Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Paying grandparents for childcare - Yes or No?

105 replies

Firsttimemumz · 08/02/2024 11:28

Context - grandparent is doing childcare for 3 days a week, sometimes 4 occasionally (around 10 hours a day)

Friend thinks paying grandparents for childcare is ridiculous, out of order that they’d even accept a penny. She said she would question if my child is a money making business for his grandparent.

I’m paying them £20 a day which in my eyes is very cheap for childcare. I offered this amount, so grandparent could buy themselves lunch etc if they go out with baby or if they want to treat themselves. Feel it’s good to pay, to show appreciation. Saving us hundreds a month. Grandparent more than happy with this, wouldn’t accept more.

Going to continue our arrangement but interested to know your views

OP posts:
Lizzieregina · 08/02/2024 12:59

I think £20 for a 10 hour day isn’t “paying” as that would cost $250 in my neck of the woods.

I do think grandparents should be paid if they’re essentially doing full time care, especially if they’ve given up their own paid work to provide this care.

A day a week to be nice/have relationship with LO would be all I’d be willing to do for nothing.

Iwasafool · 08/02/2024 12:55

If your parents were setting this up as a money making business they really aren't business minded. Up to 40 hrs care for £80, I mean that isn't even 20% of NMW. It is a nice idea to give them something for lunch or an outing, it is really paying them and as long as both parties are fine it isn't anyone else's business.

I think it is a good lesson that it isn't always a good idea to give "friends" too much information.

PictureALadybird · 08/02/2024 12:53

Your friend is right. I wouldn’t pay grandparents for looking after their own grandchildren.

It is a privilege, not a right. If you want to, that’s fine, but it isn’t “doing me a favour”. It’s fostering a relationship between the two of you.

I think it’s despicable any grandparent would accept money.

PBJsandwich123 · 08/02/2024 12:51

For context, I lost my parents in my 20s so only my (divorced) in-laws as grandparents. My mother in law thinks I'm marinating in inheritance money (an unfair and untrue assumption) so charges me for things she's never charge her other son's partner for or my partners ex's including childcare - I suppose that's her choice, but it makes me feel a bit sad that I'm just a bank account to her. For 6 hours childcare, she gets £60/day from me + all food her her plus kids + any money for activities, and I know my partner sneaks her some extra. Anyway for that she parks them in front of the TV and feeds them sweets (this drives me nuts), even though I'll make enough shepherds pie for her and them the night before. Wanted to keep my job, but I'm realising that getting affordable childcare is just not going to happen now - at least not where they get any sort of metal stimulation. Sorry for the rant. Your set up sounds good - I think £20 shows appreciation, and agree with you that it's a nice gesture - no one likes to feel used.

Maray1967 · 08/02/2024 12:51

Nothing wrong with paying or providing vouchers and treats instead. I think either are lovely thank yous - to not offer anything, unless your parents have insisted on being given nothing, is a bit cheeky, I think.

If grandparents are expecting the childminder or nursery going rate, they need to do more than put the TV on, though.

CurlewKate · 08/02/2024 12:49

20 quid a day is hardly a "money making business"!

Floralnomad · 08/02/2024 12:49

My mum looked after my eldest a couple of mornings a week and she wouldn’t have taken any money off me but we are the sort of family where you buy stuff for other people and don’t expect to get paid anyway IYSWIM . WRT the OP , it’s between you and your parent what you pay and nothing to do with your friends

Mumof2teens79 · 08/02/2024 12:49

Glittering1 · 08/02/2024 12:15

That's lot of hours for 20 quid a day. Your mother must be worn out.

My friends parents minded/minds her three children five days a week, school run, breakfast, lunch dinner and sleepovers. They pay them nothing. I think it's selfish and mean.

It's not selfish or mean if the grandparents are living comfortably and want to do it and the mother/parents need the cash for essentials.
Lots of grandparents/parents of adults give their children money through the year or pay for things....is accepting that selfish and mean?
In a lot of families you would just be passing money back and forth....here is £200 for last months childcare - OK well here is £200 to buy the kids new coats....or we'll look after the kids for free, you buy the coats.

Restinpeacefavouritecoathanger · 08/02/2024 12:47

We pay my in laws to be available. My mother in law had a morning job earning £370 a month we cover that monthly and she looks after our daughter for us four days a week usually for around 9ish hours. I'll be forever grateful to her for it, my daughter is happy with her mama and it doesn't tap us out too much.

Bbq1 · 08/02/2024 12:46

Personally, I don't agree with paying. However, my mum and dad wanted to look after my ds to help us and became they loved him so much. Mum and dad had ds for 3 days a week from when he was a year old, 4 days from 3 and then picked him up from school /nursery later on. Pils we're older so did some pick ups and had him for an afternoon /day within the time. My parents and pils would have been so offended if money had been mentioned for caring for their gs. They saw it as am absolute privilege certainly not a sacrifice of their healthy retired years. We were incredibly grateful but everyone benefitted as my ds and gp's had a wonderful relationship. He had a lovely time with them and has many fond memories. Still very close with my mum, sadly the only one still alive. We are very close as a family though. My mum still says those years were some of the best of her life. I think it's really mercenary for money to change hands unless it's absolutely necessary as in parents need the money to live. I don't really see how having a dv costs more unless you want to. Ds used to be have a great time shopping, going to parks and gardens, having a bit of lunch out, special things they did together I wouldn't want gp's caring for my child who saw it as a duty, sacrifice or paid work.

Firsttimemumz · 08/02/2024 12:44

Glittering1 · 08/02/2024 12:15

That's lot of hours for 20 quid a day. Your mother must be worn out.

My friends parents minded/minds her three children five days a week, school run, breakfast, lunch dinner and sleepovers. They pay them nothing. I think it's selfish and mean.

She wanted £10 but we got her to take the £20.

I do agree, that is mean. My friend is a bit like that, she expects her mum and MIL to do alternate days and pays them nothing and expects them to pay for his food. Which is why I wrote this AIBU.

OP posts:
Firsttimemumz · 08/02/2024 12:41

Thank you for everyone’s comments and perspectives

Maybe I shouldn’t of called it “childcare” can anyone educate on how I should label it that is better wording?

We send child with breakfast, lunch and dinner, toys etc so wouldn’t expect grandparent to pay for any food. No day trips out unless local as grandparent does not drive anymore.

Just to clarify, grandparent didn’t want more than £20. Wanted £10 max but we are giving more.

OP posts:
Laiste · 08/02/2024 12:37

Glittering1 · 08/02/2024 12:15

That's lot of hours for 20 quid a day. Your mother must be worn out.

My friends parents minded/minds her three children five days a week, school run, breakfast, lunch dinner and sleepovers. They pay them nothing. I think it's selfish and mean.

Yeah we have someone in the family who barely saw their own kids growing up. The GP virtually raised them. Driving over at silly o'clock to give breakfast and drive them to school. Drive over for school pick up, take them home, homework, food, then drive them home in the evening. Years and years of it.

Plus whole weekends while parent trained for their Very Important hobby ...

It's all gone down in history as 'helping the parent keep their career'. Hours and hours of childcare. Their own rooms at the GPs. Fair enough i suppose, but one of the GP had very bad health through much of this and i wouldn't have put upon my mum as much as this person did. The rest of the family managed to raise their own kids - and chose to spend weekends with them. Because, you know, they're their kids!
<anyway rant over>

madderthanahatter · 08/02/2024 12:27

£20 for a ten hour day isn't being paid, it's just covering costs and absolutely should be done when free childcare is given.

phoenixrosehere · 08/02/2024 12:26

As long as both parties are happy with the arrangement, it is no one else’s business but those involved so you aren’t being unreasonable.

Some grandparents would want to be paid, some wouldn’t want to be, but would like the offer, and some would find the notion to be paid for having their grandchild/grandchildren ridiculous.

WithACatLikeTread · 08/02/2024 12:17

Your friend sounds like a cheeky F.

Glittering1 · 08/02/2024 12:15

That's lot of hours for 20 quid a day. Your mother must be worn out.

My friends parents minded/minds her three children five days a week, school run, breakfast, lunch dinner and sleepovers. They pay them nothing. I think it's selfish and mean.

MabelMaybe · 08/02/2024 12:06

It used to be that anyone receiving pay for childcare had to be OFSTED registered. Not sure if this has changed.

Mishmaj · 08/02/2024 12:04

Isn’t it obvious that each family will
need to make different decisions based on their financial situation, values and lifestyles? I see no problem with GPs being paid full whack (Vs eg nanny) if that’s what works for the family. Or doing it for free if they don’t need the cash and enjoy the extra time with the kids.
It’s very weird and overly judgemental to have povs on other people’s setups unless the GP are being exploited or the kids aren’t being looked after properly. Your friend is out of order but just accept that she has a different perspective, which is fair enough, for her.
Our first was looked after by GPs one day a week for a couple of years, they didn’t want payment as they enjoyed being a closer part of the family. That was a long time ago and these days they might keep an eye over an odd weekend or evening but that’s it. My MIL is retired now and is making good use of her time doing things she wants to do for herself! I’ll probably be her age by the time mine have any kids (if they even do this!) and if I have no money I wouldn’t hesitate to ask for it if doing childcare meant that I couldn’t earn my own but if I have spare ££ then I would do it for free. Tbh it’s far more likely that I will be too old and decrepit to help out at all, unfortunately.

Mumof2teens79 · 08/02/2024 11:57

It entirely depends on the individual families.
Some will have quite wealthy grandparents with loads of time looking to help out and keep busy, while the parents themselves may be struggling.
Others will have grandparents that have given up work to try to help with the childcare and so don't have spare cash.

My parents wouldn't have taken any money but they are quite well often on their pensions and would always pay if we go out as a family fir example, where as we are usually close to the limit by pay day...but we did pay for full time childcare and only used them as back up and wrap around.

To4ornotto4 · 08/02/2024 11:54

I think it's great too are doing this. It means they are covered for food and trips out and they feel appreciated. It's a huge commitment they are offering, and you would pay far more elsewhere. Great decision OP.

Laiste · 08/02/2024 11:54

I wonder if a lot of these suggested amounts from GPs are designed to be declined 😂

Thing is, when you've done your years child rearing and those children have kids of their own, it's nice to help out. But if you're being asked to do child care for financial reasons (parents can't afford professional fees) then why shouldn't a nod to that be part of the package?

''Mum we can't afford the £80 a day child care, but wondered if you could look after little X and we'll give you 20 or so towards it? I get to go out and earn a whole day's wage and keep my career afloat, instead of being at home with him/her, and it compensates you for tying yourself down x days a week caring for x.''

Looking after a child in order that the parent can go to work is quite a big comittment. You can't just blow out if you don't feel like it or fancy doing something else because someone's day at work is reliant on you stepping up.

VivaVivaa · 08/02/2024 11:52

I would absolutely offer money for this amount of childcare. Ad hoc days here and there maybe not, but over half their week I definitely would.

MamPadi · 08/02/2024 11:51

I didn't pay my parents when they looked after my kids (1 day a week then school pickups as they got older), but they didn't need the money and wouldn't have accepted it (i know I'm very lucky). However if paying them a small amount to cover snacks, fuel and activities with the kids means the difference between them being able to do things with the kids rather than just stay at home then definitely you should pay, I would have in that situation, it's still way cheaper than nursery fees

FuckinghellthatsUnbelievable · 08/02/2024 11:51

I think there is a difference between paying market rates and a token payment to cover expenses.

Its odd to begrudge covering expenses and possibly the odd treat like cake and a coffee.