Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To not be a guarantor for my sister

362 replies

PinkShimmerSparkle · 08/02/2024 11:15

Even though this means they and their 3 children might become homeless.
My DSis and her DH are not fantastic with money, I always assumed that they made sure that bills, mortgage etc were paid and all their nights out and their regular purchases of new technology, holidays etc were bought from disposable income but in hindsight it is obvious that they were always spending beyond their means, this is none of my business and I absolutely would never get involved or say anything.
They have both been working until recently when her DH left his job, she tells me that they have missed one mortgage payment and have now been issued an eviction notice.
They are looking at renting but everything requires a guarantor and she has asked me and DH to be one, as she knows we both earn and can save every month, but this is only because we are careful with what we spend.
I have said no but feel bad that they might become homeless.
AIBU?

OP posts:
Atethehalloweenchocs · 08/02/2024 19:27

DH received a message back saying stay out of this, it’s between me and Pink, she has sent me a handful of messages and tried to call. I have not answered any of this

True colours showing I think. Glad you have such good support from your OH.

PinkShimmerSparkle · 08/02/2024 19:26

DH received a message back saying stay out of this, it’s between me and Pink, she has sent me a handful of messages and tried to call. I have not answered any of this.

It does involve DH, he is the higher earner and even if he wasn’t I would never sign up to something like that without his agreement. We have a joint account as well as individual accounts but essentially all money is family money.

He has insisted on having a chippy tea tonight as he knows my head is all over the place and I hate cooking at the best of time, he can’t cook so doesn’t attempt but happily does the clearing up.

OP posts:
Debtfreegoals · 08/02/2024 19:24

Signpost them to a debt charity like stepchange. There’s not a lot of truth to her story

Kipepeo · 08/02/2024 19:23

People have lost their home out of kindness to a relative. Hard decision but the right one.

moomoomoo27 · 08/02/2024 19:21

Your DH sounds great. Totally agree with his stance. Also, one payment is pointless as obviously they're behind by a lot more and would keep asking you for a lot more.

Unfortunately sometimes the best way to help people is to not be an enabler for them.

TheDogdidGood · 08/02/2024 19:20

YANBU I have a friend who is thousands of dollars in debt through doing this.

fuchsteufelswild · 08/02/2024 19:15

You handled this really well and you made the right decision OP, if you had given in you would feel much worse about it and it would lead to a bigger mess in the long run. Perhaps this is the shot across the bow they needed

Reugny · 08/02/2024 19:00

GasPanic · 08/02/2024 17:56

Because I value my relationships with some people, even if I'm not impressed by the way they run their finances.

The OP has a poor relationship with her sister and her parents.

So causing a feud over lending her sister unlimited amounts of money by being her guarantor isn't going to improve that relationship.

DriftingDora · 08/02/2024 19:00

GasPanic · 08/02/2024 18:15

How do you know the relationship is worthless or one way, or will continue to be in the future ?

There are more qualities and aspects to the relationships I have with people than just how good they are at juggling money.

I wouldn't "sub the feckless" but neither would I be abrupt in the way I refused help either.

I have relationships with people who I consider financially imprudent but I know I am going to have to work together with in the future to resolve various issues - keeping that relationship well maintained to me has value. Pissing it away for the somewhat dubious benefit of being abrupt doesn't.

Pissing it away for the somewhat dubious benefit of being abrupt doesn't.

Congratulations. 😁

beatrix1234 · 08/02/2024 18:58

If she can't afford her mortgage what makes you think she's going to afford rent? Unless of course her rent is going to be half of her mortgage which I doubt as rents as expensive.

Kipepeo · 08/02/2024 18:55

I am glad you have decided not to.

Viviennemary · 08/02/2024 18:47

You absolutely should not do this. It is unlikely they are being evicted after one missed mortgage payment. If they can't afford the mortgage it's unlikely they will afford rent. It would be utter madness to go guarantor for them.

viques · 08/02/2024 18:41

I think mostmortgage companies will try to connect with defaulters to work out a way to keep the agreement alive, especially if the mortgage holders are normally good payers, clearly this has not been the case here which begs the question why, and I bet the answer doesn’t involve a single missed payment.

Branleuse · 08/02/2024 18:28

Tell them you can't, you love her but won't tie yourself financially to her.
Either that or tell her you've got a bad credit rating so can't help. Suggest she goes to citizen advice

Containerhome · 08/02/2024 18:19

No no no. We where a guarantor for rent for DHs brother. His wife left him. He stopped paying the rent. They didn't pursue him for it and we ended up in court and lumbered with the debt

maddening · 08/02/2024 18:19

You don't get an eviction notice from missing one mortgage payment - it is a v long road to get to that point.

Idontgiveashitanymore · 08/02/2024 18:17

Please don’t do it .

GasPanic · 08/02/2024 18:15

DriftingDora · 08/02/2024 18:06

Well, anyone who is happy to sub the feckless on the grounds of maintaining a purely one-way worthless relationship is welcome to crack on.

How do you know the relationship is worthless or one way, or will continue to be in the future ?

There are more qualities and aspects to the relationships I have with people than just how good they are at juggling money.

I wouldn't "sub the feckless" but neither would I be abrupt in the way I refused help either.

I have relationships with people who I consider financially imprudent but I know I am going to have to work together with in the future to resolve various issues - keeping that relationship well maintained to me has value. Pissing it away for the somewhat dubious benefit of being abrupt doesn't.

DelphiniumBlue · 08/02/2024 18:10

Given what you say about your own finances I'd be surprised if you were approved as a guarantor anyway... as I understand it, your income would need to be sufficient to cover your own costs and their rent.
Just say sorry, you can't afford it.

CharlotteStreetW1 · 08/02/2024 18:07

Well done your DH! And well done you for hanging back.

My sister was a guarantor for a loan her daughter took out (no doubt to cover other debts). Suffice to say my sister paid back the whole loan as daughter reneged on every single payment.

DriftingDora · 08/02/2024 18:06

GasPanic · 08/02/2024 17:56

Because I value my relationships with some people, even if I'm not impressed by the way they run their finances.

Well, anyone who is happy to sub the feckless on the grounds of maintaining a purely one-way worthless relationship is welcome to crack on.

Gettingbysomehow · 08/02/2024 17:59

If it was just my sister I would but if a DH is involved then no way. He doesn't care if you end up paying the rent.

StopStartStop · 08/02/2024 17:57

The trouble with being a guarantor is that you end up for other people's debts. You are wise to say no.

GasPanic · 08/02/2024 17:56

DriftingDora · 08/02/2024 17:44

Maybe if it were me I would try to make some excuse to soften the blow.

Why?

Because I value my relationships with some people, even if I'm not impressed by the way they run their finances.

Tattletwat · 08/02/2024 17:54

Whatayear2023 · 08/02/2024 17:47

If they have to sell their home surely they get some money from this...then this can be put towards advance rent thus not needing a guarantee... it seems like they haven't been keeping up to date and got themselves in a pickle. Which unless you loaded even a grand or two won't really help.... they need to get proper financial advice if it was my sister I would offer to help by making appointment going with her etc you can help in other ways that's more beneficial than money long term xx

If they are getting evicted by the bank, it will be the bank selling the home. There is also no guarantee there is any equity in the house aswell and the house may be sold for less or similar to the mortgage amount, the bank won't be looking to make a profit just get their money back. Any shortfalls after the house is sold the sister would still be liable for.