Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

DD20 says she would still live with me if I had given her that option

137 replies

Mastmw7g · 08/02/2024 16:55

I want to ask if I was unreasonable for allowing the way DH encouraged her to move out, but that's probably an unreasonable thing to ask. I felt sometimes like he was almost manipulating her. So it was her choice, but she was very hesitant to make that choice.

Living with her was awful. It wasn't good for my younger children, so I know it was the best choice for the rest of us. But I doubt it was the best choice for her. I've had this surge of anxiety since she moved out and even started therapy. It's possible I'm codependent. Why else would I worry about her when I should be sleeping?

Regardless, yesterday I went over her home and she said she would still live with me if I had given her that option. In therapy I was asked if she chose to leave or I made her leave and I truthfully didn't know the answer, but I suppose now I do. I made her leave because she felt she had no option to stay. Now I'm still distracted from everything I do because I'm nervous and worried for her, but I also feel deep guilt for making her fly before she was ready to leave the nest.

OP posts:
HalebiHabibti · 16/02/2024 09:51

Do you have any sons OP? It is a bit odd that he has decided girls need so much babying (only to be suddenly dropped when he's had enough it seems).

Mastmw7g · 16/02/2024 09:46

@AdriftAbroad1 I don't think I would say my husband is controlling because he has so much fear of conflict. I understand why you'd feel sorry for my daughter, though. I have had so much anger in the past that it seems to kind to call myself passive. But I'll take note of that and make an effort to take a more active role.

OP posts:
SecondUsername4me · 16/02/2024 09:39

Did she not have her own bedroom furniture to take with her when she moved?

Mastmw7g · 16/02/2024 09:38

@Nssdth You're right that it's important to consider the underlying factors contributing to a person's behavior rather than labeling them as "bad." I need to reflect on influences before I can understand and address the root causes of her behavior. I really am doing my best to be honest in therapy and self-reflect, even when it's uncomfortable. I know I need to establish boundaries, too. I just want them to be more compassionate than just cutting her off without having given her the foundation to be independent.

OP posts:
Ktime · 16/02/2024 09:31

Mastmw7g · 15/02/2024 13:26

It's difficult for me to give examples. But he helped her with school work no matter how old she was, he wouldn't risk letting her fail. He would drive her around at all hours even when she was asking so that she didn't have to remain sober. If she didn't eat, she would stand in front of him and show him that her hand was shaking from not having eaten and he would immediately make her food, whatever she asked for. She would ask for a different meal than the rest of us were having and he'd cook that for her or leave to go pick up what she wanted. If she was unhappy he would take her out and get whatever treat she wanted to eat. When she refused to portion out food from serving dishes he would do that for her. He cut her meat for her until she was a teenager. I know I'm talking too much about food, but those are the first examples I've thought of. My youngest daughter would always get upset because she said having her sister here meant her dad was always gone getting her things or taking her places.

You're right that I would be unreasonable if I didn't support her if she decided to move in with her father's family. I wasn't thinking of being unsupportive, it's just not something I want and I would feel sad with that outcome.

No wonder you're resentful, your dh has set up your dd to fail.

Is there a reason why he made her to reliant on him? Do you have other dc that prefer you to him?

Mastmw7g · 16/02/2024 09:30

@HalebiHabibti I used to think he was just over compensating for being a stepparent, but I see many of the same behaviors around food with him in his interactions with our daughter together around food. So this just may be how he treats girls.

OP posts:
Mastmw7g · 16/02/2024 09:25

@anon2022anon It sounds like you've handled similar situations with your own daughter quite effectively, setting boundaries while still offering support and guidance when needed. Encouraging independence and responsibility is crucial at that age, and it's understandable to expect them to take initiative in solving their own issues. Boundaries can indeed be beneficial in fostering growth and self-reliance. Your approach of offering assistance with job hunting while also expecting her to take the lead is a balanced way to encourage her to take ownership of her choices and actions. And emphasizing the importance of making decisions, even if they're not perfect, is a valuable lesson in adulthood. And it sounds like I need to stop worrying so much about furniture. I approached her about her furniture and it did not go well. My husband said I shouldn't have asked her about her furniture. I'm finding it difficult to know the right things to say and do in practice, even if I'm beginning to understand it in theory.

