Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Can we talk about the elephant in the room?

263 replies

NeptunaOfTheMermaidBattleSquadron · 08/02/2024 10:57

I feel like as a society we need to start talking about the elephant in the room when it comes to climate change.

All these green measures being put on individuals are surely being wiped out because of all the bombing. Everywhere. All this war and conflict. No one is looking at the impact on the climate. Everything we're doing seems so trivial and pointless because in the same breath we're sending weapons (often called international aid) thousands of miles.

Then there's the manufacturing for it. The weapons testing. All the jet fuel to send the RAF USAF etc all around the world on bombing sprees. The supplies we're sending all over the place, weapons, medicine, rations... it's mind-boggling to think of the sheer scale of this.

And while we're acknowledging and working on fast fashion, home heating, electricity generation, over use of plastics, overpopulation, traceability etc, we're not even talking about or questioning all these bombs exploding everywhere!

We typically think of MAD as nuclear apocalypse, but surely people refusing to actually engage with each other to the point of forcing the world into something with the carbon footprint of a war (never mind several of them) is the climate change version of MAD. We can't reverse it.

I feel like politicians and diplomats just aren't trying hard enough with this because war is so profitable.

Why aren't just stop oil and all those other activists out there trying to protest the most avoidable thing we're doing with the biggest carbon footprint and pressuring governments to go back to diplomacy instead of treating their people as expendable?

IDK what the answer is but we seriously need to get a handle on this and stop using bombs to make points (they're not very good at it anyway) because of this: https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/science-environment-68110310

Sorry I just needed a bit of a rant. AIBU that they need to try harder to avoid armed conflicts and solve things like adults for the sake of the planet because the stakes are so much higher than one territory or issue? I haven't had much sleep this week so please explain why IABU if you think I am.

A firefighter sprays water during a wildfire on El Cable Hill near Bogota, Colombia, on Saturday, 27 January 2024

World's first year-long breach of key 1.5C warming limit

The last 12 months were the hottest on record, temporarily sending the world past a deeply symbolic mark.

https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/science-environment-68110310

OP posts:
Thread gallery
8
Fox111 · 09/02/2024 15:10

I think that we in the west are living with our pink sunglasses on and don't see the real problems with the world. Try to explain to a Ukranian soldier lying in the trench about net zero or to people in Middle East. We are fighting for some phantoms and really missing the real strategic and security problems however when we finally come to our senses it will be too late.

Spectre8 · 09/02/2024 14:47

makeanddo · 08/02/2024 11:21

Population is the elephant in the room. All we hear is how the birth rate is falling and we need to breed. David Attenborough has raised this but it seems to be largely ignored.

I agree, the planet cannot sustain ever growing population too many of us. I'm glad birth rates are falling but still a way to go.

whatarementomountainsandtrees · 09/02/2024 14:45

MartinsSpareCalculator · 09/02/2024 14:36

I think everyone with any awareness of climate change fully understands the impact of bombing. But the issue is that it isn't a good enough reason for the nations involved to call a ceasefire. Often science and politics are intertwined and reliant on one another, and sometimes as with war, one reigns supreme over the other.

The movement of rations, people and weapons is fairly immaterial though when you look just at the UK and how much of what we consume circumnavigates the globe either as a component or a finished product.

Ceasefires are not being called because the UK, US etc have intertwined national security with financial security, the conflicts around the world are invariably about money and power, land
Not science - politics and science rarely intertwine, covid is the only example i can think of recently.

MartinsSpareCalculator · 09/02/2024 14:36

I think everyone with any awareness of climate change fully understands the impact of bombing. But the issue is that it isn't a good enough reason for the nations involved to call a ceasefire. Often science and politics are intertwined and reliant on one another, and sometimes as with war, one reigns supreme over the other.

The movement of rations, people and weapons is fairly immaterial though when you look just at the UK and how much of what we consume circumnavigates the globe either as a component or a finished product.

whatarementomountainsandtrees · 09/02/2024 14:32

Thebestwaytoscareatory · 09/02/2024 14:00

Wow! There is so much misinformation and misunderstanding in this it's difficult to know where to start but I think your last paragraph really highlights this as you've completely misunderstood the issue.

