Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

DD20 says she would still live with me if I had given her that option

137 replies

Mastmw7g · 08/02/2024 16:55

I want to ask if I was unreasonable for allowing the way DH encouraged her to move out, but that's probably an unreasonable thing to ask. I felt sometimes like he was almost manipulating her. So it was her choice, but she was very hesitant to make that choice.

Living with her was awful. It wasn't good for my younger children, so I know it was the best choice for the rest of us. But I doubt it was the best choice for her. I've had this surge of anxiety since she moved out and even started therapy. It's possible I'm codependent. Why else would I worry about her when I should be sleeping?

Regardless, yesterday I went over her home and she said she would still live with me if I had given her that option. In therapy I was asked if she chose to leave or I made her leave and I truthfully didn't know the answer, but I suppose now I do. I made her leave because she felt she had no option to stay. Now I'm still distracted from everything I do because I'm nervous and worried for her, but I also feel deep guilt for making her fly before she was ready to leave the nest.

OP posts:
Mastmw7g · 11/02/2024 11:30

Tumbleweed101 · 11/02/2024 10:55

I moved out at 20yr. It was hard at times financially but the independence was good and you learn to be resourceful. I was clashing a bit with my mum at the time (not in a bad way just over housework etc) and we both needed our own space.

I’ve reached that point with my 23yr daughter now in that we both need our own homes to do things the way we want. Only problem is cost of living and her finding a place she can afford by herself.

Yes, I worry a lot about the cost of living and whether she can afford her place without my help. She makes enough to cover bills, but there's not much leftover for food, getting around, and going out.

OP posts:
Mastmw7g · 11/02/2024 11:27

Cogsie · 09/02/2024 08:57

"She made threats and said she was going to be violent" and what was your response to this? Because there are two routes, one is usually to tell them not to do that but the other is to say let's follow that up then and see where it would lead. It is a thing children and teens especially do, they just sit with that thought and don't think through the consequences of her actions. So follow that thought, the police would be called, she would be arrested for criminal damage or assault or both. What could that lead to? Inability to keep her job or get jobs in the future? Being known for being violent would she keep any friends? It is a very immature response to a situation.

I wonder how many times there were consequences to her behaviour whilst she was living at home because now she isn't living at home, has said she would move back but hasn't taken ownership of her actions that led to to being asked to leave which was absolutely the right thing to do. You cannot parent out of fear of her behaviour, no one benefitted from her living at home, not you, not your other children.

What was your response when she said she would live back at home? Because again it seems you didn't have that hard conversation where you would remind her of her behaviour whilst there. She has been allowed to scream, cry, explode and this is the consequence now. Of course it is hard going home to an empty house, she could choose to flat share for company. I would encourage her to get therapy and if that is something you can help her with financially I would do it. She seems angry and sad, this hasn't come from moving out this appears to be her default setting so maybe she would like to unpick that to feel better.

I didn't really have a response to her making threats and saying she was going to be violent. I exchanged a look with my husband and we stayed silent while she said these things. Afterwards I mentioned to her that it can be hard to be a worker in one of these offices because you get the full force of everyone's anger when things are badly managed by people above you. She appeared to listen.

I'll remember I cannot parent out of fear. That's a very good thing for me to read, and useful. I just listened when she said she would still live with me if I'd given her that option. I was in her home and the rest of my family wasn't there, so I could have talked about her behaviors without fear of her reaction causing a bad environment for the younger children to deal with. So maybe that was a missed opportunity.

I helped her find a therapist yesterday and we'll continue to pay for that. I wouldn't want a situation where the cost deters her from seeking treatment.

OP posts:
Mastmw7g · 11/02/2024 11:12

Spanglemum75 · 08/02/2024 17:46

Does she have a diagnosis of anything? Is it supported accommodation? She sounds like someone I know with a personality disorder. I think you've had some good advice here about maintaining your relationship whilst helping her to become more independent.

She does have diagnoses from when she was younger for things like depression and anxiety. I asked her if she wanted to see someone other than a therapist for diagnostic purposes because it may help with her therapy if she learns she's dealing with anything else, like a personality disorder. She doesn't see the point because she doesn't think she has a personality disorder. She is uncomfortable taking medication, so she may just have untreated depression and anxiety.

OP posts:
Mastmw7g · 11/02/2024 11:06

pickledandpuzzled · 08/02/2024 17:37

I would emphasise the maturity that comes with looking after yourself, that you learn things living alone that never occur to you when you live with family. Like being appreciative and not making people around you uncomfortable.

Reassure her she is always your daughter wherever she lives, and you will always support her as best you are able.

