Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Can we talk about the elephant in the room?

263 replies

NeptunaOfTheMermaidBattleSquadron · 08/02/2024 10:57

I feel like as a society we need to start talking about the elephant in the room when it comes to climate change.

All these green measures being put on individuals are surely being wiped out because of all the bombing. Everywhere. All this war and conflict. No one is looking at the impact on the climate. Everything we're doing seems so trivial and pointless because in the same breath we're sending weapons (often called international aid) thousands of miles.

Then there's the manufacturing for it. The weapons testing. All the jet fuel to send the RAF USAF etc all around the world on bombing sprees. The supplies we're sending all over the place, weapons, medicine, rations... it's mind-boggling to think of the sheer scale of this.

And while we're acknowledging and working on fast fashion, home heating, electricity generation, over use of plastics, overpopulation, traceability etc, we're not even talking about or questioning all these bombs exploding everywhere!

We typically think of MAD as nuclear apocalypse, but surely people refusing to actually engage with each other to the point of forcing the world into something with the carbon footprint of a war (never mind several of them) is the climate change version of MAD. We can't reverse it.

I feel like politicians and diplomats just aren't trying hard enough with this because war is so profitable.

Why aren't just stop oil and all those other activists out there trying to protest the most avoidable thing we're doing with the biggest carbon footprint and pressuring governments to go back to diplomacy instead of treating their people as expendable?

IDK what the answer is but we seriously need to get a handle on this and stop using bombs to make points (they're not very good at it anyway) because of this: https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/science-environment-68110310

Sorry I just needed a bit of a rant. AIBU that they need to try harder to avoid armed conflicts and solve things like adults for the sake of the planet because the stakes are so much higher than one territory or issue? I haven't had much sleep this week so please explain why IABU if you think I am.

A firefighter sprays water during a wildfire on El Cable Hill near Bogota, Colombia, on Saturday, 27 January 2024

World's first year-long breach of key 1.5C warming limit

The last 12 months were the hottest on record, temporarily sending the world past a deeply symbolic mark.

https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/science-environment-68110310

OP posts:
Thread gallery
8
Ohdeardddddeardear · 09/02/2024 06:52

HappiestSleeping · 08/02/2024 23:53

Absolutely agree. Nobody would ever say it is futile because any effort would stop if they did. But if you analyse the facts, production rates, what they would need to reduce to, and the likely timescales, we are really now reliant on some other solution.

Don't get me wrong, I still do as much as I reasonably can, but that isn't as much as I could do. I take the train when possible, but I still drive a car. I still go on flights for work and for pleasure, I still use things which contain harmful substance because I can't afford not to do any of those things.

I've given up letting it make my blood boil as that will have me in the grave earlier than the temperature rising.

You are not doing what you reasonably can. You don’t need to fly for pleasure. You could engage politically. Instead you are dampening people’s enthusiasm for changing by saying it’s pointless but not stating your source.

You are part of the problem that has already killed many and will kill many more.

Emily1583 · 09/02/2024 06:40

As others have said, I think there are more ethical reasons why war is bad. As for the environment; buying goods made in the third world powered by coal power stations and then shipping said goods across the world probably has a bigger environmental impact.

SquashedSquashess · 09/02/2024 06:37

Your view on war is very naive OP. Do you let all the Ukrainian refugees know that their country just didn’t “negotiate hard enough” with Putin’s regime when it invaded their country? Would you feel comfortable telling them that they should sacrifice their culture, language and heritage to save the planet?

Yours is an easy stance to take when you live in a country not directly affected by war.

The solution to climate change is complex and I expect the ship has sailed. Whilst of course warfare does cause environmental damage, your belief that leaders should just work harder to negotiate is on par with the understanding of a child when it comes to how wars arise and why countries choose to defend themselves. Defence is a right every country should have.

therealcookiemonster · 09/02/2024 05:24

got it in one OP. the green initiatives look like a farce when we consider all the bullshit various other countries (China, india) and our own governments get upto. however, that is no excuse not to do our part.

whatever I do 'for the environment' is pretty much for my own conscience. I couldn't carry on knowing I was contributing to harming the ecosystem we live in.

the just stop oil protesters are also usually present in the stop war rallies. so not sure I fully agree with you on environmental protesters not recognising the impact of war.

on a slightly related note, I would also ban fireworks if I had the power. People can watch fireworks on big screens if they are so bloody desperate. no need to waste millions, make things explode, cause air pollution and scare the poor animals.

DaSilvaP · 09/02/2024 04:51

GladAllOver · 08/02/2024 11:05

If we stop defending freedom against brutal dictators, you won't have any opportunity to make choices to save the planet. You'll just do as you are told.

Are you aware that the "brutal dictator" Sadam Hussein was the darling of the USA when he was killing Iranians? Just one example how hollow it sounds ...

HoppingPavlova · 09/02/2024 01:31

I think the elephant in the room is that all the fudges that are being pushed - electric vehicles, carbon trading, etc - are going to do bugger all. In some cases, like electric cars, it's a total scam.
People aren't willing to face that they will have to significantly change their consumption, and governments and business can't figure out how to make that work economically. So they tell each other, and themselves, lies about how technology will let them continue to live as they do now, more or less

Exactly this.

PurpleAxe · 09/02/2024 01:28

Meh, I have given up.

Humanity appears to have a built in self destruct. I wish I had realised this before I had had kids. But I didn't, so I am focused on trying to make sure my little family are as well resourced as possible to see out the the time we have left.

I hope my kids don't have kids. They are smart and old enough to see the the same thing I do, but you never know.

We have passed the tipping point. The planet will be fine, it just won't be able to support humans for much long (certainly not much past 30 years or so and even that is a stretch).

Humanity is fucked, all that is left to see now is how to goes down.

blueandsad · 09/02/2024 01:26

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

comeondover · 09/02/2024 00:34

One of the most recent episodes of the Last Born in the Wilderness podcast is about this, specifically the US military being 'Earth's Greatest Enemy' - the name of a documentary in post production about it. Apparently the US military is the largest consumer of fossil fuels in the world. No one ever expects the forces to reduce their carbon footprint.

NoMoreLifts · 09/02/2024 00:29

GladAllOver · 08/02/2024 11:05

If we stop defending freedom against brutal dictators, you won't have any opportunity to make choices to save the planet. You'll just do as you are told.

Completely agree.

RogueFemale · 09/02/2024 00:22

I don't think war is the elephant in the room, there's a herd of huge elephants.

Climate change is going to be devastating within the lifetimes of people aged 40 or younger. There will be mass migrations, wars, horror. It's already happening.

I just hope that the human race is destroyed sooner than later, so that there's a chance for other species to regenerate.

TempestTost · 09/02/2024 00:17

I think the elephant in the room is that all the fudges that are being pushed - electric vehicles, carbon trading, etc - are going to do bugger all. In some cases, like electric cars, it's a total scam.

People aren't willing to face that they will have to significantly change their consumption, and governments and business can't figure out how to make that work economically. So they tell each other, and themselves, lies about how technology will let them continue to live as they do now, more or less.

RogueFemale · 09/02/2024 00:12

Ohdeardddddeardear · 08/02/2024 21:50

We are pathetically apathetic.

I have been reading about the women of Greenham Common. Bloody hero’s but dear god what sacrifices. The suffragettes. I love Radical Tea Towels for highlighting just what can happen when the people come together in protest.

I can’t quite believe we haven’t had a revolution the way people have been treated.

Everyone's too busy looking at their phones.

ClosedGlassCase · 08/02/2024 23:59

MojoMoon · 08/02/2024 13:22

Why do Just Stop Oil protestors need to stop doing their protests? It's not a full time role for them - they can protest against oil AND protest against war? (If you have ever met any in the climate protest movement, they are a demographic who bloody love a protest and will absolutely have been at Palestinian matches, ban the bomb, anti Iraq)
Why can't you round up other people who aren't protesting about anything and head out in your own protest?

I'm a bit suspicious of anything that is "why don't climate protestors focusing on Y focus on X instead"? It's just a way of trying to diminish the importance of issue Y. Maybe both are important?

It just smells a bit of whataboutery and a way of trying to make taking climate action of any kind pointless. What's the point of recycling my tin cans when China is building coal fired power plants etc.

And climate change as a concept is social control and a money making extravaganza for big business, globally

Much better off ignoring it all

HappiestSleeping · 08/02/2024 23:53

Ohdeardddddeardear · 08/02/2024 21:46

So no one is saying trying to make changes is futile.

We can’t force others to change but we can lead by example. Or just do the right thing because it’s the right thing rather than what we are doing now which is granting licenses for new oil extraction. Idiotic greed. Make my blood boil if I dwell in it too much.

Absolutely agree. Nobody would ever say it is futile because any effort would stop if they did. But if you analyse the facts, production rates, what they would need to reduce to, and the likely timescales, we are really now reliant on some other solution.

Don't get me wrong, I still do as much as I reasonably can, but that isn't as much as I could do. I take the train when possible, but I still drive a car. I still go on flights for work and for pleasure, I still use things which contain harmful substance because I can't afford not to do any of those things.

I've given up letting it make my blood boil as that will have me in the grave earlier than the temperature rising.

samarrange · 08/02/2024 23:39

Wars are bad, and we should try to stop them for all kinds of reasons. But their CO2 output is a couple of places to the right of the decimal point compared to the fossil fuel consumption of the four billion or so people in the world who now have lifestyles that include a fridge, hot running water, air conditioning, and a motor vehicle of some kind.

We can tell that basically by looking at the price of oil. If the CO2 being emitted by bombs and shells going off in Ukraine or Gaza actually represented a big increase in global CO2, we would see the price of oil going sky-high because all of those explosives are manufactured using chemical processes that depend on oil. The C in CO2 has to come from somewhere.

So by all means campaign to stop whichever wars you feel most strongly about, but if your primary reason for doing so is the CO2 being emitted by those wars then your time might be better spent campaigning for CO2 to be reduced in other, more effective ways.

Bikechic · 08/02/2024 23:30

You are right OP. Apparently 400 million tonnes of CO2 emmitted as a result of iraq war 2003 -2019. It is one of the highest. However global deforestation is leaving 5 - 10 billion tonnes of CO2 in atmosphere that would not be there if the trees were.
As for all those who say its pointless doing anything while China are carrying on. Average carbon footprint for a person in Britain is much higher than china Britan is 13 tonnes per capita, whereas in China it is only 8 tonnes.
How Bad are Bananas by Mike Berners-Lee

Angrycat2768 · 08/02/2024 23:23

Ohdeardddddeardear · 08/02/2024 22:41

Money won’t buy them protection from what’s to come. They think it can but it can’t. Even if they are ok, what kind of life is it knowing you, in part, caused the awful
suffering you are seeing?

I guess you could predict the answer to that question by looking at Mark Zuckerberg after he has apologised to the parents of children who have killed themselves due to his poor regulation of his site. He just went home, looked at his share price and decided he didn't give a shit after all.

ConsuelaHammock · 08/02/2024 23:11

I think the ultra rich are getting ready to colonise space. They know they’re fecked up the earth. That’s why Elon musk is so interested in space exploration.

ConsuelaHammock · 08/02/2024 23:09

We could ration air miles?

Ohdeardddddeardear · 08/02/2024 22:59

TheBeehive · 08/02/2024 22:42

worse case, abandon earth and colonize other planets and make earth 2.0

😂😂😂 good one. That gave me a good chortle. Thanks.

ForTonightGodisaDJ · 08/02/2024 22:47

I completely agree and read this just as an item about climate change came on the TV! They were saying how many football pitches are being flooded by severe weather and by 2050 a 1/4 of football pitches will be flooded.

TheBeehive · 08/02/2024 22:43

Ohdeardddddeardear · 08/02/2024 22:41

Money won’t buy them protection from what’s to come. They think it can but it can’t. Even if they are ok, what kind of life is it knowing you, in part, caused the awful
suffering you are seeing?

thats assuming they dont belive other reasons for the climate, and then most have their bunkers

TheBeehive · 08/02/2024 22:42

Ohdeardddddeardear · 08/02/2024 22:38

Ah. The fingers crossed for a technological saviour. Again, I wish that was likely but it’s a fairy tale we tell ourselves to help us to sleep at night.

It’s not my opinion. It’s science. Yes, that shifts and changes with new findings but this is as certain as it ever gets and the predictions have been right.

I so so wish I could join you in your ‘it will be fine’ camp. It must be so much nicer there. But it’s just not reality. You have been misinformed.

worse case, abandon earth and colonize other planets and make earth 2.0

Ohdeardddddeardear · 08/02/2024 22:41

Charlize43 · 08/02/2024 22:29

Celebrities & the Elite rant - Part 2

The other thing that gets on my tits are all these rich pricks & their rockets. Yes, I mean Elon Musk & Richard Branson, et al. I can't believe that doesn't contribute to pollution in vast quantities.

Any one seen Elysium - that Matt Damon movie where LA (and the earth) is a total shit hole and Jodie Foster and the Super Rich live on that luxurious space hotel with state of the art medical advancements and care (the NHS long perished and abandoned)?

Is that what they are aspiring to?

Money won’t buy them protection from what’s to come. They think it can but it can’t. Even if they are ok, what kind of life is it knowing you, in part, caused the awful
suffering you are seeing?