Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Neighbour trying to benefit with tax thing

62 replies

bringthecactusin · 08/02/2024 13:44

Apologies, don't quite know what the correct description is.

Me and next door are replacing the (invasive) ivy hedge in the garden with a fence, and going 50/50 on the cost. Neither of us can 100% remember who's boundary it is, I vaguely remember it being mine, but might have imagined it. We're not sure and very easy going, so just splitting it 50/50. (I'm happy for them to have the posh side on their side because I want the support slats on my side for fixing things to easier.)

The Neighbour joked last week I needed to remember to ask for an invoice so he could claim it on expenses by pretending it was for one of his rental properties. I just laughed it off, but he's just rang me from work to give me the address I should ask the gardener to put down on the invoice.

I don't know if I'm being too sensible and boring, but this just doesn't sit well with me. His girlfriend has already given me their half of the money in cash, and she wasn't bothered enough to mention it. I know I'm not going to get any police knocking on my door obviously, but it really goes against my morals. The Neighbour is well known for his sense of entitlement and back handers (eg, me and the other side paid to have dropped kerbs put in by the council, but he just bribed the workmen and got his front done for free). I work for the NHS and we're on our arse and it's people taking every opportunity to not pay tax that contributes. It's a real bugbear of mine.

Am I being unreasonable by refusing to ask the gardener for a fake invoice?

Or opinions on how I can explain this to my slightly intimidating neighbour? I don't feel confident because this might totally be me being an absolute wet-wipe and everyone else on the planet happily fleeces the tax man given the opportunity, and I shouldn't stand in his way. Ultimately good neighbour relations come first. I just don't know.

Thoughts?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
bringthecactusin · 09/02/2024 09:31

As it was tipping it down last night I didn't go over, and he didn't come knocking either.

I have downloaded his title register and it refers to letter T's (Thank you @LBOCS2!) on the plan but doesn't actually show them. However there has been an extra NB. paragraph added at the end which actually specifies its the Northern boundary.

So @Terrrence and @ilovebreadsauce , who decided I knew full well it was my responsibility and was out to fleece NDN and rip him off for half a fence while gleefully rubbing my hands together......its HIS boundary fence. I will still happily be paying half. Because that's what his girlfriend and I agreed.

OP posts:
LBOCS2 · 08/02/2024 21:21

The only way you can tell who owns or has responsibility for a boundary fence is if a) there are T marks on the plans, or b) you know who paid for it last time. Otherwise it's considered a shared boundary and you have equal responsibility to the boundary (not the fence). There's no obligation to fence in your land - although people like to - which is how you end up with two layers of fencing where someone has covered up their neighbour's crap decrepit fence by putting their own one up just on their side of the boundary.

If the neighbour's house was built in the last 40 years or so it may have T markings on the deeds but otherwise shared cost is the way most reasonable people sort it out.

Also, just tell your neighbour the gardener said no.

caringcarer · 08/02/2024 21:11

CaineRaine · 08/02/2024 13:54

Just say you want the paperwork to be correct in case of any future issues with the quality of the work done. You’ll have no comeback if the paperwork is for a different property.

Yes this. If a different address is on the invoice, even if the workman agreed to do this, there is no come back if the fence is not put up properly. I'd just say no you want correct paperwork.

randomusernam · 08/02/2024 20:09

I would just say the workman refused to change the invoice address as this is where the work was completed.

Feckedupbundle · 08/02/2024 20:03

I'm a gardener and I was asked to do something very similar once,for one of my regular customers. I refused as I wasn't willing to commit fraud to facilitate their greed. I think that they were surprised,but never mentioned it again.

WiddlinDiddlin · 08/02/2024 20:02

Surely the person doing the work supplies an invoice with the details of the work on it, including the address the work was carried out at.

So it arrives in your hand with the correct address on it, nothing to do with you, if NDN doesn't like it he can do his tax fraud on his own.

allthemiddlechildrenoftheworld · 08/02/2024 19:58

@bringthecactusin get someone to do it cash in hand! no tax for her to claim back

DRS1970 · 08/02/2024 19:49

Your neighbour is part of the reason why everyone needs to pay as much tax as they do. I think his suggestion is disgusting.

FuckinghellthatsUnbelievable · 08/02/2024 19:28

I’d ask gardener to put your/ neighbour address on invoice and forward them a copy. If he needs anything changed he can contact gardener who should refuse.

BobbyBiscuits · 08/02/2024 19:26

No way should you knowingly help generate a fake invoice, it's fraud.
If he was obsessed with ripping off some scheme then it should have been he who organised the gardener and thus ask him to invoice him how he wished. As a dishonest sounding landlord surely he has a network of dodgy folk working for him. You would have had no part in it. What an arrogant prick thinking others will happily help him do his dirty work. You have their half of the money, just pay the gardener and ignore this person's attitude.

chickenpieandchips · 08/02/2024 19:20

You can claim it on the rental as a repair or if not as a capital expense when you sell it. Depending if the fence is a dramatic improvement.
Can't claim anything in your own house, hence the invoice to the rental property.

Atethehalloweenchocs · 08/02/2024 18:25

He'll get 20-45% tax relief on the amount depending on his tax rate.

Can you claim if it is your main residence? Or only if it is a rental?

Nottodaythankyou123 · 08/02/2024 18:09

bringthecactusin · 08/02/2024 16:15

@Nottodaythankyou123 Cheers for that info. He bought the house off his parents - probably some inheritance tax dodge going on 🤣🤣 I'll buy his records. I know the £3 bit you can get instantly, but the 'wordy' bit I think is only by post. I'll see what I can find off his.

Yeah some older documents are only available via the post, they’re not electronically uploaded (it’s £3 per doc just in case you weren’t aware!). Bit of a red herring for this issue as you’ve agreed 50/50 but might be useful for future reference! I think it’s unlikely a gardener would agree to fudge the invoice to be fair - not a gardener (lawyer) but a client asked me to change an invoice address once and it was a firm no, triggered loads of internal reports and paperwork 😅

bringthecactusin · 08/02/2024 17:50

ilovebreadsauce · 08/02/2024 17:17

I think it will be ypu responsibility because your house would have been fenced in before his was even built.In that case it seems a bit churlish to expect him to oay half for a boundary that is your responsibility. You are a bit rich to be getting on your high horse about the tax, when you have ripped him off

I do not EXPECT them to pay half.

His ivy was getting overgrown on my side of the fence, and also growing up the side of my house. I got a gardener in to price up removal up, which I was paying for, and asked NDN to clear his side alley for access.

Girlfriend NDN mortified that THEIR ivy is affecting MY house and she's also fed up of it getting so overgrown on their side, and is warning him if it gets onto their new extension she'll strangle him. So she came over to ask garden man to price up getting the lot removed so their ivy won't be a recurring problem.

I have never EXPECTED them to pay anything. She said she would pay to get the ivy removed off my house, and it was ME who offered to pay half.

We know full well that the ivy is so strong its got braches like 3inch thick growing into and between the boards on the fence panels. We knew straight away that getting THEIR ivy removed would just leave a relic of something that USED to be a fence. So we just agreed while nattering in the garden to get a new fence too and go halves on that too. I've said I'm happy for them to have the posh side of the panels facing them because strange little me likes the support strut side more anyway.

How the hell have I ripped him off? If turns out it's actually THEIR fence would they be ripping ME off because they wanted it doing and I offered half?

OP posts:
ilovebreadsauce · 08/02/2024 17:17

I think it will be ypu responsibility because your house would have been fenced in before his was even built.In that case it seems a bit churlish to expect him to oay half for a boundary that is your responsibility. You are a bit rich to be getting on your high horse about the tax, when you have ripped him off

forrestgreen · 08/02/2024 17:05

'Sorry we'll need it as my address as it forms part of the guarantee'

MouseMama · 08/02/2024 16:48

I think you’re absolutely right not to be facilitating tax fraud. Too many people do it and then grumble on about big companies not paying their fair share.

bringthecactusin · 08/02/2024 16:41

NeverDropYourMooncup · 08/02/2024 16:29

'I asked the gardener and he said no. How's the drive going?'

Oh the hightlight of the driveway saga was when his workmen hit MY gas main running under HIS garden (where they were extending the drive over). They got Cadent gas board out who said it would have to be relaid under my own garden and sent a JCB round. Which broke so they had to get 3 lads to dig up my garden BY HAND to 2 foot down. Where they then uncovered my REAL gas main, and the one they'd hit next door was a capped off one. 🤦🏻‍♀️Garden subsequently filled in again. The joys of having a house so old the utilities aren't on anyone's maps!! Oh, and this was all on the same day a local hotel burnt down so we had no water because the fire brigade used all supplies in the area, and had power cuts, and no internet because the burning hotel was attached to the telephone exchange.

OP posts:
romdowa · 08/02/2024 16:31

Just tell him the gardener refused. Obviously after you've gotten your name and address on the invoice and it's in your possession.

NeverDropYourMooncup · 08/02/2024 16:29

'I asked the gardener and he said no. How's the drive going?'

bringthecactusin · 08/02/2024 16:28

Well already the comments and vote have reassured me it's not just me being overly square and boring. I think living alone, and dealing with so many workmen over the past month, and battling anxiety, then dealing with turnip headed Neighbour have made me doubt myself. I definitely now 100% won't be entertaining any fake invoices, and will feel confident enough to tell him that. I'll go straight over when I'm home so conversation is on his doorstep not him turning up on mine with whatever paperwork he said he'd bring round.

I'll check the land registry to find out for certain in the long term.

And I've also told the Ivy hedge removal man that in no way do I agree with this if NDN starts pestering him directly. It's cash to him and then bank transfer and invoice with the actual fance company. Ivy man is very clear in no way is he getting involved with any tax fraud. His girlfriend works for HMRC so he was not happy, but appreciated I'd made my stance clear to him.

OP posts:
FillFall · 08/02/2024 16:27

I don't know why people are so wooly about not knowing who owns the fences between theirs and their neighbours properties.

I've got 5 neighbours houses that back on to my back garden. I think most have them have tried to get me to pay for all the fences. I have happily paid for the ones I own. It's cost a few thousand so I'm buggered if I'm going to pay for anyone else's.

Aaron95 · 08/02/2024 16:24

If you are splitting the cost 50:50 then he is entitled to an invoice for his half. Either the gardener issues two invoices, each for half the amount or you can issue one to your neighbour for his share.

What he chooses to do with it after that is not your concern.

RadiatorHead · 08/02/2024 16:21

Just say you’re considering selling your house in the next 6 months and need receipts such as this.

Or…just say no.

bringthecactusin · 08/02/2024 16:15

@Nottodaythankyou123 Cheers for that info. He bought the house off his parents - probably some inheritance tax dodge going on 🤣🤣 I'll buy his records. I know the £3 bit you can get instantly, but the 'wordy' bit I think is only by post. I'll see what I can find off his.

OP posts: