Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To not be a guarantor for my sister

362 replies

PinkShimmerSparkle · 08/02/2024 11:15

Even though this means they and their 3 children might become homeless.
My DSis and her DH are not fantastic with money, I always assumed that they made sure that bills, mortgage etc were paid and all their nights out and their regular purchases of new technology, holidays etc were bought from disposable income but in hindsight it is obvious that they were always spending beyond their means, this is none of my business and I absolutely would never get involved or say anything.
They have both been working until recently when her DH left his job, she tells me that they have missed one mortgage payment and have now been issued an eviction notice.
They are looking at renting but everything requires a guarantor and she has asked me and DH to be one, as she knows we both earn and can save every month, but this is only because we are careful with what we spend.
I have said no but feel bad that they might become homeless.
AIBU?

OP posts:
seafoamgreenhair · 10/02/2024 21:53

Iwasafool · 10/02/2024 12:11

My husband's uncle refused to be a guarantor for DHs mother mother. She was a war widow with a very comfortable pension (not British pension and considerably more generous.) DH was at school and she also had a fulltime job. She was offered her council house for peanuts but as a woman in the 50s or 60s couldn't get a mortgage without a male guarantor.

It would have made such a difference to her life, it would have been paid off in a few years but she was still paying rent for 40 years. She was no risk, it would have meant security for his only nephew who never knew his father. I think it was spiteful.

Why are you sidetracking this thread with your sad story? It has zero relevance to OP's situation - which is about someone who is very deeply in debt, is bad with money, and who has lied to the person they want to go guarantor.

DriftingDora · 10/02/2024 18:36

Iwasafool · 10/02/2024 15:36

She was getting a maximum discount which I think was 60%, even in a fire sale they'd have got more than 40% of the value of the house never mind the fact she had savings so would have been borrowing about 25% of the value of the house and the mortgage would have been less than the rent.

It was no risk to him and he wouldn't have done anything to help anyone, family members who lost money because of him would confirm that. His own son was still at school at the time but he didn't approve of his son getting married and having children and certainly wouldn't have been inclined to support that in anyway. He wouldn't even give you a lift if he was passing where you needed to go.

Like I said you don't know the individuals involved.

Edited

It's extremely likely that nobody on here will know the persons concerned, so what is your point? Is it that you just want everyone to agree that he was a nasty man? It was a completely different time, and there was enormous prejudice against working women/women trying to buy property, as well as zero job security - people were chucked out of jobs with no redress in law, not to mention the fact that he might have had other reasons for saying 'no' to your relation. He might have needed the money - his own money, after all - for something else? I can't see why you would be snarky about somebody deciding how to spend their own money, even if it was years ago.

SomeCatFromJapan · 10/02/2024 16:57

No what I'm describing is helping family.

I'd expect the OP to prioritise her own immediate family, her children, well ahead of her feckless, spendthrift sister who will almost certainly cost her thousands and ruin her credit rating.

Treesandsheepeverywhere · 10/02/2024 16:41

Iwasafool · 10/02/2024 15:36

She was getting a maximum discount which I think was 60%, even in a fire sale they'd have got more than 40% of the value of the house never mind the fact she had savings so would have been borrowing about 25% of the value of the house and the mortgage would have been less than the rent.

It was no risk to him and he wouldn't have done anything to help anyone, family members who lost money because of him would confirm that. His own son was still at school at the time but he didn't approve of his son getting married and having children and certainly wouldn't have been inclined to support that in anyway. He wouldn't even give you a lift if he was passing where you needed to go.

Like I said you don't know the individuals involved.

Edited

Like I said, I don't dispute that he could have been a mean man,
but it doesn't take knowing the individuals to know that financial situations can change unexpectedly. Two diffent things.

He chose not to help, which is his perogative.
OP isn't helping because she knows her sister most likely won't be able to pay back, not out of being mean.

I've helped and been helped, but would still look at each case individually if asked in future.
Of course some people pay back but a lot don't. If you are in a position to take the risk, then fine. But if not, that's OK too.

Tattletwat · 10/02/2024 16:13

DeeLusional · 10/02/2024 16:05

Those discounts on social housing weren't available in the 50s and 60s, but were still available long after it was possible for women to get a mortgage without a man.

Absolutely this is a 60 odd year old story passed down through levels of bitterness in family, they says we don't know the people, but neither did they at the time.

DeeLusional · 10/02/2024 16:05

Iwasafool · 10/02/2024 15:36

She was getting a maximum discount which I think was 60%, even in a fire sale they'd have got more than 40% of the value of the house never mind the fact she had savings so would have been borrowing about 25% of the value of the house and the mortgage would have been less than the rent.

It was no risk to him and he wouldn't have done anything to help anyone, family members who lost money because of him would confirm that. His own son was still at school at the time but he didn't approve of his son getting married and having children and certainly wouldn't have been inclined to support that in anyway. He wouldn't even give you a lift if he was passing where you needed to go.

Like I said you don't know the individuals involved.

Edited

Those discounts on social housing weren't available in the 50s and 60s, but were still available long after it was possible for women to get a mortgage without a man.

Tattletwat · 10/02/2024 16:00

Iwasafool · 10/02/2024 15:41

No what I'm describing is helping family.

And guess what family can be as feckless and useless and not pay you back as anyone.

It's all well and good saying help family, it doesn't protect you when you are losing your house because you helped family.

Anyone has a right to say no.

Iwasafool · 10/02/2024 15:41

SomeCatFromJapan · 10/02/2024 15:37

@Iwasafool what you've described is an entirely different scenario to OPs feckless sister. They actually had a mortgage and managed to screw it up.

No what I'm describing is helping family.

Iwasafool · 10/02/2024 15:40

EthicalBlend · 10/02/2024 15:36

Never, ever be a guarantor for anybody, in any circumstances. It is better to give money away and expect never to see it again than it is to guarantee someone else's debt.

I've done it twice and had no issues. I've taken in a relative and her children who were homeless. I'd rather help someone and risk it than turn my back on them.

SomeCatFromJapan · 10/02/2024 15:37

@Iwasafool what you've described is an entirely different scenario to OPs feckless sister. They actually had a mortgage and managed to screw it up.

Iwasafool · 10/02/2024 15:36

Treesandsheepeverywhere · 10/02/2024 15:34

Precisely. He might have been a spiteful man, but no one is "no risk"....
Life has no guarantees and financial situations can change overnight.

People who were once comfortably off have ended up being homeless.

It's a personal decision and he may have been a guarantor for somone else or wanted to be free to be one for his own kids.

Been there and it's not a nice feeling when loved ones refuse, but the reason why guarantors are requested is because the lenders/landlords have experience in how people can fall on hard times through no fault of their own or by living beyond their means.

She was getting a maximum discount which I think was 60%, even in a fire sale they'd have got more than 40% of the value of the house never mind the fact she had savings so would have been borrowing about 25% of the value of the house and the mortgage would have been less than the rent.

It was no risk to him and he wouldn't have done anything to help anyone, family members who lost money because of him would confirm that. His own son was still at school at the time but he didn't approve of his son getting married and having children and certainly wouldn't have been inclined to support that in anyway. He wouldn't even give you a lift if he was passing where you needed to go.

Like I said you don't know the individuals involved.

EthicalBlend · 10/02/2024 15:36

Never, ever be a guarantor for anybody, in any circumstances. It is better to give money away and expect never to see it again than it is to guarantee someone else's debt.

Treesandsheepeverywhere · 10/02/2024 15:34

Tattletwat · 10/02/2024 14:35

Obviously you don't know the people involved.

The problem is you don't know if someone will pay you back until they don't do it.

Precisely. He might have been a spiteful man, but no one is "no risk"....
Life has no guarantees and financial situations can change overnight.

People who were once comfortably off have ended up being homeless.

It's a personal decision and he may have been a guarantor for somone else or wanted to be free to be one for his own kids.

Been there and it's not a nice feeling when loved ones refuse, but the reason why guarantors are requested is because the lenders/landlords have experience in how people can fall on hard times through no fault of their own or by living beyond their means.

Tattletwat · 10/02/2024 14:35

Obviously you don't know the people involved.

The problem is you don't know if someone will pay you back until they don't do it.

LlynTegid · 10/02/2024 12:32

I read the updates, good to read of your DH and what he has done. Hope somehow your parents won't be affected in any way by this.

Iwasafool · 10/02/2024 12:27

wronginalltherightways · 10/02/2024 12:18

I think the real issue there was the general treatment of women as second class citizens by banks/mortgage lenders/society, not that someone couldn't afford to risk their own financial future and wellbeing to guarantee someone else's. Too many horror stories.

Honestly it was no risk to him, his mother also lived with his sister so it was a small mortgage, two women working fulltime plus a very generous pension. Both women hard working and honest. He was a spiteful man and he resented the fact that she was comfortably off and could send DH to private school when he couldn't do the same for his son so this was his way of getting at her. He ripped the family off for money more than once, being guarantor for him would have been a risk not the other way round.

Obviously you don't know the people involved.

wronginalltherightways · 10/02/2024 12:18

Iwasafool · 10/02/2024 12:11

My husband's uncle refused to be a guarantor for DHs mother mother. She was a war widow with a very comfortable pension (not British pension and considerably more generous.) DH was at school and she also had a fulltime job. She was offered her council house for peanuts but as a woman in the 50s or 60s couldn't get a mortgage without a male guarantor.

It would have made such a difference to her life, it would have been paid off in a few years but she was still paying rent for 40 years. She was no risk, it would have meant security for his only nephew who never knew his father. I think it was spiteful.

I think the real issue there was the general treatment of women as second class citizens by banks/mortgage lenders/society, not that someone couldn't afford to risk their own financial future and wellbeing to guarantee someone else's. Too many horror stories.

Iwasafool · 10/02/2024 12:11

My husband's uncle refused to be a guarantor for DHs mother mother. She was a war widow with a very comfortable pension (not British pension and considerably more generous.) DH was at school and she also had a fulltime job. She was offered her council house for peanuts but as a woman in the 50s or 60s couldn't get a mortgage without a male guarantor.

It would have made such a difference to her life, it would have been paid off in a few years but she was still paying rent for 40 years. She was no risk, it would have meant security for his only nephew who never knew his father. I think it was spiteful.

keffie12 · 10/02/2024 12:07

PS: Above should say DS, not DD

keffie12 · 10/02/2024 12:02

@PinkPinkShimmerSparkle Absolutely no way. They aren't telling you the truth either. No one gets an eviction notice over one month.

I would simply respond to your DD text and tell her to get debt advice, and a month before, they are evicted to make contact with the council over housing.

If the council won't help or can't over social housing as they have a family, they are obliged to help. Also, they can act as guarantees to the landlord, which they do here where I live providing deposits too.

The reason the council may not provide social housing is if they believe they have deliberately made themselves homeless and/or they have too much money left over from the sake of the property.

The best bet re debt is CAP (Christians Against Poverty) or StepChange. CAP provides a very good holistic service, helping far more than others with sorting out debt.

Yes, it is a service provided through the umbrella of the Christian Church. However, you do not have to be Christian or become one to have their help.

My text would go along the lines of "You're my sister, and I love you and your family dearly. However, that does not mean I will enable you. I have got anonymous advice on this. You need to contact your local council housing options who will help you and go to a debt advisory service who will help sort out your debt, contact companies to make arrangements to pay, and help you manage with your budget. You need to deal with this in a longterm grown up way. "

Suggest then those charities above. It is the only way to deal with it. Quite frankly, it sounds like she just wants to get a loan. No one will give her with her debt one. Hence, she hopes you will"

PS: I know someone ejo has hone through a repossession, and it takes around 2 years. She needs to put her house up for sale

Treesandsheepeverywhere · 10/02/2024 09:44

I asked my brother to be a guarantor on a rental flat and he politely refused.

Same for for DBF as her husband was against it.

I had a job and they trusted me, but with families of their own, it was too much of a risk.

I felt let down at the time but managed to find a flat that didn't need a guarantor.

Looking back, I totally understood why they made those decisions.

I was a single girl renting an expensive flat in London. Although they could trust me, I could have fallen ill, lost my job, met a chancer bf etc.

Don't feel bad nd if your DS has any decency, she'll come to her senses and understand one day. Even if she won't acknowledge it to you.

You did the right thing.

Landlubber2019 · 10/02/2024 07:38

@PinkShimmerSparkle well done, you have done the right thing, although I appreciate how difficult this is.

I too have had a strained relationship with my sibling which led to us being very LC/NC for a few years . I found interactions with my sibling set off my anxiety, so my husband intervened and then he took my phone for a couple of weeks. In that time, lots of messages from sibling, but he read and deleted them. I would get an update when asked, but it was simplistic in terms of " she messaged and is upset, but she will be ok'. Within a couple of weeks, the messages stopped and I got my phone back and I never did read any of the messages.

I did tell the school and friends that I was off grid for a couple of weeks, but school had dh number and he could have reached me via neighbours, his family if necessary.

Hope this helps x

riceuten · 09/02/2024 22:55

With mortgages. It’s a repossession notice rather than an eviction, unless she’s in a shared ownership property. I might consider this, but she needs to be 100% honest with you and she is not being.

T1Dmama · 09/02/2024 21:59

Your sister sounds incredibly immature and financially irresponsible!

This is not your problem though, but the second you agree to become her guarantor her fiancés become your problem… she’ll simply not pay her rent and you’ll be accountable!

Well done for saying no!….

The fact she’s blocked you on social media says that you mean nothing to her unless you are ‘useful’….. In fact how dare she block you and still ask for favours ! ….

I hope you are ok, I know how much family get in your head… I hope you have the ability to go no contact and not feel guilty… as I think your life is so much better without them all

FairFuming · 09/02/2024 21:50

I'm so glad you have such a supportive DH