Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To not be a guarantor for my sister

362 replies

PinkShimmerSparkle · 08/02/2024 11:15

Even though this means they and their 3 children might become homeless.
My DSis and her DH are not fantastic with money, I always assumed that they made sure that bills, mortgage etc were paid and all their nights out and their regular purchases of new technology, holidays etc were bought from disposable income but in hindsight it is obvious that they were always spending beyond their means, this is none of my business and I absolutely would never get involved or say anything.
They have both been working until recently when her DH left his job, she tells me that they have missed one mortgage payment and have now been issued an eviction notice.
They are looking at renting but everything requires a guarantor and she has asked me and DH to be one, as she knows we both earn and can save every month, but this is only because we are careful with what we spend.
I have said no but feel bad that they might become homeless.
AIBU?

OP posts:
PropertyManager · 08/02/2024 17:51

I'll echo what others have said, never be a guarantor.

And the mortgage, the lender would, as others and your friend have said, only go for re-possession as the last resort - they have to go to court for a reposession, process takes months, so they must be hopelessly behind, made no attempt to address the situation or come to an arrangement.

I'm afraid you will end up in the poop yourself if you sign as guarantor.

Leafpicker2000 · 08/02/2024 17:50

I would never be a guarantor for anyone except our kids for their student housing.

You may end up on the hook not only for missed payments but also interest/charges/legal fees/debt collection fees.

If you choose to help anyone it's better to make a direct payment to the lender or whoever (just don't expect it ever to be repaid and decide if that's ok for you).

Blogswife · 08/02/2024 17:49

She is lying to you , she wouldn’t get evicted for missing one mortgage payment . I would imagine that they are in significant arrears
If you don’t want to or can’t afford to bail her out then tell her that you couldn’t afford to cover her rent arrears if they defaulted again which means you would not be a suitable guarantor.

Whatayear2023 · 08/02/2024 17:47

If they have to sell their home surely they get some money from this...then this can be put towards advance rent thus not needing a guarantee... it seems like they haven't been keeping up to date and got themselves in a pickle. Which unless you loaded even a grand or two won't really help.... they need to get proper financial advice if it was my sister I would offer to help by making appointment going with her etc you can help in other ways that's more beneficial than money long term xx

DamnUserName21 · 08/02/2024 17:44

As someone who has had guarantors (family members) for renting, you've made the right decision, OP. Honesty, trust and reliability are essential in such a dynamic.
I wouldn't dream of leaving my family members in the shit and they know this.

SheepAndSword · 08/02/2024 17:44

Something is not right here!

DriftingDora · 08/02/2024 17:44

GasPanic · 08/02/2024 14:08

Judging by what you say about the circumstances there is no way in hell I would agree to this.

It is just asking for trouble.

Maybe if it were me I would try to make some excuse to soften the blow. Like say I couldn't do it because not sure of employment status or maybe my mortgage holders won't let me or I have a big loan myself or something of that nature. But if they are truly desperate I would expect them to come back and pressurize you on that.

Maybe if it were me I would try to make some excuse to soften the blow.

Why?

Ilovelifeverymuch · 08/02/2024 17:43

Justme2023123 · 08/02/2024 11:18

You can't be evicted if you're a home owner, and I doubt their mortgage company would start legal proceedings over 1 missed payment either. So either they've missed a lot more than one payment or there's something else going on.

Either way YANBU to say no to being a guarantor.

Yes you can be evicted as a home owner if you're not paying your mortgage but not after just 1 missed payment. It will take a few months before they can evict you.

LeilaDarling · 08/02/2024 17:41

In the current climate it would only be going to eviction status after a year - 18 months so she is definitely not telling the truth. Nevertheless and no matter what please don’t become a guarantor. It won’t end well for you.

RatatouillePie · 08/02/2024 17:40

@PinkShimmerSparkle

Firstly, she is LYING!

No mortgage company issues an eviction after ONE missed mortgage payment. She clearly thinks you were born yesterday!

Mortgage companies won't usually take action unless at least 3 payments have been missed, and then they won't evict - they will attempt to set up a payment plan.

Secondly, do NOT even consider being a guarantor for her! Especially as she clearly isn't being honest with you about their finances.

Do they not have any equity in their home?

DriftingDora · 08/02/2024 17:38

Caroparo52 · 08/02/2024 15:51

If you feel you want to help but not be trapped permanently as guarantor, there are other options.
If they are genuinely homeless then you could offer to pay for short term rental for 3 months (directly to the landlord).
Make it clear this is a one off during which time they sort out their financial mess.
But then they may be back to square one again but your conscience is clear .

So also saying goodbye to three months rental money? Yeah, sounds like a plan 'cos they're SUCH responsible people....🙄

SheepAndSword · 08/02/2024 17:37

Tattletwat · 08/02/2024 17:29

But if the person he was a guarantor didn't pay. He would have been liable.

I'm sure many guarantor relationships go off without a hitch, but many don't and ruin family's and friendships.

Oh we'd just moved back from abroad and initially got temp jobs before we moved into permanent roles which was why we needed a guarantor for rent. Completely understand why my father looked at the rent agreement a bit hesitantly before he signed.

@PinkShimmerSparkle it really doesn't sound like a good idea to vouchsafe for a mortgage and not sure they're being clear with you. Talk to her.

Luckyduc · 08/02/2024 17:34

Laws changed in England....not a legal requirement anymore.

Avatartar · 08/02/2024 17:31

Your DH sounds lovely and has it spot on. Re you feeling guilty - that’s only because you let them make you feel guilty. The only guilt would be if you did step in with £ because they’d learn nothing about changing their habits and you’d be robbing your own DH/DCS- disengage and dont enable your DSsis. Interesting that BIL who doesn’t like working appears to have wracked at least some of the debt up - don’t be his slave!!!

AcrossthePond55 · 08/02/2024 17:30

@PinkShimmerSparkle

Your DH sounds like a real mensch!

Although we know we can handle anything, there are times it's good to have a person who can step in and see a situation with 'clearer eyes' than our own and speak more forcefully that we feel comfortable speaking.

BobbyBiscuits · 08/02/2024 17:30

No way should you. And as others say they can't be booted out easily, and not over one missed payment. So they are lying about their level of debt, which is a huge red flag.

Tattletwat · 08/02/2024 17:29

SheepAndSword · 08/02/2024 17:08

My father acted as guarantor years back for renting - it was only a slight formality and never came to anything. Just needed sig done as they'd asked for it.

Can't understand why anyone would ever ask that about a mortgage, doesn't seem right.

But if the person he was a guarantor didn't pay. He would have been liable.

I'm sure many guarantor relationships go off without a hitch, but many don't and ruin family's and friendships.

ThirtyThrillionThreeTrees · 08/02/2024 17:26

I posted earlier but only quickly.

I used to work in debt recovery many moon ago and not in the UK.

In my opinion it falls into 4 categories:

  1. Genuine cases - usually an unplanned event, job loss, divorce, sickness or leaving job because of a child's illness - these people work with you, are very forthcoming with information and suggestionswith what thry can manage to pay & come to arrangements for certain periods and honour them & it usually works well and thry end up back on track.

  2. Bad with money but wish they weren't- again usually get back on track with some micro management and it's a 50/50 shot on whether they'll end up in the position again.

  3. Bad with money and couldn't give a hoot - head in the sand & long finger approach & usually end up a situation like your sister where if they had approached things differently ir wouldn't get do Bad

  4. Strategic defaulters- think they'll get a write off or something

Categories 1 will typically do anything they can to avoid the guarantee being called in and they don't want their problem to be the guarantor's problem.

Categories 2, and especially 3&4 are morally bankrupt and the distane with which they treated the guarantor never stopped surprising me. "Ask them they've loads of money, sure 50k to them is like a tenner to me etc. Genuinely couldn't give a fuck if the guarantor lost money. I hated these cases.

Your sister falls into the latter category and there's no way in hell that the first payment resulted in a real eviction threat.

Just no, absolute no. Help in several other ways but not financially.

Klcak · 08/02/2024 17:26

Rent could cost more than mortgage
plus the obvious lies about one missed month

you’ll have to steer well clear

Tracker1234 · 08/02/2024 17:22

I know how difficult it is when its a sibling but she has already lied to you regarding why she is being evicted. Could you say to her that no one gets evicted after missing one payment... she what she says but its a no from me as she doesnt seem to have any difficulty fibbing to you and she will carry on once you are the guarantor. If they are being 'evicted' is there any equity in the property?

There are huge amount of people who have no idea how to budget. They get paid and they spend their wages enoying themselves and whoops - never mind about the mortgage....

Quite honestly they are probably up to their eyes in debt

Maray1967 · 08/02/2024 17:09

Yes, you would be risking your own family’s security if you acted as guarantor. We will only do it for our own DC at uni as we know what we’re liable for and it’s time limited. No way would I do it for an irresponsible relative or friend.

SheepAndSword · 08/02/2024 17:08

My father acted as guarantor years back for renting - it was only a slight formality and never came to anything. Just needed sig done as they'd asked for it.

Can't understand why anyone would ever ask that about a mortgage, doesn't seem right.

DriftingDora · 08/02/2024 17:02

Don't do it, OP. As said by others, this is more than one missed payment, so you're not even being told the truth here. You will never get the money back and then there will be more than one household with financial problems.

Daffodilsandsunshine · 08/02/2024 16:52

With their track record don't be a guarantor and dragged into their money problems but be prepared that they may press your DPs to help them "for the grandkids".

Why did he "leave" his job?

DHs 60yo brother is similarly feckless - champagne lifestyle on beer money, and he has never saved for a rainy day. If he's got it he spends it (but his XW controlled his finances so they were in less debt then). Since his last divorce we reckon he's been living on tick as neither he nor his new GF are working. I've reluctantly loaned him money once to be repaid when his house sells but won't be repeating that for sure.

Couldyounot · 08/02/2024 16:48

The informal definition of a guarantor is "a fool with a pen" and it certainly holds good here.

As others have said, no way she's missed just one payment

Edit: just seen your updates. Spot on. Well done 👏🏻

Swipe left for the next trending thread