Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To not be a guarantor for my sister

362 replies

PinkShimmerSparkle · 08/02/2024 11:15

Even though this means they and their 3 children might become homeless.
My DSis and her DH are not fantastic with money, I always assumed that they made sure that bills, mortgage etc were paid and all their nights out and their regular purchases of new technology, holidays etc were bought from disposable income but in hindsight it is obvious that they were always spending beyond their means, this is none of my business and I absolutely would never get involved or say anything.
They have both been working until recently when her DH left his job, she tells me that they have missed one mortgage payment and have now been issued an eviction notice.
They are looking at renting but everything requires a guarantor and she has asked me and DH to be one, as she knows we both earn and can save every month, but this is only because we are careful with what we spend.
I have said no but feel bad that they might become homeless.
AIBU?

OP posts:
AuContraire · 08/02/2024 15:04

There is no point throwing good (your) money after bad. If they're getting letters like this, one payment will make no difference.

Don't give in to their guilt trip. They need to deal with this themselves, they've enjoyed the upside of holidays etc, now they need to deal with the consequences.

Sureaseggs44 · 08/02/2024 15:03

They are not being honest with you. There is no way there is eviction for one month missed . The lender would extend the mortgage or add it on in the end . They need proper advice. If the lender gets to sell the house in possession they will loose even more money . There is more to this than meets the eye . How long have they been in the house , are they in negative equity .

And no don’t be a guarantor .

EilonwyWithRedGoldHair · 08/02/2024 15:01

Saying you could scrape together enough for one missed payment but would only pay it directly to the bank would presumably lead to protests from the DSis about why that isn't possible - I wouldn't assume she'd come clean with the full truth though.

Personally, I'd signpost to relevant agencies that can help, possibly offer other help that wasn't financial.

Iwasafool · 08/02/2024 15:01

It's her fault they are in this mess and she isn't being honest but I'd never see my nieces homeless so I'd do it. I did it for my DD when she graduated, her friend hadn't got anyone who could do it for him so I was his guarantor as well. I'm not rich but I knew I could pay it.

Jellycatspyjamas · 08/02/2024 15:01

You have no reason to feel guilty, you can’t sacrifice your financial stability for theirs - they’ll take you down with them. It’s horrible when it’s family but you are not responsible for them. It takes a good while for the bank to issue repossession notices and longer to get authority to reposses, they’ve known about this for a very long time and haven’t acted.

Beautiful3 · 08/02/2024 15:01

My friend's husband was guarantor for a friend, in a similar position. They didn't get any letters informing them of zero payments. The only letter they got was after a year of missed payments. They had a bill for thousands, which was enforced by the court. It broke up their friendship. I think you absolutely did the right thing. If you sign as a guarantor, you're saying that you can pay their missed rent. A court order will force you to repay it, even if it means selling your home! Don't do it. You'll have sleepless nights. If They have a history of not paying rent, then they're going to do it again aren't they?!

Noshowlomo · 08/02/2024 15:00

Noooo. My sister was shit with money a few years back, was threatened with repossession so her MIL paid £4k arrears. 6 months later she was out as she couldn’t pay. What a waste that £4k was to her MIL! She was still out as couldn’t afford it. She’s turned it all around now but I still wouldn’t be a guarantor if asked.
If your sister gets shitty ask her to send you copies of the letters she’s had with the amounts owed.

BruFord · 08/02/2024 14:52

@seafoamgreenhair You’re probably right. Such a frustrating situation, esp. when it’s obvious that her sister isn’t telling her the whole truth.

seafoamgreenhair · 08/02/2024 14:50

BruFord · 08/02/2024 14:47

Well yes, but I think the OP feels that giving them that money would be some form of help and might stop the constant texts.

Alrhough it probably won’t, tbh. If you do decide to give them a lump sum, OP, make it very clear that it’s all that you can afford and don’t ask for anymore, because you can’t help further.

Yes, I understand that. It would help OP feel better temporarily. But it would be like a bandaid on this situation, and would open the door for more manipulation and pulling on her heartstrings, and encourage rather than stopping the texts.

BruFord · 08/02/2024 14:47

seafoamgreenhair · 08/02/2024 14:41

But it isn't the one missed payment.

Well yes, but I think the OP feels that giving them that money would be some form of help and might stop the constant texts.

Alrhough it probably won’t, tbh. If you do decide to give them a lump sum, OP, make it very clear that it’s all that you can afford and don’t ask for anymore, because you can’t help further.

anotherday11 · 08/02/2024 14:46

If they’ve missed that many mortgage payments, gifting one payment isn’t going to make any difference. It’s throwing good money after bad.

I would ask your sister to be honest with you about her situation. The whole truth and then see how you feel about helping them. At the moment she’s still lying to you and throwing money at the problem won’t make it go away.

Also, if the bank is repossessing their home, what about the equity? Surely they would be using that to fund the rent on their future home?

AmaryllisChorus · 08/02/2024 14:46

PinkShimmerSparkle · 08/02/2024 14:39

Thank you for the responses.

I know people probably won’t agree with this but I am not telling my parents, I already have a very strained relationship with them and keep them at arms length to protect myself. If I tell them, it will be my fault for them getting in this mess and they will then apply more pressure for me to be a guarantor.

