex is a weekend dad so presumably she's doing all the life admin, mental load, pickups and drop-offs and night wakes on top of her job. She's sacrificing 2 days per week annual leave to facilitate them only having 3 days a week childcare costs. The ex should already be paying for half the cost of 5 days a week childcare or taking the financial hit of cutting his hours to provide some of the weekly childcare. Talk about women supporting women on here!

OP if you can afford to and want to go part time, do it. I work 4 days per week because thats what I'm able to do, I love the extra day where soft plays, toddler groups etc are open. Sometimes I put them in nursery an extra day and use my day off to catch up on life admin and or sleep. It's a financial hit to go part time, but it's time with your child you'll never get back. In a few years time they'll be at school 5 days a week. Presumably if dad is having contact at weekends, you won't get even be getting a full weekend with toddler anyway a lot of the time.

ApiratesaysYarrr · 11/02/2024 12:08

AirborneElephant · 09/02/2024 08:22

It may not make as much difference as you think. You’d lose £13k, all of which is taxed at 42% so difference to take home pay would be £7,540, or £628 a month. If you pay at least 2k into your pension you’d then be able to claim child benefit in full which is £100 a month. And you’d save one day childcare a week (make sure your ex continues to pay for 2.5 days, he shouldn’t benefit from you cutting hours), which is probably another £200. So you’d be down about £300 a month. Can you afford that?

To play devil's advocate, why should the ex pay an increased proportion of nursery to facilitate OP's contact time? If the positions were reversed, and a man was asking a woman to pay 2.5/4 days instead of keeping it 50/50 then people would be up in arms.

Although currently, it sounds like they are both paying 1.5 days/week if the child is in nursery 3 days per week.

libbylane · 11/02/2024 11:51

I would definitely take the 4 days for six months while you dc is still little. You have much time to make up pensions etc.

I have a friend with three (7, 4 and 1) and she did 4 days for several months then when she went back to 5 days, she WFH Wedneday she says it makes a massive difference.

I'd do it for 6 months and then look at what you need. The problem with Fridays off is by then you are exhausted. Mid week is much better for sustainability and not always being in recovery.

You mentioned your dd's dad is a weekend dad? Sounds like maybe he takes dd for some time over the weekend? Having Wed off would give you balance in time off in that respect too. As best you can I'd also suggest doing what you can to make life easier before you have to go FT - freeze meals, learn to use a slow cooker, get into a really good routine, declutter. As a FT working Mum those things really make a difference.

Draconis · 11/02/2024 10:58

If you can be comfortable on 4 days a week, I'd do that.

Alwayslookonthebrightside1 · 11/02/2024 10:48

For everyone that works full time, do you find it a nightmare covering x5 days a week for all the holidays, x13 weeks a year? Looking at going back to work but with x2 at infants I really don’t get how I could work full time and we could cover this trying to stretch annual leave etc. no grandparent help. Eldest prob won’t cope well with holiday clubs. Once the nursery years over the childcare issue seems to get a lot harder?!! Or am I being dramatic and it works itself out?

CaramelMac · 11/02/2024 09:14

I do four longs days, you pay for nursery between 8-6 anyway so I work 8:30 - 5:30 with a 30 minute lunch, rather than paying for 8-6 and working 9-5 which means I was paying for 2 hours a day I didn’t need.

Its nice to have the extra day off to go to toddler groups, the library and swimming

Moggi · 11/02/2024 08:08

I have worked full time since my daughter was 2 - I do have a husband who helps but I could still have done it when she was at nursery. She went 5 days a week and she absolutely was fine, thrived in fact. And now she’s at school and is very sociable, finds the 9-3 day a breeze and is loving all her holidays 😂 I would give full time a go - it is a temporary problem and things do have a way of working themselves out… readdress if it really does all go to shit (which it won’t).

Mrscooper13 · 11/02/2024 07:40

Another thought is can you do your job in 4 days otherwise you could still end up working evenings and weekends to keep on top of it?
would your work allow you to drop a day?

Outofideas79 · 11/02/2024 07:33

I work 3 days as a single parent. With childcare costs, the extra tax etc etc. I wouldn't be hugely better off. And I get to-be a present parent, doing most of the 3.30 school pickups and all of the 8.30 drop offs. I have some timento do life admin. Of course I have managed to tailor my lifestyle around this, but my daughter wants for nothing. Days out weekends away, holidays in the UK, camping trips. I honestly don't feel I need anything more. I'm very happy with my lifebat the moment, and I feel a darn sight happier as I'm not running myself ragged trying to do everything.

AllTheChaos · 11/02/2024 00:53

Just a quick note to say, once your child is at school and you aren’t paying nursery, could you manage on £50k a year? If so, salary sacrifice into your pension to get down to that level. Means you will be able to build up your pension again, and you will be eligible for full child benefit (£96 every four weeks for one child). The effective tax rate above £50k is high otherwise as you start to lose child benefit.

Jamandtoastfortea · 10/02/2024 23:16

I’m a single parent (widow) of 3. Similar salary. They were all at nursery at same time and I went down to 4 days at the time. It’s not quite a 20% pay cut because the 5th day would have been at higher rate tax plus there’s not travel costs that day or childcare. But it does make a noticeable difference to your pay packet. However that day off with my 3 was invaluable. I was precious about it. Didn’t do jobs, just child centred activities with just us (no groups or anything as they had all that at nursery). To this day they still talk fondly about our “mummy Thursdays”. Only thing to bear in mind is that work don’t have to allow you to revert back to ft, so that could be tricky and you need to be strict about not working at all on that day (no emails or calls) or suddenly they’ll be getting 5 days work for 4 days pay!

MeridaBrave · 10/02/2024 22:56

Think about 3.5 to 4 days to get salary under £50k, you’ll then get child benefit and the cost won’t be as much as you think as the income over £50k will be taxed at 40%.

could do 4 days and put the bit over £50k into a pension.

TheSeasonalNameChange · 09/02/2024 23:14

Don't forget if you claim you can get interest on it before you have to pay it back too

Superscientist · 09/02/2024 19:52

If your taxable income is under £50k you get full child benefit. If your taxable income is between £50k-60k you get full child benefit but have to fill out a self assessment tax form and pay back some of it.
My partner earns in the low £50k after pensions last year and we effectively paid back 2 months work so were still 10 months up compared to not claiming at all. The form took a couple of hours to do but worth the time!

PutMyFootIn · 09/02/2024 19:52

Yes it's only £100 a month but you would also have the money you'd paid into the pension.

greenhouseparling · 09/02/2024 19:47

If I pay more in my pension to take me down to 49k a year then essentially I could work any days I like and still get child benefit? That’s only 100ish a month though, so 1,200 a year…

OP posts:
TheSeasonalNameChange · 09/02/2024 16:24

@MidnightPatrol it's worse than that, I'd be worse off from 100k to about 130k.

MidnightPatrol · 09/02/2024 15:18

@TheSeasonalNameChange it's even worse over £100k.

  • Loss of personal allowance means a 60% tax rate
  • Loss of tax free childcare
  • Loss of 15 free hours

It creates a 100% tax rate on about £25k of earnings if you have two preschoolers. Crazy.

TheSeasonalNameChange · 09/02/2024 15:14

Your income is taxed at 40% above something like £52k plus the NI and child benefit starts tapering at £50k. This means anything above £50k has the highest likelihood of not being worth it once you take nursery into account because of a high marginal tax rate.

The other calculation is nursery costs. If you can work 4.5 days in 4 or 3.5 days in 3 you're getting an extra half day pay with no extra nursery.

When I made this decision I made a spreadsheet showing cost of nursery and commute for 3,4,and 5 days and take home pay for 3.5, 4.5, and 5 days. You then compare disposable income at the end.

The other lever you can pull is taxable income. If you up your pension contributions or tweak things like salary sacrifice you may be able to get into the child benefit bracket without losing income. You can Google 50k marginal tax rate to get more detail, Bloomberg cover it Here .

Personal rant time: the current tax system is ridiculous for having variable marginal tax rates like this and I get angry every time I think about it.

Earn £50k or £100k? You Need to Read This

Your income tax rate is probably higher than you think.

https://www.bloomberg.com/news/newsletters/2022-11-22/earn-50k-or-100k-you-need-to-read-this?leadSource=uverify%20wall

Chairwoman · 09/02/2024 14:00

Can you not go down to 4 days and start claiming child benefit?

IhaveanewTVnow · 09/02/2024 13:58

Just think about the future for you. Your pension will take a hit. When your child is 18 they won’t remember if they went 3 days or 5 days.

morning could you ask ex to have her one day a week so you both work four days a week. Why shouldn’t men be more involved I agree.

m I’m at the age where I’m looking closely at my pension. Having divorced I wish I had been tougher with my ex pulling his weight re childcare rather than my pension taking the hit.

CloseTheCurtainsPlease · 09/02/2024 13:54

I dropped 5 hours a week and work 4 slightly longer days, with Wednesdays as my NWD. I love it because I never do more than 2 days of work in a row and it's nice having an extra day with my DS. Whilst it was never going to work out that I was financially better off doing it as I get paid more than nursery costs, the drop in money didn't feel quite as bad when factoring in the additional nursery fees being saved. In my case it also helped that I had a pay rise whilst on mat leave which covered most of the gap so the drop wasn't as noticeable.

I think it really boils down to whether you can afford the drop in salary. I'd start by working out what your salary would be if you were to drop x hours, factoring in any changes in tax bracket etc (there are websites which will calculate this for you), and compare to where you would be if you stay FT (ie your current salary minus half the daily nursery cost). Then consider whether you would be happy with the difference.

We've had to tighten our belts a bit to make it work but I am so glad I did it. I love my extra day off a week and can't imagine ever going back to FT now. Only you will know if it's the right decision for you though.

AirborneElephant · 09/02/2024 12:30

greenhouseparling · 09/02/2024 09:49

@TheSeasonalNameChange thanks this is v helpful. So are you saying dropping to 3 days is even better financially? Ex pays 50% nursery. I don’t intend on telling him if I do this as he never asks or even knows the name of DD’s nursery!! He is a weekend dad 🙄

No, I’m afraid not. The higher rate tax threshold is 50k, so if you dropped from 4 to 3 you’d lose another £13k gross, but that would be taxed at 30% (20% income tax and 10% NI), so would lose you £9,100 a year. You wouldn’t gain any more child benefit and I don’t think you’d be eligible for UC, but you would save a further £200 a month childcare. So while the first day off costs you £300 a month, the second would cost a further £560 for a total of £860 worse off.

The most tax effective point in your range is to earn a shade under 50k after pension deduction but before tax, then you make the most of the lower rate band and child benefit. That would be 4 days in your case. But it’s not all about tax efficiency, more about how much slack you have in the budget and what you want to do!

Bobbybobbins · 09/02/2024 12:23

I would drop the day.

Flottie · 09/02/2024 12:20

Don’t think of it as a financial decision more about whether you want to spend time with your baby more.

Also would dropping to four days mean you’ll get child benefit so under £50k? Not sure how it works if your partner earns over this though and you don’t live together?

I am in the same predicament. Going back to work october using annual leave to be three days a week until December and then need to decide in January whether to drop any days. It’s a hard decision.

Swipe left for the next trending thread