Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Naga Munchetty vs Chris Philp

61 replies

Betterbuckleupbarbara · 08/02/2024 10:54

Usually I can’t watch her but AIBU on this occasion to feel holding people accountable for what they say and when they say them is justified.

I am also wondering why the misgendering:

https://uk.news.yahoo.com/naga-munchetty-clashes-tory-minister-094145093.html?guccounter=1&guce_referrer=aHR0cHM6Ly93d3cuZ29vZ2xlLmNvbS8&guce_referrer_sig=AQAAAGfp2e1eIingbLbD2e2NX2anZV2FJjbLq5dDR71-1eabuM4r7YuRwvVyH0oLlHLDu2PsTtCB05uCjvjPXDNUE94dGNW-o_IoY5_cg-iBbmTOcdNllHctKZpvIoH5aiv3HFiBgGyphv5VcXE0L_a48rP6mIj_kH7dIlTx5UtFsORi

Naga Munchetty Clashes With Tory Minister In Angry Exchange Over Sunak Trans Row

The BBC presenter did not appreciate Chris Philp's explanation of the PM's controversial remarks.

https://uk.news.yahoo.com/naga-munchetty-clashes-tory-minister-094145093.html?guccounter=1&guce_referrer=aHR0cHM6Ly93d3cuZ29vZ2xlLmNvbS8&guce_referrer_sig=AQAAAGfp2e1eIingbLbD2e2NX2anZV2FJjbLq5dDR71-1eabuM4r7YuRwvVyH0oLlHLDu2PsTtCB05uCjvjPXDNUE94dGNW-o_IoY5_cg-iBbmTOcdNllHctKZpvIoH5aiv3HFiBgGyphv5VcXE0L_a48rP6mIj_kH7dIlTx5UtFsORi

OP posts:
Ktime · 09/02/2024 09:08

Flamme · 09/02/2024 08:48

Whether he was specifically referencing Brianna Ghey is not the issue, is it? The fact is he was making a jolly little dig about trans people at a time when he knew that the mother of a murdered trans child was in Parliament.

If, for example, he had made a jolly dig about Starmer's policies on parental supervision whilst the mother of James Bulger was in the house, would it be excusable because it didn't specifically reference him?

It wasn't a joke about trans people. It was a jibe at Keir for not understanding basic biology.

Flamme · 09/02/2024 08:56

pootlin · 09/02/2024 04:55

It wasn’t about Brianna, Keir made it about Brianna by his cynical attempt to throw the attention on Sunak, he didn’t have to go there.

Rishi was not making fun of trans people, he was clearly referencing Keir’s much publicised comment that ‘it's wrong to say only woman can have a cervix’. Which is clearly idiotic.

Keir and Rishi are as bad as each other.

Edited

Sunak didn't have to mention trans issues. He could have made his little speech perfectly well without it, and anyone with an ounce of sensitivity would have. In those circumstances, he really can't complain when the obvious point is made.

Flamme · 09/02/2024 08:48

Ktime · 08/02/2024 23:01

In the live interview Chris Philps calls Brianna Ghey he, and has to be corrected.

I've just watched the clip and I can't see where Chris Phillips calls Brianna Ghey 'he'? In the clip he clearly says 'her' three times.

I've never voted Tory in my life but I do think Keir was disingenuous here, I really don't think Rishi was referencing Brianna Ghey.

Whether he was specifically referencing Brianna Ghey is not the issue, is it? The fact is he was making a jolly little dig about trans people at a time when he knew that the mother of a murdered trans child was in Parliament.

If, for example, he had made a jolly dig about Starmer's policies on parental supervision whilst the mother of James Bulger was in the house, would it be excusable because it didn't specifically reference him?

pootlin · 09/02/2024 08:15

cakeorwine · 09/02/2024 07:16

Rishi did not know that.
He would have heard the comments from Keir

Engagements - Hansard - UK Parliament

Keir Starmer
(Holborn and St Pancras) (Lab)Sharethis specific contribution
I join the Prime Minister in sending His Majesty the King our very best wishes for his treatment. Across the House, we all look forward to seeing him back to full health as quickly as possible.
This week, the unwavering bravery of Brianna Ghey’s mother, Esther, has touched us all. As a father, I cannot even imagine the pain that she is going through. I am glad that she is with us in the Gallery today.
A year ago, the Prime Minister promised to bring down NHS waiting lists. Isn’t he glad that he did not bet a grand on it?

Maybe he didn't hear those comments?

So I will ask again:

Do you think it was appopriate to include the line in his prepared script?
Or do you think he should have dropped that line and just kept the rest?

It's not a hard question but you are doing exactly the same deflecting as Tory MPs

So why did you say she was there when you knew she wasn’t?

You seem to be quite the politician.

soupfiend · 09/02/2024 07:52

Yes, I dont have a problem with the comment or the timing of it

cakeorwine · 09/02/2024 07:25

soupfiend · 09/02/2024 07:24

It wasnt a joke about trans people, it was a joke about Keir Starmer and his idiotic statement, which is laughable and which should be made fun of

Another tory hater here but this is unfortunatley which is going to do it for Labour, they'll be wiped out even smaller with this sort of carry on

I will say it again.

Do you think that such a comment was appropriate at that time?

Or do you think there is a time and a place for such comments and that was not the appropriate time or place?

soupfiend · 09/02/2024 07:24

cakeorwine · 09/02/2024 01:54

You are missing the point.
This was not about Brianna.
This was about a joke referencing trans people.
At at time when the mother of a trans girl who had been murdered was in the House.
Do you think it was appropriate to make such a comment about "what a woman is" in such circumstances?

It wasnt a joke about trans people, it was a joke about Keir Starmer and his idiotic statement, which is laughable and which should be made fun of

Another tory hater here but this is unfortunatley which is going to do it for Labour, they'll be wiped out even smaller with this sort of carry on

cakeorwine · 09/02/2024 07:16

pootlin · 09/02/2024 07:12

Esther wasn’t there, she entered the public gallery after the comment. This is yet more fake news, such as OP being mislead that Chris Williams referred to Brianna Ghey as ‘he’ when he never did.

And I do agree with Rishi Sunak on this point, Keir’s comments were stupid.

Rishi did not know that.
He would have heard the comments from Keir

Engagements - Hansard - UK Parliament

Keir Starmer
(Holborn and St Pancras) (Lab)Sharethis specific contribution
I join the Prime Minister in sending His Majesty the King our very best wishes for his treatment. Across the House, we all look forward to seeing him back to full health as quickly as possible.
This week, the unwavering bravery of Brianna Ghey’s mother, Esther, has touched us all. As a father, I cannot even imagine the pain that she is going through. I am glad that she is with us in the Gallery today.
A year ago, the Prime Minister promised to bring down NHS waiting lists. Isn’t he glad that he did not bet a grand on it?

Maybe he didn't hear those comments?

So I will ask again:

Do you think it was appopriate to include the line in his prepared script?
Or do you think he should have dropped that line and just kept the rest?

It's not a hard question but you are doing exactly the same deflecting as Tory MPs

pootlin · 09/02/2024 07:12

cakeorwine · 09/02/2024 06:34

Do you think it was appropriate to bring up the definition of a woman - trans issues - when the mum pf a murdered trans girl was in the House?

He heard Keir say that Esther was in the Chamber. Or maybe he didn't? Maybe he was so focused on his prepared lines that he wasn't listening and he didn't think that "Hang on a moment, why don't I drop this particular line?" from my script?

Esther wasn’t there, she entered the public gallery after the comment. This is yet more fake news, such as OP being mislead that Chris Williams referred to Brianna Ghey as ‘he’ when he never did.

And I do agree with Rishi Sunak on this point, Keir’s comments were stupid.

cakeorwine · 09/02/2024 06:34

pootlin · 09/02/2024 04:55

It wasn’t about Brianna, Keir made it about Brianna by his cynical attempt to throw the attention on Sunak, he didn’t have to go there.

Rishi was not making fun of trans people, he was clearly referencing Keir’s much publicised comment that ‘it's wrong to say only woman can have a cervix’. Which is clearly idiotic.

Keir and Rishi are as bad as each other.

Edited

Do you think it was appropriate to bring up the definition of a woman - trans issues - when the mum pf a murdered trans girl was in the House?

He heard Keir say that Esther was in the Chamber. Or maybe he didn't? Maybe he was so focused on his prepared lines that he wasn't listening and he didn't think that "Hang on a moment, why don't I drop this particular line?" from my script?

HesterFields · 09/02/2024 05:47

Love Naga, she’s great.

GoldenEagles · 09/02/2024 05:20

I can’t stand Naga and Charlie either, but yes, she did a good job with this twerp of a politician.

SleepQuest33 · 09/02/2024 05:17

I really like both Naga and Charlie. Can’t see the rudeness people are referring to? They’re both excellent in my opinion.

Luddite26 · 09/02/2024 05:09

Tiddlywinks63 · 08/02/2024 23:44

@BarelyLiterate 👏👏
I can’t stand Naga (or Charlie Stayt), rude and arrogant.

I was the same but then I tuned in to Naga on the radio and she's much more personable without Stayt. I really like her on the radio she's totally different.very knowledgeable and friendly and feels like you are listening to a friend. Get rid of Stayt I say he is awful. I can't watch them on Breakfast.

pootlin · 09/02/2024 04:55

cakeorwine · 09/02/2024 01:54

You are missing the point.
This was not about Brianna.
This was about a joke referencing trans people.
At at time when the mother of a trans girl who had been murdered was in the House.
Do you think it was appropriate to make such a comment about "what a woman is" in such circumstances?

It wasn’t about Brianna, Keir made it about Brianna by his cynical attempt to throw the attention on Sunak, he didn’t have to go there.

Rishi was not making fun of trans people, he was clearly referencing Keir’s much publicised comment that ‘it's wrong to say only woman can have a cervix’. Which is clearly idiotic.

Keir and Rishi are as bad as each other.

Bululu · 09/02/2024 04:15

Of course Naga was going to be all over this.

notthatthis · 09/02/2024 02:37

I love Naga!

cakeorwine · 09/02/2024 01:54

Ktime · 08/02/2024 23:01

In the live interview Chris Philps calls Brianna Ghey he, and has to be corrected.

I've just watched the clip and I can't see where Chris Phillips calls Brianna Ghey 'he'? In the clip he clearly says 'her' three times.

I've never voted Tory in my life but I do think Keir was disingenuous here, I really don't think Rishi was referencing Brianna Ghey.

You are missing the point.
This was not about Brianna.
This was about a joke referencing trans people.
At at time when the mother of a trans girl who had been murdered was in the House.
Do you think it was appropriate to make such a comment about "what a woman is" in such circumstances?

Tiddlywinks63 · 08/02/2024 23:44

@BarelyLiterate 👏👏
I can’t stand Naga (or Charlie Stayt), rude and arrogant.

Betterbuckleupbarbara · 08/02/2024 23:31

@BarelyLiterate 😊

OP posts:
BarelyLiterate · 08/02/2024 23:27

Neither.

Notoriously rude, condescending & obnoxious TV presenter vs ghastly Tory politician. That’s like having to choose between syphilis & gonorrhoea.

Betterbuckleupbarbara · 08/02/2024 23:22

Thanks @CrispsandCheeseSandwich so it was in there, I can’t find anything now as it’s disappeared and there is nothing on YouTube either.

There were many comments on it around that too, but I only watched it once, that was enough.

OP posts:
ladygindiva · 08/02/2024 23:17

Ktime · 08/02/2024 23:01

In the live interview Chris Philps calls Brianna Ghey he, and has to be corrected.

I've just watched the clip and I can't see where Chris Phillips calls Brianna Ghey 'he'? In the clip he clearly says 'her' three times.

I've never voted Tory in my life but I do think Keir was disingenuous here, I really don't think Rishi was referencing Brianna Ghey.

I agree. And I'm a massive Tory hater.

CrispsandCheeseSandwich · 08/02/2024 23:17

I've seen a couple of clips of Chris Philps on bbc breakfast with Naga and on sky with Kay Burley and he refers to Brianna as "she". There is one point when, talking about what Sunak said, he says "he [Sunak] never referred to Brianna himself" which I think is clearly referring to Sunak when he says "himself", especially given that he refers to Brianna as "she" several times in the bbc interview. This is the point where Kay Burley corrects him by saying that Brianna was a girl.

That said, Chris Philps is a prize twit generally and never comes across remotely well. His interview with Naga was awful, and I can't understand why anyone in the Conservative Party thinks it's a good idea to send him out to speak to people. My favourite is him attempting to defend Truss's mini budget shortly after it was announced (and even more shortly before it was canned).

Swipe left for the next trending thread