Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Naga Munchetty vs Chris Philp

61 replies

Betterbuckleupbarbara · 08/02/2024 10:54

Usually I can’t watch her but AIBU on this occasion to feel holding people accountable for what they say and when they say them is justified.

I am also wondering why the misgendering:

https://uk.news.yahoo.com/naga-munchetty-clashes-tory-minister-094145093.html?guccounter=1&guce_referrer=aHR0cHM6Ly93d3cuZ29vZ2xlLmNvbS8&guce_referrer_sig=AQAAAGfp2e1eIingbLbD2e2NX2anZV2FJjbLq5dDR71-1eabuM4r7YuRwvVyH0oLlHLDu2PsTtCB05uCjvjPXDNUE94dGNW-o_IoY5_cg-iBbmTOcdNllHctKZpvIoH5aiv3HFiBgGyphv5VcXE0L_a48rP6mIj_kH7dIlTx5UtFsORi

Naga Munchetty Clashes With Tory Minister In Angry Exchange Over Sunak Trans Row

The BBC presenter did not appreciate Chris Philp's explanation of the PM's controversial remarks.

https://uk.news.yahoo.com/naga-munchetty-clashes-tory-minister-094145093.html?guccounter=1&guce_referrer=aHR0cHM6Ly93d3cuZ29vZ2xlLmNvbS8&guce_referrer_sig=AQAAAGfp2e1eIingbLbD2e2NX2anZV2FJjbLq5dDR71-1eabuM4r7YuRwvVyH0oLlHLDu2PsTtCB05uCjvjPXDNUE94dGNW-o_IoY5_cg-iBbmTOcdNllHctKZpvIoH5aiv3HFiBgGyphv5VcXE0L_a48rP6mIj_kH7dIlTx5UtFsORi

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Betterbuckleupbarbara · 11/02/2024 00:07

@OpalOrchid Why oh why do people always attack the vulnerable and easy targets.

If there cannot be a modicum of humanity and compassion around the murder of a child we are utterly lost as a species.

The politics are what go us into this mess in the first place, and to that point there is a time and place for everything.

@buckeejit the objection to the discussion was in the way it was conducted. I’m not sure many would have an issue with a fair reasonable debate around trans issues and I’m sure Brianna’s parents would welcome it considering what happened (I can’t speak for them of course), but maybe if there was sense and reason there wouldn’t be such hatred and divide.

OP posts:
YoungYeti · 11/02/2024 00:06

HermioneWeasley · 09/02/2024 09:35

Christ, I cannot believe posters are a king me defend Rishi Sunak.

the facts are clear - he was listing Starmer’s u turns and whether or not women have a penis was one of them. Nobody would have connected it to Brianna if Starmer hadn’t used the appalling murder of a child to score cheap political points. As a floating voter it makes me think less of Starmer, not Sunak.

on a related point, women are always told it’s an offensive time to talk about our rights - it’s the holy month of Pride, or asexual furrie awareness day, or it’s the day that brianna’s killers were sentenced. It’s always just an excuse to shut us up as nonsense like “women with a penis” doesn’t stand public scrutiny at all.

100%

No matter where they are on the political spectrum, any policitian who claims they can't define a woman (something so fundamental and basic) has completely and utterly lost the plot and can't be trusted to be voted for.

Biology determines male or female across the whole of nature and it's been this way from the very beginning, before even humans existed thousands of years ago. It's only in recent decades that a tiny vocal minority who refuse to accept reality have been continuously trying to gaslight the public, erase freedom of speech and stifle any form of debate. The only reason they've been gaining success is because people aren't standing up enough for common sense and it will only get worse if people don't speak out more. As with all the other crazy things humanity has done during human history, where certain societies go along with things for a easy life and those who dare speak up are persecuted, future generations will look back and wonder why people sat back and let all this happen.

I really feel for people who have gender dysphoria, which is a mental disorder. The compassionate thing is proper long term mental health and other support to get to the root of why they're feeling that way and to ultimately accept their sex. We don't go around trying to normalise the disordered self perception of people with anorexia, bulimia or ANY other type of body image dysphoria, no matter how much they genuinely believe their thoughts. There's real concerns about what the current trans lobbies are promoting regarding people suffering from gender dysphoria, especially children.

OpalOrchid · 10/02/2024 23:06

This reply has been deleted

We've removed this - it quoted a now-deleted post.

buckeejit · 09/02/2024 22:23

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

cakeorwine · 09/02/2024 22:05

buckeejit · 09/02/2024 21:57

Cheap of KS to divert attention from himself to BG's mother. Agree with Hermione's post. Women's rights & trans issues are still a massive issue - it's a ridiculous spectacle when they talk of anything in PMQ, the dramatics & provocation demean any serious issues. It's possible to feel immense compassion for people who have lost a child who identifies as trans, while realising that
Women's rights need to be protected & discussed. It often feels like the politicians egos are vying for the biggest reaction, it's galling.

So you think it's appropriate to bring it up whilst Esther was in the House of Commons?
You don't think it would have been sensitive to think "Hang on, why don't I not mention that bit, I could just mention the other things instead?"''

buckeejit · 09/02/2024 21:57

Cheap of KS to divert attention from himself to BG's mother. Agree with Hermione's post. Women's rights & trans issues are still a massive issue - it's a ridiculous spectacle when they talk of anything in PMQ, the dramatics & provocation demean any serious issues. It's possible to feel immense compassion for people who have lost a child who identifies as trans, while realising that
Women's rights need to be protected & discussed. It often feels like the politicians egos are vying for the biggest reaction, it's galling.

App13 · 09/02/2024 20:27

Ktime · 08/02/2024 23:01

In the live interview Chris Philps calls Brianna Ghey he, and has to be corrected.

I've just watched the clip and I can't see where Chris Phillips calls Brianna Ghey 'he'? In the clip he clearly says 'her' three times.

I've never voted Tory in my life but I do think Keir was disingenuous here, I really don't think Rishi was referencing Brianna Ghey.

This!

cakeorwine · 09/02/2024 19:47

Gymrabbit · 09/02/2024 19:31

I don’t think Rishi did anything wrong but I do think the PM should have more sense than to do something that can do easily be jumped on.
also although he apparently wasn’t so what if Chris Philps used male pronouns for a boy.

When people show you who they are, believe them

Gymrabbit · 09/02/2024 19:31

I don’t think Rishi did anything wrong but I do think the PM should have more sense than to do something that can do easily be jumped on.
also although he apparently wasn’t so what if Chris Philps used male pronouns for a boy.

cakeorwine · 09/02/2024 19:23

Betterbuckleupbarbara · 09/02/2024 19:01

@cakeorwine Thats reads like the playground spats of year 5s. Cringeworthy at best.

PMQs are so scripted.

And that's the issue - he clearly either didn't listen to Keir Starmer or didn't think how his scripted line might come across.

Betterbuckleupbarbara · 09/02/2024 19:01

@cakeorwine Thats reads like the playground spats of year 5s. Cringeworthy at best.

OP posts:
cakeorwine · 09/02/2024 17:41

Ktime · 09/02/2024 11:16

Why make it personal?

He was smiling but him breaking out into a 'big grin' to deliver a 'punchline' is an exaggeration on your part.

Don't forget that he was responding to KS. We don't have the full exchange.

Yes we do

Engagements - Hansard - UK Parliament

Mr Speaker
I call the Leader of the Opposition.
Keir Starmer
(Holborn and St Pancras) (Lab)Sharethis specific contribution
I join the Prime Minister in sending His Majesty the King our very best wishes for his treatment. Across the House, we all look forward to seeing him back to full health as quickly as possible.
This week, the unwavering bravery of Brianna Ghey’s mother, Esther, has touched us all. As a father, I cannot even imagine the pain that she is going through. I am glad that she is with us in the Gallery today.
A year ago, the Prime Minister promised to bring down NHS waiting lists. Isn’t he glad that he did not bet a grand on it?

The Prime Minister
At least I stand by my commitments. He is so indecisive that the only bet he would make is an each-way bet.

Keir Starmer
He says he stands by his commitments. He once insisted that if he missed his promises,
“I’m the Prime Minister…it’s on me personally”.
Today we learn from his own officials that he is the blocker to any deal to end the doctors’ strikes. Every time he is asked, he blames everyone else. What exactly did he mean when he said “it’s on me personally” if he does not meet his promise?

The Prime Minister
We are bringing down waiting lists for the longest waiters and making progress. It is a bit rich to hear about promises from someone who has broken every single promise he was elected on. I have counted almost 30 in the last year: pensions, planning, peerages, public sector pay, tuition fees, childcare, second referendums, defining a woman—although, in fairness, that was only 99% of a U-turn. The list goes on, but the theme is the same: empty words, broken promises and absolutely no plan.

Keir Starmer
Of all the weeks to say that, when Brianna’s mother is in this Chamber—shame! Parading as a man of integrity when he has got absolutely no responsibility, it is absolute—[Interruption.]

Mr Speaker
Order. I think Members are getting carried away. Our constituents want to hear the questions and they certainly want to hear the answers. They do not want to hear organised barracking, so please, I want no more of it.

cakeorwine · 09/02/2024 17:38

pootlin · 09/02/2024 08:15

So why did you say she was there when you knew she wasn’t?

You seem to be quite the politician.

I said in the House.

LlynTegid · 09/02/2024 17:22

Team Naga on this one. Charlie Stayt I just don't warm to, he may be lovely off screen, no idea though.

Apologists for hate should be challenged. As @Flamme noted, you could make the point about flip-flopping without referencing trans issues.

notthatthis · 09/02/2024 17:12

SleepQuest33 · 09/02/2024 05:17

I really like both Naga and Charlie. Can’t see the rudeness people are referring to? They’re both excellent in my opinion.

I also like Naga, I don't see what the issue is. I don't really know the other chap.

Ktime · 09/02/2024 11:16

Flamme · 09/02/2024 10:52

I didn't notice a big grin.

Seriously? Do you not know what a grin is?

Why make it personal?