(And make a special effort to spend time with her without the younger siblings- I hear a bit of jealousy there, from her. She’s desperate to keep SD on side, and punishing you for having more children leaving her feeling insecure. Obviously just a guess, but that’s how it sounds)

I'll do that. Right now I've asked her on her days off from work if she wants me to bring food over and share a meal with her. I come alone, so it's just the two of us. She was too busy this last time and I saw that as a positive thing because she'd met someone to spend time with and had made plans. I'll continue trying to make a weekly plan with her.

OP posts:
DaffodilsAlready · 11/02/2024 11:05

itsmyp4rty · 08/02/2024 17:36

I'd say she has very low self esteem - that's why she was so difficult to live with and what was making her cry and explode when people said negative things to or about her. She didn't feel safe or loved at your house for whatever reason. She needed clear consistent boundaries but instead had a step father who never said no to her and then manipulated her into leaving when he'd had enough.

I feel really bad for her.

Yes, I would tend to agree with this. The relationship with her stepfather sounds quite odd, tbh, she prefers him over you, asks him to accompany her to the rent company office and to help her choose a therapist, and yet he was the one who managed her out the family home when he had had enough of her behaviour, despite her having MH diagnoses.

Where is her dad in the picture? Because it looks a bit like she has moved out, so you, your husband and the children of this partnership can have a nice family home, whilst she is elsewhere.

Of course, on the other hand, it is pretty normal for twenty year olds to live independently, not least when they go to university or start working and earning. So to that extent, it is a life step. It sounds like one with lots of baggage that hasn’t been handled very well, though. Question is whether DH would expect his own DC to move out at that age.

Mastmw7g · 11/02/2024 11:01

itsmyp4rty · 08/02/2024 17:36

I'd say she has very low self esteem - that's why she was so difficult to live with and what was making her cry and explode when people said negative things to or about her. She didn't feel safe or loved at your house for whatever reason. She needed clear consistent boundaries but instead had a step father who never said no to her and then manipulated her into leaving when he'd had enough.

I feel really bad for her.

She has a high opinion of the way she looks and thinks the has a lot of empathy, though sometimes I think she confuses the sensitivity she feels for herself with empathy for others. Yesterday I helped her choose a therapist and she had to select what she needed to work on in therapy and she did not want to choose self esteem because she said nothing is wrong with her self esteem. Her biggest complaint seems to be that my husband always did everything for her, but she said this means he should continue to do things for her instead of expecting her to do them herself.

OP posts:
Tumbleweed101 · 11/02/2024 10:55

I moved out at 20yr. It was hard at times financially but the independence was good and you learn to be resourceful. I was clashing a bit with my mum at the time (not in a bad way just over housework etc) and we both needed our own space.

I’ve reached that point with my 23yr daughter now in that we both need our own homes to do things the way we want. Only problem is cost of living and her finding a place she can afford by herself.

Mastmw7g · 11/02/2024 10:55

helpfulperson · 08/02/2024 17:29

You have other posts about her haven't you? Whether she chose to leave or felt she had to living at home isn't making her or the rest of the family happy and she needs to stay away. You can support her when she lives elsewhere.

Yes, I have certainly posted about her before. I've started therapy myself since then. I need to learn strategies for dealing with the anxiety I feel since she moved out. It wouldn't be fair to her if my worrying caused her greater worry.

OP posts:
Mastmw7g · 11/02/2024 10:51

Ktime · 08/02/2024 17:26

The more you post the more I think don't move her back in.

You made the right decision. Is she working?

She has a job, but isn't making as much money as she would like. She's been working there almost a month and seems to hate it. It's hard to determine if her complaints are because the job is not a good fit for her or she would have such difficulties no matter where she works.

OP posts:
Mastmw7g · 11/02/2024 10:48

hiredandsqueak · 08/02/2024 17:23

I think it can be difficult. My youngest is 20 and stll lives at home she seems very young to me still. My others left when they were ready, it was always their choice. Having said that mine are easy to live with so I never felt the need to push them to move out. I am sure step parents and younger siblings make things more complicated though.

Yes, I need to be mindful of the fact that blended families have specific challenges I put on her. I know she has a good relationship with my husband, but that doesn't mean that it's easy to adjust her behavior to make it appropriate to be around small children after a hard work week.

OP posts:
Mastmw7g · 11/02/2024 10:43

Cogsie · 08/02/2024 17:22

I think from your limited posts living with her was awful, she was exploding at everyone, upsetting her younger siblings, you were on eggshells, this is no way to live.

However, you don't know what you have until you lose it, she may now be realising that being at home was much easier than being fully independent. It doesn't mean she should move back in. It might also mean she is reflecting on her behaviour that saw her leave her home. Key question, has she ever apologised for her behaviour?

Ds1 is absolutely lovely, he is away at uni, very capable but he does say it is lovely to come home for uni holidays and have someone else cook some of the meals, do the food shopping and his laundry. I don't work so this is all very easy for me to do and when he is away at uni he does all these things, eats well, cooks from scratch sort of person. But he says it is the mental load of meal planning, scheduling in haircuts etc that sound really trivial but all add up as well as doing an intense degree. He is in his final year and cannot wait to come home.

Edited

I don't know if she's ever apologised for her behavior. Yesterday we had a conflict because she was using inappropriate language around her siblings and I asked her to instead wait until she was away from them to use that language and this upset her. She didn't apologise and I walked away. But earlier in the day she'd messaged me that she wanted to quit her job because she hates it and asked for my help finding a new job, and said she'd love to look over her prospects with me after work. So I did research and was ready to do that. Then she told me she wasn't in the mood after having a bad week and a half, so I carefully told her my time and effort was valuable and deserved to be valued. While she didn't outright apologise, she said I deserve to be valued. So I think that exchange was successful.

Your son sounds lovely. I'm jealous.

OP posts:
Cogsie · 09/02/2024 08:57

"She made threats and said she was going to be violent" and what was your response to this? Because there are two routes, one is usually to tell them not to do that but the other is to say let's follow that up then and see where it would lead. It is a thing children and teens especially do, they just sit with that thought and don't think through the consequences of her actions. So follow that thought, the police would be called, she would be arrested for criminal damage or assault or both. What could that lead to? Inability to keep her job or get jobs in the future? Being known for being violent would she keep any friends? It is a very immature response to a situation.

I wonder how many times there were consequences to her behaviour whilst she was living at home because now she isn't living at home, has said she would move back but hasn't taken ownership of her actions that led to to being asked to leave which was absolutely the right thing to do. You cannot parent out of fear of her behaviour, no one benefitted from her living at home, not you, not your other children.

What was your response when she said she would live back at home? Because again it seems you didn't have that hard conversation where you would remind her of her behaviour whilst there. She has been allowed to scream, cry, explode and this is the consequence now. Of course it is hard going home to an empty house, she could choose to flat share for company. I would encourage her to get therapy and if that is something you can help her with financially I would do it. She seems angry and sad, this hasn't come from moving out this appears to be her default setting so maybe she would like to unpick that to feel better.

Isitovernow123 · 08/02/2024 21:05

Some people you can live with and some you can’t. Don’t feel guilty for providing a better place for you and your family to live in - that amount of negativity in a home is not good for anyone.

saltinesandcoffeecups · 08/02/2024 18:57

Mastmw7g · 08/02/2024 17:56

She says she's unhappy. But I don't believe she was happy living with us, either. She does have a good time when she goes out, but then she said it's a letdown when she comes home. Financially, she makes enough to pay her bills, but I worry she doesn't have enough for food or to get around, especially since I know she believes in going out and spending money to make herself feel happy.

I am still in therapy. I just started, so I'm at a point where it makes me feel worse. I think I need to get through this part before I can learn strategies to feel better.

So she’s in the same boat as every just starting out young adult.

Stick with the therapy… I think it will help you recalibrate. It’s normal to worry, it’s normal to feel sad if they’re struggling a bit. It’s not normal or healthy for you to feel guilty for others decisions nor is healthy for you to tie yourself up in knots because of her feelings.

A wise person once told me “You don’t own anyone else’s issues” if she’s unhappy with something in her life it she owns those feelings and the responsibility to make changes.

You and your DH sound like you are giving normal physical support to an adult at her stage of life. That’s really a positive thing. You need to make sure you’re also giving her the emotional space to mature. That comes with a bit of bad decision making, frustration, and yes sadness. It also comes with excitement, self satisfaction, and enjoyment. All young adults need a healthy amount of good and not so good to grow

Mastmw7g · 08/02/2024 18:16

@Ktime She has mental health diagnoses from when she was younger, but I do wonder if she has a personality disorder or something similar. She hasn't seen a psychiatrist since becoming an adult, but she is open to therapy. She recently said she would like DH to help her choose a new therapist.

OP posts:
Mastmw7g · 08/02/2024 17:56

saltinesandcoffeecups · 08/02/2024 17:15

I guess the real question is how is she doing on her own? You didn’t mention anything is bad about her current situation so can’t you just leave her comment on the table so to speak. I’m sure she was comfortable living with the family. You all bent backwards for her… what’s not to love from her perspective.

Just because she expressed her wishes doesn’t mean you have to pick them up and make them your own. Maybe if you’re still in therapy use this as a discussion topic.

She says she's unhappy. But I don't believe she was happy living with us, either. She does have a good time when she goes out, but then she said it's a letdown when she comes home. Financially, she makes enough to pay her bills, but I worry she doesn't have enough for food or to get around, especially since I know she believes in going out and spending money to make herself feel happy.

I am still in therapy. I just started, so I'm at a point where it makes me feel worse. I think I need to get through this part before I can learn strategies to feel better.

OP posts:
sprigatito · 08/02/2024 17:52

itsmyp4rty · 08/02/2024 17:36

I'd say she has very low self esteem - that's why she was so difficult to live with and what was making her cry and explode when people said negative things to or about her. She didn't feel safe or loved at your house for whatever reason. She needed clear consistent boundaries but instead had a step father who never said no to her and then manipulated her into leaving when he'd had enough.

I feel really bad for her.

I agree. She sounds vulnerable and in need of mental health support to me. My 19yo can be hard work sometimes, because he's mentally unwell and distressed a lot of the time. The thought of him out on his own in his current state is terrifying. I do look forward to the day he can move on, but not until he's stable and well enough to manage independently.

OP what's done is done, but I would be trying to offer as much support as possible, and accepting that the way she was managed out of her home has probably made her mental health problems worse. You may have to hear some difficult things if you want an honest relationship with her in the future.

Foxesandsquirrels · 08/02/2024 17:51

Ok well from your updates, there's nothing you can do. It may help you to think more of your other kids. Remind yourself that if you hadn't done this, you would feel guilty for forcing them to grow up around the environment she was causing. Even if she had a diagnosis, she sounds typical enough to be independent, so she will have to learn, and life does that quickly once you live alone. She will learn that you get further with kindness. Or she won't. Some people are unfortunately just like this. It's not your fault.

It sounds like you did the right thing getting her out. I think you're overthinking it and your DH needs to establish some healthy boundaries with her, as him appeasing her is not helping her at all. It's also teaching her that she can disrespect you and he does nothing.

Spanglemum75 · 08/02/2024 17:46

Does she have a diagnosis of anything? Is it supported accommodation? She sounds like someone I know with a personality disorder. I think you've had some good advice here about maintaining your relationship whilst helping her to become more independent.

Mishmaj · 08/02/2024 17:45

She is an adult. She is unpleasant to live with. Don’t beat yourself up over it all. Sounds like she needs to figure it out for herself.
Yes I probably sound a bit harsh but why do we infantilise grown adults? I would expect anyone aged 20 to be learning from their own mistakes, not being pandered to by parents who are willing to be treated with disrespect.
That said, I think pickled’s approach above is spot on, and will help her to figure it out herself whilst feeling supported.

pickledandpuzzled · 08/02/2024 17:37

I would emphasise the maturity that comes with looking after yourself, that you learn things living alone that never occur to you when you live with family. Like being appreciative and not making people around you uncomfortable.

Reassure her she is always your daughter wherever she lives, and you will always support her as best you are able.

(And make a special effort to spend time with her without the younger siblings- I hear a bit of jealousy there, from her. She’s desperate to keep SD on side, and punishing you for having more children leaving her feeling insecure. Obviously just a guess, but that’s how it sounds)

itsmyp4rty · 08/02/2024 17:36

I'd say she has very low self esteem - that's why she was so difficult to live with and what was making her cry and explode when people said negative things to or about her. She didn't feel safe or loved at your house for whatever reason. She needed clear consistent boundaries but instead had a step father who never said no to her and then manipulated her into leaving when he'd had enough.

I feel really bad for her.

Mastmw7g · 08/02/2024 17:33

@SeaBlueSky I don't think anyone can assess whether I'm unreasonable. I wanted to ask the question, but realized what was unreasonable was asking it in the first place.

OP posts:
Ash099 · 08/02/2024 17:30

I think you know she had to move out as it wasn't working with siblings etc. However it is okay to feel guilty, and feel that you could have done something different. However it is very hard to change a person, and when it is your child, it hurts a lot. But you know you did everything you could, and some kids are just hard.

helpfulperson · 08/02/2024 17:29

You have other posts about her haven't you? Whether she chose to leave or felt she had to living at home isn't making her or the rest of the family happy and she needs to stay away. You can support her when she lives elsewhere.