Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Can we talk about the elephant in the room?

263 replies

NeptunaOfTheMermaidBattleSquadron · 08/02/2024 10:57

I feel like as a society we need to start talking about the elephant in the room when it comes to climate change.

All these green measures being put on individuals are surely being wiped out because of all the bombing. Everywhere. All this war and conflict. No one is looking at the impact on the climate. Everything we're doing seems so trivial and pointless because in the same breath we're sending weapons (often called international aid) thousands of miles.

Then there's the manufacturing for it. The weapons testing. All the jet fuel to send the RAF USAF etc all around the world on bombing sprees. The supplies we're sending all over the place, weapons, medicine, rations... it's mind-boggling to think of the sheer scale of this.

And while we're acknowledging and working on fast fashion, home heating, electricity generation, over use of plastics, overpopulation, traceability etc, we're not even talking about or questioning all these bombs exploding everywhere!

We typically think of MAD as nuclear apocalypse, but surely people refusing to actually engage with each other to the point of forcing the world into something with the carbon footprint of a war (never mind several of them) is the climate change version of MAD. We can't reverse it.

I feel like politicians and diplomats just aren't trying hard enough with this because war is so profitable.

Why aren't just stop oil and all those other activists out there trying to protest the most avoidable thing we're doing with the biggest carbon footprint and pressuring governments to go back to diplomacy instead of treating their people as expendable?

IDK what the answer is but we seriously need to get a handle on this and stop using bombs to make points (they're not very good at it anyway) because of this: https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/science-environment-68110310

Sorry I just needed a bit of a rant. AIBU that they need to try harder to avoid armed conflicts and solve things like adults for the sake of the planet because the stakes are so much higher than one territory or issue? I haven't had much sleep this week so please explain why IABU if you think I am.

A firefighter sprays water during a wildfire on El Cable Hill near Bogota, Colombia, on Saturday, 27 January 2024

World's first year-long breach of key 1.5C warming limit

The last 12 months were the hottest on record, temporarily sending the world past a deeply symbolic mark.

https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/science-environment-68110310

OP posts:
Thread gallery
8
fuchsteufelswild · 11/02/2024 02:10

Spectre8 · 09/02/2024 19:47

A male coworker said to me there is 6yrs and we are 6yrs away from climate catastrophe and he was saying this after boasting about how he got an electric car and I said well there is still a carbon footprint somewhere e.g generating electricity.

So I look forward ro 6yrs time when there isn't one and I can tell him I told u so.

I always wanted to find out which make is used when someone compares an ICE and an EV in terms of emission parity. Let's say your EV finally has as big a carbon footprint as a gas guzzling car after driving it for five years, in a worst case scenario that's half the battery's lifespan. What kind of ICE is used for comparison is what I would like to know.

ShineOnBrightly · 10/02/2024 23:00

Everyone stop using the Internet. That would help.

RunningFromInsanity · 10/02/2024 16:27

Of all the reasons to stop war and bombing, the impact on the climate is not the top one..

Yalta · 10/02/2024 16:18

Why aren't just stop oil and all those other activists out there trying to protest the most avoidable thing we're doing with the biggest carbon footprint and pressuring

Because they like to cause a huge carbon footprint rather than doing anything meaningful.

Anyone who was around the Dartford crossing during the time that they decided to scale the bridge will understand what havoc they caused not just to motorists but the environment thy supposedly want to save

Supernova23 · 10/02/2024 13:18

I stopped worrying about something I can’t control years ago. I do my bit, but also I’m a hypocrite because I drive a car, travel a couple of times a year by plane etc. Collectively we won’t stop until we’ve destroyed the entire planet. That won’t change and will only get worse with the ever increasing population and gas guzzling countries like America, China etc.

samarrange · 10/02/2024 13:07

Fox111 · 10/02/2024 07:57

@NeptunaOfTheMermaidBattleSquadron
Some sort of UN resolution banning armed conflicts and forcing people to resolve issues like adults instead of scrapping like kids in a playground would go a long way.

I think that you have summarized it very well in one sentence. Your intentions are correct but the absence of means to in-force them makes the world a very dangerous and unpredictable. There needs to be a huge multi national armed force which could in force UN resolution.

Same with the global warming. What use is it when we voluntarily give up our industry, force whole regions of the country into unemployment and misery just to achieve net zero. We know for sure that steel demand is rising and if we close one plant in Wales there will be two plants build in China and India.

What you mention here in the first paragraph is actually right there in the UN Charter. States are meant to solve their differences at the International Court of Justice. However, I think Stalin might have had his fingers crossed behind his back when he signed the charter.