OP posts:
Mastmw7g · 16/02/2024 09:16

@Gerwurtztraminer It sounds like you're offering some valuable insight and advice. I need to approach the situation with empathy and understanding while also encouraging independence and growth. I asked my therapist for an easy way to tell if I'm doing normal support for an adult child or being codependent and she just asked me several questions. I think she was trying to get me to be independent instead of relying on her for the answer. Encouraging me to step back and let my daughter make her own choices, even if they're not always the best ones, can be a crucial step in her development as an independent adult. It's a delicate balance, but ultimately empowering her to learn from her mistakes and take responsibility for her own life is key.

Her mother was much less sympathetic about her various dramas and got annoyed with him a lot - I'm sure it didn't help their relationship (now divorced)."

I used to fight with my husband often about how he treated her. I had a lot of anger, and it's a wonder we didn't divorce. I'm feeling now like he cut her off while she's still very dependent. And I'm trying to not feel resentful that she's turned all this reliance on me, but I need to acknowledge the role I played. Even if I did agree, I stayed married which is a choice. And eventually I focused on controlling my anger, which had the side effect of going along with her not learning independence. Right now she's coming to me instead of him and that's unfamiliar territory. I know I need to get this right.

I joined an online support group for failure to launch and I have read the posts of others. My daughter has a car, a job, lives elsewhere in a home of her own, and has finished school. These are things the other parents would give anything for. So she has all the keys. I need to stop opening door for her, especially with things like the furniture where she hasn't even asked for my help.

OP posts:
Apolloneuro · 16/02/2024 00:29

My spidey sense are up about your husband. He sounds weirdly controlling.

Are you all ok?

unsureaboutmyheart · 15/02/2024 22:15

I’m probably going to get attacked here but I find your updates odd and I feel sorry for your daughter. The way you are writing raises alarm bells for me, it comes across manipulative. All you are doing is painting a bad picture of your daughter to strangers and criticising her and making it seem like you don’t know why she is like this. There’s obviously a reason she is like this - IF she is like this. My mum has been incredibly emotionally and verbally abusive to me my entire life, and I’ve recently gone LC with her at 28. She would talk badly about me to other people to paint herself as the doting victim mother who doesn’t understand why her child is just so awful. I’m not saying this is you, but your posts are very much like her and it makes me suspicious that there’s a lot more to the story and her side would be very different. I don’t know you so can’t say, but my there’s something about the way you’re sort of half blaming yourself in a way that still makes you look like you’re trying your best that makes me feel like there’s probably a big reason for her actions (if totally true). People are quick to blame mental illness in people who actually didn’t have the normal parenting experience. Sounds like she’s dealing with trauma and I feel bad for her.

MyGooseisTotallyLoose · 15/02/2024 20:13

Is it that she doesn't want to spend her own money on furniture, doesn't want any furniture she's bought by you to be 2nd hand and will only accept brand new her perfection?

Testina · 15/02/2024 19:52

There is something weird as fuck going on with your husband 🤷🏻‍♀️
Who cuts up meat for a teen, then a couple of years on, won’t buy them a chair for a new flat?

MorningSunshineSparkles · 15/02/2024 19:27

@Nssdth said it fair better than I could.

XiCi · 15/02/2024 19:05

HalebiHabibti · 15/02/2024 15:22

Am I the only one who finds the way your husband has babied your daughter immensely weird 😳

No, youre not. Very strange family dynamic.

DaffodilsAlready · 15/02/2024 19:04

HalebiHabibti · 15/02/2024 15:22

Am I the only one who finds the way your husband has babied your daughter immensely weird 😳

It reminds me of the kind of interactions you have with a narcissist, where the relationship is all love-bombing and they cannot do enough for you, and they are everything you want, and then they start to move the goalposts, devalue the things which are important to you, and remove affection/love.
But it is the DD being devalued in the OP’s eyes and the daughter having the affection and love removed. The DD has not only been babied but she has then been completely cast off by the DH here.

I honestly wonder whether you are worried Mastmw7g that the love, affection and support will be removed from you too if you don’t go along with what this man says.

I do agree that it is controlling. I mean, when you get to the point you are having to ask whether your own child can have furniture, when she is expected to sit on the floor on cushions, there is a problem which is not just of the DD’s making.

DaisyDaisyDaisyDaisyDaisyDaisy · 15/02/2024 18:28

@AdriftAbroad1 I'll join you in the minority

DaffodilsAlready · 15/02/2024 18:17

Mastmw7g · 15/02/2024 14:14

We bought her bed and the sheet, duvet, a knitted blanket. She bought a rug on Amazon, so many cushions to sit on from a charity shop, and two tv benches from ikea. I asked my husband "Since it's been a month and she still doesn't have furniture, do you think we-" and he interrupted and said no before I could finish. I'll make more of an effort to talk to her about secondhand furniture. We've had some conversations and she has a specific "look" she has in mind, which isn't matching what she's been able to find on her own. So I'll try to show her more options online, and perhaps speak to her about lowering her expectations.

Yes, this sounds sensible.
if she has a table and chairs, she has more options for bringing friends over for dinner and cooking together.
it is her first flat, it does not have to be perfecf. She is in a bit of a chicken and egg situation as she is wasting money on takeaways probably because she doesn’t want to cook for one person (herself) but for as long as she is wasting money on takeaways, she cannot save up for the furniture she wants. So if she has somewhere to sit down and have her meal, maybe invite a friend over, that will help her also save for what she wants.
Equally, I am not sure why you would need your husband’s permission to buy your DD some basic furniture.

AdriftAbroad1 · 15/02/2024 15:59

Nssdth · 15/02/2024 15:35

You seem to be pathologising her a lot. It reminds me of a case in The Examined Life when the family bring their anxious unruly child to a therapist; as the child becomes happier and more confident the rest of the family falls apart as they had always located the 'bad' in her.

I wonder if you can't answer the therapist honestly because it is painful to acknowledge how things really may have played out.

It's easy to say yes she was awful, whilst not thinking about what may have made her that way.

Absolutely.

I feel so sorry for your daughter.

Your DH sounds odd and completely controlling. You soundvery passive.
But I am clearly in the minority. Good luck to DD and you.

Nssdth · 15/02/2024 15:35

You seem to be pathologising her a lot. It reminds me of a case in The Examined Life when the family bring their anxious unruly child to a therapist; as the child becomes happier and more confident the rest of the family falls apart as they had always located the 'bad' in her.

I wonder if you can't answer the therapist honestly because it is painful to acknowledge how things really may have played out.

It's easy to say yes she was awful, whilst not thinking about what may have made her that way.

HalebiHabibti · 15/02/2024 15:22

Am I the only one who finds the way your husband has babied your daughter immensely weird 😳

MyGooseisTotallyLoose · 15/02/2024 14:24

Your updates are really not helping paint a very good picture of your daughter here. It may not be entirely her fault that she's spoiled, manipulative, entitled and not functioning as an adult very well, as you and your husband have brought her up that way. But she is an adult now and you are still doing it and that's not helping anyone, least of all her. This exactly. There's a book I remember people being recommended on here, it's for teenagers but think would be useful called something like, 'mom I hate you get out of my life, but first take me shopping to the mall'?

anon2022anon · 15/02/2024 14:21

This all sounds very tiresome. Do either of you remind her that she's now an adult and she also has to try and solve issues herself?

I have a (just) 20 year old, away at uni. She didn't want to work. However her course is not over demanding, and she has expensive tastes, she needs a job. We just put the reminder there that while we are happy to support her at uni, we are not happy to fund her going out 2 or 3 times a week while not working, so she needed something. She sulked a bit, then realised that she wanted the kind of social life she wanted, so went looking. She found a job, no she doesn't like it, but she likes what the money can do for her.
She needed a dentist appointment. She asked me to ring, as she doesn't like making those calls. I reminded her that I was at work, busier than her at that moment, and as she was almost 20, they probably wouldn't accept me calling anyway. She realised she needed to crack on, and did it.

The point I'm trying to make is at that age, I think that they would quite happily let you do everything for them. But what good is it going to do? That's not to say don't help them, but surely you have boundaries. For example the job hunting, you went researching, she couldn't be bothered. Why are you researching, not her? If that was me, I would be telling her that if she found some things she liked the look of, then I would happily work with her to look through her CV and help write a covering letter. But how is she supposed to actually do the job if she's not even having to take the stress of looking for it?

As for the furniture, I think I would point out that it takes years of work before a house is exactly to your taste, so if it was me, I would buy something cheap and cheerful, until I could save up for the right one, and that life is a lot happier with a sofa to sit on with a friend. But, at the same time, I would realise that she is an adult, so if she would rather go without than have the perfect one, that's her decision to make, and not one that makes you a bad parent, she is an adult with enough of a brain and enough money to make that choice.

Gerwurtztraminer · 15/02/2024 14:17

Your updates are really not helping paint a very good picture of your daughter here. It may not be entirely her fault that she's spoiled, manipulative, entitled and not functioning as an adult very well, as you and your husband have brought her up that way. But she is an adult now and you are still doing it and that's not helping anyone, least of all her.

Your husband may have handled it badly by suddenly drawing some boundaries but he's not wrong that she needs them. You're still trying to baby her or letting her manipulate you - back off a bit. Even if she does have ADHD or a mental illness or whatever, it can't go on like this as she isn't developing as a independent young adult.

Let her learn, make mistakes, make her own choices - even if they aren't great ones. I know its hard. Help a little when asked and where reasonable but I think you are doing too much and need to stop jumping in to 'save' her and don't take over. For example if she's being picky about buying furniture and that means she doesn't have a table and chairs, that's her choice. You've made helpful suggestions; now sit back and let her do it, or at the least ask for your help.

I know someone very like your husband with the same sort of relationship with his daughter. All through her teenage years he mollycoddled her both practically and emotionally. The food examples sound very similar too. He and I argued once as he wrote an important university essay for her and I thought that was morally wrong (he backtracked and said it was only proofing her draft...). She self diagnosed as dyslexic when really she just couldn't be bothered doing all the required reading (admitted as much). Unsurprisingly she has grown up very dependent on him and now on her 'rich husband'. Her mother was much less sympathetic about her various dramas and got annoyed with him a lot - I'm sure it didn't help their relationship (now divorced).

Mastmw7g · 15/02/2024 14:14

XiCi · 15/02/2024 09:34

Couldn't you and you husband help buy her some furniture? Or even help her source a 2nd hand sofa, often people give them away for free on freecycle etc. It's her first flat and she doesnt seem to be coping well, I would be doing more to help her settle. Even a few bean bags to sit on would be a start!

We bought her bed and the sheet, duvet, a knitted blanket. She bought a rug on Amazon, so many cushions to sit on from a charity shop, and two tv benches from ikea. I asked my husband "Since it's been a month and she still doesn't have furniture, do you think we-" and he interrupted and said no before I could finish. I'll make more of an effort to talk to her about secondhand furniture. We've had some conversations and she has a specific "look" she has in mind, which isn't matching what she's been able to find on her own. So I'll try to show her more options online, and perhaps speak to her about lowering her expectations.

OP posts:
Mastmw7g · 15/02/2024 14:00

GreenCycler · 15/02/2024 00:42

Can you check charity shops for some furniture? I get you may not want to get brand new if it’s temporary accommodation. Involve her in the search, have her do it while you sit beside and gently encourage… she will be learning.

And I think your time would be better spent cooking together very simple meals in her home, so she can learn and feel confident in this also… it needs to extend to the supermarket shop, putting things away, how to use the pots and pans.

It will help you to imagine that she is still a young child… these are the things she missed out on being coached in… now is a good time to do it, and it will help you bond. Don’t move on to a new dish until she’s mastered the first.

I think more than once a week would be more helpful.

Your husband can look after his other kids if he’s abandoned yours, you need to help her.

I did go with her once to a charity shop and she didn't find me an appropriate shopping partner. She met someone at work and he must be able to find things better than me, or has a better eye for what she likes because they went together again on Tuesday. She did but two kallax TV benches to put under the windows next to her fireplace. She got them from ikea. And she has a tv, pots, pans, and dishes.

I'll try to encourage her to go online and look at secondhand items since she hasn't found anything in shops yet.

She can cook, and probably better than me.

She comes over twice a day Thursday through Monday (Tuesday and Wednesday are her days off) because we take care of her dog while she's working, so the most she would be home for me to come over would be twice a week, and she's not always there both days since she goes out. I think she enjoys the ritual I started of coming over on Tuesdays, but also prefers socializing with those she's met, so she isn't hesitant to make plans that keep me from coming over, which is ok.

OP posts: