Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

DD20 says she would still live with me if I had given her that option

137 replies

Mastmw7g · 08/02/2024 16:55

I want to ask if I was unreasonable for allowing the way DH encouraged her to move out, but that's probably an unreasonable thing to ask. I felt sometimes like he was almost manipulating her. So it was her choice, but she was very hesitant to make that choice.

Living with her was awful. It wasn't good for my younger children, so I know it was the best choice for the rest of us. But I doubt it was the best choice for her. I've had this surge of anxiety since she moved out and even started therapy. It's possible I'm codependent. Why else would I worry about her when I should be sleeping?

Regardless, yesterday I went over her home and she said she would still live with me if I had given her that option. In therapy I was asked if she chose to leave or I made her leave and I truthfully didn't know the answer, but I suppose now I do. I made her leave because she felt she had no option to stay. Now I'm still distracted from everything I do because I'm nervous and worried for her, but I also feel deep guilt for making her fly before she was ready to leave the nest.

OP posts:
Mastmw7g · 17/02/2024 13:10

@Notgoodatpoetrybutgreatatlit I appreciate your reminder to ensure my younger children receive attention and care as well. I'm really sorry you felt there wasn't anything left for you because your brother's MH needs were so great.

OP posts:
Mastmw7g · 17/02/2024 13:04

HalebiHabibti · 16/02/2024 09:51

Do you have any sons OP? It is a bit odd that he has decided girls need so much babying (only to be suddenly dropped when he's had enough it seems).

We have two sons. In the past I've objected to how hard he is on them, and he said some nonsense about believing the world doesn't give second chances to men. I said that was silly coming from a white man.

OP posts:
Mastmw7g · 17/02/2024 13:02

SecondUsername4me · 16/02/2024 09:39

Did she not have her own bedroom furniture to take with her when she moved?

She had a specific bed she wanted.

OP posts:
Mastmw7g · 17/02/2024 12:58

@Ktime I wouldn't say our other dc prefer me to him. They are just as likely to come to me if they want something. My youngest daughter prefers her grandmother to either of us. That's the only thing I can think of.

OP posts:
Mastmw7g · 17/02/2024 12:53

Apolloneuro · 16/02/2024 00:29

My spidey sense are up about your husband. He sounds weirdly controlling.

Are you all ok?

We're ok. He said yesterday that he often thinks the best way forward is the decision he made and that causes him to disregard the decisions of others, so that's a trait he has to work on.

OP posts:
HalebiHabibti · 17/02/2024 12:51

So your husband was really over-involved with your daughter for ages (as in, fussing over her to a large degree) and then suddenly decided he was done and she should move out. He now avoids her when she is in your home.

OP, this is so weird and really seems to me to indicate that their relationship has been/is a very unhealthy one. The fact that he is now avoiding her sets off alarm bells for me.

Mastmw7g · 17/02/2024 12:49

@unsureaboutmyheart It sounds like you're expressing concern about how my writing comes across and comparing it to experiences you've had with emotional and verbal abuse from your own mother. I want to assure you that it's not my intention to manipulate or paint a negative picture of my daughter. I appreciate your perspective and your willingness to share your own story.

I understand that my posts may have raised some red flags for you, and I want to clarify that I'm simply sharing my experiences. I'm open to hearing different perspectives and know that there may is more to the story. I've posted a great deal about it, so this isn't even the whole story of my post history.

I'm sorry to hear about the challenges you've faced with your own mother, and I admire your courage in setting boundaries to protect yourself. It's important to acknowledge the impact of trauma and how it can affect someone's behavior.

Moving forward, I'll make sure to consider how my words might be perceived and strive to be more mindful of how I present my experiences. Thank you for bringing your concerns to my attention.

OP posts:
Mastmw7g · 17/02/2024 12:35

MyGooseisTotallyLoose · 15/02/2024 20:13

Is it that she doesn't want to spend her own money on furniture, doesn't want any furniture she's bought by you to be 2nd hand and will only accept brand new her perfection?

I asked her and she got very angry, called my husband and said he needed to stop avoiding her when she's over our house, and stay with her to help mediate between the two of us. So I don't think I should approach her on the subject again.

OP posts:
Mastmw7g · 17/02/2024 12:32

@Testina He would say that the difference there is that she is an adult now. I told him that I understand that the only way she will change is if we change, but just because he changed suddenly doesn't mean I did.

OP posts:
DaffodilsAlready · 16/02/2024 19:51

Mastmw7g · 16/02/2024 10:21

@DaffodilsAlready He met her when she was six and was babying her until a month ago, so I don't think that could be love-bombing.

My marriage has definite challenges, but him setting boundaries, albeit without first showing her the way, doesn't make me worry about him doing the same to me. If I were mistreating him and asking for things that caused him to think of himself much less and me much more, then that would be what he was doing to try to make a healthier path for himself. I don't think he's controlling. He's always seemed too passive to me when faced with confrontation. But I definitely could be wrong.

Thank you for taking the time to answer my posts.
Obviously you have lived with and know the situation way better than me, as I have only read your posts on this thread.
I think being controlling can rooted in fear and insecurity, though, It’s a way of minimising things you are not comfortable with and ensuring your environment is the way you want it. It’s a way of having your needs met, without considering the needs of other people or seeing those other people as lesser.
The reason I wondered about your agency and whether your husband is controlling is because of the amount of times you say ‘my husband said’ and refer to what he does or does not do or want or think. This sticks out a bit because you are describing your daughter and it seems almost like you do not know how to relate to her. So how is it that you do not know how to relate to your own DD and have to learn the best way forward?
It seems to me that this is because your husband has asserted his way of looking after her, even though she is your daughter, even though it made you angry. I think that is controlling.
However, what matters now is how you find a way forward. And the important part in that sentence is you . Not what your husband says or what his boundaries are or his health needs or his fear of conflict or any of that. How you find a way forward, with your DD. because to be honest, that is what you should have been allowed to do for the last fourteen (I think) years.

WhatNoRaisins · 16/02/2024 11:50

OP if your DD is going to grow up and become a better person that has to come from her. You wanting it for her isn't going to be enough to change things.

The dynamic between you and especially your DH and her sounds very unhealthy from what you have told us. She might be better off with some third party help, support with her mental health, life coaching or even some mature peers that she respects. It doesn't seem like something you can fix when there's obviously a lot of baggage between you.

MyHornCanPierceTheSky · 16/02/2024 11:15

If she didn't eat, she would stand in front of him and show him that her hand was shaking from not having eaten and he would immediately make her food, whatever she asked for. She would ask for a different meal than the rest of us were having and he'd cook that for her or leave to go pick up what she wanted.

So was the hand shaking real or attention seeking? She sounds like a spoiled little madam who's actually trying to bully you into buying her what she wants!

beetr00 · 16/02/2024 10:43

@Mastmw7g wrt the furniture, this may be useful?

https://www.bhf.org.uk/shop

FancyJapflack · 16/02/2024 10:31

She sounds awful.

mumda · 16/02/2024 10:26

If you support her still then you're doing the right thing for everyone. @Mastmw7g don't beat yourself up about this. Find a future you can all be happy with.

Mastmw7g · 16/02/2024 10:21

@DaffodilsAlready He met her when she was six and was babying her until a month ago, so I don't think that could be love-bombing.

My marriage has definite challenges, but him setting boundaries, albeit without first showing her the way, doesn't make me worry about him doing the same to me. If I were mistreating him and asking for things that caused him to think of himself much less and me much more, then that would be what he was doing to try to make a healthier path for himself. I don't think he's controlling. He's always seemed too passive to me when faced with confrontation. But I definitely could be wrong.

OP posts:
BoohooWoohoo · 16/02/2024 10:20

I think that it’s clear from your posts that your dd has some MH issues and these have been made worse by your h babying her one minute then treating her like she should be a fully independent adult the next. She sounds impossible to live with but your h has definitely contributed to that imo. Is he unable to tolerate her behaviour because of her age? I mean the attitude that she’s physically an adult so must be independent?

I think that you need to make sure that the younger ones are parented better so that they are ready when the time comes. I understand that your h thought that he was being kind and wanted to be liked as a stepparent but I’m not surprised to hear that this is the result of his actions. Instead of forcing adulthood at age 18 gradually give your children responsibility so that it’s not a massive shock when they turn 18. Over the years my kids moaned about stuff that they had to do like take a bus or help change bedding but they later realised that they are handy things to be able to do and they had the respect of their peers for being able to help them learn too.

Stop asking her about the furniture. Indecision and inaction might be part of her issues and like the tv stand, she will hopefully buy when ready. I know that you mean well but buying for her is babying her and pressuring her is going to just make her angry or make it harder to buy other stuff. Of course she knows that having a sofa or whatever would be great but she was babied for so long that making decisions and carrying them out is much harder and she needs time before she takes the plunge.

If she has issues then fitting in at work will be even more important to her- regardless of whether or not she enjoys the job. This is another issue where you should wait until she asks you for help to find another job rather than treat her like she’s very young and tell her what to go. She might just be venting and not want you to fix things. Part of being an adult is exercising the power to fix your own problems and that experience will help her become wiser.

DaisyDaisyDaisyDaisyDaisyDaisy · 16/02/2024 10:17

@Kelly51 I agree. It's so strangely claustrophobic.

Kelly51 · 16/02/2024 10:16

OP you have written so many posts on here about this situation, it's the same thing every time, what are you taking from all the advice? because you're repeatedly posting the same thing over and over.
I could write this myself I've read it so often.

Mastmw7g · 16/02/2024 10:05

@DaffodilsAlready She comes to our house after work to pick up her dog, so she's eating here instead of wasting money on takeaways. And she always asks for leftovers. It does seem like she is spending money on takeaways at work. I don't know if the problem is that she doesn't know how to prepare to eat away from home or if it's difficult to be the only one at work bringing food from home.

She hasn't asked for furniture. I did ask her about the absence of furniture and she got angry and said "What the fuck? I've been looking for furniture this whole time." I said I was just wondering if her reason for not having furniture was that she didn't want to spend money on furniture or if she hadn't found furniture in keeping with her vision. She said she didn't want to talk about that anymore, so I stopped asking questions and my husband said I shouldn't have brought it up and upset her. She did respond to a message I sent her over the phone about some chairs I found secondhand online. She said she has to be mindful that her dad's parents are elderly and will need a comfortable place to sit down and the chairs I sent a picture of didn't look comfortable enough. I asked when they were going to visit and she responded that she didn't know, but she seems to have a plan in place to have furniture before then.

OP posts:
Ktime · 16/02/2024 10:03

The hand shaking food thing is in itself so weird.

I think this is something kids do. I used to do this myself because I didn't understand hand shaking was due to the crash after eating too much sugar. I thought it must be because I was starving!

Tempnamechng · 16/02/2024 10:02

I think her seeing a therapist again is a good idea. She sounds vulnerable and young. I know 20 is legally an adult, but they certainly aren't emotionally mature, and I wouldn't pressure a 20yo to move out unless I was absolutely desperate.

anon2022anon · 16/02/2024 09:59

Honestly, step back from it all. You've realised you don't need to be on the failure to launch group- great. She's doing okay.
She doesn't want to go to further therapy and enjoys looking for her own solutions. Okay. If further issues develop, then look at them then.
She's enjoying having time alone with you on one night a week- that's lovely, and it sounds like the first time it's happened regularly, so enjoy it.
She's currently cooking for herself, doesn't sound like she's getting into debt, has some savings and is holding down a job.

Where it sounds like she does need you is when the teenage tendancy to over-react kicks in- they all do this, by the way. But she doesn't necessarily need you to babysit her, but instead to tell her to calm down and think about what she wants the outcome to be before she kicks off or does something dramatic.

Thinking back, what might have been a better option than marching down with her to the rent office with the threat of violence? I personally would have told my daughter to stop being silly, as she's not a child or a thug, to go get a cup of tea, and then to call back. Once she's calm, does she need some help getting an email written asking them to check again, can she take a screenshot of her payment going out, take it from there.

When she's threatening to quit her job, again tell her to cool down and think it through. She hates it, she might be better elsewhere, but now she's an adult and needs to think it through first. That means looking for the next job while she's in one, and keeping a bit extra in the bank while she's looking if she can. Your job is to help her see the bigger picture, not to jump to fixing it for her.

It also sounds like she's maybe taken on too much financially with a flat, and needs to think about a house share or similar. I would be selling it as spare money to have fun with , or to book a holiday for later in the year.

Notgoodatpoetrybutgreatatlit · 16/02/2024 09:56

Omg what a complex bunch of issues. The hand shaking food thing is in itself so weird. And the things you posted at the start about how you would have to come home because she was crying in public. You daughter clearly has a lot of MH issues. The whole thread reminded me of my brothers struggles. He was bi polar. Not saying your daughter is but something is definitely going on here.
I can't help obviously, I'm just another random stranger, but I would say you are focused on your older daughter so much I do wonder how the younger children are doing. Maybe you and your husband could plan some activities for them. I was the younger sibling and my childhood has some very unhappy memories because my brother needed so much there was just nothing left for me.

DaisyDaisyDaisyDaisyDaisyDaisy · 16/02/2024 09:56

Reading the OP and subsequent responses is like wading through treacle

Swipe left for the next trending thread