Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To want to catch him in a clever way? Pls help

791 replies

badgergirl5 · 08/02/2024 16:38

I think I have just discovered evidence that my husband is having an affair. Please bear with me as I explain the background - I want to be smart about how I confront him and how I make my next move, because I know he will deny it. So I’ve come here to ask for advice and ideas on how to do this. A big part of me just wants to blurt everything out but I know this might be my only chance to know the truth.

This starts all the way back in 2005!! Our kids were babies at the time. I’d had a suspicious feeling that something wasn’t right for a few months so I looked at his phone and found outrageously flirty texts with a woman at work. They were trying to arrange meeting up for a drink and he had actually checked one of the dates with me and told me he’d be going out with a mate. The texts including descriptions of what she was wearing, how she had fancied him and blushed whenever he spoke to her etc etc. I confronted him and he apologised and acted sorry - said he was having a moment of madness, would cancel the evening out with her and break off all contact. But he didn’t let me see the messages he sent to her in order to do this (yes I know this was crazy of me not to insist!!!!).

Three years later I received anonymous text messages telling me he was cheating. I never understood where they came from. He said he had no idea and someone was just trying to cause trouble.

So that brings me to 2024. We have been happily married, at least on the surface, for the last 6 years since those text messages. I have always had an uneasy feeling that he’s a flirt and needs attention from other women but have never known whether he would actually cheat.
Today I was using our shared laptop and he had left his emails open. I don’t even know why given it was YEARS ago, but I searched for that girl’s name. I found 3 separate occasions of him sending presents to her - all the same name and address. Chocolates, clothes and a book (the book actually hurt the most - it was a book about hormones that I have actually read myself. From the date, it looks as though he heard my recommendation and decided to send her one). I find a book about hormones to be a particularly intimate thing to send to someone.

first of all, AIBU to suspect a full blown and potentially long term affair ? If he’s been seeing her, it can’t ever involve overnight stays. He is never away. But I guess he could meet her during the day. Is there any other explanation for still being in contact with her after so many years and sending presents?

I would love advice on how I can play this to be sure before I confront him. How much should I admit I’ve seen?

OP posts:
PinkCardigan93 · 11/02/2024 18:09

Came back to see your updates OP. Gutted for you. A truly remorseful man who will do anything to make it work will do ANYTHING, literally ANYTHING to fight to fix this. And the only way the relationship could ever work is from that level of commitment / remorse / regret / willingness to admit his faults. He would show you the WhatsApps, ultimately, if he was truly sorry / fully accepting responsibility and telling you the whole truth. As he would have nothing else to loose in showing you and everything to gain - hope, the starting point to rebuild trust, transparency, the willingness to do WHATEVER IT TAKES to fix it.

He's fallen at the first hurdle, and I suspect it's because the massages will reveal more than you know and expose that he is still being dishonest.

If he wants to have any chance of ever coming back from this he needs to be honest and own up everything. He's not willing to do that. The relationship can therefore never have a hope of being fixed.

Ispywithmycynicaleye · 11/02/2024 17:44

There was an OP on here around a year ago, maybe just over a year who suspected her DH of cheating. She hired a PI and they got evidence of him cheating for her. For all the same reasons you have shared, she needed to know for sure Flowers

Sceptical123 · 11/02/2024 16:30

I think you’re right, I just think the suggestion would likely cause panic on husband’s side which would indicate there’s a lot to hide. If he reacts differently to the last time where he essentially called OP’s bluff and confidently told her to call the OW, then it’s fairly obvious there is a difference between the situations.

BlueGrey1 · 11/02/2024 16:19

There are no guarantees that if you did get to speak to her that she would tell you the truth, he might have already spoken to her and given her the heads up that you might call

I would definitely want to see the messages

Sceptical123 · 11/02/2024 15:59

Even if you don’t, just to watch his reaction

Sceptical123 · 11/02/2024 15:59

badgergirl5 · 11/02/2024 15:39

I’ve just remembered something which could be nothing or could be significant.
When I discovered the first OW that he had been exchanging flirty texts with/ arranging to meet behind my back, he immediately responded to that confrontation by saying “you can call her - please call her! She will tell you it’s nothing.” At the time it made me apoplectic that he would give her that power, but now i look back (knowing that it wasn’t physical on that occasion because I later read all of their flirty messages) and realise that he wanted me to speak to her because he really was “innocent.” She was a horrible flirt and definitely fancied him, but nothing had happened.
This time, he won’t even let me see her number in his phone (although I could easily get it as I have her work number) and he won’t let me see their messages. So that’s either because:
a) it’s deeply embarrassing for him because he’s been trying so hard but nothing much has actually happened - but he knows how bad he looks because it’s 90% him
or b) their relationship is a full blown affair this time

Edited

Maybe say this to him OP - you’d like to speak to her, like he offered the last time

badgergirl5 · 11/02/2024 15:39

I’ve just remembered something which could be nothing or could be significant.
When I discovered the first OW that he had been exchanging flirty texts with/ arranging to meet behind my back, he immediately responded to that confrontation by saying “you can call her - please call her! She will tell you it’s nothing.” At the time it made me apoplectic that he would give her that power, but now i look back (knowing that it wasn’t physical on that occasion because I later read all of their flirty messages) and realise that he wanted me to speak to her because he really was “innocent.” She was a horrible flirt and definitely fancied him, but nothing had happened.
This time, he won’t even let me see her number in his phone (although I could easily get it as I have her work number) and he won’t let me see their messages. So that’s either because:
a) it’s deeply embarrassing for him because he’s been trying so hard but nothing much has actually happened - but he knows how bad he looks because it’s 90% him
or b) their relationship is a full blown affair this time

OP posts:
badgergirl5 · 11/02/2024 15:31

I guess that reaction is what I’ve been scared of since the start and exactly why I wanted to find more/ hire a PI/ call her/ get more evidence.
But he’s already told such dreadful lies and admitted to deleting WhatsApp chats on top of what I already knew, so I feel quite confident now to tell him that he didn’t do enough when he was given the chance.

OP posts:
Thementalloadisreal · 11/02/2024 14:07

Gymnopedie · 11/02/2024 14:03

I need to update on what happened last night. He had a big breakdown (first time I’ve seen him cry in 15 years together) and admitted he’s been totally stupid and clearly has a problem.

Ah, it's The Script.

He's tried pretending he doesn't know what you're talking about - it didn't work.
He's tried minimising it - it didn't work
He's fed you a long complicated explanation that was all lies - it didn't work.

So now he's trying the MH route. It's not really him, he's got a problem. The aim of that one is to put it onto you and make it your problem, that you'll feel sorry for him and feel the need to rescue him. Don't let that one work.

The next act in the script is to get angry. He will say it's all your fault. That you didn't give him enough love/sex/attention. That you should have kept your beak out of his business and then you wouldn't have known. Be prepared.

I agree and with that anger will come the twisting and guilting and blackmailing -
how dare you accuse me, you are paranoid, you can’t leave me over nothing, I will tell everyone you’re crazy, you’ll be the one destroying the family, think of the kids etc etc

Gymnopedie · 11/02/2024 14:03

I need to update on what happened last night. He had a big breakdown (first time I’ve seen him cry in 15 years together) and admitted he’s been totally stupid and clearly has a problem.

Ah, it's The Script.

He's tried pretending he doesn't know what you're talking about - it didn't work.
He's tried minimising it - it didn't work
He's fed you a long complicated explanation that was all lies - it didn't work.

So now he's trying the MH route. It's not really him, he's got a problem. The aim of that one is to put it onto you and make it your problem, that you'll feel sorry for him and feel the need to rescue him. Don't let that one work.

The next act in the script is to get angry. He will say it's all your fault. That you didn't give him enough love/sex/attention. That you should have kept your beak out of his business and then you wouldn't have known. Be prepared.

Owlontheprowl · 11/02/2024 14:03

It isn’t about protecting his reputation. It’s about protecting yours.

Owlontheprowl · 11/02/2024 14:02

Watercolourpapier · 11/02/2024 11:57

When they go low, you go high. Keep your dignity, never foul mouth your husband to people in RL, keep to the facts and play by the book. Be generous with contact and don’t give your STBX any reason for him to diss you

What sort of 1950s playbook did this come from?

Why shouldn't the op talk to people about what her husband has done?

That "advice" sounds more like she should protect his reputation than anything else. She's allowed to speak about her own experience.

Because I did this and I kept all his friends in the divorce while ex husband is now alone in a one bedroom shack with cats.

pawebi · 11/02/2024 14:01

I would say to him something along the lines of..

Your refusal to show me the messages indicates guilt and I will take it as an admission of a physical affair and proceed with a separation/divorce. If you in any way want to salvage or work on this I need full access to those messages and full honestly and transparency on what went on and why followed by intensive therapy to see where this disgusting behaviour is stemming from. Full transparency and honestly is the only way to take the first step back onto the already shattered ladder of trust and you need to be willing to put a lot of work in to work on this relationship. In the mean time it is best you move out till we can begin the next steps, whether that is divorce or healing and therapy.

SlightlyJaded · 11/02/2024 14:00

OP - you don't need a PI

You know what you know and you feel what you feel and there is no going back now.

It sounds to me like the PI thing is for everyone else's benefit - so that you can show others proof of his cheating - because you have this misconception that you need to 'prove' his infidelity it to justify your actions and not be the 'baddie'.

You really really don't. You don't owe anyone anything. You can leave him for being a repeat offender in flirting/lying/crossing boundaries and you nobody has to see the 'evidence' for this. And to anyone that says "Well you don't know if he slept with her?" you respond "And I don't know that he didn't - because he is still lying/minimising/covering up and deleting texts. And that is NOT the sort of man I deserve to be married to and that is NOT the sort of man I want modelling 'husband' to the DC".

You don't need a PI - just the confidence to believe that you deserve better.

Thementalloadisreal · 11/02/2024 13:34

Wouldn’t bother with a PI but would demand full access to bank statements, credit card statements for the last year or two and check for hotels and restaurants

Thementalloadisreal · 11/02/2024 13:13

@badgergirl5 He actually slipped and said “for God’s sake I know where the boundaries are” which is the biggest joke of the century, but also an insight perhaps into how he thinks. His boundary is very different to mine - perhaps anything less than sex he could excuse to himself?

I can’t for a second believe that he genuinely thinks messaging a woman that he promised years ago not to connect, sending gifts and (probably) saucy messages, isn’t crossing a boundary! The boundary was set years ago when he agreed to cut contact. He’s kidding himself.

BlueGrey1 · 11/02/2024 13:08

I would definitely need to see those messages…… no excuses

I would need to know for the future that I 100% made the correct decision

Thementalloadisreal · 11/02/2024 13:07

Sceptical123 · 11/02/2024 10:50

Yes that is a risk. She could contact the police if she knows it is you and tell them she is feeling anxious and scared etc and they will log it. Someone said that a bf did that to her following a breakup after they had reconnected and she grilled him as to his part in the breakdown of their relationship. He didn’t like that and blocked her and she tried to call on a different phone and the police contacted her. I think if it happens twice they take further action. Obviously things aren’t black and white and it’s the nature of the conversation that’s relevant but unless you recorded it (I’m not sure if you’re allowed to if they are oblivious) she could tell them whatever she wanted and they have to take action without any evidence to the contrary.

People really are shit aren’t they 🙄

I would probably text her rather than call.
.. something like… look I know somethings been going on, I’m not mad at you it’s all him, he won’t tell me the truth. Will you please tell me the truth? Happy to call if it’s easier over the phone. I just need closure.

Or do call and record the call, saying at the start I hope you don’t mind I am going to record this because I don’t think he will believe me if I tell him we spoke. You don’t have to say anything if you don’t want to talk to me but I’d really appreciate it woman to woman if you could just let me know what’s been going on.

badgergirl5 · 11/02/2024 12:32

“ I’d give him one last chance to show you WhatsApp’s to prove it wasn’t an affair and explain you will be telling your parents or a friend if he doesn’t want, to as that will be conclusive proof that he’s cheated. If he’s sticking to his guns he didn’t cheat - why won’t he show you? What is there that you won’t want to see? “

@Sceptical123 This is what I tried this morning. He actually slipped and said “for God’s sake I know where the boundaries are” which is the biggest joke of the century, but also an insight perhaps into how he thinks. His boundary is very different to mine - perhaps anything less than sex he could excuse to himself?
I demanded his blackberry many years ago (when it was the first flirtation - the one that came before this woman). I knew he couldn’t delete blackberry messages and, similar to this situation, I needed conclusive proof of whether it was physical. He resisted for DAYS before agreeing to hand it over when he could tell I was going to walk out. I locked myself in the bathroom and read every message between them. Outrageous flirtation, but obvious nothing physical had happened. This could be similar - perhaps he just can’t take the shame of showing me how slimy he has been. But I don’t have the fight left in me to keep demanding like I did back then.
And of course - there’s always the possibility that he HAS slept with this one.

OP posts:
Maybelater434 · 11/02/2024 12:17

@badgergirl5
you are being admirably strong, I’m sure you haven’t felt strong at times, but you really have.

I’d advise against PI & contacting OW. You wouldn’t find anything to make you feel better. I suspect you’d just feel worse & in the future when u can look back, that would be the only part you’d regret.

you know you’ll never trust him again & now just want the easiest way out.
All you need to tell DC for now is that daddy is staying at the other house for a while. If he won’t go, tell him you will, but he’d be choosing to make things more difficult for DC
(Make yourself busy elsewhere when he’s spending time with them, don’t try to act like everything is normal)
Find a good therapist for yourself & find one that specialises working with children (possibly available through school?) have an appointment made for DC ready for telling them about divorce. The earlier they have a therapist to talk things through, the easier they’ll find the whole situation. A professional will encourage them to verbalise their feelings, fears & questions. They’ll help them work through it calmly without judgement or catastrophising & encourage them to come to you with questions they need answered.
children that age need to know how their world will change, what it will look like for them. They need to know they are still loved by both parents & their wishes will be considered

As to what to tell others, your parents, best friend & very very close people can have the whole truth (if u want to). Other family & friends “There were indiscretions, infidelities & lies spanning several years. I’m no longer prepared to live with no trust so we are separating. We hope you can respect our decision & assist in making the whole situation as easy as possible for our DC”
for more distant friends/work colleagues “we are separating & trying to be as civil as possible for DC”

You cannot control what he tells people so don’t beat yourself up over what he might say. You can ask him to stick to basic “we are separating and staying civil” so that you don’t have to “correct them with the truth”

As you’ve already started to see glimmers of positivity of what your future might hold, focus on that, make yourself a list of the positives, the things you want to do. I agree with PP, get a massage, facial, therapist, pamper yourself a bit, you deserve it.

Youve got this 💪🏼

Watercolourpapier · 11/02/2024 11:57

When they go low, you go high. Keep your dignity, never foul mouth your husband to people in RL, keep to the facts and play by the book. Be generous with contact and don’t give your STBX any reason for him to diss you

What sort of 1950s playbook did this come from?

Why shouldn't the op talk to people about what her husband has done?

That "advice" sounds more like she should protect his reputation than anything else. She's allowed to speak about her own experience.

AcrossthePond55 · 11/02/2024 11:43

@badgergirl5

Ok, decision made then. The main thing now is to keep your dignity. You'll be so glad you did when this is all over.

Will contacting the OW look dignified? Will hiring a PI to dig into his activities help you keep your dignity? Chances are they won't.

At some point this will all be over. You don't want to look back and cringe at anything you did. You want to look back with pride and know you kept your dignity.

You've made a good start. Keep going the way you're going.

And yes, speak to your parents. Let them be your rock to lean on and your soft place to land.

You've got this.

Sleepandchocolate2202 · 11/02/2024 11:38

Have you recorded any of his admissions so far?

i feel like that might be wise insurance if you are able to do so discreetly ( for when he turns on his water works and pleas of innocence to others )

Sceptical123 · 11/02/2024 11:34

Threecrows · 11/02/2024 11:01

@GreenCycler had it spot on. Preserve your dignity.

I had all these ridiculous ideas when I was in your position. I know how tempting it is.

But really, what will it change?

make that your mantra.

its not just the cost of the PI. It’s the wasted time and energy dealing with it. And the inevitable upset. You know enough. Spend your precious time looking forward- not backward

Edited

I agree with this - focus on the future. But I can see why OP would want categorical proof that he has been unfaithful so she has no guilt about seeking divorce and being the one to actively separate the family (yes HE did this by his actions, obviously, but he has passively divided the family bc he will claim he doesn’t want to leave etc). It’s a massive decision.

Sexting, sharing sexual photos or even just heavy flirting equates to physical cheating in some ppl’s book but not others, as does emotional affairs. I don’t blame OP for wanting to know what category this falls into before ending it once and for all. She is owed that but that’s not to say she will get that type of closure. OP, I think it’s something you may have to accept as he sounds thoroughly ashamed of his actions, knows you are justified in wanting to kick him out, and won’t be offering proof of his abhorrent behaviour. The fact he isn’t angrily pleading his innocence and going above and beyond to prove it speaks volumes, he’s feeling guilty.

This has been a life lesson for him if nothing else. Actions have consequences. He didn’t realise how lucky he was to be given a 2nd and 3rd chance all those years ago. He decided to take you for a ride again now bc he thought he could get away with it as the previous times were so long ago. In his mind he may have framed it that he wasn’t being a shit to you bc you were oblivious and therefore there was no harm to his flirting or whatever it was . He may have had no intention to actually get physical, but the fact that he sees her semi regularly for work, it’s not someone he met online living the other side of the globe, and he’s got form for trying to arrange meet-ups with women behind your back - this was actively deceitful as he was checking you were free to look after the kids/would be away or whatever so he could go on a date. You foiled those instances, but they were the ones you knew about.

Massive, massive hugs. I’d give him one last chance to show you WhatsApp’s to prove it wasn’t an affair and explain you will be telling your parents or a friend if he doesn’t want, to as that will be conclusive proof that he’s cheated. If he’s sticking to his guns he didn’t cheat - why won’t he show you? What is there that you won’t want to see?

Would he be ok with discovering all this about you if the tables were turned? Ask him. How would he react?

If he cares about you he’ll acknowledge you need to speak to somebody about all this in RL as you are in real need of support. Whether that’s someone close or a therapist is up to you at this stage x

GreenCycler · 11/02/2024 11:10

Yes, I’d love to hear more about your glimmer of excitement about the prospect of being free of all this.

What other things might you be able to do then that you can’t do now? Maybe you can begin to do some of them already.