Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Neighbour trying to benefit with tax thing

62 replies

bringthecactusin · 08/02/2024 13:44

Apologies, don't quite know what the correct description is.

Me and next door are replacing the (invasive) ivy hedge in the garden with a fence, and going 50/50 on the cost. Neither of us can 100% remember who's boundary it is, I vaguely remember it being mine, but might have imagined it. We're not sure and very easy going, so just splitting it 50/50. (I'm happy for them to have the posh side on their side because I want the support slats on my side for fixing things to easier.)

The Neighbour joked last week I needed to remember to ask for an invoice so he could claim it on expenses by pretending it was for one of his rental properties. I just laughed it off, but he's just rang me from work to give me the address I should ask the gardener to put down on the invoice.

I don't know if I'm being too sensible and boring, but this just doesn't sit well with me. His girlfriend has already given me their half of the money in cash, and she wasn't bothered enough to mention it. I know I'm not going to get any police knocking on my door obviously, but it really goes against my morals. The Neighbour is well known for his sense of entitlement and back handers (eg, me and the other side paid to have dropped kerbs put in by the council, but he just bribed the workmen and got his front done for free). I work for the NHS and we're on our arse and it's people taking every opportunity to not pay tax that contributes. It's a real bugbear of mine.

Am I being unreasonable by refusing to ask the gardener for a fake invoice?

Or opinions on how I can explain this to my slightly intimidating neighbour? I don't feel confident because this might totally be me being an absolute wet-wipe and everyone else on the planet happily fleeces the tax man given the opportunity, and I shouldn't stand in his way. Ultimately good neighbour relations come first. I just don't know.

Thoughts?

OP posts:
Flottie · 08/02/2024 16:10

If you don’t want to decline yourself just say the gardener won’t do it. But I’d definitely not be facilitating fraud.

Dotjones · 08/02/2024 16:07

I know I'm not going to get any police knocking on my door obviously

Probably not, but you'd be helping to commit fraud and could face prosecution if it gets traced back to you.

Whatevershallidowithmylife · 08/02/2024 16:04

Presuming you are paying a legitimate company you should be getting an invoice anyway. Just give him a copy of it surely? If he wants anything else he can contact the company himself?

Nottodaythankyou123 · 08/02/2024 16:02

bringthecactusin · 08/02/2024 15:25

I already had the land registry records so I've just dug them out, and his house isn't even on there! There's been 2 extra houses built between 68 and mine 🤦🏻‍♀️ My house is 150 years old so the actual document bit of the deeds is in really old calligraphy type cursive, I remember the solicitor fuming at the time that she's sent it back to the land registry complaining it was useless. Is that where it would say for definite? I don't know what I'm looking for on the map. Can anyone tell me? Unless the red box shows I have responsibility on BOTH sides?. Could well be, as for at least the first 100 years it was here there was nothing next to it but fields.

The red outline is your land, not which boundaries you’re responsible, but the extent of your property. The responsibility for boundaries would be found in one of the original conveyances, which is probably referred to in the title register (and which will have the funky font). You’d need to see the documents for next door - also available for £3 - and hope the transfer of his land contains details of the boundary responsibility, although it may not actually specify.

JCLV · 08/02/2024 16:01

Blame the workman. Say he refused as it is fraud.

DadJoke · 08/02/2024 15:59

@bringthecactusin then I am afraid the best course of action is to say no and pay for it yourself.

Check your deeds - they sometimes have a mark showing who owns the boundary.

OldLabMummy · 08/02/2024 15:52

You are over thinking this. Next time he asks just say I can’t do that, that’s illegal.

He can’t argue with that.

mrsbyers · 08/02/2024 15:41

Pay £3 to get the land registry details of next door ? Theirs should be more recent if built later

bringthecactusin · 08/02/2024 15:34

DadJoke · 08/02/2024 15:03

Ask your neighbour to deal with the supplier and invoicing. Don't commit fraud on his behalf.

Oh god no, it would a) be months and months before he got round to it b) be done on the cheap and by complete coyboys and c) only be 3ft tall so he can chat to me over it. Even if turns out to be his fence I'd still happily pay for it myself just to get one that I know will be decent and won't be bodged.

He's currently having his drive done. We're currently on week 4 of a 3 day job. He's got pallets of bricks on the pavement and all his cars parked on 3 other neighbours drives. I think he knows no-one in the entire Neighbourhood would let him organise a piss up in brewery at this point.

OP posts:
bringthecactusin · 08/02/2024 15:25

I already had the land registry records so I've just dug them out, and his house isn't even on there! There's been 2 extra houses built between 68 and mine 🤦🏻‍♀️ My house is 150 years old so the actual document bit of the deeds is in really old calligraphy type cursive, I remember the solicitor fuming at the time that she's sent it back to the land registry complaining it was useless. Is that where it would say for definite? I don't know what I'm looking for on the map. Can anyone tell me? Unless the red box shows I have responsibility on BOTH sides?. Could well be, as for at least the first 100 years it was here there was nothing next to it but fields.

Neighbour trying to benefit with tax thing
OP posts:
DadJoke · 08/02/2024 15:03

Ask your neighbour to deal with the supplier and invoicing. Don't commit fraud on his behalf.

Tinkerbyebye · 08/02/2024 14:55

Just say sorry xx has already given me cash so I am getting the invoice addressed to me

and leave it

Newestname002 · 08/02/2024 14:51

@bringthecactusin

Neither of us can 100% remember whose boundary it is, I vaguely remember it being mine, but might have imagined it.

Would those show up on the deeds though? If you can't find your hard copy you should be able to get a copy from the Land Registry? 🌹

BMW6 · 08/02/2024 14:39

Why don't you just tell him that you won't be complicit in tax Evasion and dishonesty?

I had a neighbour approach me years ago for similar. When I told her that I worked in HMRC Investigations her face was a picture.

She never spoke to me again.

Thedance · 08/02/2024 14:39

Cam you just tell him the gardeners will only put the correct name and address on the invoice. You and he can't expect them to falsify their records.

Lovebeingamummy2 · 08/02/2024 14:38

Say you want your name and address on the on the invoice for your home insurance purposes

RandomPoster456 · 08/02/2024 14:35

You can pay £3 from the Land registry for the deeds and it will show whos boundary it is. You can do this in a matter of about two minutes. It really is important to know this information and if it’s yours just pay for it yourself. Stand firm and say you’re not going to help him commit tax fraud. Any nonsense from him all you have to say is I’ve already told you no and won’t be discussing any further and remove yourself from his presence. Cheeky bastard. I doubt the gardener would be willing to invoice the incorrect address anyway tbh.

TomeTome · 08/02/2024 14:33

The gardener will refuse anyway so just get it in your name and say you thought that would be ok and you’ve sent a copy to the address he gave. He will say it’s useless if it’s for the address you are at and you can say well it’s not useless to you because it’s proof if there’s any problem with the fence going forward.

bringthecactusin · 08/02/2024 14:32

Terrrence · 08/02/2024 14:17

You are also pretending you don't know whose fence it is when you remember it is. It is not just 'everyone else on the planet' who is dishonest.

What the actual chuff? No that's not true. I said I'm not sure and meant it.

I've got it the back of my head that while traditionally everyone owns the border on their left, in this house it's the right. But I've lived in 5 different houses so I have no idea which one that thought related to. I felt very guilty when my other neighbour on the left paid for the whole back fence to be replaced, so I gave her some money towards it because I'm sure i remember thinking it should have been my job.

I paid for the left fence at the front to be replaced myself. And the brick wall on the right at the front had my neighbours posh finial things on the end post, inducating it's actually his. We've all tried to decide at various times but between us we can't. If I knew 100% it was mine I would have no trouble talking responsibility. Ultimately it's HIS ivy coming from HIS side of whoever's fence that's climbed up the side of MY house and is eroding MY brickwork. And that's one reason he should pay towards getting the ivy taken down regardless of who's fence it destroyed and grew through.

OP posts:
ShoePalaver · 08/02/2024 14:30

I think you should check whose boundary it is and if it's yours pay it all yourself.

It's one thing to insist on someone else paying their share but you don't seem to want to?

But no I wouldn't be happy to ask the gardener for a fake invoice

WhereIsMyLight · 08/02/2024 14:27

The evidence you need is that you need it to correct in case there are any issues at a later stage. You don’t need to clarify those issues because they could be in any format - insurance, installed incorrectly. It can be anything. It can even be you might want to sell in the next few years and have that paperwork for future buyers.

You’ve organised it and so in terms of protecting yourself, you need to pay the invoice and be able to prove you’ve paid it for your address.

chickenpieandchips · 08/02/2024 14:20

Just laugh!
He'll get 20-45% tax relief on the amount depending on his tax rate.
So he basically will get his money back if it's 45% which he probably is.
He didn't think this through if he asked you to deal with it 😂.
You've organised the works, don't want to engage in fraudulent activity and will be sorting out the invoice for the correct address for warranty/insurance purposes. Then smile sweetly and hope he has a good day. Then say your phone is ringing and you need to go.

Mosaic123 · 08/02/2024 14:19

Just say "I need to be able to sleep at night"!

Terrrence · 08/02/2024 14:17

You are also pretending you don't know whose fence it is when you remember it is. It is not just 'everyone else on the planet' who is dishonest.

bringthecactusin · 08/02/2024 14:16

shreknjumps · 08/02/2024 14:11

Fucking hell, you don't need "ammo".

Just say no, I want a proper receipt for the work we've paid for and if you want your own you'll need to ask the gardener yourself.

Maybe ammo was the wrong word. Evidence. Back up. Dunno.

I'm not very confident, he'll try and talk me round and I'll be squirming so if I feel more confident about explaining when I see him if I've got practical reason to mention IN ADDITION to my morals. I'm no doubt over thinking.

OP posts: