Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Can we talk about the elephant in the room?

263 replies

NeptunaOfTheMermaidBattleSquadron · 08/02/2024 10:57

I feel like as a society we need to start talking about the elephant in the room when it comes to climate change.

All these green measures being put on individuals are surely being wiped out because of all the bombing. Everywhere. All this war and conflict. No one is looking at the impact on the climate. Everything we're doing seems so trivial and pointless because in the same breath we're sending weapons (often called international aid) thousands of miles.

Then there's the manufacturing for it. The weapons testing. All the jet fuel to send the RAF USAF etc all around the world on bombing sprees. The supplies we're sending all over the place, weapons, medicine, rations... it's mind-boggling to think of the sheer scale of this.

And while we're acknowledging and working on fast fashion, home heating, electricity generation, over use of plastics, overpopulation, traceability etc, we're not even talking about or questioning all these bombs exploding everywhere!

We typically think of MAD as nuclear apocalypse, but surely people refusing to actually engage with each other to the point of forcing the world into something with the carbon footprint of a war (never mind several of them) is the climate change version of MAD. We can't reverse it.

I feel like politicians and diplomats just aren't trying hard enough with this because war is so profitable.

Why aren't just stop oil and all those other activists out there trying to protest the most avoidable thing we're doing with the biggest carbon footprint and pressuring governments to go back to diplomacy instead of treating their people as expendable?

IDK what the answer is but we seriously need to get a handle on this and stop using bombs to make points (they're not very good at it anyway) because of this: https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/science-environment-68110310

Sorry I just needed a bit of a rant. AIBU that they need to try harder to avoid armed conflicts and solve things like adults for the sake of the planet because the stakes are so much higher than one territory or issue? I haven't had much sleep this week so please explain why IABU if you think I am.

A firefighter sprays water during a wildfire on El Cable Hill near Bogota, Colombia, on Saturday, 27 January 2024

World's first year-long breach of key 1.5C warming limit

The last 12 months were the hottest on record, temporarily sending the world past a deeply symbolic mark.

https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/science-environment-68110310

OP posts:
Thread gallery
8
Neverpostagain · 08/02/2024 17:55

bakewellbride · 08/02/2024 14:17

If you want to help the planet the best thing you can do is go vegan. Everything else doesn't come anywhere near as close when it comes to your carbon footprint.

Having no offspring is much more effective

HappiestSleeping · 08/02/2024 17:53

Ohdeardddddeardear · 08/02/2024 17:40

We can still limit it. That’s what the science points to. Surely we may as well try?

I agree that we could still limit it. "We" being the whole planet. Good luck getting Putin on board with that. Or India. Or China. Any one of which in isolation will pump out more greenhouse gas than the planet can cope with. Don't get me wrong, there is an infinitesimally small chance that the minority doing its bit will make a difference, so we should continue to try, even if it enables us to have the moral high ground and look the next generation in the eye and say "I did my best".

That, of course, would mean we give up our cars, our foreign holidays, etc. Putting the odd thing in the recycling doesn't really cut the mustard.

Ohdeardddddeardear · 08/02/2024 17:52

bythelightofthemoons · 08/02/2024 17:46

Yes - it can be limited, slowed down but unfortunately I don’t think that’s enough. It will just be a case of prolonging the agony. Unless something huge happens that shocks the whole world and those in power into immediate action there’s no hope for this planet. It’s desperately sad.

I remember in the 80s learning songs about caring for animals and the planet, we were told not to waste paper so that trees weren’t cut down, yet things carried on and got worse. In the 90s we learnt about cfc gases and the hole in the ozone layer, we tried to recycle what we could. In the 00s and onwards my own dc were learning about global warming and pollution but progress to address these issues is slow and never enough.

In some ways I hope I’m wrong and that it can all be rectified but being realistic I think we are on a fast track to catastrophe.

In the article it says we can still have an impact. We all need to;

  • talk about it more
  • engage politically
  • cut our own carbon footprint in whatever way possible.

I don’t think the ‘we are all doomed’ rhetoric is helpful at all. It gives people the go ahead to continue as they are. Which is madness.