I have asked DH how he would feel about us paying the missed payment, but only directly to the bank. I am not giving them money as I’m not sure they will use it as intended.
We could gift them one payment from our savings and this may make me feel less guilty.

I wouldn't. Paying off an existing default won't register with them as you having helped out, as they won't see any of the money. I'd have sympathy if they were in debt due to both working low paid jobs and the rising cost of living, but if they spend all the time, then it isn't your job to be their pet adult who gets them out of a scrape by shelling out for the dull essentials.

LakieLady · 08/02/2024 14:45

PinkShimmerSparkle · 08/02/2024 14:39

Thank you for the responses.

I know people probably won’t agree with this but I am not telling my parents, I already have a very strained relationship with them and keep them at arms length to protect myself. If I tell them, it will be my fault for them getting in this mess and they will then apply more pressure for me to be a guarantor.

I have asked DH how he would feel about us paying the missed payment, but only directly to the bank. I am not giving them money as I’m not sure they will use it as intended.
We could gift them one payment from our savings and this may make me feel less guilty.

Making one payment wouldn't touch the sides, OP. They must have missed loads more than that.

If there really is a repossession order out, they'll be months behind with their payments.

seafoamgreenhair · 08/02/2024 14:41

But it isn't the one missed payment.

PinkShimmerSparkle · 08/02/2024 14:39

Thank you for the responses.

I know people probably won’t agree with this but I am not telling my parents, I already have a very strained relationship with them and keep them at arms length to protect myself. If I tell them, it will be my fault for them getting in this mess and they will then apply more pressure for me to be a guarantor.

I have asked DH how he would feel about us paying the missed payment, but only directly to the bank. I am not giving them money as I’m not sure they will use it as intended.
We could gift them one payment from our savings and this may make me feel less guilty.

OP posts:
LakieLady · 08/02/2024 14:38

I wouldn’t be a guarantor for a rental but I would offer a one off help with larger deposit to secure tenancy if I could afford it.

So would I. There used to be a decent landlord in my area who would accept a deposit of 6x monthly rent in lieu of a guarantor. Back then, 6 months was about the time it took to get a possesion order, so it covered a large chunk of the lost income.

I don't do homelessness work any more, but I think that's no longer allowed because there's a maximum amount of deposit a landlord can charge.

YeahBrackie · 08/02/2024 14:32

The fact your sister is telling you they are being evicted after missing one payment is a lie. That alone means you can't trust her. They never evict when you've missed just one payment. Definitely been going on for a good while. Do NOT be a guarantor whatever you do.

AmaryllisChorus · 08/02/2024 14:32

Just tell her that guarantors need to have thew kind of money for them if they default and you don't have that cash to spare. Your saving are tied up and the rest is already allocated.

You don't have to feel guilty or sound judgemental. It's a horrible situation to be in.

ragdoll12345 · 08/02/2024 14:28

You should never be a guarantor unless you are fully prepared to pay and from your explanation that sounds highly likely. As many others have said eviction notices are not issued for one missed payment and if they did have a possession claim through the Court they could go to Court and arrange a suspended order based on a repayment plan - providing they could realistically afford to repay what they owe. Eviction is the last resort for lenders and the Courts. She is not being honest

LumpyandBumps · 08/02/2024 14:27

The only way she is likely to have an eviction order for missing one payment is if there is already a suspended possession order in existence. If that is the case her husband was ridiculously reckless leaving his job voluntarily.

I am a landlord and there is no way I would be a guarantor for anyone. You potentially take on all of the risks, with none of the control. If they didn’t pay the rent and had to be evicted, which takes many months, you could be responsible for all of the unpaid rent and legal costs. It’s like signing a blank cheque.

Without wishing to sound harsh it seems like the short term pain of needing to go into temporary accommodation might be worth the long term gain of a secure social housing tenancy. ( assuming they are not classed as intentionally homeless if they are judged to have sufficient funds to have paid the mortgage).

ZsaZsaTheCat · 08/02/2024 14:22

I wouldn’t be a guarantor for a rental but I would offer a one off help with larger deposit to secure tenancy if I could afford it.

DeeLusional · 08/02/2024 14:15

Rubytoos · 08/02/2024 14:04

Aside from anything else, they are delusional if they think they can walk in to rented accommodation. The rental market is dire for availability at the moment. Rents are as high as they’ve ever been and round here there are 45 applicants per property. This means a landlord can choose the absolute best tenant. Unemployed and with a shit credit score will make renting for them virtually impossible.
I also don’t believe the council has a duty to house them since they will have made themselves voluntary homeless.

If their house is repossessed by the bank, and they stay till actually thrown out by the bailiffs, that is not voluntary homelessness and the council will have to put a roof over their heads. That roof will not necessarily be a house though, it might just be a B&B.

Gillypie23 · 08/02/2024 14:14

Absolutely no way. They've not paid their mortgage for a long time. To get into that mess.

MadeForThis · 08/02/2024 14:08

You can't fix their debt habit by giving them more credit.

GasPanic · 08/02/2024 14:08

Judging by what you say about the circumstances there is no way in hell I would agree to this.

It is just asking for trouble.

Maybe if it were me I would try to make some excuse to soften the blow. Like say I couldn't do it because not sure of employment status or maybe my mortgage holders won't let me or I have a big loan myself or something of that nature. But if they are truly desperate I would expect them to come back and pressurize you on that.