He was smiling but him breaking out into a 'big grin' to deliver a 'punchline' is an exaggeration on your part.

Don't forget that he was responding to KS. We don't have the full exchange.

Flamme · 09/02/2024 10:52

I didn't notice a big grin.

Seriously? Do you not know what a grin is?

Laiste · 09/02/2024 10:30

When KS works out what a woman is he'll get my vote.

I think a lot of this was grasping at an opportunity to deflect about his U turn on spending on climate change.

Naga is uncomfortably rude to lots of people. When it's someone you might find dissagreable yourself it's great obviously.

Most of the time though it's cheap shots with glances at camera and pretending to be bored or confused. Rude.

Ktime · 09/02/2024 10:22

Xol · 09/02/2024 10:01

Not quite a full description. He was listing alleged U turns, leading up to the big punchline about transpeople which he uttered with a big grin because he clearly thought he was being immensely funny and clever. He could have done his little list without that line, he could certainly have done it without making it the punchline, and he could certainly have uttered it without making it seem like being a trans woman is ever such a hilarious joke. Anyone with an ounce of sensibility and brainpower would have avoided this one.

Do you really think that Brianna Ghey's parents wouldn't have connected this to her murder when this idiot chose to say it whilst her mother was actually in Parliament?

I didn't notice a big grin. When your opponent says something stupid, he deserves to be called out for it.

Keir saying it's not just women who have a cervix was supremely stupid and his backtracking to '99% of women' made him even more stupid.

I think they're both odious toads, as a pp put it, but in this instance Keir did use the appalling murder of a child to score cheap political points, as Hermione put it.

Xol · 09/02/2024 10:01

HermioneWeasley · 09/02/2024 09:35

Christ, I cannot believe posters are a king me defend Rishi Sunak.

the facts are clear - he was listing Starmer’s u turns and whether or not women have a penis was one of them. Nobody would have connected it to Brianna if Starmer hadn’t used the appalling murder of a child to score cheap political points. As a floating voter it makes me think less of Starmer, not Sunak.

on a related point, women are always told it’s an offensive time to talk about our rights - it’s the holy month of Pride, or asexual furrie awareness day, or it’s the day that brianna’s killers were sentenced. It’s always just an excuse to shut us up as nonsense like “women with a penis” doesn’t stand public scrutiny at all.

Not quite a full description. He was listing alleged U turns, leading up to the big punchline about transpeople which he uttered with a big grin because he clearly thought he was being immensely funny and clever. He could have done his little list without that line, he could certainly have done it without making it the punchline, and he could certainly have uttered it without making it seem like being a trans woman is ever such a hilarious joke. Anyone with an ounce of sensibility and brainpower would have avoided this one.

Do you really think that Brianna Ghey's parents wouldn't have connected this to her murder when this idiot chose to say it whilst her mother was actually in Parliament?

pootlin · 09/02/2024 09:47

on a related point, women are always told it’s an offensive time to talk about our rights - it’s the holy month of Pride, or asexual furrie awareness day, or it’s the day that brianna’s killers were sentenced. It’s always just an excuse to shut us up as nonsense like “women with a penis” doesn’t stand public scrutiny at all.

Agreed.

HermioneWeasley · 09/02/2024 09:35

Christ, I cannot believe posters are a king me defend Rishi Sunak.

the facts are clear - he was listing Starmer’s u turns and whether or not women have a penis was one of them. Nobody would have connected it to Brianna if Starmer hadn’t used the appalling murder of a child to score cheap political points. As a floating voter it makes me think less of Starmer, not Sunak.

on a related point, women are always told it’s an offensive time to talk about our rights - it’s the holy month of Pride, or asexual furrie awareness day, or it’s the day that brianna’s killers were sentenced. It’s always just an excuse to shut us up as nonsense like “women with a penis” doesn’t stand public scrutiny at all.

MotherofChaosandDestruction · 09/02/2024 09:29

P.s I'm a big fan of Naga.

MotherofChaosandDestruction · 09/02/2024 09:28

I think this has been blown way out of proportion by Starmer and has made it a lot worse for Brianna's mother and father. I am definitely not a Tory voter and dislike Sunak with a passion but the furore around this is ridiculous.

Sunak made a jibe about Starners u turns and frankly ludicrous suggestion that some women have a penis, it was not transphobic or about Brianna. Would I have made it given Brianna's mother was in the house? No probably not. Was it insensitive? Probably a bit, given Brianna was trans. Did Starmer make a fuss and make it worse? Definitely. It was a flippant comment that wouldn't have even been noticed if Starmer hadn't made a big deal of it.

Whatafustercluck · 09/02/2024 09:12

SleepQuest33 · 09/02/2024 05:17

I really like both Naga and Charlie. Can’t see the rudeness people are referring to? They’re both excellent in my opinion.

This. Is it because she's not a soft pushover? I love her steely approach to interviewing politicians and she's very professional. Charlie, too.

I also can't stand Sunak and can't wait till the Tories are voted out. But I think this is all massively overblown. Sunak made a point that many agree with about Labour's views on women. His timing was poor, but not malicious imo. Still an odious little toad, mind you.