Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

WWYD, Partners Partner Hit My Car

33 replies

WithManyTot · 08/02/2024 20:56

This is a WWYD

My car is 8 years old, and has done almost 100,000 miles, so on paper you might think I shouldn't be precious about it anymore. However it was quite expensive when it was new, I've never scratched it, the manufacturer doesn't make a direct replacement any more, this sort of car should easily do 200,000 miles and at least another 8 years.

This evening DP has returned home to report that their senior business partner swiped it in the car park and has scratched the wing and gouged bumper a bit.

If I'd done the damaged, I chalk it down to 'life' and get all my crafting gear out and do an invisible mend, but it would take weeks. They apparently didn't seem keen to go via insurance on an 'old car', and seem not to have opened with "I'm very sorry, I'd do whatever it takes to rectify this..." I also suspect they might deny the incident if I inform our insurance and then it will be an uninsured loss.
I'm also looking at the loss of the car while it is repaired...
There is also the uncomfortableness of claiming against DP's snr partner.

So WWYD, should I report it to our insurance, or just suck it up and live with it?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Curioushorse · 09/02/2024 17:18

This exact thing happened to me recently. It's a quick, non-issue. My insurance would barely have covered it.

We got quotes of around £350 to have it done properly in a couple of hours. But I'm not that fussed about my car so got a nearly perfect job from a mobile garage guy who came to my work. Paid him £50 and it took him about 45 minutes.

My colleague paid.

Resilience · 09/02/2024 17:11

I know lots of people do it and it's not illegal, but failing to tell your insurance company technically invalidates your policy regardless of whose at fault. Not necessarily a problem if everyone is decent and can afford to cover unforeseen costs. However, if the other party starts quibbling about how much to pay etc, you're shafted if you haven't told your insurer about it within their specified timeframe.

Fortunately, you can use this to diplomatically explain why it's vital you go through insurance as you can say your 'older car' is more vulnerable to unseen structural damage and therefore everything needs to be done properly to ensure everyone's safety in the event of unforeseen costs.

ZeroFucksGivenToday · 09/02/2024 17:09

I'd play absolutely dumb in this and message them saying "as you obviously don't want to go through insurance do you prefer to settle with the garage directly once I have a quote?" Just make it fully assumed that as they've asked not to go through insurance, they must obviously be paying for it direct.

Im one of the ones that's happy not to go through insurance for something small and cosmetic. My neighbour parked behind me once, she'd had her licence 5 weeks when she misjudged pulling away from the kerb, and hit the back of my car. She was sobbing. I was fine to go grab a suitable quote. I dropped it through their door and Her dad popped around with the cash (around £300) the very next day. My bumper was sorted and no drama for anyone.

schloss · 09/02/2024 17:02

I wouldn't straight away go through the insurance, I would state, in writing, exactly what you would like to happen:

Your car repaired at a garage of your choice and a replacement car whilst yours in unavailable.

Clear and concise, then up to the person who damaged your car to say yes or no. If no, then go through the insurance companies.

Universalsnail · 09/02/2024 16:42

I would ask them for the cost of repairs. They can even pay for it out of pocket or they can claim through their insurance. They have offered to rectify it so that should be fine, theyll probably be happy to pay to repair it.

TimetoPour · 09/02/2024 16:31

I would get a couple of quotes for a repair privately and say to the woman it is either that or insurance. Either way, she has damaged your property and it is up to her to fix the issue

Bestinshow22 · 09/02/2024 15:59

If it's minor/cosmetic and you don't want the inconvenience of leaving the car at a garage for repairs you could use a company who will come to you, like Chips Away. I used a similar company who did a good job.

https://www.chipsaway.co.uk/

TinyYellow · 09/02/2024 15:56

Go through insurance, definitely.

Thats what you should do anyway, but especially when the person who damaged your car isn’t falling over themselves to apologise and rectify it.

Kittenkitty · 09/02/2024 15:53

I’d just go with what your partner wants to do to be honest. If it’s only cosmetic I wouldn’t want their work life to suffer.

C00k · 09/02/2024 14:06

@SoupDragon where did the OP write that the woman has offered to rectify it?

KrisAkabusi · 09/02/2024 14:06

tara66 · 09/02/2024 13:11

Absolutely claim against the man who did the damage - if possible without involving your DH. He must be a terrible driver if he cannot park properly. Ask how he did it and why. He doesn't have the right to ask you not to go to insurance. If necessary point out the car is very good for another 8 years or more and not really that ''old'' and we are supposed to not be a society that disposes of stuff to dump on the environment - like a car. I have 2 cars that lasted for 20+ years each. He has the wrong attitude.

Your sexism is showing!

SoupDragon · 09/02/2024 13:59

I'm also looking at the loss of the car while it is repaired...

Get a quote from one of the mobile repair companies. They will fix it on your driveway in less than a day.