InkySplott · 08/02/2024 17:50

I don't think people will care about climate change until it really starts to affect them directly. I worked in two care homes and no one recycled, switched off plugs or turned off lights after leaving a room and cranked the heating up leaving doors and windows open . Everything was tumble dried even on a roasting hot day . Dish washer were run half full and food waste was appalling . I bet other care homes were the same.

bythelightofthemoons · 08/02/2024 17:46

Ohdeardddddeardear · 08/02/2024 17:40

We can still limit it. That’s what the science points to. Surely we may as well try?

Yes - it can be limited, slowed down but unfortunately I don’t think that’s enough. It will just be a case of prolonging the agony. Unless something huge happens that shocks the whole world and those in power into immediate action there’s no hope for this planet. It’s desperately sad.

I remember in the 80s learning songs about caring for animals and the planet, we were told not to waste paper so that trees weren’t cut down, yet things carried on and got worse. In the 90s we learnt about cfc gases and the hole in the ozone layer, we tried to recycle what we could. In the 00s and onwards my own dc were learning about global warming and pollution but progress to address these issues is slow and never enough.

In some ways I hope I’m wrong and that it can all be rectified but being realistic I think we are on a fast track to catastrophe.

OneTC · 08/02/2024 17:45

Yeah if only people would consider the impact on the environment when they're bombing countries back to the stone ages

Ohdeardddddeardear · 08/02/2024 17:40

bythelightofthemoons · 08/02/2024 17:39

You’re absolutely correct. Tipping point has been passed a long time ago. It’s going to get worse and very sadly the suffering of future generations will be immense.

We can still limit it. That’s what the science points to. Surely we may as well try?

bythelightofthemoons · 08/02/2024 17:39

HappiestSleeping · 08/02/2024 11:13

I honestly think we are already beyond tipping point. If the global powers that be were really interested, we could stop producing greenhouse gasses now, however that would mean such a fundamental shift in how economies work that I don't think it is tenable. It is theoretically possible (or it was) to adjust certain aspects, however there has been little to no appetite for that it seems. Governments around the world are only interested in what will get them elected, or keep them elected.

Realistically, Russia, China, India and probably America all need to change, and I can't see that happening, maybe with the exception of the US.

The human race is a blight on this planet. I fear for future generations.

You’re absolutely correct. Tipping point has been passed a long time ago. It’s going to get worse and very sadly the suffering of future generations will be immense.

HighQueenOfTheFarRealm · 08/02/2024 17:30

Yes. I wonder what the carbon footprint of ammunition's, bombs, military planes and vehicles and so on is.

Ohdeardddddeardear · 08/02/2024 17:26

itsmyp4rty · 08/02/2024 17:17

The idea of fighting climate change while China merrily builds more and more coal fired power stations just seems absolutely pointless to me. There are currently 256 coal fired power stations in Europe. In China there are 1142 and they are currently approving two new plants every week.

China are investing massively in renewables. We should be doing the same. Instead we are agreeing to more oil extraction which will do nothing to help us in the UK.

MotherOfCatBoy · 08/02/2024 17:24

Yes but they are also building wind and solar. It’s not simplistic and binary.
Planetary CO2, and methane, is higher than it’s been for 10,000 years - most of recent human evolution - and is rising much more rapidly than natural processes (moving away from an ice age) would change it. We don’t know the impact that will have on plants, animals, crops, food supplies, not to mention dramatic weather events. 2023 was the hottest year on record. This is real and although the effects will be unevenly distributed, some of them will still ripple through societies and economies.
Despite “China” every fraction of a degree of warming we can prevent, is still valuable and worth while, in terms of avoiding more adaptation, rebuilding, or whatever we need to do after disastrous events. Major studies like Lord Deben’s reports and the IPCC pathways show it is cheaper to avoid disastrous climate change than adapt now. And a lot of changes are free - you can adapt your diet (you don’t have to give up meat and dairy, just reduce it); walk more; buy a car with a small engine; have fewer (not zero) children. All you libertarians out there can have your personal freedom - all that is required is a lack excess and permanent growth.
Everyone can contribute, and it’s not miserable and negative. The only part that is miserable is if you and your family are the ones in floods or wildfires. It’s just as easy to change your consumption as it is to moan about hoaxes.

Ohdeardddddeardear · 08/02/2024 17:24

I agree OP and saw the same article and almost started a thread. I feel so exasperated with humans.

cutting down on or quitting unnecessary flights is an easy win. No one NEEDS a holiday. It’s a luxury.

Can we talk about the elephant in the room?
itsmyp4rty · 08/02/2024 17:17

The idea of fighting climate change while China merrily builds more and more coal fired power stations just seems absolutely pointless to me. There are currently 256 coal fired power stations in Europe. In China there are 1142 and they are currently approving two new plants every week.

SerenityNowInsanityLater · 08/02/2024 17:17

All the bombing in the world isn’t as bad for the planet as fossil fuel energy generation, food & agriculture, travel etc.

Have you ever read about the Kuwaiti oil fires- and the rest? Setting oil wells on fire IS a military tactic so actually, all the bombing in the world is as bad for the planet and is a major contributor to our climate crisis and shouldn't be minimised.

missmollygreen · 08/02/2024 17:09

As long as we have people in charge of countries we will have wars. Never going to change.

People should be looking at the likes of China, who produce more greenhouse gasses than the entire developed world combined

ginasevern · 08/02/2024 17:01

Nothing but the complete elimination of the human race will stop climate change. Any adjustments we make are probably too little, too late and nobody is going to forego a lifestyle that has been evolving since the industrial revolution.

MargaretThursday · 08/02/2024 16:30

Hey Russia, do you think you could pull out of Ukraine because it's bad for the environment?

Or do you want:

Ukraine, just let Russia take over you because fighting back is bad for the environment?

Don't think either's listening.

fetchacloth · 08/02/2024 16:06

MaggieFS · 08/02/2024 11:05

I don't have the data, but gut feel is that there are far more things which would have a greater impact. I think you've picked the wrong elephant.

This, without doubt.

Dotjones · 08/02/2024 15:53

A big war with a huge number of casualties could actually be very good for the planet. Say Russia, the whole of Africa and whole of Asia had their populations wiped out, there would be enough of a population to keep the human race going, cheap land going begging and a drastically reduced population clamouring for the planet's resources. India and China account for between a fifth and a quarter of the global population alone.

Clearly in a big war it wouldn't happen like that, casualties would unfortunately be spread amongst the participants and collateral damage to anyone else. But war in itself isn't necessarily a bad thing in terms of climate change - it could be the short (in terms of a few years) sharp shock that sends humanity on a different course.

I would like to see the XR/IB type activists target their efforts against Russia, China, Iran and so on, if only to see how differently they would be dealt with compared to here.

Lassiata · 08/02/2024 15:32

But very few people actually want these wars to be happening. It's not an elephant - we're already opposed!

RhubarbGingerJam · 08/02/2024 15:27

Sorry to derail - what’s MAD?

Mutually Assured destruction - policy of cold war nuclear arms race era.

InShockHusbandLeaving · 08/02/2024 15:26

I’d love to stop all wars with immediate effect but how? Waving flags and banners isn’t working. The world could be a much better place for everyone if people laid down their grenades, rocket launchers, guns etc. Ditto if we all worked together to feed everyone instead of diverting food aid, making farmers into enemies etc. There are so many things we could do but like I said, no matter how many flags I’ve waved (and I’ve waved a few) nothing has ever changed, in fact it’s worsened considerably over my lifetime.

Voting for politicians at the ballot box isn’t the answer either. I’m not politically affiliated with any party because I think every one of them is full of self serving liars and we only realistically get a choice of right or left wing useless tosspots anyway. I’d vote for anyone who could actually make a better world for us all but they are conspicuous by their absence.

Moonmelodies · 08/02/2024 15:25

Bombing isn't happening 'everywhere'.

MorningSunshineSparkles · 08/02/2024 15:17

Sorry to derail - what’s MAD?

I agree with the points you make, a war is always going to be a climate disaster. We shouldn’t be involving ourselves in international conflict, no country should. If we all minded our business and acted like we didn’t have the coping skills of a 5 year old when unpleasantness did occur the world would be a hell of a lot better place to live.

dollyolly · 08/02/2024 14:48

chopinwaltz26 · 08/02/2024 14:33

Berthold Brecht wrote that war is trade carried out by other means.
As for climate change, removing the internet would make an enormous saving in CO2 emissions, but nobody ever wants to talk about data centres etc.

Yeah. My job is seriously at risk from AI, but the vast resources AI and data centres will require are apparently no problem.

A lot of us roll our eyes and stop listening when it comes to climate change, as 95% of it – the entire conversation – seems to be bullshit. I don't deny that humans are polluting and endangering natural resources, but I'm also not willing to believe most of the talk around it.