I used to be a fan of the UN, and I used to get Very Cross Indeed when right-wing American politicians called it a useless talking shop. It still does a lot of good in many areas. But in terms of preventing the biggest military powers doing what they want, it is indeed a useless talking shop, because of the vetoes in the Security Council. Realising that the UN is simply not able to do what most of us were told in primary school that it would do is, I think, part of being a realist about the world.

threatmatrix · 10/02/2024 11:05

Ohdeardddddeardear · 10/02/2024 07:13

😂😂😂

You’re really good at debate aren’t you 🙄

T1Dmama · 10/02/2024 10:21

Write to putin and express your concerns.

mjf981 · 10/02/2024 10:09

I feel hopeless about it all. Wars don't help, but the whole world is set up to use and consume and its finite. And it won't change, as we're too weak and selfish to make any sort of difference until it is too late (and i believe we're past that point anyway).
I deal with it by remaining childless, ignoring the negative news where I can, enjoying nature as much as I can and realizing that before too long I'll be gone and forgotten. I fear for the next generation but for now, I'm now I'm just to trying to live my life and enjoy it for what it is.

Popeyewhereareyou · 10/02/2024 09:43

Ohdeardddddeardear · 08/02/2024 17:24

I agree OP and saw the same article and almost started a thread. I feel so exasperated with humans.

cutting down on or quitting unnecessary flights is an easy win. No one NEEDS a holiday. It’s a luxury.

I'll stop going on holiday when the elites stop flying into Davos in their private jets.

Merlin3189 · 10/02/2024 09:14

YANBU, but you should not worry about it. I'm grateful for anything which counters the Net Zero policy. War is a ridiculous extreme! So I'd rather we had other ways.

Wars are very costly. They make funding NZ even more difficult, but that also makes the good solution - adaptation - more difficult. It's much cheaper than NZ, but we can't afford it so long as we spend so much on NZ.
Wars also illustrate another problem with NZ. If people want to kill each other on the scale of wars, they'll hardly cooperate and sacrifice their standard of living to save their enemies from a hypothetical climate change.

anon666 · 10/02/2024 08:48

The difference is control. We have no control over Putin and other world dictators like the religious maniacs in the Middle East. They will, if left, keep pursuing their goals of totalitarianism.

We could stand by or we can try to defend free peoples of the world.

Putin doesn't give flying f* about climate change, he's a megalomaniac.

There are many ways for humanity to annihilate itself and at the moment it feels like a race to the finish as to which one will.

YABU to think it's an elephant in the room - noone is ignoring it they just don't have control

Fox111 · 10/02/2024 07:57

@NeptunaOfTheMermaidBattleSquadron
Some sort of UN resolution banning armed conflicts and forcing people to resolve issues like adults instead of scrapping like kids in a playground would go a long way.

I think that you have summarized it very well in one sentence. Your intentions are correct but the absence of means to in-force them makes the world a very dangerous and unpredictable. There needs to be a huge multi national armed force which could in force UN resolution.

Same with the global warming. What use is it when we voluntarily give up our industry, force whole regions of the country into unemployment and misery just to achieve net zero. We know for sure that steel demand is rising and if we close one plant in Wales there will be two plants build in China and India.

Ohdeardddddeardear · 10/02/2024 07:13

threatmatrix · 09/02/2024 23:12

look up the ones you believe then see who pays them, you might be surprised. What about when they dug up many feet of ice that you see everything that’s been going on for hundreds of not more years. That debunked it as well. A group of high ups got together in the 60’s to discuss how to make more money from the masses, guess what they came up with ? Climate change. Telling you I’ve been to Alaska might give you the hint I’m very interested in it. The worst thing for the world at the moment is plastic. Oh I spent 4 months there it’s amazing you should go.

😂😂😂

Bogwood · 10/02/2024 06:15

Thebestwaytoscareatory · 09/02/2024 14:00

Wow! There is so much misinformation and misunderstanding in this it's difficult to know where to start but I think your last paragraph really highlights this as you've completely misunderstood the issue.

It's not about cows directly increasing CO2 levels on the planet. It's about the unnatural movement of CO2 within the carbon cycle. Cows consume CO2 locked in the biosphere (where it is not acting as a greenhouse gas) and release it as CH4 (which is c28 times more potent than CO2 as a GHG) into the atmosphere, where it does contribute to the greenhouse effect.

Naturally you are correct this could be balanced out with the natural breakdown of CH4 into CO2 which is then reabsorbed by plants but, were not talking about a natural cycle as humans are artificially increase cattle numbers beyond what nature can cope with. And that's before you factor in all the other ghg emissions associated with the breeding, rearing, slaughtering, etc of cattle.

That's the crux of the entire issues, we are taking CO2 that should be locked away in the biosphere or geosphere and putting it into the atmosphere.

And part of the reason modelling is so flawed is because the rate of change is genuinely unprecedented. In previous cycles of warming and cooling, where the concentration of atmospheric CO2 has risen 200ppm to 1600+ppm have taken millions of years to complete.At current rates we'll do the same journey in 400-600 years.

I do agree the language used can be unhelpful but the idea that this isn't an issue because it's not outside the norms of history from a planetary perspective is ludicrous. From a planetary perspective it's far more common for their to be 20t carnivorous reptiles roaming around but if t-rex suddenly appeard on Oxford Street we would all go "meh, no point trying to stop it eating everyone, it's just part of Earth's cycle".

From a human perspective our entire existence has existed during a period where atmospheric CO2 was between. 180ppm and 300ppm. Every plant, animal & ecosystem we depend on evolved under those conditions. We're now at 420ppm and rising at a rate never before seen and with no idea how we or any of Earth's current systems will react to these changes.

Oh dear, I did say that my first post on this thread would be my only one - but there is something that really grates about the supercilious "Oh Wow" responses, which imply disbelief at my stupidity! I am very well read on this matter, I do understand the complexity of the science (I am a scientist). I am not misunderstanding the fundamentals, as you suggest. In a forum like this, it is only possible to set out the principal areas in a relatively simplistic way. Thus, you picked up on my example of grass-fed cattle representing a closed system - I stated that I was painting a deliberately simplistic model, for the sake of argument - yet you still thought it pertinent to point out the impact of ancillary issues of intensive farming's carbon footprint - I could choose to do the same with the massive carbon footprint and environmental damage associated with the production of renewable technology and EV production (including the massive mining programme needed to supply the basic raw materials). As for the methane product of the bovine metabolic process, which is a more powerful radiative forcing agents than CO2. Agreed - but at concentrations a couple of hundred times lower than CO2, and with an atmospheric lifespan measured in decades, rather than hundreds of years, the contribution of methane is most probably being somewhat exaggerated - and is certainly difficult to model with any accuracy.
As for CO2, there is no straightforward, linear relationship, and I would challenge you to find any place within the actual main body of the most recent IPCC report contributing evidence (not from the headline-grabbing summaries written for political purposes!) that indicates that there is! The problem is that the complex, nonlinear climatic system is being modelled in a linear way, through imposing a wide range of artificial constraints and assumptions. The supposed accuracy of climate model simulations is tested by trying to match output to past climatic variation - but this is, in turn, achieved through retrospectively 'tuning' the models to that data, which builds in a ludicrous level of circularity and ensures that the ascribed level of CO2 sensitivity of individual variables within the model is not based on actual scientific understanding, but is fudged to achieve the desired crude match. Thus, if this 'match' has been achieved through tuning the wrong variables to the wrong degree, this will have an inbuilt error that can produce huge inaccuracy to simulations of future climate, skewed towards exaggerated sensitivity to CO2, which has framed and constrained the initial modelling parameters.

My fundamental gripe is that the current context is skewed in favour of politics over science. Just as it turned out that the science was far more nuanced when it came to Covid, and the politicians certainly were not 'following the science' in a transparent and objective way, so too (only to a far greater degree, with an area of science that is arguably far more complicated) is the climatic system being misrepresented as a known quantity, in which the balance of probabilities dictates a narrow range of logical responses. Any competent scrutiny would conclude that this is a dangerously simplistic analysis of the risk landscape - and that such a limited application of the precautionary principle is likely to face untold socioeconomic fallout that could make the ostensible cure far worse than the poorly-modelled problem.

Anyway, I cannot pretend (in contrast to the 'science is settled' propaganda that is perpetuated through the media and by the political class) to have all the answers - no competent scientist would. But it is worth being aware that the balance of probability is not being accurately reflected in the headline messages that are being churned out, in order to justify some extreme policy changes that will, in turn, have potentially extreme socioeconomic consequences over very short time periods. If you really are interested in gaining a balanced insight into the actual complexity of climate science, I can recommend Dr Judith Curry's intelligent overview and framing of the principal issues   - which is reasonably accessible. Her latest book is very accessible https://anthempress.com/climate-uncertainty-and-risk-pb. And, actually, that is what it takes to even scrape the surface of the complex issues underpinning this debate (for, indeed, it should still be socially acceptable to have a debate) - a book, with many links to many scientific papers - not a quick headline-screaming post on Mumsnet!

Climate Uncertainty and Risk

Dr. Judith Curry, President & Co-Founder of the Climate Forecast Applications Network, delivers the keynote at NJBIA's 2023 Energy Policy Conference where sh...

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=hp5ANZuV7FA

Barbadossunset · 10/02/2024 05:36

ensayers · 10/02/2024 00:02

The real elephant in the room regards climate change is a MASSIVE overpopulation of the planet. Compared to even a hundred years ago medicine is more effective, we are living much longer, fewer childbirth deaths etc etc
For obvious reasons nobody wants to start a discussion on dealing with that one!

Korea and China (and maybe Japan) the birth rate is falling but rather than seeing this as a good thing, the governments there are theming to persuade people to have more children.

Barbadossunset · 10/02/2024 05:34

Some sort of UN resolution banning armed conflicts and forcing people to resolve issues like adults instead of scrapping like kids in a playground would go a long way.

Op how would the UN enforce this resolution?

Bridgetta · 10/02/2024 05:33

Why are you worried about climate change? Honestly…

blueandsad · 10/02/2024 03:08

... or just by a slightly dippy hippie-mumsnet type ...Probably would have appeased Hilter and got us all to learn fluent German ( not a bad idea in itself ... given how thick Brits are )

blueandsad · 10/02/2024 02:31

SquashedSquashess ·

Your view on war is very naive OP. Do you let all the Ukrainian refugees know that their country just didn’t “negotiate hard enough” with Putin’s regime when it invaded their country? Would you feel comfortable telling them that they should sacrifice their culture, language and heritage to save the planet?

TOTALLY AGREE - MY IMMEDIATE REACTION TO THIS POSTING WAS A STRONG SUSPICION THAT IT IS WRITTEN BY A RUSSIAN / A RUSSIAN PROPAGANDA OPERATIVE or even an FSB algorithm bot . Russsian stooges are flooding the internet / FB / newspapers with covert propaganda : it is often heavily disguised and it is absolutely everywhere - eg on Facebook Homes For Ukraine ......., a lot of the seemingly " English "contributors are FSB propaganda handlers . No wonder Hilary Clinton lost to Trump and Marine Le Pen's vote is rocketing / Brexit etc etc

TempestTost · 10/02/2024 01:47

Ohdeardddddeardear · 09/02/2024 07:02

Whilst electric cars have their issues. There is a lot of misinformation. If you look at the evidence they work out better than petrol or diesel cars. If the batteries are mad using renewables they are lower footprint at the start but over a few years, no matter how they are produced, taking into account production too, they are lower emissions.

I assume you mean there is a larger footprint at the start.

But to replace conventional cars with electric cars would mean stripping the world of many of its minerals. Which is hugely environmentally destructive. It's not just about emissions.

Comfortablechair · 10/02/2024 00:09

This is useful post actually as I’ve thought about this a lot so I’ll try and be short. My old mindset was basically I care but what can I do? Does it really matter what I do in little old England if the millions in the BRIC countries are still pumping out fossil fuels as they are going through a growing middle class? And why do we have the right to restrict them given that the West / UK built our empire on their natural resources? So lots of moral and geopolitical questions - then I had a lightbulb moment - positive climate change behaviour is an attitude that does matter because if we all do small acts it can lead to big action and big legislative changes can happen. I was thinking in a lazy way about it all rather than an engaged way. Most positives changes are difficult and uncomfortable. Your war comment is an interesting one - I would say there comes a point where stopping human casualties today (or stopping the people who create these) through the most effective military strategies beats saving the planet tomorrow. It’s one day at a time, one action at a day. But I have learnt those little
tbings do matter to me - they align with my own values and beliefs And Contribute.

ensayers · 10/02/2024 00:02

The real elephant in the room regards climate change is a MASSIVE overpopulation of the planet. Compared to even a hundred years ago medicine is more effective, we are living much longer, fewer childbirth deaths etc etc
For obvious reasons nobody wants to start a discussion on dealing with that one!

Spectre8 · 09/02/2024 23:39

OldPerson · 09/02/2024 20:29

Look on the bright side. If half the world's human population did not exist, there would be no climate change issues. I'm all for people having fewer children, than buying into Ponzi scheme of "Year-on-Year Government growth" fuelled by an ever expanding and unsustainable human population. War, Famine, Diesease and Natural Disasters have always been the counter-balances on too many people.

100%

We wouldn't need to manufacture so much stuff if there were less people to consume things like, there would be far less waste

NeptunaOfTheMermaidBattleSquadron · 09/02/2024 23:39

I'm also a bit stunned at how much this thread grew! But hey everyone's talking about it now.

I do disagree with those saying "tell that to the people in Ukraine". Err... their country is the one getting fucked over in all the ways I described. It looks like both sides are in a massive stalemate that can either end now with some proper talks or in 2-3 years time with some proper talks and even more damage to both sides.

Wars never solve anything, they just get people into stalemates when they are running out of people and resources on both sides and have to actually start listening to each other.

I don't think it's crazy to want to cut out all the suffering and pain and skip to the bit where the people sending their populations to their deaths just stop that and sort their problems out around a table.

Some sort of UN resolution banning armed conflicts and forcing people to resolve issues like adults instead of scrapping like kids in a playground would go a long way.

OP posts: