Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To not be a guarantor for my sister

362 replies

PinkShimmerSparkle · 08/02/2024 11:15

Even though this means they and their 3 children might become homeless.
My DSis and her DH are not fantastic with money, I always assumed that they made sure that bills, mortgage etc were paid and all their nights out and their regular purchases of new technology, holidays etc were bought from disposable income but in hindsight it is obvious that they were always spending beyond their means, this is none of my business and I absolutely would never get involved or say anything.
They have both been working until recently when her DH left his job, she tells me that they have missed one mortgage payment and have now been issued an eviction notice.
They are looking at renting but everything requires a guarantor and she has asked me and DH to be one, as she knows we both earn and can save every month, but this is only because we are careful with what we spend.
I have said no but feel bad that they might become homeless.
AIBU?

OP posts:
SequentialAnalyst · 08/02/2024 21:57

Please don't be tempted to make one last reply.

In situations like this, it is the better part of valour to let the antagonist have the last word.

CJsGoldfish · 08/02/2024 21:56

There are more qualities and aspects to the relationships I have with people than just how good they are at juggling money
I 'get' what you're saying and I would be the same in certain situations.

I wouldn't "sub the feckless" but neither would I be abrupt in the way I refused help either
What I wouldn't do is start a post for the purpose of feeling superior about a family member who could very well identify themselves from such a post with all the 'new technology' they are constantly purchasing whilst spending all the 'disposable income' I innocently 'assumed' they had 🫢
Took a long time and a lot of, almost gleeful, derision before we learnt that you obviously don't like her and don't have a relationship with her anyway. And this thread is passive aggressive enough without sending an unnecessary pa message as one poster suggested. Don't do that.

Your DH has stepped in to save the day so now all you need to do is block and move on. Job done. It's not like you were ever really going to consider doing it. Who would? Not me. Not a single person on this thread. As the 'better sister', time to rise above and not engage any further

Puzzledandpissedoff · 08/02/2024 21:50

DH received a message back saying stay out of this

Sadly I'm not at all surprised. Clearly your brilliant DH has the best handle on this - no disrespect OP, but he doesn't have the same emotional involvement with her as you do - so naturally she'd rather target the one she considers most likely to bend

Be prepared for messages about "her kids suffering", but also know you're doing exactly the right thing

slore · 08/02/2024 21:44

PinkShimmerSparkle · 08/02/2024 15:36

DH is in agreement with all of you. He says he had asked a friend of his who’s other half/sibling works as a mortgage advisor (I think). They said it is definitely a lot more than one missed payment and repossession is the absolute last resort for any lender.

We will not be giving them anything and he reminded me why we are very low contact with my family.

He is non confrontational but has now sent my sister a message, stating that we will not be helping them out and they need to seek help from all the agencies out there that are trained in this. He also said that we are only in a financially stable position now, after many years of sacrifice while our children were small. They have spent many years being frivolous with money and should have done something sooner to help themselves. We are not responsible for digging them out of the hole that they created and all future communication about this will be met with silence from us.

He has asked me not to respond to anything to do with this so that they get the message.

I am hoping that will be it now.

This was a terrible message to be honest.

It's brilliant that he's setting strong boundaries, but openly judging them (correctly - but no good can come of this) will do nothing but hurt them and damage your relationship with them. It was unnecessary and will cause you more problems in your life, this time personal problems between you and your sister. And this message will definitely get back to your parents who will take sides.

He should have just said "we will not be helping you out and you need to seek help from all the agencies out there that are trained in this. All future communication about this will be met with silence from us." That was sufficient and not offensive.

I totally understand your sister and BIL deserve to be called out for trying to trick you into being dragged down into their self-inflicted financial ruin - but in reality there is no way of doing this without scorching the earth.

venusandmars · 08/02/2024 21:37

@PinkShimmerSparkle your dh is right. You have done so much, so well, to move on from your past. I'm glad you have such a supportive dh. Treasure each other.

anothernewstart9 · 08/02/2024 21:28

You have definitely made the right decision. A friend lost her entire savings and ended up with a county court judgement against her name because the family member she had acted as a guarantor for couldn't/wouldn't pay their bills. Going forward, I would respectfully suggest a period of no contact with your sister.

LadyBird1973 · 08/02/2024 20:52

How is it not your DH's business? It's his money too! She would be happy for his money to help bail her out, but thinks he's not entitled to an opinion? Shows you what her attitude would be like down the line if she defaulted on rent.

DeeLusional · 08/02/2024 20:37

AcrossthePond55 · 08/02/2024 20:34

@PinkShimmerSparkle

I think I'd message her "This issue certainly does involve DH because that's the way our marriage works. We make all financial decisions together and the two of us have made the joint decision not to be your guarantor. So you need to drop it. If you don't I will have to strongly consider blocking you. I may also have to consider calling our parents and letting them know your situation".

The last would be an empty threat, if I were you I wouldn't do it. But I would block her if she doesn't drop it.

Nah, OP's DH's request to not engage any more is the only sensible option.

AcrossthePond55 · 08/02/2024 20:34

@PinkShimmerSparkle

I think I'd message her "This issue certainly does involve DH because that's the way our marriage works. We make all financial decisions together and the two of us have made the joint decision not to be your guarantor. So you need to drop it. If you don't I will have to strongly consider blocking you. I may also have to consider calling our parents and letting them know your situation".

The last would be an empty threat, if I were you I wouldn't do it. But I would block her if she doesn't drop it.

Iloveacurry · 08/02/2024 20:19

Well done op. You’ve done the right thing.

Kipepeo · 08/02/2024 20:04

Fair point @DeeLusional . Family and money is so tricky.

DeeLusional · 08/02/2024 19:59

Kipepeo · 08/02/2024 19:48

The only reason to tell the parents would be to forewarn them if the sister ever asks them to become guarantor. This would however destroy the relationship.
Tough call.

That's not the only reason. The other reason is to let them know in advance that OP and her DH will not be getting involved and will not communicate any more on the subject. OP doesn't have a good relationship her parents anyway and thinks that sooner or later the parents will be in touch to try to persuade them to be guarantors. Hence, knock it on the head now.

Kipepeo · 08/02/2024 19:52

@strawberrysalsa exactly, it is very fishy. One more reason not to trust the sister.
The article is here, and the section
https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/business-63486782# and the section @strawberrysalsa refers to says:
"Could I lose my home?
Some people may decide to sell their home and - in extreme circumstances - the lender could take court action to repossess it.
Repossessions are far rarer than they used to be.
There are several stages before a lender can do this, and the whole process takes about two years."

Woman looking at bills

Mortgages: What happens if I am struggling to pay?

Many homeowners are worried about higher mortgage costs, but lenders must help those struggling.

https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/business-63486782#

Crumpleton · 08/02/2024 19:50

Wow, your Dsis really is one isn’t she.
I can imagine she was hoping you'd keep it quiet and not tell your DH.
Does she honestly believe you'd go or are going to go behind his back and hand over lord knows how much money because there's no way it would be 'a just this once' payment.

I really don't think you'd have much to lose if you ignore her and she trounced off, her and her DH are the only one's that are, if it even does happen, be at blame for being homeless.

Kipepeo · 08/02/2024 19:48

The only reason to tell the parents would be to forewarn them if the sister ever asks them to become guarantor. This would however destroy the relationship.
Tough call.

strawberrysalsa · 08/02/2024 19:47

There is an article on the BBC News online site currently about 'What happens if I can afford my mortgage'.

According to the article it is a long process to repossess a house and takes about 2 years. Your sister is lying...as you already know.

Janelle7 · 08/02/2024 19:47

No nope no way

BigFatCat2024 · 08/02/2024 19:45

I think it was the same baliff programme as @TruJay which means I will never be a guarantor for someone, unless I would happily pay their rent for them. That parent/step parent had tried to do a nice thing, never expecting that they would actually be saddled with a load of debt

I know we'd all like to think the best of our family, but your sister clearly not beyond lying as there is no way that they'd be losing their house for one missed payment. On that basis alone I wouldn't trust them to pay the rent

DeeLusional · 08/02/2024 19:43

So far, so good. But I think it's a mistake to not inform your parents that your sister has approached you to be a guarantor for rent, that you will not be doing this. and that you will not be communicating further on this matter. Sounds like DH will back you up if necessary. Make that clear now, and then when they contact you about it, all you have to do is - NOTHING. Otherwise there will still be that hanging over your head, waiting for it to fall. Lance the boil.

Vimtoribena · 08/02/2024 19:38

Unfortunately she’s going to have to learn the hard way, that living/ spending beyond your means, has consequences. If you bail her out now, they will just continue to be frivolous.. and if you help them once they may well expect it every time. A sad situation to be in - especially for their kids, but one that could’ve been avoided.

Moier · 08/02/2024 19:34

Takes about 12 months or more for an eviction notice after their lender has taken them to court.
There is a lot more going on here..

InkySplott · 08/02/2024 19:31

TruJay · 08/02/2024 11:24

I would never be a guarantor for anyone.
I once watched a bailiff programme where parents had been guarantors for their eldest daughter (they had younger children at home too) and the bailiffs showed up to take all their stuff as eldest daughter had stopped paying rent. They rang eldest daughter and she was horrible and just said something to the effect of ‘not my problem, it’s your debt now!’ And hung up!

The younger siblings were crying saying ‘she always does this! She ruins everything’ it was a bloody horrible watch and I always felt so sad for that family.

You can love your family members and obviously want to help them but not at the sacrifice of your own security.

Wasn't it the step dad that stood guarantor in that programme? I think it was a 10k debt she ran up . I felt so sorry for him .

GasPanic · 08/02/2024 19:29

Reugny · 08/02/2024 19:00

The OP has a poor relationship with her sister and her parents.

So causing a feud over lending her sister unlimited amounts of money by being her guarantor isn't going to improve that relationship.

I didn't say anywhere that she should. Read my OP.

Jellybean23 · 08/02/2024 19:29

No matter how bad the relationship with your sister becomes because of your refusal to be a guarantor, it is nothing to how bad it would be if she embroiled you in their financial mess.

She isn't telling you the whole truth, they haven't been wise with their money and they never will learn if other people bail them out.

You and DH are doing exactly the right thing. Stay strong.

Reugny · 08/02/2024 19:28

DH received a message back saying stay out of this, it’s between me and Pink, she has sent me a handful of messages and tried to call. I have not answered any of this.

OP you now need to block your sister on all devices you can.

Also see if you can block private numbers on your mobile phone. (Make sure you learn how to do it as you will need to unblock for calls from the GP. )

If you think you need to also block your parents.

They can all contact you through your DH if necessary.

Edited to say - Blocking them isn't permanent is only for a couple of months.