It's not about cows directly increasing CO2 levels on the planet. It's about the unnatural movement of CO2 within the carbon cycle. Cows consume CO2 locked in the biosphere (where it is not acting as a greenhouse gas) and release it as CH4 (which is c28 times more potent than CO2 as a GHG) into the atmosphere, where it does contribute to the greenhouse effect.

Naturally you are correct this could be balanced out with the natural breakdown of CH4 into CO2 which is then reabsorbed by plants but, were not talking about a natural cycle as humans are artificially increase cattle numbers beyond what nature can cope with. And that's before you factor in all the other ghg emissions associated with the breeding, rearing, slaughtering, etc of cattle.

That's the crux of the entire issues, we are taking CO2 that should be locked away in the biosphere or geosphere and putting it into the atmosphere.

And part of the reason modelling is so flawed is because the rate of change is genuinely unprecedented. In previous cycles of warming and cooling, where the concentration of atmospheric CO2 has risen 200ppm to 1600+ppm have taken millions of years to complete.At current rates we'll do the same journey in 400-600 years.

I do agree the language used can be unhelpful but the idea that this isn't an issue because it's not outside the norms of history from a planetary perspective is ludicrous. From a planetary perspective it's far more common for their to be 20t carnivorous reptiles roaming around but if t-rex suddenly appeard on Oxford Street we would all go "meh, no point trying to stop it eating everyone, it's just part of Earth's cycle".

From a human perspective our entire existence has existed during a period where atmospheric CO2 was between. 180ppm and 300ppm. Every plant, animal & ecosystem we depend on evolved under those conditions. We're now at 420ppm and rising at a rate never before seen and with no idea how we or any of Earth's current systems will react to these changes.

I agree you are missing the point @bogwood. And this is not just about CO2. Look at the incredible and devastating changes within the ocean in the last 15 years - we have about 10 years before all the coral reefs disappear, the sea becomes a grave for dead fish and the only biodiversity you will see will be in relation to jellyfish. And how many electrical items are built now to last about 10 minutes? Soon the entire earth will be one huge rubbish tip full of electrical junk made out of plastic. Big business really does need to stop its antics. Totally unnecessary - just about increasing their already overwhelming wealth and power.

Thebestwaytoscareatory · 09/02/2024 14:00

Bogwood · 09/02/2024 11:06

There is not always one - but we are quickly silenced and very much ignored. There is very little unequivocal evidence. Yes, CO2 is a 'greenhouse gas' - a 'radiative forcing agent' - but the degree to which it contributes to any warming trends, beyond natural background causality, simply cannot be definitively known!
Climate science is not a monolithic body of accepted facts - climate is an extraordinarily complex system. Models have not managed to effectively predict climatic trajectories, nor can it be said with any certainty that they have managed to correctly ascertain past climatic patterns with accuracy . For instance, when it comes to palaeoclimate, we are dependent on proxy data and dating methods, for which the margin of error is invariably greater than the temperature range being modelled. We simply do not have the analytical resolution necessary to come out with headline-grabbing propaganda such as "the hottest day in human history". Really? Anyway, the very proxy temperature records that feed into the climatic models indicate warmer average temperatures during the last main interglacial (Eemian) than current temperatures. Why did no runaway global warming occur in the past, when temperatures and CO2 levels were higher? When we are told that there has never been a period of more rapid temperature increases - how does that fit in with the scientific evidence for the very rapid temperature changes of Dansgaard–Oeschger events?

I am not going to enter into any debate here - simply because I have been through the experience on enough occasions to know that it is too time-consuming (not because any response has made me 'see the light' - I know exactly what those responses will be because we are subjected to the same unchallenged rhetoric relentlessly). But you should all be sceptical about politicians telling you that the science is settled. Many eminent scientists will tell you differently (eg ) - the IPCC headlines are not sufficiently representative of the underlying complexity of climate science that the IPCC reports actually detail - simple as!

The climate narrative is just one more mechanism of societal control. So, if the climate emergency is really akin to a war, and if humans really have the power to control climate by simply turning the CO2 thermostat down, why are governments not rushing to issue everyone with carbon quota ration books immediately? The truth is the carbon footprint and environmental cost of much renewable technology, EV vehicles etc (not to mention the mining of rare earth metals) carries a cost that wouldn't stand up to scrutiny. So, too does the vegan nonsense. For instance, in very simple terms, grass-fed cattle cannot increase CO2 levels - it is a closed system. The carbon that becomes stored in and released from grass-fed cattle comes from the grass that they eat - which is a renewable resource (grown through storing CO2 from the atmosphere!) Yes, an overly simple example, but it serves to illustrate a point.

Wow! There is so much misinformation and misunderstanding in this it's difficult to know where to start but I think your last paragraph really highlights this as you've completely misunderstood the issue.

It's not about cows directly increasing CO2 levels on the planet. It's about the unnatural movement of CO2 within the carbon cycle. Cows consume CO2 locked in the biosphere (where it is not acting as a greenhouse gas) and release it as CH4 (which is c28 times more potent than CO2 as a GHG) into the atmosphere, where it does contribute to the greenhouse effect.

Naturally you are correct this could be balanced out with the natural breakdown of CH4 into CO2 which is then reabsorbed by plants but, were not talking about a natural cycle as humans are artificially increase cattle numbers beyond what nature can cope with. And that's before you factor in all the other ghg emissions associated with the breeding, rearing, slaughtering, etc of cattle.

That's the crux of the entire issues, we are taking CO2 that should be locked away in the biosphere or geosphere and putting it into the atmosphere.

And part of the reason modelling is so flawed is because the rate of change is genuinely unprecedented. In previous cycles of warming and cooling, where the concentration of atmospheric CO2 has risen 200ppm to 1600+ppm have taken millions of years to complete.At current rates we'll do the same journey in 400-600 years.

I do agree the language used can be unhelpful but the idea that this isn't an issue because it's not outside the norms of history from a planetary perspective is ludicrous. From a planetary perspective it's far more common for their to be 20t carnivorous reptiles roaming around but if t-rex suddenly appeard on Oxford Street we would all go "meh, no point trying to stop it eating everyone, it's just part of Earth's cycle".

From a human perspective our entire existence has existed during a period where atmospheric CO2 was between. 180ppm and 300ppm. Every plant, animal & ecosystem we depend on evolved under those conditions. We're now at 420ppm and rising at a rate never before seen and with no idea how we or any of Earth's current systems will react to these changes.

samarrange · 09/02/2024 13:26

Angrycat2768 · 09/02/2024 12:46

Yes partly due to cost and partly due to the pandemic we hadn't been abroad in 5 years, but we've had two holiday this year. One of them was by train, but we were lucky to be able to do it, and I woukd never have dine it with young children. I think of we had a carbon ration per person then you wouldn't have people being told they couldn't have 2 weeks in Benidorm flying on a package flight while others can seemingly just fly around for 15 minutes on their private jet without a care in the world.

Well, if you did that you would also have to ration pretty much everything else, not least because almost everything we own in a modern economy is full of energy (i.e., carbon). You would essentially have to build a Soviet- (or even Maoist-) style planned economy in which nobody can have a bigger house, a nicer car, or indeed a computing device that fits in the palm of your hand (or on your desk) and allows you to communicate your ideas to anyone who will listen. Good luck getting people to vote for that.

There are actually not very many private jets, and most of them spend most of their time sitting on the ground while their owners do Very Rich People Wheeling And Dealing Stuff. So while the most ostentatious lifestyles make headlines and consume a lot CO2 per person, and the people involved often seem to be awful human beings, they aren't contributing all that much in absolute terms to climate change. I saw an article last year showing that of the ten biggest CO2 emitters in Europe, nine were horrible coal-fired power stations in Germany or Poland, and the 10th was Ryanair.

So while I think Very Rich People are a bit weird (I pity some of them... they kind of have to stay away from 99.9% of the population because it would be weird to be sitting next to a billionaire in the pub), I think they are probably a necessary consequence of living in the kind of world where nice things like restaurants and travel are possible. I can pretty much guarantee that a world with a truly equitable carbon ration would not involve anybody having two weeks by air to Benidorm.

greengreengrass25 · 09/02/2024 12:48

Yes the wealthy and influential don't lead by example

Angrycat2768 · 09/02/2024 12:46

samarrange · 09/02/2024 12:36

This hits the nail on the head.

The vast majority of people will not accept any detectable reduction in their standard of living. They might just about accept a reduction in future improvements to that standard of living, which they don't really know they're missing, but if they could afford two weeks in Lanzarote last year and this year they can only afford a week in Minehead, they are going to be very unhappy, and if they think that the reason for that difference is because of increased taxes on energy, they will vote for the party that will reverse those tax increases.

You can see this when petrol gets expensive due to an oil price rise. In fact the politicians who annoy me the most when that happens are the Greens. When petrol hits £2 a litre or even more, a principled Green leader would say "This is great. It will lead to people driving less, which we have consistently said we want to see. Of course we'd prefer that the extra cost be in taxes rather than going to the oil companies and Saudi/UAE/Venezuela/Russia, but it's a start. We cannot save the planet while emitting as much CO2 as we do". Do they say that? Do they heckers.

(In our house we are probably just as guilty as everyone else. We don't buy much processed food and we only use the car once or twice a week, but we do like to travel. It's part of what makes life worth living. We all have things that are important to us, and it's not easy to accept other people whose major lifestyle preferences might be slightly less carbon-intensive that your own to wag fingers at you. If you do that enough, a lot of people just throw their hands in the air and vote for the wingnut party.)

Yes partly due to cost and partly due to the pandemic we hadn't been abroad in 5 years, but we've had two holiday this year. One of them was by train, but we were lucky to be able to do it, and I woukd never have dine it with young children. I think of we had a carbon ration per person then you wouldn't have people being told they couldn't have 2 weeks in Benidorm flying on a package flight while others can seemingly just fly around for 15 minutes on their private jet without a care in the world.

samarrange · 09/02/2024 12:36

Angrycat2768 · 09/02/2024 07:06

Only because people still want to have the same lifestyles- drive cars, eat meat every day. So instead of saying to people that the 90% of journeys of a mile or less should not be taken by car, we manufacture electric cars. Instead of saying ' eat more vegetables', we manufacture fake ultra processed ' meat' that is expensive and unpalatable. Instead of rationing airmiles for everyone we let the super rich do as they like and then plant some trees. We don't shame the middle classes into stopping their dinner party cocaine habits, even though huge swathes of rainforest, not to mention peoples lives, are being destroyed in its production. If we just, as others said, reduced consumption ( particularly those most able, so the most wealthy), then that would be a start. The reason China has so many coal fired power stations is because they in the main make money by manufacturing throwaway crap to us. They are also investing hugely in green energy. They aren't doing what we did, which was close coal mines and throw people on the scrapheap and not invest in alternative technologies. In 30 years' time, we will be scrabbling around wondering why we didn't invest in new technologies while China and India hold all the power. Because instead of investing in alternative energy we were saying ' but China ...' Short termism as usual.

This hits the nail on the head.

The vast majority of people will not accept any detectable reduction in their standard of living. They might just about accept a reduction in future improvements to that standard of living, which they don't really know they're missing, but if they could afford two weeks in Lanzarote last year and this year they can only afford a week in Minehead, they are going to be very unhappy, and if they think that the reason for that difference is because of increased taxes on energy, they will vote for the party that will reverse those tax increases.

You can see this when petrol gets expensive due to an oil price rise. In fact the politicians who annoy me the most when that happens are the Greens. When petrol hits £2 a litre or even more, a principled Green leader would say "This is great. It will lead to people driving less, which we have consistently said we want to see. Of course we'd prefer that the extra cost be in taxes rather than going to the oil companies and Saudi/UAE/Venezuela/Russia, but it's a start. We cannot save the planet while emitting as much CO2 as we do". Do they say that? Do they heckers.

(In our house we are probably just as guilty as everyone else. We don't buy much processed food and we only use the car once or twice a week, but we do like to travel. It's part of what makes life worth living. We all have things that are important to us, and it's not easy to accept other people whose major lifestyle preferences might be slightly less carbon-intensive that your own to wag fingers at you. If you do that enough, a lot of people just throw their hands in the air and vote for the wingnut party.)

Bawdrip · 09/02/2024 11:17

urbanbuddha · 09/02/2024 07:28

Herds of elephants in every room.

For instance it’s really common to receive goods ordered online in boxes which are far too big for the contents. Recent examples include a hat, a small bottle of serum, a silicone tray for the air fryer. All of these goods arrived in boxes which could have fitted a shelf’s worth of the product. So the many delivery lorries which drive these goods up and down motorways are mainly transporting empty space. Total waste of space! Appropriately sized boxes would mean fewer lorries, less energy.

There are so many examples where companies have not adjusted their strategies to deal with the crisis we are facing and time is running out.

Yes! My bugbear is Easter eggs. If you melted down all the chocolate in a lorry full of Easter eggs I reckon you'd get about a suitcase full. Such a stupid waste of resources and that's before you even get to the ingredients in the horrible chocolate. They should be banned.

Lilifer · 09/02/2024 11:16

@Bogwood the best summing up of this matter I have read in a long time!

MasterBeth · 09/02/2024 11:10

War is bad and climate change is bad.

No army will stop a war because of its climate impact.

Bogwood · 09/02/2024 11:06

There is not always one - but we are quickly silenced and very much ignored. There is very little unequivocal evidence. Yes, CO2 is a 'greenhouse gas' - a 'radiative forcing agent' - but the degree to which it contributes to any warming trends, beyond natural background causality, simply cannot be definitively known!
Climate science is not a monolithic body of accepted facts - climate is an extraordinarily complex system. Models have not managed to effectively predict climatic trajectories, nor can it be said with any certainty that they have managed to correctly ascertain past climatic patterns with accuracy . For instance, when it comes to palaeoclimate, we are dependent on proxy data and dating methods, for which the margin of error is invariably greater than the temperature range being modelled. We simply do not have the analytical resolution necessary to come out with headline-grabbing propaganda such as "the hottest day in human history". Really? Anyway, the very proxy temperature records that feed into the climatic models indicate warmer average temperatures during the last main interglacial (Eemian) than current temperatures. Why did no runaway global warming occur in the past, when temperatures and CO2 levels were higher? When we are told that there has never been a period of more rapid temperature increases - how does that fit in with the scientific evidence for the very rapid temperature changes of Dansgaard–Oeschger events?

I am not going to enter into any debate here - simply because I have been through the experience on enough occasions to know that it is too time-consuming (not because any response has made me 'see the light' - I know exactly what those responses will be because we are subjected to the same unchallenged rhetoric relentlessly). But you should all be sceptical about politicians telling you that the science is settled. Many eminent scientists will tell you differently (eg ) - the IPCC headlines are not sufficiently representative of the underlying complexity of climate science that the IPCC reports actually detail - simple as!

The climate narrative is just one more mechanism of societal control. So, if the climate emergency is really akin to a war, and if humans really have the power to control climate by simply turning the CO2 thermostat down, why are governments not rushing to issue everyone with carbon quota ration books immediately? The truth is the carbon footprint and environmental cost of much renewable technology, EV vehicles etc (not to mention the mining of rare earth metals) carries a cost that wouldn't stand up to scrutiny. So, too does the vegan nonsense. For instance, in very simple terms, grass-fed cattle cannot increase CO2 levels - it is a closed system. The carbon that becomes stored in and released from grass-fed cattle comes from the grass that they eat - which is a renewable resource (grown through storing CO2 from the atmosphere!) Yes, an overly simple example, but it serves to illustrate a point.

Dansgaard–Oeschger event - Wikipedia

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dansgaard%E2%80%93Oeschger_event

Angrycat2768 · 09/02/2024 09:05

Narwhalsh · 09/02/2024 08:28

Mass extinctions of the past (geological past, not human past) have taken thousands of years if not longer, so saying the word won’t be able to support life in 30 years is very much an exaggeration. But those mass extinctions haven’t killed EVERYTHING. Some animals have adapted and evolved and continued. Under normal climate change processes and timeframes, life does have the ability to adapt but the additional challenge here is the timeframe is being sped up (by us).

Yes. Animals have adapted to eat plastic and live in our rubbish in the oceans. Life forms will evolve to live in any kind of altered environment. We wouldnt have been able to breathe the air that dinosaurs breathed, andcthey would not be able to live in our atmosphere. The Earth will be fine, life on earth will continue in a different form on and on until the sun dies. The only reason to care about the environment is to save humanity from itself.

kerstina · 09/02/2024 08:51

You can slag off electric vehicles all you like but as someone who walks most places in a city there is no doubt the air is purer with less petrol fumes on the road.

Narwhalsh · 09/02/2024 08:28

PurpleAxe · 09/02/2024 01:28

Meh, I have given up.

Humanity appears to have a built in self destruct. I wish I had realised this before I had had kids. But I didn't, so I am focused on trying to make sure my little family are as well resourced as possible to see out the the time we have left.

I hope my kids don't have kids. They are smart and old enough to see the the same thing I do, but you never know.

We have passed the tipping point. The planet will be fine, it just won't be able to support humans for much long (certainly not much past 30 years or so and even that is a stretch).

Humanity is fucked, all that is left to see now is how to goes down.

Mass extinctions of the past (geological past, not human past) have taken thousands of years if not longer, so saying the word won’t be able to support life in 30 years is very much an exaggeration. But those mass extinctions haven’t killed EVERYTHING. Some animals have adapted and evolved and continued. Under normal climate change processes and timeframes, life does have the ability to adapt but the additional challenge here is the timeframe is being sped up (by us).

HappiestSleeping · 09/02/2024 07:33

Ohdeardddddeardear · 09/02/2024 06:52

You are not doing what you reasonably can. You don’t need to fly for pleasure. You could engage politically. Instead you are dampening people’s enthusiasm for changing by saying it’s pointless but not stating your source.

You are part of the problem that has already killed many and will kill many more.

I meant I'm doing what I can reasonably for me. I know I don't need to fly for pleasure, but I don't intend to stop. I don't do it often. I'm not going to stop driving either. I do ride a motorcycle which reduces my output.

I did quote my source. Pick any scientific study you like that gives a view of the reduction in co2 output necessary, and then match that with the actual output and the projected levels of actual output.

As for engaging politically, I haven't really been successful in that for any particular issue. I didn't want brexshit, but couldn't stop it. I didn't vote for the current shower screwing up the economy, but we have them anyway, and I have been voting based on climate change for decades. All of that is a drop in the ocean and only influences what happens in the UK at best.

Is it dampening enthusiasm, or is it being realistic about the need for alternative solutions?

urbanbuddha · 09/02/2024 07:28

YouveGotAFastCar · 08/02/2024 11:23

There's a lot of elephants in the room.

Taylor Swift's private jet, for example, and the lengths her legal team are going to to stop people from being able to see that she took a 13 minute flight yesterday... And she's not alone.

Climate change is the elephant, really. Nobody wants to think about impending devastation. It's much, much easier to ignore it, put your recycling out and "do your bit", and not have to contemplate that your children, or their children, won't have a habitable world.

Edited

Herds of elephants in every room.

For instance it’s really common to receive goods ordered online in boxes which are far too big for the contents. Recent examples include a hat, a small bottle of serum, a silicone tray for the air fryer. All of these goods arrived in boxes which could have fitted a shelf’s worth of the product. So the many delivery lorries which drive these goods up and down motorways are mainly transporting empty space. Total waste of space! Appropriately sized boxes would mean fewer lorries, less energy.

There are so many examples where companies have not adjusted their strategies to deal with the crisis we are facing and time is running out.

Angrycat2768 · 09/02/2024 07:23

Barbadossunset · 09/02/2024 07:21

ConsuelaHammock · Yesterday 23:09
We could ration air miles?

I agree but surely that would only work if every country agreed to it. Otherwise people would fly to the nearest country then go on from there.

Yes this is the problem. This is what Cop should be doing but we have weak world leaders who don't really care that much.

Barbadossunset · 09/02/2024 07:21

ConsuelaHammock · Yesterday 23:09
We could ration air miles?

I agree but surely that would only work if every country agreed to it. Otherwise people would fly to the nearest country then go on from there.

Ohdeardddddeardear · 09/02/2024 07:13

Angrycat2768 · 09/02/2024 07:06

Only because people still want to have the same lifestyles- drive cars, eat meat every day. So instead of saying to people that the 90% of journeys of a mile or less should not be taken by car, we manufacture electric cars. Instead of saying ' eat more vegetables', we manufacture fake ultra processed ' meat' that is expensive and unpalatable. Instead of rationing airmiles for everyone we let the super rich do as they like and then plant some trees. We don't shame the middle classes into stopping their dinner party cocaine habits, even though huge swathes of rainforest, not to mention peoples lives, are being destroyed in its production. If we just, as others said, reduced consumption ( particularly those most able, so the most wealthy), then that would be a start. The reason China has so many coal fired power stations is because they in the main make money by manufacturing throwaway crap to us. They are also investing hugely in green energy. They aren't doing what we did, which was close coal mines and throw people on the scrapheap and not invest in alternative technologies. In 30 years' time, we will be scrabbling around wondering why we didn't invest in new technologies while China and India hold all the power. Because instead of investing in alternative energy we were saying ' but China ...' Short termism as usual.

So true. We could be world leaders in green technology. We were on the cusp. Too many oil related vested interests have a seat at the table. Even at the COP meetings oil companies have strong representation. It’s like allowing tobacco companies a say in policies to limit lung cancer.

Angrycat2768 · 09/02/2024 07:06

ClosedGlassCase · 08/02/2024 23:59

And climate change as a concept is social control and a money making extravaganza for big business, globally

Much better off ignoring it all

Only because people still want to have the same lifestyles- drive cars, eat meat every day. So instead of saying to people that the 90% of journeys of a mile or less should not be taken by car, we manufacture electric cars. Instead of saying ' eat more vegetables', we manufacture fake ultra processed ' meat' that is expensive and unpalatable. Instead of rationing airmiles for everyone we let the super rich do as they like and then plant some trees. We don't shame the middle classes into stopping their dinner party cocaine habits, even though huge swathes of rainforest, not to mention peoples lives, are being destroyed in its production. If we just, as others said, reduced consumption ( particularly those most able, so the most wealthy), then that would be a start. The reason China has so many coal fired power stations is because they in the main make money by manufacturing throwaway crap to us. They are also investing hugely in green energy. They aren't doing what we did, which was close coal mines and throw people on the scrapheap and not invest in alternative technologies. In 30 years' time, we will be scrabbling around wondering why we didn't invest in new technologies while China and India hold all the power. Because instead of investing in alternative energy we were saying ' but China ...' Short termism as usual.

Ohdeardddddeardear · 09/02/2024 07:02

TempestTost · 09/02/2024 00:17

I think the elephant in the room is that all the fudges that are being pushed - electric vehicles, carbon trading, etc - are going to do bugger all. In some cases, like electric cars, it's a total scam.

People aren't willing to face that they will have to significantly change their consumption, and governments and business can't figure out how to make that work economically. So they tell each other, and themselves, lies about how technology will let them continue to live as they do now, more or less.

Whilst electric cars have their issues. There is a lot of misinformation. If you look at the evidence they work out better than petrol or diesel cars. If the batteries are mad using renewables they are lower footprint at the start but over a few years, no matter how they are produced, taking into account production too, they are lower emissions.

Ohdeardddddeardear · 09/02/2024 06:55

PurpleAxe · 09/02/2024 01:28

Meh, I have given up.

Humanity appears to have a built in self destruct. I wish I had realised this before I had had kids. But I didn't, so I am focused on trying to make sure my little family are as well resourced as possible to see out the the time we have left.

I hope my kids don't have kids. They are smart and old enough to see the the same thing I do, but you never know.

We have passed the tipping point. The planet will be fine, it just won't be able to support humans for much long (certainly not much past 30 years or so and even that is a stretch).

Humanity is fucked, all that is left to see now is how to goes down.

Who says ‘we have passed the tipping point?’ I haven’t heard any credible sources that have said that.