Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

How do I tell my this person to have some compassion at a funeral?????

36 replies

inneedofaglowup · 08/02/2024 22:39

Long story short I have an 2 aunts both are just weird. An elderly relative has passed away and we all got together as a family to pay respects. The two aunts come (50s), one is crying more than the deceased's daughters are (they're also in their 50s) and the other is going from person to person telling them how the elderly deceased passed away in her arms and how he'd taken his last breath in her arms. It wasn't in a compassionate loving way, it was more of a boastful rubbing it in to the daughters kind of way.

Mind, one of the daughters was also present with the aunt when her father had passed on however, the other was not in the room when he took his last breath and I find it so hurtful towards her. Like why does this aunt keep repeating his last moments to every person who comes to pay their respects and why is the other crying more than the whole room combined? I must add they have had family rivalry/competition for years. I'd like to say to the aunt to stop repeating the same last moment story to everyone and let the family grieve in peace without her adding her two pence. But how do I say this in a way she doesn't kick a fuss??? (She's that type to get rowdy if she's told what she's doing is not nice or correct and I don't want to add any drama for the grieving family). I find it really frustrating and I just think how must the daughters be feeling.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
inneedofaglowup · 09/02/2024 09:07

Yes agreed, I just know if I did say something they'd react in the most horrendous way possible and victimise themselves. It is obvious to others around that it's too much, but saying nothing is better than something in this situation I suppose. Very sad to see other people having gone through similar experiences. I sympathise with you all and as someone said some people just don't know how to behave.

OP posts:
Whatevershallidowithmylife · 09/02/2024 08:43

Everyone grieves differently and it’s really not your place to say anything unless the daughters have asked you to. I could ignore the aunts being dramatic but I would be seriously pissed off at anyone causing a scene. Different people see different things.

Bedazzling · 09/02/2024 08:27

My Mother always had to be the centre of attention, she was on stage when young until she had children so was very good at it. These sound like mild shenanigans compared to what she used to do. One of my sisters is the same. Christenings, weddings, funerals all of them.

I went to a wedding last year of a friend where a woman who was done up to the absolute eyeballs started wailing in the service with emotion. I ignored as best as I could by not turning my head nor asking her if she was allright after which some did.

Topjoe19 · 09/02/2024 08:09

The behaviour of some people at the funeral of a close family member still causes me upset to this day. They clearly had no feelings, just there to gossip/gawp. Disgusting specimens. I understand.

JustGotToKeepOnKeepingOn · 09/02/2024 08:04

I had a step cousin and his wife skipping around at my dad's funeral telling everyone they were expecting a baby, to 'lighten the mood.'

Some people just have no idea how to behave.

I'm so sorry for your loss and sorry that you had to listen to the performance grieving. Other people at the funeral will have known they were idiots.

Mariposistaaa · 09/02/2024 00:27

saraclara · 08/02/2024 23:13

At my dad's funeral, my brother's teenaged step daughters, who'd barely had anything to do with him, were sat behind my mum and I, sobbing and sniffing (loudly and snottily) most of the way through.

I was irrationally angry with them, as my mum and I (who were stoically trying to hold it together) could barely concentrate on the service for their noise.

Same. My mum and I sat in numb silence at my gran’s funeral in the other side of the aisle to the rest of the family. We did everything for her right until the last second while the rest of the family ‘lived their lives’ and just showed up on the day, way more emotional than us. Of course grief if weird, but still.
I am very good friends with the lovely lady vicar and she said seeing is sat alone was one of the most symbolic and haunting things she has seen in her time in ministry and she had to go and have a little cry in the vestry afterwards.

Gingernaut · 08/02/2024 23:42

inneedofaglowup · 08/02/2024 22:39

Long story short I have an 2 aunts both are just weird. An elderly relative has passed away and we all got together as a family to pay respects. The two aunts come (50s), one is crying more than the deceased's daughters are (they're also in their 50s) and the other is going from person to person telling them how the elderly deceased passed away in her arms and how he'd taken his last breath in her arms. It wasn't in a compassionate loving way, it was more of a boastful rubbing it in to the daughters kind of way.

Mind, one of the daughters was also present with the aunt when her father had passed on however, the other was not in the room when he took his last breath and I find it so hurtful towards her. Like why does this aunt keep repeating his last moments to every person who comes to pay their respects and why is the other crying more than the whole room combined? I must add they have had family rivalry/competition for years. I'd like to say to the aunt to stop repeating the same last moment story to everyone and let the family grieve in peace without her adding her two pence. But how do I say this in a way she doesn't kick a fuss??? (She's that type to get rowdy if she's told what she's doing is not nice or correct and I don't want to add any drama for the grieving family). I find it really frustrating and I just think how must the daughters be feeling.

Long story short, you can't

Performative grief is disgusting and hopefully people will see them for the nutters they are, but unless you somehow prevent them from coming, you're going to get their embarrassing show.

eilaka · 08/02/2024 23:37

Keep away from the weird aunts. Nothing else you can do.

inneedofaglowup · 08/02/2024 23:35

KittySmith1986 · 08/02/2024 23:32

After my mum died, my aunt (mums SIL) went around telling everyone how my mum had died in her arms and that she never thought she’d be able to be with someone when they died etc.. I was there, I was with my mum too when she died, as was my sister. Aunt just had to make it about her and what a ‘ hero’ she’d been. I distanced myself from her.

😔 more or less the same scenario I'm describing. She's not mentioned once how the deceaseds daughter has had to process witnessing her father slip away but has made it about herself (repeatedly). I've swayed to staying quiet and not bringing it up. I will be at hand to support the grieving family.

OP posts:
spanishviola · 08/02/2024 23:34

inneedofaglowup · 08/02/2024 23:30

Spanishviola I have seen them deal with a lot of nasty comments and one upping from the aunts over the years hence the frustration.

I can understand but they are adults and have to deal with it in their own way. What can you do about it unless you tell the aunts directly and would it make any difference? Go and grieve for your relative and ignore them. I hope it goes ok tomorrow.

MorningMinion · 08/02/2024 23:33

You seem to want other people to agree with your hierarchy of grief, and your idea of appropriate behaviour, OP. You don’t know that the dead person’s daughters are resenting the aunts’ visible grief (they might be touched someone else is very obviously sad), and what you see as ‘performance grieving’ might actually come from complex feeling — maybe the aunt who seldom saw the dead person feels bad about that. Maybe the aunt who was there when the person died was very shocked by it, and is imagining her own parents’ deaths. Death throws up all kinds of complicated and often not very nice emotions. You seem to be taking umbrage on behalf of two people who have given you no sign they need you to police other people’s behaviour.

KittySmith1986 · 08/02/2024 23:32

After my mum died, my aunt (mums SIL) went around telling everyone how my mum had died in her arms and that she never thought she’d be able to be with someone when they died etc.. I was there, I was with my mum too when she died, as was my sister. Aunt just had to make it about her and what a ‘ hero’ she’d been. I distanced myself from her.

inneedofaglowup · 08/02/2024 23:30

Spanishviola I have seen them deal with a lot of nasty comments and one upping from the aunts over the years hence the frustration.

OP posts:
inneedofaglowup · 08/02/2024 23:28

rustlerwaiter · 08/02/2024 23:26

Are the daughters particularly bothered?

I have to say, at my own mam's funeral I couldn't tell you what anyone else was or wasn't doing because I was concentrating on myself.

The one who wasn't with her father when he passed, even though she did not say anything when I said to her she does not need to be in the same room constantly listening to the aunt repeat herself of her fathers last moments she agreed to go to another room so she didn't have to listen. The other one also did not say anything but you could see from her expression she was exhausted from hearing it over and over.

OP posts:
spanishviola · 08/02/2024 23:26

inneedofaglowup · 08/02/2024 23:16

No both their own parents are alive. Yes I understand they may have good memories with the deceased but personally I'd want the people most closest to be able to express their grief without feeling if they do someone out there is going to try and top how they're feeling. The daughters have been very composed, the actual funeral is tomorrow and I am dreading the aunts make some stupid comments that are going to upset the deceaseds family. I know they would not say anything back to them so as to not ruin the day for anyone and that just makes me more sad that that's just deal with it whilst these horrid aunts think they'd have scored a point against them.

Also note the deceaseds family have never done anything mildly similar to them hence why I find it particularly nasty.

I’m not suggesting it is good memories necessarily but you can’t police someone else’s grief even if you think it is performative. People can often behave oddly when someone dies. Without going into details, I’ve seen it a few times. The fact that the daughters are composed will stand them in good stead though I’m finding it a bit odd that you are so concerned on their behalf given they are in their 50s and not children.

rustlerwaiter · 08/02/2024 23:26

Are the daughters particularly bothered?

I have to say, at my own mam's funeral I couldn't tell you what anyone else was or wasn't doing because I was concentrating on myself.

inneedofaglowup · 08/02/2024 23:25

BrightLightTonight · 08/02/2024 23:21

With regards to the crying aunt - I am a nightmare at funerals - I always cry, even if I don’t know the person who has died (I don’t go to funerals for fun, but to support my elderly mum)

I am the same with sad songs, books and films. If I am in a situation where tears are expected - I cry.

I don’t do it on purpose, or to try and claim I am more upset than anyone else, but I just cry. When it’s someone who is close to me it’s even worse. Can’t help it - I’m just emotional

I can understand this. I know people who are the same. Sad things can make them very upset and emotional. But believe when I say the aunt isn't in that category. It was very clear she wanted to be seen as someone who was majorly impacted by the death and many people picked up on it. She is not the over emotional type.

OP posts:
BrightLightTonight · 08/02/2024 23:21

With regards to the crying aunt - I am a nightmare at funerals - I always cry, even if I don’t know the person who has died (I don’t go to funerals for fun, but to support my elderly mum)

I am the same with sad songs, books and films. If I am in a situation where tears are expected - I cry.

I don’t do it on purpose, or to try and claim I am more upset than anyone else, but I just cry. When it’s someone who is close to me it’s even worse. Can’t help it - I’m just emotional

inneedofaglowup · 08/02/2024 23:18

saraclara · 08/02/2024 23:13

At my dad's funeral, my brother's teenaged step daughters, who'd barely had anything to do with him, were sat behind my mum and I, sobbing and sniffing (loudly and snottily) most of the way through.

I was irrationally angry with them, as my mum and I (who were stoically trying to hold it together) could barely concentrate on the service for their noise.

I'm so sorry to hear that. And yes you're right it is very triggering. I cannot understand why people can't just have some grace and decorum for others for just a little bit of time to allow them to grieve freely.

OP posts:
inneedofaglowup · 08/02/2024 23:16

spanishviola · 08/02/2024 23:12

Funerals can trigger past grief. Have they lost their own parents? Maybe they weren’t able to be present at another death that was important to them. There might well be something else going on.

No both their own parents are alive. Yes I understand they may have good memories with the deceased but personally I'd want the people most closest to be able to express their grief without feeling if they do someone out there is going to try and top how they're feeling. The daughters have been very composed, the actual funeral is tomorrow and I am dreading the aunts make some stupid comments that are going to upset the deceaseds family. I know they would not say anything back to them so as to not ruin the day for anyone and that just makes me more sad that that's just deal with it whilst these horrid aunts think they'd have scored a point against them.

Also note the deceaseds family have never done anything mildly similar to them hence why I find it particularly nasty.

OP posts:
saraclara · 08/02/2024 23:13

At my dad's funeral, my brother's teenaged step daughters, who'd barely had anything to do with him, were sat behind my mum and I, sobbing and sniffing (loudly and snottily) most of the way through.

I was irrationally angry with them, as my mum and I (who were stoically trying to hold it together) could barely concentrate on the service for their noise.

spanishviola · 08/02/2024 23:12

Funerals can trigger past grief. Have they lost their own parents? Maybe they weren’t able to be present at another death that was important to them. There might well be something else going on.

inneedofaglowup · 08/02/2024 23:09

nocoolnamesleft · 08/02/2024 23:06

How are the aunts related to the deceased? I'd assume the one allowed at the death bed must be a pretty close relative? Obviously if they're 2nd cousins thrice removed it's a bit off.

They are close related. Neices to the deceased. But as mentioned they weren't particularly close and even if they were the behaviour still isn't justified. The daughters have actually been superbly gracious but the aunts are just something else. Point scoring it looks like.

OP posts:
inneedofaglowup · 08/02/2024 23:07

Mangledrake · 08/02/2024 23:03

It's nice of you to notice and be concerned, though. Turn those energies directly to the daughters and speak / listen to them in their grief if you can. They'll remember that.

Yes you're right

OP posts:
nocoolnamesleft · 08/02/2024 23:06

How are the aunts related to the deceased? I'd assume the one allowed at the death bed must be a pretty close relative? Obviously if they're 2nd cousins thrice removed it's a bit off.

Swipe left for the next trending thread