Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Can we talk about the elephant in the room?

263 replies

NeptunaOfTheMermaidBattleSquadron · 08/02/2024 10:57

I feel like as a society we need to start talking about the elephant in the room when it comes to climate change.

All these green measures being put on individuals are surely being wiped out because of all the bombing. Everywhere. All this war and conflict. No one is looking at the impact on the climate. Everything we're doing seems so trivial and pointless because in the same breath we're sending weapons (often called international aid) thousands of miles.

Then there's the manufacturing for it. The weapons testing. All the jet fuel to send the RAF USAF etc all around the world on bombing sprees. The supplies we're sending all over the place, weapons, medicine, rations... it's mind-boggling to think of the sheer scale of this.

And while we're acknowledging and working on fast fashion, home heating, electricity generation, over use of plastics, overpopulation, traceability etc, we're not even talking about or questioning all these bombs exploding everywhere!

We typically think of MAD as nuclear apocalypse, but surely people refusing to actually engage with each other to the point of forcing the world into something with the carbon footprint of a war (never mind several of them) is the climate change version of MAD. We can't reverse it.

I feel like politicians and diplomats just aren't trying hard enough with this because war is so profitable.

Why aren't just stop oil and all those other activists out there trying to protest the most avoidable thing we're doing with the biggest carbon footprint and pressuring governments to go back to diplomacy instead of treating their people as expendable?

IDK what the answer is but we seriously need to get a handle on this and stop using bombs to make points (they're not very good at it anyway) because of this: https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/science-environment-68110310

Sorry I just needed a bit of a rant. AIBU that they need to try harder to avoid armed conflicts and solve things like adults for the sake of the planet because the stakes are so much higher than one territory or issue? I haven't had much sleep this week so please explain why IABU if you think I am.

A firefighter sprays water during a wildfire on El Cable Hill near Bogota, Colombia, on Saturday, 27 January 2024

World's first year-long breach of key 1.5C warming limit

The last 12 months were the hottest on record, temporarily sending the world past a deeply symbolic mark.

https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/science-environment-68110310

OP posts:
Thread gallery
8
WhatWhereWho · 08/02/2024 14:45

GladAllOver · 08/02/2024 11:05

If we stop defending freedom against brutal dictators, you won't have any opportunity to make choices to save the planet. You'll just do as you are told.

Who is 'we' and how are 'we' doing that?

dollyolly · 08/02/2024 14:45

We keep talking about manufacturing and fast fashion and landills

Mmmm. A huge amount of this discourse is simply marketing. It's noise and PR, pushed by brands and manufacturers, as a way to differentiate themselves, appear virtuous/high status and sell more shit. For politicians, similar.

Yeah, it seems like 'we're all talking about it'. But it's just noise. Are companies actually refraining from pollution and exploitation? Are people actually choosing not to take flights, buy loads of shit and stop driving? No and no.

RhubarbGingerJam · 08/02/2024 14:33

If there is only "public" transport, you can charge companies to get a licence to operate, and they must do EXACTLY as they're told or you can pull their licence. Fares paid upfront, dynamic pricing, all in the name of the great god of Climate Change.

As someone who doesn't drive and lives outside London I'd really like someone anyone to invest in public transport - public transport in many part of the UK are so bad and unreliable after decades of underinvestment getting worse many people are increasingly forced into private car travel even if they'd rather use public transport.

We are so far from having half decent public transport than idea of only having public transport is unbelievable.

chopinwaltz26 · 08/02/2024 14:33

Berthold Brecht wrote that war is trade carried out by other means.
As for climate change, removing the internet would make an enormous saving in CO2 emissions, but nobody ever wants to talk about data centres etc.

aloris · 08/02/2024 14:29

I agree that economic dependence on growth is part of the problem because it means everyone is motivated to increase the amount of "stuff" sold so that we can have growth and therefore healthy economies.

We are constantly being sold more gadgets to do stuff for us, but each gadget is made of physical resources that must be mined, processed, shipped (many miles, using trucks or ships etc), and then after they are used (and used up) will end up in a landfill somewhere. How many broken laptops are thrown away each year. All those plastic cases and now-useless little circuits made of metal and all sorts. Clothing is discarded because it is stained or frayed. Washing machines "wear out" and it's more expensive to fix them than replace them.

It also bothers me to hear I must do this and that to reduce my dependence on climate-destroying energy when a wealthy person can wipe out all the benefits of my efforts and sacrifices with one short flight on their private jet.

Also, the claims that we must all eat less meat or no meat, to save the planet, bother me because I have a dietary restriction that means I depend on meat to survive.

MissyB1 · 08/02/2024 14:26

Really interesting thread OP, and yes I agree with you. War is all about greed, and there are always profits to be made from war, and I suspect the damage done to our world by war doesn’t worry the profit makers too much!

And yes I’m furious with the current war mongering going on, and I include our politicians in that!

Hereyoume · 08/02/2024 14:26

First of all, stop stressing about "Climate Change". That is a narrative being pushed by Western political dogma, and while there are some points we shold take note of, saving the planet isn't the reason we are supposed to be "net zero" by 2050.

Have you ever stopped to think about why EVERY single "solution" to the "climate crisis" involves YOU paying money?

For example, the air quality in London is apparently so bad, that the only "solution" is to charge people £12.50 a day to drive there! Money cleans the air! Who knew!

You can end global warming by paying lots of money to buy a new EV, because yeah, you guessed it, money cleans the air! (We will ignore the carbon footprint of the EV and gloss over the fact it has a useful lifespan of less than 10 years)

You can help the Polar Bears by spending thousands on a "heat" pump. Again, spending money saves the day!

The government drive to get rid of private vehicle ownership is nothing to do with saving penguins. It's about putting control measures in place so revenue streams can be manipulated to generate the most profit. If there is only "public" transport, you can charge companies to get a licence to operate, and they must do EXACTLY as they're told or you can pull their licence. Fares paid upfront, dynamic pricing, all in the name of the great god of Climate Change.

And if the people don't like being told what to do, we'll tough, because if they ever try to protest you can just shut the transport system down and prevent them travelling anywhere they might wave some flags around.

Cashless society ensures a perfect record of every individuals purchase history.

Carless society ensures a perfect record of every individuals travel history.

If the government really cared about the climate, they would be calling for a huge reduction in the number of children being born. WE create the pollution. There are simply too many people alive on this planet, less people equals less pollution, but politicians don't have the guts to say that.

It hurts to say this, but, if you cared about the planet, actually cared, not just pretend outrage, you would not have children.

All this faux outrage about SUV's killing the planet is a little pathetic. The irony of 30 school kids telling drivers to switch off their engines outside the school, when those kids mere existence will cause immesurably more damage to the planet than a little petrol engine will ever do.

Don't stress about "Climate Change" OP, because if you do then you are falling for the rhetoric.

Regarding war, don't worry, unless it's nuclear, the planet will.survive just fine, its survived much worse things that we have ever done to it, and even if we wipe ourselves out in a Nuclear conflict, the planet will recover, and move on without us.

I mean, even Just Stop Oil don't bother coming out during the winter, it's far too cold to play planet warriors this time of year. Saving the Polar Bears can wait until at least the end of May 🙄

That's how much they care about the planet.

User135644 · 08/02/2024 14:26

Or watch your carbon footprint but let's import a million people every year.

Not to mention all the displaced people heading west to flee all these bullshit wars.

MotherOfCatBoy · 08/02/2024 14:23

On China, yes they are still building coal fired plants but they are building wind and solar at the same rate: they are predicted to hit peak emissions soon (2035 or something) and then drop thereafter, like the EU did. They are driving the change in technology hard, faster than in the West.
Im no fan of China’s politics - haven’t forgotten the Uighurs - but I can’t stand the whataboutery that people use to absolve themselves of any personal responsibility or national lobbying.
All countries need to make this switch.

bakewellbride · 08/02/2024 14:17

If you want to help the planet the best thing you can do is go vegan. Everything else doesn't come anywhere near as close when it comes to your carbon footprint.

NeptunaOfTheMermaidBattleSquadron · 08/02/2024 14:13

@Poppysmom22 Yes I 100% agree with that.

OP posts:
NeptunaOfTheMermaidBattleSquadron · 08/02/2024 14:12

gmgnts · 08/02/2024 13:08

Do you have any statistics to show that current wars are contributing disproportionately to climate change, compared to, say, the aviation industry (or many other global industries) or the shipping industry, or greenhouse emissions, or modern agricultural practices, or population growth, et, etc.?

No because I didn't say any of that. Please don't twist my words to suit yourself.

OP posts:
Poppysmom22 · 08/02/2024 14:07

We can make all the changes we want as individuals and even as a nation but unless you make the USA and China think differently there’s no chance of any real change

NeptunaOfTheMermaidBattleSquadron · 08/02/2024 14:02

With regards to population, I did mention that in my OP that people do talk about that quite a lot as an aspect of climate change. It's constantly talked about. It's the go-to on MN every time anyone mentions the climate people all but come out with "put those babies back inside you, that'll fix it". Maybe that's why people are being so dismissive of war, because by ending human lives, on the surface it ends their carbon footprint. Except it doesn't. Because for every life lost, another human has to come into the economy to replace their peacetime role. Which means double the carbon footprint per war casualty up to the age of death.

My personal view on that is (like war and a bunch of other issues) the economy is too dependent on growth. Until we reimagine the global economy as something that doesn't need to be propped up by the Military Industrial Complex and a constant stream of people being fed in at the bottom of the economy to prop up those at the other end like the world's biggest pyramid scheme, I don't see how we can sort any of this out.

We keep talking about manufacturing and fast fashion and landills, and we should, but conflicts are turning countries into landfills full of pointless manufactured items whose sole purpose was to do as much damage to the other side's resources. It's so blase and I don't think this attitude to conflict resolution has a place in the 21st century and certainly doesn't move us forward.

Even on this thread someone has the idea that war is about opposing dictators that threaten some given value of freedom, where in reality, most wars seem to involve two sides chucking a load of resources at each other, breaking each other's stuff as much as possible, until they're in a stalemate and have to go back to the negotiating table.

It doesn't seem crazy to expect modern leaders to cut all that crap out and to just insist they try harder at the negotiating table in the first place.

It's not a case of "this is more important than all the other stuff we already know/talk about" it's a case of "this is as important and should be talked about at all". Climate change isn't an either/or. It's a "we need to look at all of it together and sort it all out".

I think we need a culture shift on everything, and with so much recent news reporting that we're on the brink of an even bigger major European war in the next decade, I think we need to think about what will be left of the planet if that were to happen, even if no one presses the button on the nukes.

I just don't know where we start with it all. Maybe I'm just rambling IDK.

OP posts:
NeptunaOfTheMermaidBattleSquadron · 08/02/2024 14:02

I'm really pleased that I've come back to find lots of good well made points looking at lots of different aspects of this and not much "you wear shoes so you can't care about the planet!!" a smidge of whataboutery and only one "why don't you protest then???" (who says I don't? And I do know a few protesters who are out every week for every little thing and who resent those who aren't; I don't think that actually helps anything TBH, but I can't march by myself, that's just a walk, and no one is marching to stop war for climate reasons because no one is talking about it).
I was a bit hesitant posting in AIBU especially when I'm not sure I've expressed this very well.

OP posts:
strawberriesarenot · 08/02/2024 13:30

I have exactly the same fears. And the habitat destruction, and death to wildlife. A year ago I heard 50,000 dolphins killed due to missiles in the Black Sea. It must be much worse now.
I cannot bear being lead into war and destruction by wicked old men. In Russia, the USA, Israel, UK, Iran and Iraq, Sudan.. the list is endless.

ilovebreadsauce · 08/02/2024 13:29

You don't still believe all that climate change nonsense?

Poppysmom22 · 08/02/2024 13:27

While there are people making $$$$$$$$$$$$$ from fossil fuels you will never eradicate them not to mention the lack of a viable alternative

Serrates · 08/02/2024 13:25

Even if diplomacy ends up being the way we resolve conflicts, we still need to maintain and fund armed forces and weapons (even if they never get used). Because not having defences is an open door to our enemies.

As for the other stuff, it requires government intervention. Companies will keep selling damaging products as long as they’re legally allowed to, and people will keep buying them because they’re cheap. The government literally has to ban the cheap harmful stuff otherwise it will keep getting made and bought.

I sell stuff in my job and we make great efforts to be eco friendly, only for consumers to say “this is too expensive compared to this cheap but environmentally damaging product”. We can’t compete on price without being equally damaging - the only way to make people buy eco products (which cost more) is to ban the cheap and damaging alternatives.

MojoMoon · 08/02/2024 13:22

Why do Just Stop Oil protestors need to stop doing their protests? It's not a full time role for them - they can protest against oil AND protest against war? (If you have ever met any in the climate protest movement, they are a demographic who bloody love a protest and will absolutely have been at Palestinian matches, ban the bomb, anti Iraq)
Why can't you round up other people who aren't protesting about anything and head out in your own protest?

I'm a bit suspicious of anything that is "why don't climate protestors focusing on Y focus on X instead"? It's just a way of trying to diminish the importance of issue Y. Maybe both are important?

It just smells a bit of whataboutery and a way of trying to make taking climate action of any kind pointless. What's the point of recycling my tin cans when China is building coal fired power plants etc.

ADoggyDogWorld · 08/02/2024 13:17

I am assuming in this instance that MAD = mutually assured destruction.

OP you make good points.

wheo · 08/02/2024 13:15

Also countries like china and India which are some of the biggest polluters. Me cycling to work a few times a week isn't going to tip the scale if we are still doing business with countries like this.

cerisepanther73 · 08/02/2024 13:13

@NeptunaOfTheMermaidBattleSquadron

Very interesting thread post idea..

Swipe left for the next trending thread