Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think my baby shouldn’t be in this nursery room?! Or am I being precious?

112 replies

Hippan · 08/02/2024 19:35

DD is fifteen months (last week). She is quite big but can’t walk yet. I was told when joining the nursery that she would be in a room for 8-9 months to 16-18 month olds, depending on her physical development. Every day I have collected her in the last 2 weeks she has been in the room up which is 16-18 months to 24 months. AIBU to think this is wrong? She is still crawling around two years olds above her?

OP posts:
Loonyloopylupin · 09/02/2024 09:59

IME nurseries are generally obsessed with moving them to the "next stage" as quickly as possible.

Speaks to the wider issue of childhood being seen as a race imo.

Superduper02 · 09/02/2024 09:58

I was in the same situation. My DD wasn't walking yet but all of her baby room were moving into the next class (where all children could walk and run). They moved her so she wouldn't be left behind and she was the eldest in the bay room.. I was worried she would be trampled etc but actually the opposite happened. She became really confident at asserting physical boundaries with the faster kids and began walking really quickly afterwards. It is scary for us. I would still voice my concerns so that the nursery are aware this is something you want them to keep an eye on.

Kerfuffleplunk · 09/02/2024 09:49

Mine didn't walk 'til 22 months (bottom shuffler)and i never even thought about this as a problem! ....but i rejected one (ofsted outstanding rated) nursery because when i turned up for a visit the staff member who opened the door then disappeared upstairs to fetch someone and i found a young toddler wandering around downstairs on her own smeared with poo. Staff ratios and how they balance the needs of the kids ie. mobility versus appropriate age stimulation/aactivites are probably more important.

celticprincess · 09/02/2024 09:48

It may also be to do with ratios. They change with age.

celticprincess · 09/02/2024 09:48

At 15 months she is much younger than a 2 year old but she is also much older than an 8-9 month old. A somewhere in between. Maybe they want her in the walking room so she can watch other toddlers who can walk so she can maybe try copying? Other than walking she’s probably closer to the older ones though for the kids on things on offer to play with.

Panda368 · 09/02/2024 09:39

Both my DS were moved rooms early. the eldest was moved because he was "a bit of a bulldozer" and had been walking / running from 12 months. I think he was moved up from the nurserys older baby room to the toddler room.

DS 2 was moved up at 14 months before he could walk because "he liked sitting on the younger babies"

Its possibly the case that your daughter can more than easily hold her own even with children who are older and on paper look a bit more competent.

It might be the case that your nursery have taken in a few very young babies and its more appropriate for her to be with bigger kids than for the young babies to be with her. Nurserys have to juggle safety for all children and I really wouldn't worry too much about it. As long as she is happy and safe which she will be if the ratios are working she will be fine.

user1492757084 · 09/02/2024 08:52

In a family setting there would be children about a year or two older playing near a crawling baby. It is not that far of natural or normal. Perhaps being the only baby the carer is free to pay her extra attention easily.
Like they say, your baby might gravitate towards that space and be happier.

You need to ask to find the answer.

Debtfreegoals · 09/02/2024 07:52

Sometimes they merge the children towards the end of the day

Moonlaserbearwolf · 09/02/2024 07:44

Our nursery took children between 6 months-3yrs. It was small, so there were usually about 15 children spread across 3 rooms with about 5 adults. Never crossed my mind to worry about my child when she was smaller - she was a late walker. It was like a big family and lovely that the children were all ages. Just chat with the staff. The important thing is that your child is safe.

My elder daughter went to a bigger nursery with split ages. Agree with others that it’s normal to combine ages at the end of a day. As child are picked up, it makes sense to send some staff home and have children in one room with a few staff.

Neurodiversitydoctor · 09/02/2024 07:41

Castlereagh · 08/02/2024 20:14

Hmm when my kids were young nurseries used to tell parents their kids were really advanced so they could move them up to the toddler room early...spoiler: the babies weren't advanced at all and nurseries were trying to save staff. , I'd be asking lots of questions like what about safe sleeping and about the ratios and how closely their eating is monitored e.g. likelihood of choking at 15 months is quite different to two. But prob all the 2 year olds are so advanced they are in the preschool room anyway...

Liklihood of choking at 15m ? Really ? As long as children are sat up at a table to eat with an adult present the chance of choking is miniscule. What are you talking about ?

Highlighta · 09/02/2024 07:34

I do think you are being a bit precious OP.

As for the Google screenshot of babies not interacting, just because you are able to screenshot something that you believe, doesn't make it so. I am sure there are plenty of screenshots I could add saying that babies do interact below this age. Of course they interact. Ok they aren't making cups of tea for each other, but they are interacting.

Helenahatstand · 09/02/2024 07:24

MariaVT65 · 09/02/2024 02:32

YABU

I agree with the previous points made:

-Most nurseries including mine have the age range as 0-2.
-This means that in a common setting, there would be a mix of walking and non-walking children.

My son didn’t walk until he turned 2 due to hypermobility, but no way would I have wanted him stuck the baby room forever. It’s also very common to move kids up slightly early. It also depends on when they have space.

Yes the fact many nurseries are 0-2 anyway really hadn't been acknowledged by the OP or some pps.

dancinginthewind · 09/02/2024 06:20

I had exactly this worry 12 years or so ago when DC1 was in the same position. After that first room move, I looked forward to room moves as she would have a massive developmental leap each time. With her next room move around her second birthday, she went from putting a couple of words together to sentences within days. It was remarkable.
The other thing I learned was that nurseries are juggling the needs of all of the DC who attend and that it can be quite difficult to do this. Children are born throughout the year & start nursery at different ages due to when parents return to work. There is only ever one real departure point though which is over the summer before they start school so there will be a real exodus at that point. So you've got a cohort in the pre-school room who aren't going anywhere and then you've got new babies joining and you're having to balance their needs with the existing babies & toddlers across the rooms that you have,
Finally, our nursery often used to merge rooms after tea. When it was DC1, I was terrified about her in with these huge kids who to me seemed to be going around like marauding pirates. Roll on two years to the summer after DC2 joined and the whole nursery ended up together in the afternoons and i thought it was lovely that they were spending time together at nursery and DC1 loved telling me what DC2 had been doing, particularly on the day when our neighbour's baby was also there.

Natsku · 09/02/2024 06:19

I wouldn't be concerned, I think its good to mix the ages as the little ones learn from the older ones and the older ones learn to be gentle with the little ones. At my son's nursery they have from 1-3/4 (depending on when their 4th birthday is) in the same group, there were crawlers there when my son was in the class with no issues. At my daughter's nursery they had them in the same group from 1-6 (live abroad, nursery goes to age 6 here)

Bournetilly · 09/02/2024 05:57

The room only goes up to 24 months so she’s not going to be in the room with many 2 year olds. I was always happy when mine moved up as they learn new skills.

Also she is probably a lot bigger than some of the babies if they are only 8/9 months old, she could be crawling over them.

MariaVT65 · 09/02/2024 02:32

YABU

I agree with the previous points made:

-Most nurseries including mine have the age range as 0-2.
-This means that in a common setting, there would be a mix of walking and non-walking children.

My son didn’t walk until he turned 2 due to hypermobility, but no way would I have wanted him stuck the baby room forever. It’s also very common to move kids up slightly early. It also depends on when they have space.

TomeTome · 09/02/2024 01:09

Maybe there’s a biter in her room so they are giving her a break. Ask the nursery, they will explain?

Waffle19 · 09/02/2024 01:02

I think I would have worried about this with my first so I do understand where you’re coming from. But now seeing the way my youngest DS interacts with my oldest DS and the positive impact on their relationship with each other then it wouldn’t bother me. The only thing that I’d be slightly concerned about is that the nursery haven’t mentioned it, ours will discuss a room change in advance and do some settling in periods. But like others have said if they’re just merging them later on in the day that’s different.

thebestinterest · 09/02/2024 00:54

Hippan · 08/02/2024 19:35

DD is fifteen months (last week). She is quite big but can’t walk yet. I was told when joining the nursery that she would be in a room for 8-9 months to 16-18 month olds, depending on her physical development. Every day I have collected her in the last 2 weeks she has been in the room up which is 16-18 months to 24 months. AIBU to think this is wrong? She is still crawling around two years olds above her?

I’d be happy about that! Why would you want her with 8-9 month olds? She’s 15 months…

Emmelina · 09/02/2024 00:05

Kids are often merged at the end of the day as numbers go down, it frees up staff to write up reports/refresh training etc. But you will often have a crossover period around the age barriers as she acclimatises to the next room and carers. In just a few weeks it’ll be the room she’s in always, and if they say she enjoys it there then she’s mentally ready to go up if not quite physically.

*edited for typo

ColleenDonaghy · 08/02/2024 23:29

Rycbar · 08/02/2024 23:09

I am an early years teacher and I have seen many children before their second birthday making bonds with other children. They get excited to see each other and will interact.

It was our experience too. Both girls loved socialising with the other babies, but DC1 in particular formed a real friendship with a little boy when they were about 18 months that stuck around until they started school and alas the class very quickly split down boy/girl lines. I was sceptical but the room lead said she'd seen it a few times and theirs was a definite friendship. It was very sweet.

Rycbar · 08/02/2024 23:09

HomeEdMom · 08/02/2024 20:08

@MamaToABeautifulBoy no they don’t. Google it.

I am an early years teacher and I have seen many children before their second birthday making bonds with other children. They get excited to see each other and will interact.

Noseybookworm · 08/02/2024 22:29

Maybe the nursery are giving your DD time in there to encourage her to walk?

Sellingbedtime · 08/02/2024 22:19

Your going to worry about your child, that's part of being a mum 🙂
Whose to say she won't get pushed over by another child when she is able to walk? Bumps and accidents are inevitable. Best bet is to talk to her assigned key person for some reassurance.
My youngest is nearly 18 months and I know they mingle him in with the other older children as the day goes on and the numbers thin out. Regardless of the room they still need to have the correct ratio of children to adult so be confident that there is someone always keeping a close eye.

Swipe left for the next trending thread