There is also the uncomfortableness of claiming against DP's snr partner.

They have offered to rectify it so it shouldn't be too uncomfortable.

araiwa · 09/02/2024 13:52

tara66 · 09/02/2024 13:11

Absolutely claim against the man who did the damage - if possible without involving your DH. He must be a terrible driver if he cannot park properly. Ask how he did it and why. He doesn't have the right to ask you not to go to insurance. If necessary point out the car is very good for another 8 years or more and not really that ''old'' and we are supposed to not be a society that disposes of stuff to dump on the environment - like a car. I have 2 cars that lasted for 20+ years each. He has the wrong attitude.

Outstanding amounts of misogyny and misandry are impacting your comprehension skills

Dillydollydingdong · 09/02/2024 13:29

Once you put a claim in to the insurance company, this will affect your insurance, whether the company has to pay up or not. I notified my insurance company of a bump but it went no further. I didn't claim and neither did the 3rd party. There was also a no fault claim. I wouldn't claim again unless it was unavoidable. My insurance this year has trebled!

Rainbowshit · 09/02/2024 13:12

It'll affect your insurance premium as well as his. Just get a quote from a garage like most normal people do.

Jovacknockowitch · 09/02/2024 13:12

tara66 · 09/02/2024 13:11

Absolutely claim against the man who did the damage - if possible without involving your DH. He must be a terrible driver if he cannot park properly. Ask how he did it and why. He doesn't have the right to ask you not to go to insurance. If necessary point out the car is very good for another 8 years or more and not really that ''old'' and we are supposed to not be a society that disposes of stuff to dump on the environment - like a car. I have 2 cars that lasted for 20+ years each. He has the wrong attitude.

Woman.

kcchiefette · 09/02/2024 13:12

My car recently got hit by an elderly lady who drove in a busy street at the speed of light knocking my wing mirror RIGHT OFF and chipping all my paint from where it bounced off.

This was right before Christmas and I had rang multiple garages who could not take it until after the Christmas period. Couldn't drive the car as the electric wing mirror was too heavy and tape would not have held it on for 2 weeks. They told me it was not road worthy.

I realised a hire car would be £100 per day for 2 weeks, plus wing mirror and paint repair. It was coming in almost £3000 for repairs which I doubted the lady would have paid and I was not about to be out of pocket.

I went through insurance. Definitely dont regret it either. It wasnt my fault, I wasn't about to be inconvenienced or out of pocket for somebody else's carelessness.

Hopefully she learnt a lesson in the process.

tara66 · 09/02/2024 13:11

Absolutely claim against the man who did the damage - if possible without involving your DH. He must be a terrible driver if he cannot park properly. Ask how he did it and why. He doesn't have the right to ask you not to go to insurance. If necessary point out the car is very good for another 8 years or more and not really that ''old'' and we are supposed to not be a society that disposes of stuff to dump on the environment - like a car. I have 2 cars that lasted for 20+ years each. He has the wrong attitude.

purplehotdogs · 09/02/2024 13:10

They need to pay one way or another, so you can either just go through the insurance (assuming you have their reg) and they can sort it, or ask them if they would prefer another route. Insurance will be cheapest though.

Maybe check to see if the car park has footage of them swiping your car first, so there's no deniability from them though.

DisappearingGirl · 09/02/2024 13:10

bestbefore · 08/02/2024 21:02

I'd just get a cost for the repair from a local guy and let him know the cost, ask if he's happy to settle directly with the repairer

I would suggest the above too. We've done this 3 times over the years (twice the other driver's fault, once my fault, all v minor bumps in old ish cars). Person at fault paid the garage directly.

nononocontact · 09/02/2024 13:05

I would get a quote from a garage and ask for the money. If it doesn’t appear, then I’d claim. I wouldn’t claim in the first instance to avoid my insurance going up. Also presumably a senior partner will be able to afford it so no harm in sending on the garage quote.

Dotjones · 09/02/2024 11:34

You have to inform your insurer even if you don't formally claim through them. Once your car has been damaged once you're statistically more likely to have it damaged again - even if you weren't driving it and it wasn't your fault. You need to inform the insurer so they can adjust your premium.

Hatty65 · 09/02/2024 10:58

I'd make sympathetic noises and say, 'Sorry, I'll need to inform my insurance company I'm afraid'.

If you think they will deny it - how do they expect your DP to keep working for them? Or do they think your DP will just quietly forget about it?

Whatevershallidowithmylife · 09/02/2024 10:52

Claim on insurance- much easier and keeps things right.

Hairspray123 · 09/02/2024 10:51

OP dont claim on insurance, get a quote for the work first, if they will just pay it surely thats so much better all round.

If you claim on insurance, regardless of fault it will alter your premiums, trust me been there done that!

Obviously if they are completely being asses and refusing to pay way up if its worth still claiming or just payung to get it repaired.

All else fails then claim!!!