Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

She always wins because she cheats!

246 replies

abouttogetlynched · 08/02/2024 10:28

AIBU to be pissed off that my 8 y/os friends mum makes stuff for her kid for school when it’s supposed to be made by the kid and she ultimately wins every time for the best item?
She won best Easter bonnet competition and won a giant Easter egg, she won best something or other at Christmas and got extra breaks, she won something creative last year and got to sit on a ‘throne’ all day at school and a big bag of sweets. But the mum makes all these things for her and not only should it be very obvious to the teachers that it’s not been made by an 8 year old, but the mum tells me she’s made it all and laughs about it. The kid is never involved in helping or even gives ideas, and often doesn’t even see the item until it’s given to her on the day of the competition. The one at Christmas she hadn’t seen at all coz the mum just handed it in directly to school.
The kid never admits that she’s had no involvement in making it and gratefully accepts the rewards and attention lavished on her for always winning at these creative competitions. My DD is getting quite jealous at this friend apparently being so much better than her at things and always winning. Pisses me off.

OP posts:
threatmatrix · 09/02/2024 18:09

abouttogetlynched · 08/02/2024 10:28

AIBU to be pissed off that my 8 y/os friends mum makes stuff for her kid for school when it’s supposed to be made by the kid and she ultimately wins every time for the best item?
She won best Easter bonnet competition and won a giant Easter egg, she won best something or other at Christmas and got extra breaks, she won something creative last year and got to sit on a ‘throne’ all day at school and a big bag of sweets. But the mum makes all these things for her and not only should it be very obvious to the teachers that it’s not been made by an 8 year old, but the mum tells me she’s made it all and laughs about it. The kid is never involved in helping or even gives ideas, and often doesn’t even see the item until it’s given to her on the day of the competition. The one at Christmas she hadn’t seen at all coz the mum just handed it in directly to school.
The kid never admits that she’s had no involvement in making it and gratefully accepts the rewards and attention lavished on her for always winning at these creative competitions. My DD is getting quite jealous at this friend apparently being so much better than her at things and always winning. Pisses me off.

I’d be making a snidy remark to the teacher like ‘ wow imagine an 8 year old making that she must be a genius’.
If I made it they’d think a six year old did it 😂

1974devon · 09/02/2024 17:59

It's v annoying but happens throughout school. My child would spend ages making stuff or whatever was needed and end result would be good/obvs made by child. And yet always the same child would.win and the things were all obv made by a parent..unless he did cake decorating classes in the womb!

Islandgirl68 · 09/02/2024 17:56

That is so hard for other kids. The teachers should know better. But the mum is not doing her kid any favours, is she going to sit her exams for her. The kid is learning you can win by cheating and not putting in any effort.

Notchangingnameagain · 09/02/2024 14:31

ClairDeLaLune · 09/02/2024 00:24

My husband did this. He entered a cake competition at work with a cake made by my mum, and won! I grassed him up to all his colleagues! Be that grass OP.

Love this. Ya grass! 😀

Nimmykins · 09/02/2024 14:01

My nephew made a castle for school with support but did it himself. He was disappointed it wasn't as good as the parent-made ones so BIL made a spectacular one labelled "parent's homework project". He got the point across. The school doesn't have make at home things anymore for this reason.

Devon23 · 09/02/2024 13:26

Sounds like she is enjoying winding you up -

Sto123 · 09/02/2024 13:23

Cathbrownlow · 08/02/2024 10:37

I might have a private word with the teacher if I were you, OP. That is disgraceful behaviour.

The teachers should know better. Happens in every school!

HoppingPavlova · 09/02/2024 09:06

@tralalalalalalalalYou think that's bad- I know a 21 year old who's mum writes all her cv's and job applications

You do know that there are legit professional services that do this for people, right? You go in, tell them what you have done, relevant dates and positions, and what you want. They then write a CV, make sure your LinkedIn has all the right info and searchable buzz words in it, and they do your applications. Obviously they can’t sit the interviews for you though! Many people use such a service. Given this, no idea why a young person’s mum doing essentially the same thing is noteworthy.

My DH used such a service when he was last looking to change jobs. They also know lots of tips and tricks like how if you claim you are gender uncertain and currently exploring your gender, it gets you on pretty much everyone’s interview list as it seems to tick a box. Hot tip there😁.

tralalalalalalalal · 09/02/2024 07:49

You think that's bad- I know a 21 year old who's mum writes all her cv's and job applications 😑

ClairDeLaLune · 09/02/2024 00:24

My husband did this. He entered a cake competition at work with a cake made by my mum, and won! I grassed him up to all his colleagues! Be that grass OP.

WimbyAce · 08/02/2024 22:49

Things like this wind me up too. I nearly emailed the school once as it seemed the same old kids were getting all the air time in the newsletter but I managed to stop myself on that one! I think in your case though I would have to say something if it happens every time, pointless for anyone else to enter.

Mumsanetta · 08/02/2024 22:45

And yes, YABU because she doesn’t win because she cheats, she wins because she cheats and no one does anything to stop her.

Mumsanetta · 08/02/2024 22:41

There will always be people that play the system and win because they do not care about fairness. These people will never change because it is who they are. What I don’t understand are the onlookers who know this behaviour is wrong but do nothing to try and stop it happening. @abouttogetlynched you know that this is having a detrimental effect on your DD but you would rather complain about it on MN than walk whatever distance it is to your DD’s class after school to speak to her teacher or drop her teacher an email. 5 years this has been happening and you have stood by and just watched it happen! I am raising my DD to speak up in the face of injustice and to be the change that she wants to see in the world and one of the main ways I do this is by speaking up myself. If your DD hasn’t already clocked it, she will soon realise that this other girl’s mum is cheating and has always cheated and that knowledge will sting.

SerafinasGoose · 08/02/2024 22:31

Yes: but my assumption is that it's the way of the world and not something either I or DC are about to lose sleep over. Had a wry smile with DH about the kid who's always the lead in the play and given the roles of house captain etc, probably being the child of a prominent PTA member. As far as I'm concerned they can have their perks: I have little involvement with organising school activities owing to work commitments and if someone else wants to do it, as far as I'm concerned they're removing that burden from parents like me.

There's one parent who, in the fun cake decorating competitions etc, takes it entirely seriously, brings in components clearly professionally made beforehand, and her kid assembles them onsite whilst smiling around everyone having finished first and invariably scooping the 'prize'.

In the scheme of things, it's silly and overall pretty harmless as far as the other kids are concerned. It's also not doing the children of the 'cheats' any particular favours in the long-run. Mostly, people have to put in a lot harder work and effort in order to achieve recognition in this life: it rarely falls into people's laps unless they really do have nepotism on their side.

Let them crack on!

Mindovermatter247 · 08/02/2024 22:19

There’s many people that do this.. was when I was at school and the same with dc schools. When DS was in primary school, one of the parents helped out at the school, she won everything, got seats reserved at every assembly, school play etc. everybody noticed but there’s no point saying anything because it just gets swept under the rug.

WhatFlavourIsIt · 08/02/2024 21:58

Sounds like you need to up your arts & crafts game op.

ScruffMuffin · 08/02/2024 21:45

@Sharontheodopolodous Oh no, that really is a double whammy of crapness - your mum not letting you have a go for yourself, and her being shit at it too!! How infuriating.

Inkyblue123 · 08/02/2024 21:40

Ah it starts in primary school and carries on at uni and work. Life isn’t fair. You could have a word with the school, but to what end? They clearly couldn’t give a hoot. Or you could reward your child for their efforts instead and explain that cheaters are losers. Best done in front of cheating mum.

Whatisgoingon025 · 08/02/2024 21:35

I think a lot of mums at my daughters school feel this about us 🤣 truth is I don’t have a creative bone in my body and she is incredibly creative and talented. That is not a brag she isn’t top of the class on anything else and struggles academically
but works book day / bonnet making / craft competitions etc it’s always her that wins.

Delphiniumandlupins · 08/02/2024 21:34

The cheating mum is going to be devastated when she gets beaten by a child one day (I hope)

Sharontheodopolodous · 08/02/2024 21:25

I remember back in the day,school asked parents to boil an egg and get us to decorate it (I'm guessing it was for easter)

In all my years at that hell hole,I never went near that blasted egg (neither did my brothers when it was their turn)

We never got to choose what we wanted to do either

My mother sat every single year,crafted the damn thing and sent it in as our work

Never won a prize either as
A-my face didn't fit and B-she was crap at it

Really took the fun out of it-it was my project not hers and a waste of time as I could have made the best egg in the world and still wouldn't have won

It would have been better if they'd got parents to send an egg in,let us decorate it at school and when displayed,taken the names away

Justifiedcheese · 08/02/2024 21:08

TheDogdidGood · 08/02/2024 10:43

I’d have a word with the teacher. I used to be a teacher and if was obvious when a kid did low standard classroom work and amazingly brilliant homework! It’s rally unfair on the other kids

Teachers certainly think they can spot this. I'll never forget the teacher who snered at my son, who had worked really hard on a project from books and his own imagination, that he'd clearly just lifted it from a website. Bastard.

mumedu · 08/02/2024 21:04

As a teacher and parent, I think this is shoddy. What is she teaching her daughter about life? How is her daughter ever going to learn to do things independently and develop a sense of agency, a growth mindset or resilience. It's basically a grown woman competing with 8 year old (and possibly other parents) for a prize. The school should see through these things and reward the imperfect, yet genuinely, child made entries.

slore · 08/02/2024 20:51

abouttogetlynched · 08/02/2024 11:24

Because she said to me
OK so you and your child are jealous, do the mature thing and just ignore it
It is non of your business

which I actually thought was quite a rude comment from her.

And yes I had already stated that my daughter was jealous. Wouldn’t say I was jealous, just pissed off. Maybe I’m missing the point here.

YANBU, but you need to nip your child's jealousy in the bud.

Cheaters do usually win, the world isn't fair, and jealousy isn't healthy or a good look.

If you want, you can tell the teacher or the head, and focus on how it's unfair for all the other children, and how the child in question is being shown that cheating is good, plus made to feel her real work is inadequate.

ScruffMuffin · 08/02/2024 20:50

Sadly, this has always been the case for a minority of families. I fail to understand quite why a children's art/ craft/ baking event means so much to them, but apparently it does. It continues as well - in Year 6, my kids were each given a pound or something, and told to invest it to make more money. Whoever made the most money for charity won something. My DD and her friends made and painted little door signs and toys out of offcuts of wood. I helped with sawing, but otherwise they just got on with it and did a good job. One girl decided to have a lemonade stand, and EVERY DAY we'd see her mum arrive with the 'lemonade' she had clearly spent the afternoon making, and popcorn too. Predictably, this mother won!!

I'm not artistically talented, so my DDs were usually perfectly happy to be left alone to make their Easter bonnets etc. DD1 did win one year, but only because I was being lazy. I couldn't be arsed to go into town after work to buy a hat for her to decorate, so I showed her some pictures of fascinators that women sometimes wear to weddings/ the races instead of a hat. I asked if she'd like to make something like that out of an Alice band and some bits from the craft box (feathers, ribbon, foam shapes etc). She agreed, and won! I think it was a case of less is more, and the fact that a child had obviously done it.

I left primary school more than 30 years ago, but still remember vividly that my friend's dad used to do all of her homework for her. She had older parents who were always at home, so had plenty of time. Crucially, her dad was a retired architect. We spent a whole term of Year 6 working on a history and geography project, which involved learning about a city and culminating in a Mon-Fri visit there towards the end of term. Every week, we'd do a written activity in our special topic books at school, then take them home to finish or illustrate. Every week, my friend would bring hers back to school, complete with exquisite drawings of buildings and city scenes, or floor plans of famous buildings. We all knew her dad had done them. It was obvious. Even after the trip, this continued. Alongside her age-appropriate diaries and diagrams and brass rubbings, these amazingly intricate drawings would appear. At the end of the year, she won a trophy and small cash prize for the best topic book. The teacher knew she had cheated, but I guess one of the governors or somebody like that got to judge the competition.

At best, parents like this are infuriating. At worst, they can be very damaging for their children. It didn't end all that well for my friend. At secondary school, she began to struggle - the teachers all thought she was OK because she seemed to understand the homework, but she'd inexplicably flunk tests in class and was often in tears. It turns out that her dad was doing her homework for her, which as you can imagine was incredibly detrimental in subjects like Maths and French, where you need to master each bit before you can move to the next bit. Ultimately, she failed her A levels. Years later (we'd have been in our mid 20s by then, and grown apart after leaving school), my mum bumped into my former friend. She was married and had two little girls, including a newborn. Mum congratulated her on the baby and told her how happy we all were for her. She had always wanted to be a mum, so was delighted having her children. Friend asked Mum what I was up to, and Mum told her that I'd recently gone back to university, to do my teacher training. Friend said, "oh she's so lucky. I'd have loved to have gone to university." The sad thing is - she probably could have, had she been parented differently. She managed to pass the 11+ and most of her GCSEs, in spite of the fact that her dad rarely let her do anything for herself. She was clearly a bright girl, and was also talented at sport, from what I remember. Unfortunately by the time it came to A levels, she simply didn't have the perseverance or the independent study skills she needed to succeed. My mum wasn't perfect (who is?!) and she also brought us up on her own, so time, money and resources were all in short supply. But I ultimately felt sorry for my friend, who was raised in relative luxury, and not allowed to learn how to do things for herself. I'm certain that her parents thought they were helping her to succeed, and doing what they thought was best, but in the end, cheating isn't going to benefit the child.

Swipe left for the next trending thread