Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Can we talk about the elephant in the room?

263 replies

NeptunaOfTheMermaidBattleSquadron · 08/02/2024 10:57

I feel like as a society we need to start talking about the elephant in the room when it comes to climate change.

All these green measures being put on individuals are surely being wiped out because of all the bombing. Everywhere. All this war and conflict. No one is looking at the impact on the climate. Everything we're doing seems so trivial and pointless because in the same breath we're sending weapons (often called international aid) thousands of miles.

Then there's the manufacturing for it. The weapons testing. All the jet fuel to send the RAF USAF etc all around the world on bombing sprees. The supplies we're sending all over the place, weapons, medicine, rations... it's mind-boggling to think of the sheer scale of this.

And while we're acknowledging and working on fast fashion, home heating, electricity generation, over use of plastics, overpopulation, traceability etc, we're not even talking about or questioning all these bombs exploding everywhere!

We typically think of MAD as nuclear apocalypse, but surely people refusing to actually engage with each other to the point of forcing the world into something with the carbon footprint of a war (never mind several of them) is the climate change version of MAD. We can't reverse it.

I feel like politicians and diplomats just aren't trying hard enough with this because war is so profitable.

Why aren't just stop oil and all those other activists out there trying to protest the most avoidable thing we're doing with the biggest carbon footprint and pressuring governments to go back to diplomacy instead of treating their people as expendable?

IDK what the answer is but we seriously need to get a handle on this and stop using bombs to make points (they're not very good at it anyway) because of this: https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/science-environment-68110310

Sorry I just needed a bit of a rant. AIBU that they need to try harder to avoid armed conflicts and solve things like adults for the sake of the planet because the stakes are so much higher than one territory or issue? I haven't had much sleep this week so please explain why IABU if you think I am.

A firefighter sprays water during a wildfire on El Cable Hill near Bogota, Colombia, on Saturday, 27 January 2024

World's first year-long breach of key 1.5C warming limit

The last 12 months were the hottest on record, temporarily sending the world past a deeply symbolic mark.

https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/science-environment-68110310

OP posts:
Thread gallery
8
Ohdeardddddeardear · 08/02/2024 19:36

godlikeAI · 08/02/2024 18:33

The capitalist system itself is the problem. Run by and for people to enrich themselves, without giving a stuff for others. It has succeeded in turning us all from people to “consumers”, in economies that must endlessly grow and where the value of everything is expressed in money.

To change, we’d need completely different leaders with the will to introduce regulation to make change at a much higher level, but by controlling the media, they’ve ensured that anything that’s good for people is deemed as “woke” and therefore somehow bad.

As a child of the 80s, I’m astonished that it has been possible to completely erode the consensus around climate change that existed back in the early 90s. It’s depressing to think about, and wars add to it, yes, but are actually a symptom of the underlying problem of rampant, unchecked greed and the pursuit of wealth at any cost.

I agree completely. Unfettered capitalism and letting ‘the market’ dictate change is the issue. As consumers we do hold some power though. As voters we do. Not much. But some and we should use it.

Kipepeo · 08/02/2024 19:35

I can't see any of the countries engaged in bombing right know giving a toss about climate change.
Actually, even countries not engaged in bombing give a toss. Taking measures now would cost money and possible a politician's career so they project their ambition in the future.

RhubarbGingerJam · 08/02/2024 19:34

Problem with political uncertainly and more wars - is there will inventible be more military investment - so contribution of wars and military towards global warming will likely increase.

Ohdeardddddeardear · 08/02/2024 19:34

HappiestSleeping · 08/02/2024 19:33

I hear you, and admire the sentiment, but it's futile.

Says who?

Ohdeardddddeardear · 08/02/2024 19:33

Viviennemary · 08/02/2024 18:32

Its a really boring topic. The politicians and the experts can deal with it. I'm not that interested tbh. What about the threat of a world war. Thats far more worrying.

If it doesn’t worry you then you don’t know enough about it. I’m not going to spell it out because it’s petrifying. But I actually think war is going to be more likely because of the climate emergency.

HappiestSleeping · 08/02/2024 19:33

Ohdeardddddeardear · 08/02/2024 18:03

We can’t control other people or other countries. We can only do what we can do. Be the change you want to see in the world.

I hear you, and admire the sentiment, but it's futile.

RhubarbGingerJam · 08/02/2024 19:32

On the over population front - they think world wide it will peak earlier and at lower level then once feared- and we are likely at peak child already - we already at 2.3 fertility rate and projected to reach 2.1 replacement level by 2050 if not before. Then we get aging populations to content with.

On energy front - https://www.theguardian.com/business/2023/oct/09/worlds-largest-offshore-windfarm-project-starts-powering-uk-grid

We've reduced our Co2 output 38% since 1990, faster than any other major developed country.
https://www.carbonbrief.org/analysis-why-the-uks-co2-emissions-have-fallen-38-since-1990/

There' more to do but we have made and are making progress despite doom and gloom posts on green topics on here.

Our cities at least have public transport and walkable distances - Americans seems oblivious to climate problems and their infrastructure is poorly laid out and they have cheap petrol prices compare to rest of the world.

https://thehustle.co/why-gas-is-actually-cheap-in-america/

The also had a lot of very cold weather and seemed shocked their electric car batteries wouldn't charge - which been very bad PR for electric cars over there.

World’s largest offshore windfarm project starts powering UK grid

First of 277 turbines goes into operation at site that will produce enough energy for 6m homes

https://www.theguardian.com/business/2023/oct/09/worlds-largest-offshore-windfarm-project-starts-powering-uk-grid

fuchsteufelswild · 08/02/2024 19:28

NeptunaOfTheMermaidBattleSquadron · 08/02/2024 14:12

No because I didn't say any of that. Please don't twist my words to suit yourself.

You kind of did, weapons testing, logistics, manufacture. Surely there are statistics about the carbon footprint of arms manufacturing.

Since wars often don't spare industrial infrastructure, and poor dictatorships are probably rather climate friendly despite increased fossil fuel consumption in the general population, there may be some sort of balancing out going on I guess?

As for wars taking the focus away, yes, diversion is often the point.

But as long as enough money can enable enough people to lead a lifestyle with gigantic carbon footprints, this will go on, and it will be very hard to justify to the "little people" why they should stop driving cars to work when China is building more coal power plants than the rest of the world combined.

unsync · 08/02/2024 19:11

Overpopulation is the problem no one talks about. There are too many humans, using too many resources and destroying the planet to get more. There's a finite supply and other species, who usually live in harmony with their environment, are being wiped out because of us.

If we wipe ourselves out through war, we'd be doing the planet a favour.

NeverDropYourMooncup · 08/02/2024 19:01

Perversely, war can actually have effects upon the environment that are different - reduced populations, less demand for consumer goods (because people are just concentrating upon staying alive), lack of safe housing or medical care results in a lower birth rate in terms of maternal and infant mortality, disease outbreaks, huge areas left to go fallow/regenerate without the poor people who have suffered being there.

If there is no war, people continue having children, consuming, growing, polluting. When the population reduces, the demand and impact reduces.

This doesn't mean it's a good thing, war is never a good thing - but it's far more complex than somebody in a safe, prosperous country saying 'isn't it bad for the planet when planes fly overhead? They should stop doing that when told to by pensioners supergluing themselves to the x embassy front steps'

Gymnoob · 08/02/2024 18:49

If they aren’t going to stop wars for the simple reason it’s results in people being blown up then they aren’t going to stop wars for climate change.

godlikeAI · 08/02/2024 18:33

The capitalist system itself is the problem. Run by and for people to enrich themselves, without giving a stuff for others. It has succeeded in turning us all from people to “consumers”, in economies that must endlessly grow and where the value of everything is expressed in money.

To change, we’d need completely different leaders with the will to introduce regulation to make change at a much higher level, but by controlling the media, they’ve ensured that anything that’s good for people is deemed as “woke” and therefore somehow bad.

As a child of the 80s, I’m astonished that it has been possible to completely erode the consensus around climate change that existed back in the early 90s. It’s depressing to think about, and wars add to it, yes, but are actually a symptom of the underlying problem of rampant, unchecked greed and the pursuit of wealth at any cost.

Riapia · 08/02/2024 18:33

Why don’t countries adopt the MN approach to a dispute.
Go NC.
That would solve everything.
😉😁😁

Viviennemary · 08/02/2024 18:32

Its a really boring topic. The politicians and the experts can deal with it. I'm not that interested tbh. What about the threat of a world war. Thats far more worrying.

Firecarrier · 08/02/2024 18:27

We are the carbon they want to eradicate 😉

"you will own nothing and be happy"

Enjoy eating bugs.

Itsnotallaboutyoulikeyouthink · 08/02/2024 18:20

I’m a sustainability manager and I’m not going to lie I think about this every morning before work. However……

Green measures aren’t just about the environment. If we did it properly it would have a positive impact on our economy, alleviate fuel poverty, positive impacts upon health etc. this is the issue people need to expand their understanding as to the benefits of sustainability.

yes war will create carbon emissions, but seeing as those countries have had their industry , businesses wiped out then perhaps it balances out somewhat.

it’s a very giving up attitude too. Surely we want to wars to end. If we all stop doing these green measures we will be in a worse situation once the wars do end.

as individuals there is only so much that you can do. Evs are expensive. Energy efficiency measures are expensive. But there is so much that you can do and there’s so much influence that you can have. Don’t sit there moaning that the government isn’t doing this and the other get in contact with them… regularly. Don’t sit there moaning about packaging and then continue to buy from that retailer. You don’t need to follow your social media influencers and buy all the tit tat that they promote. Pick up the phone to your energy company and ask if you can get on a renewable contract. Don’t get sucked into the need to be vegan but look up impact of beef production…. If everyone reduced their meat consumption by even one day it would make an impact.

bythelightofthemoons · 08/02/2024 18:14

Ohdeardddddeardear · 08/02/2024 18:06

I disagree. I think we can all;

Talk to each other about rather than ignoring it.
Engage politically in whatever way possible.
Cut our own carbon footprint as much as possible.
Be a conscious consumer - including engagement with celebrity.

We were getting there in the UK until the pandemic shifted us off course.

I actually hope you are right , I really do

ickky · 08/02/2024 18:11

All the guilt is put on the individual. If Government policy was to stop production of all the harmful things, we wouldn't be in this mess.

It is all lip service, while the polluters reap all the benefit, with a lovely backhander to MP's via lobby groups etc.

If a bath is overflowing, you don't start bailing it out, you turn off the tap.

Ohdeardddddeardear · 08/02/2024 18:06

bythelightofthemoons · 08/02/2024 17:58

Well , that’s human selfishness unfortunately- we know that we aren’t doomed right now but future generations will be it comes down to whether people love themselves and their life right now or want to make sacrifices now for those in the future . I think too many people are selfish and care only about themselves. Changing the mindset of the whole population isn’t possible.

I disagree. I think we can all;

Talk to each other about rather than ignoring it.
Engage politically in whatever way possible.
Cut our own carbon footprint as much as possible.
Be a conscious consumer - including engagement with celebrity.

We were getting there in the UK until the pandemic shifted us off course.

Ohdeardddddeardear · 08/02/2024 18:03

HappiestSleeping · 08/02/2024 17:53

I agree that we could still limit it. "We" being the whole planet. Good luck getting Putin on board with that. Or India. Or China. Any one of which in isolation will pump out more greenhouse gas than the planet can cope with. Don't get me wrong, there is an infinitesimally small chance that the minority doing its bit will make a difference, so we should continue to try, even if it enables us to have the moral high ground and look the next generation in the eye and say "I did my best".

That, of course, would mean we give up our cars, our foreign holidays, etc. Putting the odd thing in the recycling doesn't really cut the mustard.

We can’t control other people or other countries. We can only do what we can do. Be the change you want to see in the world.

scatterolight · 08/02/2024 18:01

The elephant in the room is China. If our elites really believed in climate change and that it was a clear and present danger to the existence of the planet, we would at the very least be ceasing all trade with China. If not, going to war with them to stop their earth destroying industrial emissions. But no, we keep deindustrialising in the west and importing ever more from China. China, like Mordor, just destroys more and more of its nature and pumps endless CO2 into the atmosphere. No one seems to question this.

Occam's razor would say perhaps our leaders don't believe climate change is the big issue they say it is. A bit like that event in 2020 that everyone wants to pretend never happened.

Towerofsong · 08/02/2024 18:01

I reckon the real elephant in the room Is how many trucks on the roads are just full of waste. Waste being moved from one place to another to be shredded, sorted, packaged up, sent to landfill or shipped across the world. Incredible numbers of waste trucks on the roads of the UK. As a species we are incredibly heavy consumers and polluters of all kinds of resources, and we need to halve the world population, but in a way that it doesn't totally destabilise our economic systems.

However much nobody in their right mind wants war, stopping wars and allowing dictators and sadistic terror regimes to take over is not what will save the planet or humanity.

David Attenborough's A Life on Our Planet was brilliant.

I would also like to see an experiment where only women can be in national leadership roles for the next 30 years. Men have had their turn and it's not going great.

bythelightofthemoons · 08/02/2024 17:58

Ohdeardddddeardear · 08/02/2024 17:52

In the article it says we can still have an impact. We all need to;

  • talk about it more
  • engage politically
  • cut our own carbon footprint in whatever way possible.

I don’t think the ‘we are all doomed’ rhetoric is helpful at all. It gives people the go ahead to continue as they are. Which is madness.

Well , that’s human selfishness unfortunately- we know that we aren’t doomed right now but future generations will be it comes down to whether people love themselves and their life right now or want to make sacrifices now for those in the future . I think too many people are selfish and care only about themselves. Changing the mindset of the whole population isn’t possible.

EasternStandard · 08/02/2024 17:57

Neverpostagain · 08/02/2024 17:55

Having no offspring is much more effective

I think it’s hard for many to suppress a consumerist lifestyle but having fewer dc is happening generally

I’d keep going with that and hopefully some equilibrium will emerge

Missingmyusername · 08/02/2024 17:55

Population - but it’s taboo.
38% think YABU - people don’t want to be affected, don’t want to cut back on anything. The vast majority of the public wouldn’t change their daily activities for even one day of the week.
We are running out of time / may have already gone beyond tipping point.
There will be wars, there will be fighting over land, food etc. We have stopped evolving. We’re like a plague of cockroaches consuming everything.
It reminds me of the movie, Don’t look up. It’s too late, thankfully I’ll be long gone before the shit hits the fan.

What will the planet look like in 100/200 years for regular folk? 🤔 bloody shit I bet.